Definitely Stinky
This story really had to work hard for this rating, and really it was the second story about Santa's grotto that brought it up a notch from 3 stars. I'm trying hard not to come off as stuffy and unimaginative but I just have a hard time portraying Santa as a lazy, smelly, neglectful character for most of the year even if he does his job at the end. It's not the way I want my children or grandchildren to envision Santa, but it still offers discussion points with young children, such as, do you really think Santa could get everything done in so short a time, and do you think it's his best work? There were a couple words that confused me too- pong and grotty- but, if the author is British, and I don't know if he is, those words may have meanings that I'm not familiar with. In the end, I changed my rating back to 3 stars