This one gets four stars for the compilation of original documents. Super helpful for navigating critical documents throughout various time periods of American Presbyterianism.
With that said, some of the sermons and treatises are heavily edited to try and capture the “core” material, which somewhat defeats the whole purpose of reading the original sources to begin with. Overall, it’s still a good reference book.
A compendium of primary source materials from the history of Presbyterianism in America. The volume includes letters, diary entries, ecclesiastical meeting minutes, sermons, and church documents. It is organized around periods in American Presbyterian history.