Full disclosure: I was chosen a First Reads winner, and received a paperback copy of Sautee Shadows, signed by the author, in the mail. She even personalized her note, as both us are named Denise. Here is my honest review:
What an inspiring historical novel! This is the first installment in a set of four, and I am already looking forward to purchasing the second one. (All four novels are currently available, the fourth having just been published this month.) There are quite a few diverse and fascinating characters, some who are historical persons and some who are fictional, and they are well-integrated into this moving story, set in both Georgia and the American northeast beginning in 1835 and progressing into 1855. Fortunately, Denise Weimer has provided a genealogical chart for four of the main families in the story. I initially referred to it several times, as I was getting the cast of characters firmly in mind.
My favorite character is a young half-Cherokee girl (Mahala) with a feisty streak that gets her into trouble more than once. But the southern belles and their Yankee cousins are well-painted, too, as are the hoteliers and shop-keepers, the shipping tycoons, and their servants and slaves. Of course, one could not write a historical novel of this era without touching on the issues of slavery and forced emigration of the native American tribes. Weimer, a native of Georgia herself, seamlessly integrates her love of history as well as her experiences in period dance research into the well-crafted tale. It's always exciting to discover the voice of an enjoyable new author. Here is one who clearly knows the south and writes well about it!
I found only one proof-reading error in the entire book (a place where a three word phrase was repeated within a sentence) and no misspellings or other typos. That in itself was refreshing!
I debated overnight, before writing this, about whether to give it four or five stars, and finally settled on four, only because I can't really say that this works as a stand-alone novel. There are basic questions from the very start of the novel that remain unanswered at its close.
I would, however, highly recommend this lyrical start to an intriguing story -- there's history, romance, and even a bit of mystery in it -- and am so grateful for the opportunity to have read it. If you're a fan of historical fiction, this will not disappoint!