What do you think?
Rate this book
Hannah's Voice
When six-year-old Hannah’s brutal honesty is mistaken for lying, she stops speaking. Her family, her community, and eventually the entire nation, struggle to find meaning in her silence. All she wants is to find her momma, a little peace and quiet, and maybe some pancakes.
Pinnacle Book Achievement Award – Best Fiction~
Hidden in protective foster care for twelve years, Hannah loses all contact with her mother and remains mute by choice. When she leaves foster care at age eighteen to search for her momma, a national debate rages over her silence. One word would put an end to the chaos... if only Hannah can find her voice.
“This book is so well written and Hannah is so compelling, her voice lingers in my mind long after I have finished reading. If Hannah’s Voice doesn’t end up on the bestseller’s list, on every notable list... I will be shocked. I will definitely keep my eyes open for more from Robb Grindstaff!” ~ Michelle L. Johnson
“Hannah’s Voice is a beautiful story, and I’m going to tell you about it, but before I seriously, you guys, read it. I’m not kidding. You’ll be changed forever, inside... it’s not a book with such strong thematic material that it will make anyone cringe, but it will be burned into your brain for eternity in such a delightful way. Touching, moving, funny, awesome. I can’t say it this book is revolutionary, and the best thing I’ve read in years.” ~ Naomi Sarah
EVOLVED PUBLISHING PRESENTS a novel that captures the heartwarming and unique voice first of six-year-old Hannah, and later of the teenage Hannah, in a story sure to bring a smile to your face, and occasionally a tear. Brought to you by the author of such award-winning greats as Carry Me Away, Slade, and Turning Trixie. [DRM-Free]
Pinnacle Book Achievement Award – Best Fiction~
Hidden in protective foster care for twelve years, Hannah loses all contact with her mother and remains mute by choice. When she leaves foster care at age eighteen to search for her momma, a national debate rages over her silence. One word would put an end to the chaos... if only Hannah can find her voice.
“This book is so well written and Hannah is so compelling, her voice lingers in my mind long after I have finished reading. If Hannah’s Voice doesn’t end up on the bestseller’s list, on every notable list... I will be shocked. I will definitely keep my eyes open for more from Robb Grindstaff!” ~ Michelle L. Johnson
“Hannah’s Voice is a beautiful story, and I’m going to tell you about it, but before I seriously, you guys, read it. I’m not kidding. You’ll be changed forever, inside... it’s not a book with such strong thematic material that it will make anyone cringe, but it will be burned into your brain for eternity in such a delightful way. Touching, moving, funny, awesome. I can’t say it this book is revolutionary, and the best thing I’ve read in years.” ~ Naomi Sarah
EVOLVED PUBLISHING PRESENTS a novel that captures the heartwarming and unique voice first of six-year-old Hannah, and later of the teenage Hannah, in a story sure to bring a smile to your face, and occasionally a tear. Brought to you by the author of such award-winning greats as Carry Me Away, Slade, and Turning Trixie. [DRM-Free]
242 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 13, 2013
25 people are currently reading
324 people want to read
About the author
Robb Grindstaff
38 books70 followersIn addition to a career as a newspaper editor, publisher, and manager, Robb Grindstaff has written fiction most of his life. The newspaper biz has taken him and his family from Phoenix, Arizona, to small towns in North Carolina, Texas, and Wisconsin, from seven years in Washington, D.C., to five years in Asia. Born and raised a small-town kid, he’s as comfortable in Tokyo or Tuna, Texas.
The variety of places he’s lived and visited serve as settings for the characters who invade his head.
His novels are probably best classified as contemporary southern lit, and he’s had more than a dozen short stories published in a wide array of genres. His articles on the craft of fiction writing have appeared in various writer magazines and websites, and one of his seminars was presented at the Sydney (Australia) Writers Festival. He also has taught writing courses for the Romance Writers of America, Romance Writers of Australia, and Savvy Authors.
Robb retired from the newspaper business in the summer of 2020 to write and edit fiction full time. He and his wife relocated to the beautiful Lake of the Ozarks in Missouri.
Robb also edits fiction and non-fiction books for authors from around the world. It helps that he's fluent in five languages: U.S. English, UK English, Canadian English, and Australian English, plus his native language, Texan.
The variety of places he’s lived and visited serve as settings for the characters who invade his head.
His novels are probably best classified as contemporary southern lit, and he’s had more than a dozen short stories published in a wide array of genres. His articles on the craft of fiction writing have appeared in various writer magazines and websites, and one of his seminars was presented at the Sydney (Australia) Writers Festival. He also has taught writing courses for the Romance Writers of America, Romance Writers of Australia, and Savvy Authors.
Robb retired from the newspaper business in the summer of 2020 to write and edit fiction full time. He and his wife relocated to the beautiful Lake of the Ozarks in Missouri.
Robb also edits fiction and non-fiction books for authors from around the world. It helps that he's fluent in five languages: U.S. English, UK English, Canadian English, and Australian English, plus his native language, Texan.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 52 reviews
June 24, 2025
I really enjoyed this quick reading book. Hannah, was utterly lovable in her uncensored manner of speaking, and later when she eschewed speaking, lovable in her thoughts! The ending was perfect.
Read
November 20, 2012This book was incredible! It has the distinct honor of being the second novel that made me cry upon reaching the end. The only other book that did that to me was my all-time favorite, A Prayer for Owen Meany. This book is amazing on every level--the characters, the plot, the religious and political implications and discussions, and the symbolism of pancakes (they're not just for breakfast, you know).
Hannah's Voice easily makes my top three reads of 2012--along with Jellicle Girl by Stevie Mikayne and Wither by Lauren DeStefano.
I only wish I could assign a star-rating to this book, but since I'm creating the book club guide, Mr. Grindstaff is my client, which means I'm not allowed :-(
Look for Hannah's Voice on January 15, 2013. This is an absolute must-read!
Hannah's Voice easily makes my top three reads of 2012--along with Jellicle Girl by Stevie Mikayne and Wither by Lauren DeStefano.
I only wish I could assign a star-rating to this book, but since I'm creating the book club guide, Mr. Grindstaff is my client, which means I'm not allowed :-(
Look for Hannah's Voice on January 15, 2013. This is an absolute must-read!
September 22, 2013
I have been mulling this review over in my head for days: every day I have a new approach, a new thought about the story, or a new idea that is the best thing ever about this story. There are so many things to adore about this story, which makes it more difficult to not miss an element. I should start by saying that this book will call to you if you put it down, it demands that you continue on the journey with Hannah, and doesn’t allow you to savor it slowly. Were it not so beautifully written with a style that shows Robb Grindstaff as a wonderful storyteller, this would be a simple book to review. So unlike any other book I have read, yet so comfortable in its difference, it is safe for me to say that this is another of my favorite reads of the year.
Hannah is different from the other children in her community: with a father who lost a long battle with cancer and a mother who’s ability to cope with the world was tenuous at best, this child grew up far too fast. She was a clever and artistic child, not comfortable with the company of other children, preferring to draw and take care of her mother to being singled out at school for her skills.
Like all children, Hannah has a singular thread of reasoning: if adults won’t believe me when I tell the truth, for she always did, and their reactions cause trouble when I speak: then speaking is something I should not do to not be ‘trouble’. As her silence becomes more noticeable, the community becomes alarmed, and the more fundamentalist members of the church start to take action.
Hannah is always silent but never without her own thoughts and opinions, her confusion, anger and sense of unjustly being used by those who should have known better: from the self-proclaimed Christian community, to the media to an “occupy wall street” type group founded by a trust-fund baby in an obvious in-your-face to her parents. The notoriety does little but bring danger to Hannah’s door: fearful people are dangerous people, fearful fanatics are deadly.
What sits at the core of this story is Hannah’s commitment to truth: and we see all of the variations and manipulations that are used to spin a belief into the “truth” that all should see from the other characters she encounters. Mixing religion, media and politics in a manner that feels very now and far-reaching , yet is wholly specific to the story of Hannah, Grindstaff has penned a novel that works on several levels to expose the fallacies in the “true story” and the way that belief is manipulated and influenced by belief, dogma and even a need for power.
There are no extras added to this story: each phase of Hannah’s life is solidly voiced and appropriate for her age, showing small changes in perspective without losing the core of the child we first met. There is nothing added for effect: this is a beautiful story that will stir emotions and thoughts as you read, and will stay with you long after the last page.
I purchased a copy of this title for my own library. I was not compensated for this review: all conclusions are my own responsibility.
Hannah is different from the other children in her community: with a father who lost a long battle with cancer and a mother who’s ability to cope with the world was tenuous at best, this child grew up far too fast. She was a clever and artistic child, not comfortable with the company of other children, preferring to draw and take care of her mother to being singled out at school for her skills.
Like all children, Hannah has a singular thread of reasoning: if adults won’t believe me when I tell the truth, for she always did, and their reactions cause trouble when I speak: then speaking is something I should not do to not be ‘trouble’. As her silence becomes more noticeable, the community becomes alarmed, and the more fundamentalist members of the church start to take action.
Hannah is always silent but never without her own thoughts and opinions, her confusion, anger and sense of unjustly being used by those who should have known better: from the self-proclaimed Christian community, to the media to an “occupy wall street” type group founded by a trust-fund baby in an obvious in-your-face to her parents. The notoriety does little but bring danger to Hannah’s door: fearful people are dangerous people, fearful fanatics are deadly.
What sits at the core of this story is Hannah’s commitment to truth: and we see all of the variations and manipulations that are used to spin a belief into the “truth” that all should see from the other characters she encounters. Mixing religion, media and politics in a manner that feels very now and far-reaching , yet is wholly specific to the story of Hannah, Grindstaff has penned a novel that works on several levels to expose the fallacies in the “true story” and the way that belief is manipulated and influenced by belief, dogma and even a need for power.
There are no extras added to this story: each phase of Hannah’s life is solidly voiced and appropriate for her age, showing small changes in perspective without losing the core of the child we first met. There is nothing added for effect: this is a beautiful story that will stir emotions and thoughts as you read, and will stay with you long after the last page.
I purchased a copy of this title for my own library. I was not compensated for this review: all conclusions are my own responsibility.
March 7, 2013
I think it is safe to say that this will be unlike any story you have ever read, and this poignant, intriguing story will probably stick with you quite some time after you finish it. It is haunting, thought-provoking, and probably contains more truth about the state of our country and world than we would like to admit.
Let me put out one warning. There is some profanity--some of it rather "hardcore." Let me be honest here. The author used a lot of the profanity in such humorous ways that sometimes I was not even offended. There were other times that I was offended, but it pointed out hypocrisy within the various characters. I will admit that I could have done without some of it, but I was able to tolerate it.
I was so completely drawn into this story from the beginning, and the author certainly kept me guessing about various details from time to time within the story. And he thankfully tied up the loose ends by the end of the book--very much appreciated! This is a fairly quick read, but it packs a pretty powerful punch.
Speaking from a Christian perspective, I was not offended at the portrayal of Christians within this book. So many "Christian" people are church-going hypocrites who put down people and live "like the devil." I was quite amused at the depictions of these people and genuine impressed by the pastor and other genuine people in the church at the beginning of the story. It is never preachy, but you will find much truth in this book. I definitely recommend this book to the vast majority of my reraders.
I was sent a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. I was not financially compensated, and all opinions are 100 percent mine.
Let me put out one warning. There is some profanity--some of it rather "hardcore." Let me be honest here. The author used a lot of the profanity in such humorous ways that sometimes I was not even offended. There were other times that I was offended, but it pointed out hypocrisy within the various characters. I will admit that I could have done without some of it, but I was able to tolerate it.
I was so completely drawn into this story from the beginning, and the author certainly kept me guessing about various details from time to time within the story. And he thankfully tied up the loose ends by the end of the book--very much appreciated! This is a fairly quick read, but it packs a pretty powerful punch.
Speaking from a Christian perspective, I was not offended at the portrayal of Christians within this book. So many "Christian" people are church-going hypocrites who put down people and live "like the devil." I was quite amused at the depictions of these people and genuine impressed by the pastor and other genuine people in the church at the beginning of the story. It is never preachy, but you will find much truth in this book. I definitely recommend this book to the vast majority of my reraders.
I was sent a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. I was not financially compensated, and all opinions are 100 percent mine.
June 17, 2013
I'm not sure why everyone seems to be so enamored with this book. It's ok, but I was often pretty bored throughout the story. Nothing much happens until the last quarter of the book, and it's all written with little emotion. I will say that it accurately portrays many fundamentalist religions as well as extremist social organizations, and colors both as dangerous to the core beliefs on which America was founded.
May 26, 2025
I've been needing feel-good stories. I've bought more of Grindstaff's books thanks to this one.
The audiobook narrator also did a good job with the various characters' voices – except the deaf character, who she gave a southern accent (although, to be fair, I don't recall if we were told if she had been deaf from birth or not... but it was an odd choice).
The audiobook narrator also did a good job with the various characters' voices – except the deaf character, who she gave a southern accent (although, to be fair, I don't recall if we were told if she had been deaf from birth or not... but it was an odd choice).
January 13, 2013
All great art should have three essential qualities: It should either entertain or be aesthetic in some way. It should be provocative. And it should be relevant to the culture and preferably with timeless themes. Robb Grindstaff’s HANNAH’S VOICE has all three of these qualities.
Hannah Cross is an honest but precocious six-year-old girl who wants to be believed when she tells the truth, and she doesn’t want to be in the spotlight. She doesn’t get either wish, and over the course of a week she stops talking. If she doesn’t talk, no one will accuse her of lying. If she doesn’t talk, she can’t cause problems. But quickly her church becomes divided over her silence and problems come to her door. One faction believes she has visions and is a prophet of God. The other is convinced she’s possessed with a demon, and a exorcise gets interrupted when the police and Child Protective Services steps in and whisks her away to foster care, separating little Hannah from her momma.
Ten years later, Hannah still doesn’t talk, but every night she prays to be reunited with her momma. Through a series of events, the controversy surrounding her suddenly resurges and gains national attention. Now with the impending Presidential election, two factions wanting control of Hannah and her voice as their icon start to divide the nation. All she wants is to be left alone, find her momma, and have some pancakes.
The theme of truth is explicit and richly woven into Grindstaff’s prose. Hannah brushes her teeth vigorously when she’s a young child so no lie will stick to her teeth. And she stops talking because answering the same question three or four times doesn’t make the truth any truer. However, she’s exploited for other people’s agendas, and for them the truth is subjective and can be subverted for the “greater good” of their end goals. Since this novel has a political component to it, in addition to the obvious religious one, the theme of truth and the twisting of such for ideology expose the ugliness of placing agenda ahead of virtue. This contrasts beautifully with the people in Hannah’s life who live a life of truth and simple righteousness and love Hannah as the girl she really is.
Robb Grindstaff’s writing is pure, and free of the hyperbole and love for one’s own words that often get in the way of a good story. His deft handling of the character and personality of Hannah at two distinct stages in her life showcase his mastery of language and characterization. He carefully chose each word to show the ten year difference in Hannah’s life while staying true to who she really is. That is no small feat.
I only had one issue, which I hesitate to bring up. As with some of the characters in the novel, I am offended by the use of the Lord’s name in vain. The usage is rare, and in one spot is both ironic and necessary. With the exception of that one caveat, HANNAH’S VOICE is breathtaking and a rare treat. And I can’t help but wonder with religion being a major part of the novel and with Hannah’s selective mutism if the author chose her name because of the Biblical Hannah who had a son by the name of Samuel, meaning “God has heard”.
Hannah Cross is an honest but precocious six-year-old girl who wants to be believed when she tells the truth, and she doesn’t want to be in the spotlight. She doesn’t get either wish, and over the course of a week she stops talking. If she doesn’t talk, no one will accuse her of lying. If she doesn’t talk, she can’t cause problems. But quickly her church becomes divided over her silence and problems come to her door. One faction believes she has visions and is a prophet of God. The other is convinced she’s possessed with a demon, and a exorcise gets interrupted when the police and Child Protective Services steps in and whisks her away to foster care, separating little Hannah from her momma.
Ten years later, Hannah still doesn’t talk, but every night she prays to be reunited with her momma. Through a series of events, the controversy surrounding her suddenly resurges and gains national attention. Now with the impending Presidential election, two factions wanting control of Hannah and her voice as their icon start to divide the nation. All she wants is to be left alone, find her momma, and have some pancakes.
The theme of truth is explicit and richly woven into Grindstaff’s prose. Hannah brushes her teeth vigorously when she’s a young child so no lie will stick to her teeth. And she stops talking because answering the same question three or four times doesn’t make the truth any truer. However, she’s exploited for other people’s agendas, and for them the truth is subjective and can be subverted for the “greater good” of their end goals. Since this novel has a political component to it, in addition to the obvious religious one, the theme of truth and the twisting of such for ideology expose the ugliness of placing agenda ahead of virtue. This contrasts beautifully with the people in Hannah’s life who live a life of truth and simple righteousness and love Hannah as the girl she really is.
Robb Grindstaff’s writing is pure, and free of the hyperbole and love for one’s own words that often get in the way of a good story. His deft handling of the character and personality of Hannah at two distinct stages in her life showcase his mastery of language and characterization. He carefully chose each word to show the ten year difference in Hannah’s life while staying true to who she really is. That is no small feat.
I only had one issue, which I hesitate to bring up. As with some of the characters in the novel, I am offended by the use of the Lord’s name in vain. The usage is rare, and in one spot is both ironic and necessary. With the exception of that one caveat, HANNAH’S VOICE is breathtaking and a rare treat. And I can’t help but wonder with religion being a major part of the novel and with Hannah’s selective mutism if the author chose her name because of the Biblical Hannah who had a son by the name of Samuel, meaning “God has heard”.
August 13, 2013
Review 6******
I received a copy of this book from the author for an honest review.
WOW!! This is an extremely touching story! I loved it!
Hannah is a wonderful character. She is a precocious six year old when the story begins, but picks up again 12 years later.
This is a fantastic story that had me on a roller coaster ride of emotion! I struggled to put this book down, as I was completely hooked with Hannah's tale. Hannah as a 6 year old is sweet and curious. However, due to an event where the truth is seen as lies, Hannah decides to stop speaking. I can understand why she did what she did, but I honestly don't know how she kept from speaking for so long! Twelve years is a long time not to utter a single sound. I struggle not to talk for 5 minutes, even if it's to myself! Selective muteness is usually due to trauma, but there are those who consciously decide not to talk; Hannah is one such person. This story has a few scenes that had me in tears, so be prepared with a tissue! There is an element of religion, but it is in context and is not preachy. The older Hannah has matured into a wonderful woman, who knows what she wants - to find her Momma. Oh, and to eat some pancakes!
Robb Grindstaff has written an amazing debut novel! To say this is his first novel, it certainly doesn't feel like it! The story flowed beautifully, and the pace of it never left me feeling bored. I would certainly read the next book written by this author. I highly recommend this book to everyone! - Lynn Worton
I received a copy of this book from the author for an honest review.
WOW!! This is an extremely touching story! I loved it!
Hannah is a wonderful character. She is a precocious six year old when the story begins, but picks up again 12 years later.
This is a fantastic story that had me on a roller coaster ride of emotion! I struggled to put this book down, as I was completely hooked with Hannah's tale. Hannah as a 6 year old is sweet and curious. However, due to an event where the truth is seen as lies, Hannah decides to stop speaking. I can understand why she did what she did, but I honestly don't know how she kept from speaking for so long! Twelve years is a long time not to utter a single sound. I struggle not to talk for 5 minutes, even if it's to myself! Selective muteness is usually due to trauma, but there are those who consciously decide not to talk; Hannah is one such person. This story has a few scenes that had me in tears, so be prepared with a tissue! There is an element of religion, but it is in context and is not preachy. The older Hannah has matured into a wonderful woman, who knows what she wants - to find her Momma. Oh, and to eat some pancakes!
Robb Grindstaff has written an amazing debut novel! To say this is his first novel, it certainly doesn't feel like it! The story flowed beautifully, and the pace of it never left me feeling bored. I would certainly read the next book written by this author. I highly recommend this book to everyone! - Lynn Worton
March 1, 2013
It's only March but this was one of my best reads of 2013 so far! Hannah is six years old and has stopped talking. Nope she hasn't "lost" her voice she just has decided that no matter what she says nobody is going to believe her or pay her any attention anyhow so why bother? I must say after what this child went thru I can't say I blame her not one bit!
This book scared the crap out of me and it has nothing to do with The Wrath of God or even The Hounds of Hell but the pure stupidity of some folks and how easily this story could actually be a reality for some. Folks take her silence in many ways drastically in some instances to the point the poor child is removed from her home and placed in foster care! Some think she was struck silent with a message from God while others feel she needs an exorcism performed on her for fear she is possessed by a demon. All poor Hannah wants is her mom and to be left alone. Just goes to show how far things can get out of hand when you leave things up to extremist.
This book scared the crap out of me and it has nothing to do with The Wrath of God or even The Hounds of Hell but the pure stupidity of some folks and how easily this story could actually be a reality for some. Folks take her silence in many ways drastically in some instances to the point the poor child is removed from her home and placed in foster care! Some think she was struck silent with a message from God while others feel she needs an exorcism performed on her for fear she is possessed by a demon. All poor Hannah wants is her mom and to be left alone. Just goes to show how far things can get out of hand when you leave things up to extremist.
March 10, 2013
This author took on a challenging topic and with a lot of room for potential offense to readers. He handled it masterfully. I'm a fully committed Christian and I found his descriptions of some of the extreme characters to be humorous and, sadly, accurate on many levels.
This book was deep, beautiful, and it left me feeling as though Hannah would forever be a part of my life. The conclusion is not easy or rushed. The ending left me with a sense of satisfaction mixed with bittersweet emotions for all that Hannah faced in her young life.
My hope is that this book will be discovered and possibly made into a screenplay in the future. I encourage you to treat yourself to a copy of Hannah's Voice. You'll thank me.
This book was deep, beautiful, and it left me feeling as though Hannah would forever be a part of my life. The conclusion is not easy or rushed. The ending left me with a sense of satisfaction mixed with bittersweet emotions for all that Hannah faced in her young life.
My hope is that this book will be discovered and possibly made into a screenplay in the future. I encourage you to treat yourself to a copy of Hannah's Voice. You'll thank me.
February 6, 2013
Hannah's Voice has all the elements of a "best of the year" book: It's an engaging, entertaining story; it has a wonderfully interesting lead character; and it provokes the inquisitive reader to think deeply about what's going on in the story. For less inquisitive readers, the entertainment is still there. As Hannah, who chose at age six to stop talking because no one believed that she was telling the truth, comes of age, she discovers that people will inject their beliefs and opinions into everything, whether someone says something or not.
March 11, 2013
Silence is Golden…..
Hannah’s Voice is one of my surprise reads of the year. When I read Hannah’s words – “I want the goddamn pancakes.” I knew this was going to be an interesting read. Author Robb Grindstaff’s novel is, despite some controversial subjects, both thought-provoking and enjoyable. Hannah's Voice will stay with you long after reading this book.
I really enjoy discovering new authors to add to my Authors to Read. I highly recommend this book.
December 8, 2016
When I was a kid and wanted to torture my siblings or worry my parents, I used to zip my lip, clam up, and refuse to speak a word. For the small effort of simply holding my tongue, I could drive my entire family to distraction – what was wrong?, what did I want?, why wouldn’t I answer them? As a device for attracting attention, silence was far more effective than begging, arguing, threatening, or throwing a tantrum. It was also just a bit devious.
When the young lead character of Robb Grindstaff’s “Hannah’s Voice” chooses silence, she seems to do so not because she wants something, nor to hide from anything, nor, even, to play for sympathy or to make some kind of a point. Instead, when asked a repetitive question, she simply seems to calculate her options and reaches the reasonable decision that saying nothing is the most sensible thing to do:
“I raised my eyes to meet his. Blue eyes. Bright blue. Pretty blue eyes, but they were also red, like mine after I go swimming at the city pool. I started to speak, to ask why she would make up a story like this, why she hated me so. Was it because I always won the spelling championship? But I didn’t say anything. I’d told him the truth. Saying it again wouldn’t make it any truer. If he didn’t believe me the first time, or the second time, why would he suddenly believe me if I said it a third time.”
On the surface, “Hannah’s Voice” is an engaging, fast-paced story with a clever, unique premise, a likeable cast of characters (and equally reprehensible villains), with an emotional core that tugs on the heart strings. And, at that level, the book succeeds admirably. Reading through several online reviews, I find any number of ardent and sincere testimonies from reader who were touched, emotionally, by Hannah’s pluck, optimism, and goodness in the face of extremely trying and downright peculiar circumstances. In places the story rather strains credulity, but even so, Hannah deserves her happy ending.
However, approaching this book as literal narrative misses what I surmise to be the author’s more intriguing designs. “Hannah’s Voice” works at a couple of levels. It is possible to read it as a kind of contemporary Christian parable, or a broader social allegory, or as a mischievous satire on faith and innocence. Personally, I think that the more rewarding interpretation is the latter, for it gently lampoons the mindset of today’s “post truth” society, wherein simple, straightforward honesty like Hannah’s is so rare that folks just can’t process it.
When Hannah says that all she wants is pancakes, that’s what she means, no more or less. Doesn't it?
July 7, 2021
Hannah’s Voice is a poignant coming of age tale about a girl who was forcibly ripped away from her home and her mother when she was a small child. The story follows her through to adulthood as she seeks answers to this tumultuous beginning and searches for her lost mother. Robb Grindstaff writes a surprisingly strong female protagonist with plenty of complexity, tenacity, and faith in God and family, without being overly political or religious, despite the religious and political roots of the story. Throughout, the author does a good job of examining different sides and all the grey areas and taking a neutral stance in between the political and religious upheaval that surrounds the protagonist for the duration of the book.
From an early point in this story, Hannah is forced to deal with death and suspicion. As a six-year-old, she has to deal with the recent death of her father, and as the beginning unfolds, she is closely related to the deaths of her classmate and her father’s best friend. She is also forced to deal with her mother’s faulty memory and aggravating repetition. The loss of these things that are dear to her and the accusations against her involving the classmate’s death play a part in her decision to stop speaking. Through the exchanges with her teacher, the principal, the school counselor, and her Sunday school instructor, Hannah begins to feel bullied and misunderstood.
The feelings of being misunderstood and unheard are powerful ones and feelings that many people can relate to. One thing about Hannah’s voluntary muteness that was bothersome throughout the book was that no one seemed to have bothered to teach her sign language, and even when she has a deaf roommate, even though the roommate can read lips and speak, no sign language is used and is hardly even mentioned.
Although Hannah takes it to a new level, the psychological impact of grief and trauma are discussed reasonably in this novel. Her silence invokes the attention of two different groups of people: the radical religious nutcases and the radical political ones. While these two communities clash heads over the reason Hannah doesn’t speak, Hannah takes solace in the comfort of her friends, and they heroically defend her right to live her life as she pleases.
Overall, Grindstaff does a fantastic job with inclusivity and the importance of family and diversity. He captures the emotional turmoil of the foster system and being bounced from one family to the next, all the while clinging to the hope that Hannah’s mother is out there somewhere, waiting for that joyous reunion.
From an early point in this story, Hannah is forced to deal with death and suspicion. As a six-year-old, she has to deal with the recent death of her father, and as the beginning unfolds, she is closely related to the deaths of her classmate and her father’s best friend. She is also forced to deal with her mother’s faulty memory and aggravating repetition. The loss of these things that are dear to her and the accusations against her involving the classmate’s death play a part in her decision to stop speaking. Through the exchanges with her teacher, the principal, the school counselor, and her Sunday school instructor, Hannah begins to feel bullied and misunderstood.
The feelings of being misunderstood and unheard are powerful ones and feelings that many people can relate to. One thing about Hannah’s voluntary muteness that was bothersome throughout the book was that no one seemed to have bothered to teach her sign language, and even when she has a deaf roommate, even though the roommate can read lips and speak, no sign language is used and is hardly even mentioned.
Although Hannah takes it to a new level, the psychological impact of grief and trauma are discussed reasonably in this novel. Her silence invokes the attention of two different groups of people: the radical religious nutcases and the radical political ones. While these two communities clash heads over the reason Hannah doesn’t speak, Hannah takes solace in the comfort of her friends, and they heroically defend her right to live her life as she pleases.
Overall, Grindstaff does a fantastic job with inclusivity and the importance of family and diversity. He captures the emotional turmoil of the foster system and being bounced from one family to the next, all the while clinging to the hope that Hannah’s mother is out there somewhere, waiting for that joyous reunion.
July 29, 2022
A six-year-old girl, intelligent and clearly with above-average capabilities for her age, suddenly stops talking. Not a word and not to anyone. No one can figure out why and everyone has their own theory. Promising, isn't it? Well, I certainly thought so. I wanted/expected the book to be more about Hannah and whatever turmoil she was going through. It turned out that it was more about the various shades of 'believers' that there are - from activists to bizarre bigots to the media - and the mayhem that they can cause. And Hannah's voice? Six-year-old Hannah and teenage Hannah believes that when she speaks up something bad happens. And then suddenly, she doesn't.
July 16, 2022
I really enjoyed this book both as a parent and a former teacher. We so often assume what children are thinking or what they mean when they do tell us their truth. My only problem was I felt he rushed the ending..as if he had tired of the whole mess that was created by adults when an innocent child told the truth. Maybe that was his point! We are all tired of the mess created by zealots on all sides.
June 30, 2025
Her speakinng up at 6 is mistaken as lying. Young girl taken away from her parents placed in foster care stops talking. communicates by writing. fire in her foster home separated from her brother from. foster care. the dilemma in finding her mother and how she begins to speak again.
probably easier o follow in written form
probably easier o follow in written form
June 20, 2013
We all choose to read books for different reasons, thought perhaps not as extreme a choice as Hannah's silence, choosing what to read can be tough.
The central 'voice' (or in this case lack of one) ties the entire story together brilliantly. Robb Gridstaff is an amazing author working with Evolved Publishing, and you should definitely check out his work. There are many reasons people quit talking, quit engaging and try to take a step back from the world at large.
Sometimes, and I think in the case of Hannah, the world is simply too much to deal with, and we all need a break. Or, maybe we all just need to feel like there's some aspect of our life we can control. For Hannah, it's her voice. For the rest of us, it can be many things. For me, it's music and writing. When I do those two things, I know I have a piece of the world only I can control and have access to.
In this case, I'm not sure why it took me so long to start the book, as it was an astounding read, and a book I would recommend far and wide.
Upon further recollection, I probably needed to be in the right head space. Some of the religious and social issues the book deals with (unbelievably well) are really tough issues. I wasn't sure from the synapses what stance the book would take, but the openness, and brilliant writing that allowed the reader to form their own conclusions on some aspects was a pleasant surprise.
I think, while there are many adult aspects of the book, it's the kind of literature that can reach out to many different genres. I'd give it to my daughter in highschool - if I had one, or son. I've already recommended it to a few people, and they've all picked it up and enjoyed it too. There will be something in this book for almost every reader, and that's why I gave it 5/5 stars on Goodreads.
Or was it Riffle? Or It's a Library Thing? There are so many book apps/networks to choose from. Soon, I'll even post about why I use what I do, and what's keeping me from jumping ship on some of the big name book sites. You know, when i find that magical time-monkey in the sky.
Today though, Hannah's voice will get all my attention.
When six-year-old Hannah’s brutal honesty is mistaken for lying, she stops speaking. Her family, her community, and eventually, the entire nation struggle to find meaning in her silence.
School officials suspect abuse. Church members are divided—either she has a message from God or is possessed by a demon. Social workers interrupt an exorcism to wrest Hannah away from her momma, who has a tenuous grip on sanity.
Hidden in protective foster care for twelve years, she loses all contact with her mother and remains mute by choice.
When Hannah leaves foster care at age eighteen to search for Momma, a national debate rages over her silence.
A religious movement awaits her prophecy and celebrates her return. An anarchist group, Voices for the Voiceless, cites Hannah as its inspiration. The nation comes unhinged, and the conflict spills into the streets when presidential candidates chime in with their opinions on Hannah—patriotic visionary or dangerous radical. A remnant still believes she is evil and seeks to dispatch her from this world.
Hannah stands at the intersection of anarchists and fundamentalists, between power politics and an FBI investigation. All she wants is to find her momma, a little peace and quiet, and maybe some pancakes.
One word would put an end to the chaos… if only Hannah can find her voice. (From Goodreads)
My thoughts?
It didn't make me cry, and it only made me chuckle in sarcastic laughs. What it did do, was make my heart ache.
So why do I think you should read this book?
Simple, for a new perspective, and for a story with so many levels, and so much time and effort to draw you in and really develop a character who doesn't speak for most of the book. Does that mean Hannah regains her voice?
We clearly I'm not going to give that up, and that's just one of those things you have to read and experiences and find out for yourself.
I've been less active on my blog for a variety of life business reasons, but plan to release a number of reviews shortly. one book I'm very excited about reviewing is an ARC copy of The Dream Palace. I can't wait to share with you :) I'll also be taking part in the Blogger Book Fair and the upcoming Novel Publicity Tour for Along the Watchtower!
The central 'voice' (or in this case lack of one) ties the entire story together brilliantly. Robb Gridstaff is an amazing author working with Evolved Publishing, and you should definitely check out his work. There are many reasons people quit talking, quit engaging and try to take a step back from the world at large.
Sometimes, and I think in the case of Hannah, the world is simply too much to deal with, and we all need a break. Or, maybe we all just need to feel like there's some aspect of our life we can control. For Hannah, it's her voice. For the rest of us, it can be many things. For me, it's music and writing. When I do those two things, I know I have a piece of the world only I can control and have access to.
In this case, I'm not sure why it took me so long to start the book, as it was an astounding read, and a book I would recommend far and wide.
Upon further recollection, I probably needed to be in the right head space. Some of the religious and social issues the book deals with (unbelievably well) are really tough issues. I wasn't sure from the synapses what stance the book would take, but the openness, and brilliant writing that allowed the reader to form their own conclusions on some aspects was a pleasant surprise.
I think, while there are many adult aspects of the book, it's the kind of literature that can reach out to many different genres. I'd give it to my daughter in highschool - if I had one, or son. I've already recommended it to a few people, and they've all picked it up and enjoyed it too. There will be something in this book for almost every reader, and that's why I gave it 5/5 stars on Goodreads.
Or was it Riffle? Or It's a Library Thing? There are so many book apps/networks to choose from. Soon, I'll even post about why I use what I do, and what's keeping me from jumping ship on some of the big name book sites. You know, when i find that magical time-monkey in the sky.
Today though, Hannah's voice will get all my attention.
When six-year-old Hannah’s brutal honesty is mistaken for lying, she stops speaking. Her family, her community, and eventually, the entire nation struggle to find meaning in her silence.
School officials suspect abuse. Church members are divided—either she has a message from God or is possessed by a demon. Social workers interrupt an exorcism to wrest Hannah away from her momma, who has a tenuous grip on sanity.
Hidden in protective foster care for twelve years, she loses all contact with her mother and remains mute by choice.
When Hannah leaves foster care at age eighteen to search for Momma, a national debate rages over her silence.
A religious movement awaits her prophecy and celebrates her return. An anarchist group, Voices for the Voiceless, cites Hannah as its inspiration. The nation comes unhinged, and the conflict spills into the streets when presidential candidates chime in with their opinions on Hannah—patriotic visionary or dangerous radical. A remnant still believes she is evil and seeks to dispatch her from this world.
Hannah stands at the intersection of anarchists and fundamentalists, between power politics and an FBI investigation. All she wants is to find her momma, a little peace and quiet, and maybe some pancakes.
One word would put an end to the chaos… if only Hannah can find her voice. (From Goodreads)
My thoughts?
It didn't make me cry, and it only made me chuckle in sarcastic laughs. What it did do, was make my heart ache.
So why do I think you should read this book?
Simple, for a new perspective, and for a story with so many levels, and so much time and effort to draw you in and really develop a character who doesn't speak for most of the book. Does that mean Hannah regains her voice?
We clearly I'm not going to give that up, and that's just one of those things you have to read and experiences and find out for yourself.
I've been less active on my blog for a variety of life business reasons, but plan to release a number of reviews shortly. one book I'm very excited about reviewing is an ARC copy of The Dream Palace. I can't wait to share with you :) I'll also be taking part in the Blogger Book Fair and the upcoming Novel Publicity Tour for Along the Watchtower!
May 23, 2021
This is a great story. The writer really knows how to draws you in. Every time you think you figured it out it throws a curve ball.
May 27, 2025
Read this in one sitting. Enough said…. See what I did there?
June 3, 2025
Interesting premise. Well written and easy to listen to.
February 23, 2013
This book was absolutely incredible. Probably the best part about it was how perfectly the author captured Hannah's thoughts at each point in her life: six, sixteen, and eighteen years old. Each age felt so authentic, but still distinctly Hannah the whole way through.
While I liked the later parts of the book the best, I have the say that the thoughts of an inquisitive six year old girl were much more entertaining. Just the things that Hannah noticed and came up with on her own were amazing, but everything still always sounded like it was coming from a young child. It was really interesting to try to see the world through her eyes. Everything made absolute sense, but I kept thinking to myself, "Huh, I'd never thought of it that way before."
When I first starting reading, I was a little nervous considering how it began. Usually, when books start with the "big reveal" in a prologue on the very first page, it doesn't leave the reader much to look forward to. This book, however, is the very epitome of the journey being more important than the destination. After getting all the way through the book, I can completely understand why the author chose to do it that way. Had he not given the readers a little sneak peak, it might have seemed anticlimactic and ridiculous instead of very fitting.
But he doesn't just end it there, in what would seem like a nice place to tie things up. Had this novel been just about the fact that Hannah wasn't talking anymore, it just might have been. It wasn't; that was what the entire world was focused on, everyone excerpt for Hannah, that is. To her, it wasn't about some life changing message she had to pass on to everyone around her; it was about getting back to her life, and opening her mouth wasn't going to change that.
So the story continued, at least for a little while. Those final few chapters were my favorite because things were finally starting to look up for Hannah. I really liked how the issue with her mother was handled because it explained her behavior so well, without making me dislike her for how she had acted when Hannah was a child.
The final page was the best, though. Some part of me keeps saying that it may have been a little cheesy, and that part is probably right. It doesn't really matter, however, because cheesy or not, it was exactly what the novel needed. Hannah's entire journey had been epic, and as I saw that the book was coming to a close, I was wondering how on Earth something like that could be wrapped up well. Somehow, the author managed to pull it off, and I can't possibly imagine a better way for him to have done it.
Out of all of this, the thing that amazed me the most was how willingly people are able to distort the simplest of things into some crazy idea that they just couldn't let go. It's like they see something that may in some way support what they're saying, and then suddenly they're making excuses for it and twisting it into their own image to make it fit. They want to believe something so badly that they'll take the most easily explained of circumstances and make it the most complicated thing out there just to prove a point that doesn't really exist. Suddenly a little girl's silence speaks volumes louder than any words ever could, yet it never seem to be saying the same thing to anyone.
Taylor
For the original review and more, please visit Marked By Books.
While I liked the later parts of the book the best, I have the say that the thoughts of an inquisitive six year old girl were much more entertaining. Just the things that Hannah noticed and came up with on her own were amazing, but everything still always sounded like it was coming from a young child. It was really interesting to try to see the world through her eyes. Everything made absolute sense, but I kept thinking to myself, "Huh, I'd never thought of it that way before."
When I first starting reading, I was a little nervous considering how it began. Usually, when books start with the "big reveal" in a prologue on the very first page, it doesn't leave the reader much to look forward to. This book, however, is the very epitome of the journey being more important than the destination. After getting all the way through the book, I can completely understand why the author chose to do it that way. Had he not given the readers a little sneak peak, it might have seemed anticlimactic and ridiculous instead of very fitting.
But he doesn't just end it there, in what would seem like a nice place to tie things up. Had this novel been just about the fact that Hannah wasn't talking anymore, it just might have been. It wasn't; that was what the entire world was focused on, everyone excerpt for Hannah, that is. To her, it wasn't about some life changing message she had to pass on to everyone around her; it was about getting back to her life, and opening her mouth wasn't going to change that.
So the story continued, at least for a little while. Those final few chapters were my favorite because things were finally starting to look up for Hannah. I really liked how the issue with her mother was handled because it explained her behavior so well, without making me dislike her for how she had acted when Hannah was a child.
The final page was the best, though. Some part of me keeps saying that it may have been a little cheesy, and that part is probably right. It doesn't really matter, however, because cheesy or not, it was exactly what the novel needed. Hannah's entire journey had been epic, and as I saw that the book was coming to a close, I was wondering how on Earth something like that could be wrapped up well. Somehow, the author managed to pull it off, and I can't possibly imagine a better way for him to have done it.
Out of all of this, the thing that amazed me the most was how willingly people are able to distort the simplest of things into some crazy idea that they just couldn't let go. It's like they see something that may in some way support what they're saying, and then suddenly they're making excuses for it and twisting it into their own image to make it fit. They want to believe something so badly that they'll take the most easily explained of circumstances and make it the most complicated thing out there just to prove a point that doesn't really exist. Suddenly a little girl's silence speaks volumes louder than any words ever could, yet it never seem to be saying the same thing to anyone.
Taylor
For the original review and more, please visit Marked By Books.
June 30, 2013
This book was so riveting and well-written, it should be a classic. The character of Hannah is original because her interactions with almost everyone else in her life never convey what is going on within her. She is completely misunderstood throughout the whole book, and so the reader feels her frustration. Her voice has become an absent secondary character that we miss and long for its return, to save the day by explaining herself.
The beginning of the book is set when Hannah is a six-year-old child. We immediate deduce that Hannah is really a brilliant girl, but is surrounded by many adults who don't take her seriously. They can't comprehend her maturity. Maybe because I have a daughter who is six (and also one named Hannah!) I cried even before the end of the first chapter and continued through most of the book. I wanted to shake the adults for misunderstanding her and treating her wrongly. But it also made me appreciate characters such as her father (in flashback appearances) and Brother Ronnie, the only ones sane enough to understand her and comfort her. Later, she is able to find this same comfort in Daniel, another mistreated youth.
Looking at mental illness (or selfishness) from the perspective of a child was humbling. It made me look at myself and realize that sometimes I don't give my own kids enough credit for knowing what they know. Adults can be so wrapped up in ourselves, we don't see the rapid growth in the spirits of our children.
As the book processed, we find many more characters in Hannah's life that also range from the self-centered ones who need her only to use her and exploit her selective mutism to benefit their own causes, to others not completely accepted by society who seem to accept her for who she is and see the normalcy in her. Hannah, of course, clings to the latter, while not always hiding from the former.
When I began the book and saw how much fundamental Christianity was involved, I was excited as a Christian to see how religion affected Hannah's life. Many of her religious leaders as a child completely let her down. A Christian needs to read this with an open mind, more as a reminder of how we shepherd children in Christ's love, like Brother Ronnie, rather than the others who did not see the person of Hannah at all. It was a reminder to focus on the importance of individuals over what may be perceived as "the great good." I would also like to note that Biblical references in the book were very accurate.
Another note to Christians who might read this work, there are several instances of vulgar language. It made me blush, but it contributed to the reality of the circumstance which Hannah faced. A reminder of the world we are in and need to face, even when we want to put our head in the sand.
Bravo to this author for an excellent work.
The beginning of the book is set when Hannah is a six-year-old child. We immediate deduce that Hannah is really a brilliant girl, but is surrounded by many adults who don't take her seriously. They can't comprehend her maturity. Maybe because I have a daughter who is six (and also one named Hannah!) I cried even before the end of the first chapter and continued through most of the book. I wanted to shake the adults for misunderstanding her and treating her wrongly. But it also made me appreciate characters such as her father (in flashback appearances) and Brother Ronnie, the only ones sane enough to understand her and comfort her. Later, she is able to find this same comfort in Daniel, another mistreated youth.
Looking at mental illness (or selfishness) from the perspective of a child was humbling. It made me look at myself and realize that sometimes I don't give my own kids enough credit for knowing what they know. Adults can be so wrapped up in ourselves, we don't see the rapid growth in the spirits of our children.
As the book processed, we find many more characters in Hannah's life that also range from the self-centered ones who need her only to use her and exploit her selective mutism to benefit their own causes, to others not completely accepted by society who seem to accept her for who she is and see the normalcy in her. Hannah, of course, clings to the latter, while not always hiding from the former.
When I began the book and saw how much fundamental Christianity was involved, I was excited as a Christian to see how religion affected Hannah's life. Many of her religious leaders as a child completely let her down. A Christian needs to read this with an open mind, more as a reminder of how we shepherd children in Christ's love, like Brother Ronnie, rather than the others who did not see the person of Hannah at all. It was a reminder to focus on the importance of individuals over what may be perceived as "the great good." I would also like to note that Biblical references in the book were very accurate.
Another note to Christians who might read this work, there are several instances of vulgar language. It made me blush, but it contributed to the reality of the circumstance which Hannah faced. A reminder of the world we are in and need to face, even when we want to put our head in the sand.
Bravo to this author for an excellent work.
February 27, 2013
Things have been going from bad to worse for six-year old Hannah. Her father passed away and her mother's actions are getting stranger. Their church is made up of some serious religious fanatics, and when half the church decides Hannah is demon-possessed and the other half believes she had a vision, all hell breaks loose. Hannah retreats behind a wall of silence until she's unsure if she can't speak, or won't. The officials step in and place Hannah in the foster care system, where she remains for twelve years. Meanwhile, fundamentalists on both sides continue to use her as a poster child for their political cause. All it would take to end the chaos is for Hannah to find her voice.
There are books that are interesting, and then there are books that you just can't put down. This is one of those books. This story will follow the reader long after they have closed the book for the last time. The political aspect, along with the religious aspect, combines with the subject of the foster care system to create a timely novel. Not to imply that it is serious from beginning to end; there are moments that are laugh-out-loud funny. Having been raised in the South, I've known people like Mrs. Buchanan and the Stovers. Fortunately, I've also known people like Brother Ronnie and Sheriff Dunleavy and his wife. As the author points out in the interview at the end of the book, this is not a Christian novel, but a secular novel with characters who are Christians, and those who claim to be Christian, while also containing characters who are not religious. This is a good reflection of real life. Something in Mr. Grindstaff's writing style is reminiscent of Flannery O'Connor. He captures the quirks of Southern characters while maintaining their humanity. It would have been easy to write so many of these as stereotypical comical buffoons, but he avoided the easy way out.
Excellent novel; may offend some of fundamentalist religious backgrounds; strong language.
5 stars
*Disclosure of Material Connection: I am a member of Reading Addiction Blog Tours and a copy of this book was provided to me by the author. Although payment may have been received by Reading Addiction Blog Tours, no payment was received by me in exchange for this review. There was no obligation to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are entirely my own and may not necessarily agree with those of the author, publisher, publicist, or readers of this review. This disclosure is in accordance with the Federal Trade Commision’s 16 CFR, Part 255, Guides Concerning Use of Endorcements and Testimonials in Advertising*
There are books that are interesting, and then there are books that you just can't put down. This is one of those books. This story will follow the reader long after they have closed the book for the last time. The political aspect, along with the religious aspect, combines with the subject of the foster care system to create a timely novel. Not to imply that it is serious from beginning to end; there are moments that are laugh-out-loud funny. Having been raised in the South, I've known people like Mrs. Buchanan and the Stovers. Fortunately, I've also known people like Brother Ronnie and Sheriff Dunleavy and his wife. As the author points out in the interview at the end of the book, this is not a Christian novel, but a secular novel with characters who are Christians, and those who claim to be Christian, while also containing characters who are not religious. This is a good reflection of real life. Something in Mr. Grindstaff's writing style is reminiscent of Flannery O'Connor. He captures the quirks of Southern characters while maintaining their humanity. It would have been easy to write so many of these as stereotypical comical buffoons, but he avoided the easy way out.
Excellent novel; may offend some of fundamentalist religious backgrounds; strong language.
5 stars
*Disclosure of Material Connection: I am a member of Reading Addiction Blog Tours and a copy of this book was provided to me by the author. Although payment may have been received by Reading Addiction Blog Tours, no payment was received by me in exchange for this review. There was no obligation to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are entirely my own and may not necessarily agree with those of the author, publisher, publicist, or readers of this review. This disclosure is in accordance with the Federal Trade Commision’s 16 CFR, Part 255, Guides Concerning Use of Endorcements and Testimonials in Advertising*
October 11, 2013
This story is unique and interesting and I was impressed with the author's ability to capture Hannah's changing age and emotional state throughout the book. She was spunky and broken; a combination not usually depicted. Grindstaff elegantly dealt with the transition from speaking to silence so well that the reader takes it as a natural occurrence. Definitely a difficult feat he accomplished well. My favorite moment was when Hannah's mother tells her she has her fathers teeth and she says "I didn't have my father's teeth. His were still in his mouth..."
The characters were generally well drawn, except that more than once, Hannah's internal thoughts mimicked the way Ginger speaks (pg. 153 "I felt like the third-uh whee-ul.") and strongly suggested that Hannah was making fun of the way she spoke which was not only out of character for Hannah but somewhat offensive. I liked that there was a deaf character, but other than the way she spoke, she was completely normalized and her deafness wasn't an issue for her or anyone around her; this wasn't believable and made the speech pattern stand out all the more. Also - though this is personal preference - the way the deaf character's speech was written out felt excessive.
The plot read well until the end, where it jumped from ch 31 to 32 . It was way way too sudden. I thought I'd missed a chapter or there was a printing problem with the book. The author gave us the climax but no declining action. Just skipped to the denouncement. Same thing with 32 to 33 and then for the entire reuniting sequence for Hannah and her mom. That was such a pivotal part of the story but it was rushed and not given the weight it needed. I feel like another 3-4 chapters need to be written after ch 31 to fill in and flesh out the story before it's really done.
While well crafted and well written, I feel the issue at the end of the book warrants a lower star rating.
There were some major issues with the formatting in the copy I received, however, I have spoken to the author and he is having this fixed and will be uploading the correct edition soon.
I received a review copy from the author in exchange for an honest opinion.
AIA Reviewers
The characters were generally well drawn, except that more than once, Hannah's internal thoughts mimicked the way Ginger speaks (pg. 153 "I felt like the third-uh whee-ul.") and strongly suggested that Hannah was making fun of the way she spoke which was not only out of character for Hannah but somewhat offensive. I liked that there was a deaf character, but other than the way she spoke, she was completely normalized and her deafness wasn't an issue for her or anyone around her; this wasn't believable and made the speech pattern stand out all the more. Also - though this is personal preference - the way the deaf character's speech was written out felt excessive.
The plot read well until the end, where it jumped from ch 31 to 32 . It was way way too sudden. I thought I'd missed a chapter or there was a printing problem with the book. The author gave us the climax but no declining action. Just skipped to the denouncement. Same thing with 32 to 33 and then for the entire reuniting sequence for Hannah and her mom. That was such a pivotal part of the story but it was rushed and not given the weight it needed. I feel like another 3-4 chapters need to be written after ch 31 to fill in and flesh out the story before it's really done.
While well crafted and well written, I feel the issue at the end of the book warrants a lower star rating.
There were some major issues with the formatting in the copy I received, however, I have spoken to the author and he is having this fixed and will be uploading the correct edition soon.
I received a review copy from the author in exchange for an honest opinion.
AIA Reviewers
January 28, 2013
Hannah's life was never really normal. Her father died when she was just a little girl, and her mother suffered from dementia and would always ask Hannah over and over if she had brushed her teeth and cleaned her room. Hannah went to church every Sunday and read the bible every night. She was a good girl who always did was she was asked and who never told a lie.
When a series of events leads to Hannah being blamed for things she did not do, a tragedy looming over her head with fingers pointing in her direction leaves Hannah with an indefinite loss for words.
A bad situation only gets worse when local church members are split by what Hannah's silence could mean. Some claim she is possessed by a demon while others are certain she bears an important message from God that has rendered her mute.
Chaos stirs the controversy into more tragedy resulting in Hannah being removed from her home and her mother. Twelve long years later, Hannah still has not said a single word but has never lost hope that one day she will find her mother again.
"Hannah's Voice" presents a unique and stirring tale that unravels through the eyes of a girl who won't speak. Author, Robb Grindstaff, delves into religion, politics, and affects of social mayhem throughout this book, giving readers plenty to mull over as they bear witness to Hannah's plight against the burdens and assumptions society places on her in the absence of her voice.
What I enjoyed most about this book is the author's impeccable attention to detail. Grindstaff captures the very essence of each scene by playing on all the senses of the body - touch, taste, smell, sound... it enriches the experience and really brings each page to life!
While the story presents an extreme case with Hannah's situation - for me - it presented frightening take on the very nature of extremists and what can happen in the absence of reason. A lesson or two can be learned in these pages for those willing to open their minds and hearts to the notion that life is not black and white, that somewhere in the gray, the truth can be found.
When a series of events leads to Hannah being blamed for things she did not do, a tragedy looming over her head with fingers pointing in her direction leaves Hannah with an indefinite loss for words.
A bad situation only gets worse when local church members are split by what Hannah's silence could mean. Some claim she is possessed by a demon while others are certain she bears an important message from God that has rendered her mute.
Chaos stirs the controversy into more tragedy resulting in Hannah being removed from her home and her mother. Twelve long years later, Hannah still has not said a single word but has never lost hope that one day she will find her mother again.
"Hannah's Voice" presents a unique and stirring tale that unravels through the eyes of a girl who won't speak. Author, Robb Grindstaff, delves into religion, politics, and affects of social mayhem throughout this book, giving readers plenty to mull over as they bear witness to Hannah's plight against the burdens and assumptions society places on her in the absence of her voice.
What I enjoyed most about this book is the author's impeccable attention to detail. Grindstaff captures the very essence of each scene by playing on all the senses of the body - touch, taste, smell, sound... it enriches the experience and really brings each page to life!
While the story presents an extreme case with Hannah's situation - for me - it presented frightening take on the very nature of extremists and what can happen in the absence of reason. A lesson or two can be learned in these pages for those willing to open their minds and hearts to the notion that life is not black and white, that somewhere in the gray, the truth can be found.
March 15, 2013
At the beginning of Hannah’s Voice, Hannah is just a little girl who seems to have been given the short end of the stick in life — her loving father dies leaving her only with memories of happy times and a mother who is teetering on the edge of insanity. Everything she says and does seems to be twisted or misunderstood, or, more likely, people are blindly influenced by their own sensitivities to peg her as they see fit. She stops talking because all she really wants to do is fade into the background, and for everybody to leave her alone, when, unfortunately, the exact opposite happens. Due to a run of unfortunate circumstances, Hannah gets placed in the foster system. The book skips ahead to 10 years later, when Hannah is 16 years old and the ideas that have been shaped around her have grown into a manic phenomenon. Two radical groups, religious and political, take an unprovoked stance on Hannah’s status, and the floodgates open.
The feeling of Hannah’s Voice is very different from anything I have read before. I sort of felt like I was reading a political short story that may have been an assignment for a university writing course. I must admit that the frequent political discussions did have me zoning out, but that is pretty much the effect that all politics has on me. It was really cute seeing things from Hannah’s perspective when she was six years old, and didn’t have an adult’s understanding or wasn’t able to express herself in the way that she would have liked. Despite this, the author was sure to fill in the gaps, and connect the dots for us.
There was no romantic thread to the story, which could have added a little fun. Still there was a lot of humor thrown in, and keeping track of all of the minor characters kept me busy enough.
Hannah’s Voice is wrapped up concisely, tying up all the loose ends. The touching and emotional conclusion nicely ended a book where people’s uncontrolled first-reactions snowballed to the point of absurdity.
Read more of my reviews at Book Wookie.
The feeling of Hannah’s Voice is very different from anything I have read before. I sort of felt like I was reading a political short story that may have been an assignment for a university writing course. I must admit that the frequent political discussions did have me zoning out, but that is pretty much the effect that all politics has on me. It was really cute seeing things from Hannah’s perspective when she was six years old, and didn’t have an adult’s understanding or wasn’t able to express herself in the way that she would have liked. Despite this, the author was sure to fill in the gaps, and connect the dots for us.
There was no romantic thread to the story, which could have added a little fun. Still there was a lot of humor thrown in, and keeping track of all of the minor characters kept me busy enough.
Hannah’s Voice is wrapped up concisely, tying up all the loose ends. The touching and emotional conclusion nicely ended a book where people’s uncontrolled first-reactions snowballed to the point of absurdity.
Read more of my reviews at Book Wookie.
April 21, 2013
Thought-provoking, powerful message
I don't know where to begin. I told the author (who I have the privilege of knowing "virtually", and who by the way DID NOT request or require a review of this book, which I bought for my reading pleasure) that I had no words. I was speechless, a GOOD speechless, though not like Hannah -- more like because of Hannah. Hers is the most powerful wordless message. Robb manages to convey his main character, Hannah, as amazingly real -- even though she is at the beginning a 6-year-old girl, then we follow her as she grows to be a young adult. Communicating with no dialog, Robb nevertheless masters the inner feelings and thoughts of the protagonist, to the point that one thinks one is inside her head.
The book touches on religion, politics, media, psychological traits, and pure human emotions and traits. It is incredibly complex, yet a smooth, flowing read. A diversity of characters, with distinct personalities and actions, add to the complexity and thought-provoking context.
"Hannah's Voice" is a treat for any reader, but particularly if you are interested in social and psychological issues, as well as politics, government systems, and church ideologies. So, what are you waiting for? Go ahead and get your copy. I guarantee when you're done you'll be sitting, mute in Hannah-esque fashion, and reflecting on all that has so far shaped your world.
I don't know where to begin. I told the author (who I have the privilege of knowing "virtually", and who by the way DID NOT request or require a review of this book, which I bought for my reading pleasure) that I had no words. I was speechless, a GOOD speechless, though not like Hannah -- more like because of Hannah. Hers is the most powerful wordless message. Robb manages to convey his main character, Hannah, as amazingly real -- even though she is at the beginning a 6-year-old girl, then we follow her as she grows to be a young adult. Communicating with no dialog, Robb nevertheless masters the inner feelings and thoughts of the protagonist, to the point that one thinks one is inside her head.
The book touches on religion, politics, media, psychological traits, and pure human emotions and traits. It is incredibly complex, yet a smooth, flowing read. A diversity of characters, with distinct personalities and actions, add to the complexity and thought-provoking context.
"Hannah's Voice" is a treat for any reader, but particularly if you are interested in social and psychological issues, as well as politics, government systems, and church ideologies. So, what are you waiting for? Go ahead and get your copy. I guarantee when you're done you'll be sitting, mute in Hannah-esque fashion, and reflecting on all that has so far shaped your world.
August 22, 2013
Hannah’s Voice is an original, well-written novel that, like most good books, transcends genre. The main character, Hannah, is a complex and endearing young girl who is struggling to come to terms with a painful past. The story is a little reminiscent of The Secret Life of Bees, as we follow Hannah’s journey of discovery of the good and bad in life. On the way she encounters some who will help, some who would exploit and some who expose her to the more bizarre aspects of humanity.
It’s quite a feat to tell a story in the first person point of view of a character who doesn’t speak. The author not only accomplishes this in a believable and engaging manner, but also shows us three different Hannah’s: the intelligent but traumatized six-year-old girl; the blossoming teen; and the young woman who finally comes to terms with the absurdity of the world around her.
The book occasionally skirts the ragged edge of social commentary and political satire by highlighting the irrationality of extremes on all sides. But the author never climbs so high on his soap box that it interferes with the story.
The success of this fine novel rests on the marvelous character of Hannah. I became attached to her in the first few pages and continued to root for her all the way through to the end.
It’s quite a feat to tell a story in the first person point of view of a character who doesn’t speak. The author not only accomplishes this in a believable and engaging manner, but also shows us three different Hannah’s: the intelligent but traumatized six-year-old girl; the blossoming teen; and the young woman who finally comes to terms with the absurdity of the world around her.
The book occasionally skirts the ragged edge of social commentary and political satire by highlighting the irrationality of extremes on all sides. But the author never climbs so high on his soap box that it interferes with the story.
The success of this fine novel rests on the marvelous character of Hannah. I became attached to her in the first few pages and continued to root for her all the way through to the end.
September 4, 2013
3.5 of 5 stars
Six-year-old Hannah stops talking when her honesty is questioned. People in her fundamentalist church either think she's possessed by the devil, or god-like. Flash forward ten years, she's in a foster home and an act of bravery thrusts her into the national spotlight. All Hannah wants to do is find her mother, who she hasn't lived with since age six.
There's lots to like about HANNAH'S VOICE. The beginning chapters sound like a six-year-old would think. Unfortunately, the writer didn't do as well capturing Hannah's young adult voice. The plot was at best, unrealistic, at worst, contrived. Only one of the fundamentalists is portrayed as remotely sane, the others want to exorcize or canonize her. Even Hannah's character is a bit one dimensional.
While this isn't a religious book, there is a lot of prayer and religion in parts of the book. HANNAH'S VOICE isn't particularly preachy, at times Hannah's observations are comical. This slightly better than average novel didn't make me think, as it could have if better executed.
Six-year-old Hannah stops talking when her honesty is questioned. People in her fundamentalist church either think she's possessed by the devil, or god-like. Flash forward ten years, she's in a foster home and an act of bravery thrusts her into the national spotlight. All Hannah wants to do is find her mother, who she hasn't lived with since age six.
There's lots to like about HANNAH'S VOICE. The beginning chapters sound like a six-year-old would think. Unfortunately, the writer didn't do as well capturing Hannah's young adult voice. The plot was at best, unrealistic, at worst, contrived. Only one of the fundamentalists is portrayed as remotely sane, the others want to exorcize or canonize her. Even Hannah's character is a bit one dimensional.
While this isn't a religious book, there is a lot of prayer and religion in parts of the book. HANNAH'S VOICE isn't particularly preachy, at times Hannah's observations are comical. This slightly better than average novel didn't make me think, as it could have if better executed.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 52 reviews