To start with, don't hold how long it took me to read this book against it. I got one page in and then had to leave it to deal with other things - It actually took me about three days to read the book.
I had a really hard time deciding how to rate this book. I liked it. Did I really like it? Yes. Did I notice some flaws that should technically drop the score down? Yes. I finally decided I would rate this a 3. although I debated a 3.5 for a really long time. Will I read a sequel? Most likely so. I do want to know more about Caspa and Rum.
The characters made this book for me. I love Caspa's voice, as it's so normal, so relatable. Caspa responds to situations the way that I think most girls would, and it is this which makes her so wonderful. The other characters are equally as lovable - the complex Rum, the precocious Jai, the stern because she has to be Etz.
Most of my problems with this piece can boil down to the requiring a sequel to stand up ending, and small editing details. There are a few moments where I couldn't help but draw a comparison to The Hunger Games, which is probably the trouble for most current dystopian novels, although I thought some slight edits could change that. There were a few points about the worldbuilding that confused me, but that could be because I was overanalyzing it. My biggest problem is that there's no way this book stands on its own, and I like for a book to clearly end, despite a sequel coming. I know this is the latest trend...I just don't care for it.
I try not to focus on the story and not the formatting at Goodreads, but for those who care, there were some distracting spelling and formatting errors, but not enough to frustrate me.
All in all, I liked the book. There were a few great quotes, a few moments of that dystopic makes-you-think wonder, and interesting path getting from point A to point B. It's not an earthshattering read, but it's an enjoyable light dystopia.