I went into the library and said "I'm going to read an Amish book." I see them all the time, it's a genre I've never read, so I decided to finally try it. Boy, was this book horrendous.
One, there is no romance. As one of the heroines mentions, "lip kissin is for marriage." Look, I don't care if a romance novel doesn't have furious humping, but I expect there to be an emotional connection between romantic leads. There is none here. I think they eat popcorn together and ride a horse buggy at night and that equals love? Yup. Alright. Whatever.
But what bothered me most about this book is the message of blood sacrifice that it sent. SPOILERS AHEAD
Sadie, one of the Amish sisters, gets pregnant out of wedlock. Later, when she thinks her baby has died, she's all like "Ohhhh, I'm soooo sad, but when you break a vow to God you must pay with blood!"
WHAT. What. wat. Holy hell, what kind of message is this sending to girls? You sinned! Expect your child to die! Or be severely mentally handicapped at the very least (which seems to be what will happen, but I refuse to read the sequels to find out.)
Ugh. Oh, it makes me angry. Plus, the girls aren't allowed to go to school higher than 8th grade. As an adult, you can choose to stop educating yourself. When you are in 8th grade YOU ARE TOO YOUNG. That is too young to stop school. How can they know for themselves at that point? By the way, the girl that got pregnant received an education higher than 8th grade on accident and so she became EVIL. This genre, as far as I can tell, is sexist. This book specifically is so sexist that I felt offended.
One final thing. There is a female character that likes doing "man's" work outside. One day, she sprains an ankle, sits inside for a few days, and realizes that she should be working in the kitchen instead of outside. So she starts training to be a housewife. Be cause cooking, sewing, and cleaning are the only things a woman really wants to do.