Actually, I rate this 3.5 stars.
This sequel is interesting, but not as involving as Gulliver Takes Manhattan. It tells the tale of what happens to "the crew" the night Gulliver gives up porn and vanishes a second (or is it a third?) time.
All the stories are told in first person, which is quite a feat, but I don't think the "voices" are different enough to be wholly successful. The chapter devoted to Rowan and Servy is a case in point: also told in first person, the two characters are differentiated only by the use of italics. Todd's story is the most effective, even though I saw the reveal coming a mile off.
However, I still enjoyed it. A fun read. But I'm waiting for more about Gulliver. :)