Initial Evidence: Historical and Biblical Perspectives on the Pentecostal Doctrine of Spirit Baptism by Gary B. McGee

by Gary B. McGee

This is a superb collection of articles on the central issue of Pentecostalism--speaking in tongues as the initial evidence for the baptism in the Holy Spirit. The articles, written by both Pentecostals and non-Pentecostals, are historically informative, scholarly, irenic in spirit, ecumenical in treatment, and wide-ranging in interest. Here is an opportunity for both Pentecostals and non-Pentecostals to become better informed about Pentecostalism. While offering a solid defense of traditional Pentecostalism, the book also offers candid assessments that take a different view. This book should become a must for those who want to understand both historic and present-day Pentecostalism. --Gordon D. Fee, Professor Emeritus of New Testament, Regent College The most complete and scholarly analytical treatment of glossolalia as 'initial evidence' of the baptism in the Holy Spirit that has yet appeared. Both the historical and theological sections support and challenge the distinctive Pentecostal teaching on the subject of tongues. --Vinson Synan, Former Chairman, North American Renewal Service Committee . . . a remarkably diverse collection of essays that thoughtfully probe the distinctive which has come to characterize the Pentecostal Movement, speaking in an unknown tongue. . . . Irenic in tone, the volume is a must for scholars, pastors, and lay persons of all theological perspectives who desire to enter into dialogue in this area of debate. --D. William Faupel, Professor of the History of Christianity, Wesley Theological Seminary Initial Evidence, edited by Gary McGee, is a substantive contribution to the study of American Pentecostalism. The historical overviews in it are of tremendous value, particularly for newcomers to Pentecostalism, who may lack a historical grounding in the movement. Exegetical essays, such as that by Donald Johns, will challenge readers who are comfortable with current hermeneutical models to rethink the biblical text, and it offers great promise for more contributions to Pentecostal exegesis. --Howard M. Ervin, Professor Emeritus of Old Testament, Graduate School of Theology, Oral Roberts University

Paperback

First published October 1, 1991

About the author

Gary B. McGee (1945–2008) received his PhD from St. Louis University and taught at the Assemblies of God Theological Seminary.

Reviews

[Kaden Clark · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book provides a wide range of perspectives on the question of "Initial Physical Evidence." The diversity of viewpoints alone makes it a worthwhile read for both Pentecostals and non-Pentecostals alike. By including contributions from non-Pentecostals, Oneness Pentecostals, Classical Pentecostals, and even ex-Pentecostals, the book offers a unique and comprehensive look at the ongoing debate surrounding this topic. Rather than giving readers simple answers, it raises important questions that both Pentecostals and non-Pentecostals must wrestle with, which is precisely what makes it valuable for the body of Christ. My hope is that this book will continue to encourage thoughtful dialogue, both in academic circles and among lay readers.