An emotionally gripping, brutally invasive tale of four young Native Americans wrongly committed to our nation's only Indian insane asylum during the 1920s.
This powerful narrative is unputdownable, unforgettable, and an unbelievable combination of drama, conflict, and romance.
Gathered from true events in the records of the South Dakota State Archives, this long hidden world of heartbreak takes you to the darkest depths of the human spirit and promises to touch your very soul.
★ Red Carpet Book Awards 2014 Historical Fiction Readers' Choice Nominee.
★ Artifacts and related photographs on display at jmbarlog.com.
Goodreads readers offered rave reviews:
"It was definitely a page turner. I found myself caring about the patients and rooting for them to win. Well written J.M. Barlog!" -- Dawn, Goodreads
"Not for the faint of heart. This story is a gut-twister, evoking anger at man’s inhumanity to his fellow man." --Susan, Goodreads
"It was incredibly hard at points to remember fact from fiction because the characters are so well formed." -- Gidget, Goodreads
"I loved the plot of the book and the many twists and turns it took me on as a reader." -- Teresa, Goodreads
"This is not a sugar-coated piece and I highly recommend this book to those that want to understand and learn about this time in history." --Sandy, Goodreads
"It's terrifying as it was derived from actual crimes against Native Americans, but it has moments of love, insight and suspense." -- Michelle, Goodreads
"Sometimes difficult to read because of its brutal honesty, Fallen Hopes, Taken Dreams illustrates a tragic, yet important, chapter in American history regarding the horrific treatment of Native Americans and the eradication of their culture." --Sherry, Goodreads
It was the roaring 20s, and Americans were living the dream, except for…
… the hundreds of Native Americans wrongly committed to our nation’s only Indian insane asylum. Once there, they endured unimaginable torture and abuse with no hope of ever being set free. The unrelenting power of love must overcome the hateful forces if they are to survive.
Fallen Hopes, Taken Dreams is a must-read for Red Hearts and all fans of US historical or Native American literature.
Barlog grew up in Chicago before serving in Vietnam with the U.S. Air Force.
He has authored numerous novels across many genres. Windows to the Soul, his debut novel, won the Readers' Choice award for suspense at an Illinois 'Love Is Murder' Mystery Conference.
But his greatest accomplishments are his three children and his grandchildren.
Barlog currently lives with his wife in Southern California, where he is busy writing sequels to his popular novels The Heart of the Lion, Minno, and A Connecticut Nightmare.
I received this via the First Reads program and was eager to learn more about a period of American history that was unfamiliar to me.
I have read about the forced boarding of Indian students in schools designed to rid them of their heritage, culture, and language, but had no knowledge of the insane asylums under the auspices of the Bureau of Indian Affairs. These were cruel, inhumane institutions--a blight on the history of this country. Even though Fallen Hopes, Taken Dreams is a fictionalized telling of the horrors experienced at Canton Indian Insane Asylum, I thought it would provide some welcome insight into this bleak period. Unfortunately the only insight I received was in the epilogue. Canton was operational for 32 years, admitted 371 Indians, (of whom 121 died while in residence)and was closed by decree of Congress in 1934. Even though the abuses were investigated, none of the employees were ever charged.
I had to abandon the book about half-way through and skimmed quickly through the remainder. The premise was exceptional, the writing--not so much. If Mr. Barlog had availed himself of the services of an accomplished editor, the book has promise. However, there were too many awkwardly worded sentences that caused me to have to re-read several times in an attempt to make sense of them; the aggravation factor outweighed the desire to finish the book. Words were mis-used: several times we are informed that the Dr. in charge of the institution used his mortar and "pistol" to grind medications--a dangerous proposition indeed. "A smile glimpsed his face"--what?, (these are two very small examples of many) Punctuation was missing or mis-used many times and caused confusion. Could I write a better book? Possibly not, but I *would* hope to have the wisdom to have advisers to help me along in the process so that I could provide the best possible reading experience.
This book is an unbelievable combination of drama, conflict and romance. I couldn't put this one down. The author makes you feel like you are inside a terrible place where terrible things happen to innocent people. The relationship between Mana and Evey tugged at my heart strings. It's hard to fathom that people could be so cruel. This one definitely blurs the line between fact and fiction.
I received this book as a first read from goodreads!!
A frustrating story of tremendous injustice and prejudice against Native Americans. Institutionalized and labeled as mentally ill, the Canton Indian insane asylum houses many-some don't belong there. Victims of abuse and neglect, Mana and Tesqua forge a friendship and a plan...
This is an excruciatingly painful account of how cruelly Native Americans were treated by the strangers that had invaded their homeland. The novel is set in an Indian Insane Asylum and the poor souls that have been committed there will steal your heart and make you cry.
This is an excellent fictionalized novel about what might have happened,to the handful of Indians,that were left after the final,desecration of the Indian nation. In 1924,a teenage Indian,named Jimmy (not his Indian name) came to the Asylum to supposedly spend the rest of his life.Jimmy made few friend's but the one's he did were advantageous. After yrs.of torture by a Dr. and his minions,who were trying things like electric shock therapy straight jackets for days at a time and leaving the patients to wallow in their own excrement without food or water of any kind. A good Dr.Barry came to the Asylum to work,sometime in the late 20's.He soon realized that the majority of the Indians were not insane and didn't belong there. He was fired by the head doctor who realized that his experiments,would be halted if he stayed around. But,the Indians kept a low profile and waited for an opportunity to escape,although Dr.Barry had told them,that he would return and help them. He came back.after Jimmy had been there for more than a decade But come back he did, with the head of the state asylums and armed guards The Indians were soon in.Dr.Barry's care and he proved that a lot of them were not insane and didn't belong in an.institution.
This was a powerful book to read and although fictionalized,it might have happened. I would like to thank NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review "Fallen Hopes.Taken.Dreams" written by J.M Barlog.
This was hard for me to review because a lot happened during those yrs. and writing them down,would have spoiled the book for you. Take a chance and read for yourselves you won't be disappointed.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Wow, this book is a treasure trove of history, with an up-close account of an insane asylum in the early 1900s. What really is the center of the story is the unjust imprisonment of several native american indians. They are experimented on with electric shock treatment and drugged constantly, never able to leave the grounds of the institution. It's a shocking story as unscrupulous orderlies and doctors do unimaginable things to the women and men and sometimes children kept here. Because the indians are thought of in general society as second class citizens with no rights, these patients are not allowed to communicate with family or have visitors. It gets really bad in this place, and soon the patients who are really okay mentally start working together to survive and try to escape. The situation is very tense, and sometimes they despair of their freedom. When a staff member realizes the atrocities going on and try to speak up, they are quickly fired, so they can't interfere. I recommend this story, because of all it reveals and the unique perspective of history.
This is one intense read! It’s a credit to the author that at times it’s difficult to believe that this is a work of fiction, that doesn’t mean that nothing like this ever happened, as most people shall readily recognize the Native American Indians were treated harshly and unfairly on many occasions. This book is intense and shines a spotlight on a part of history that a lot of people may find uncomfortable and so they choose to ignore it. I highly recommend this book to everyone, it’s really well put together and flows nicely whilst not detracting from the fact that for some this book that we refer to as fiction was in fact reality. I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
This story was written to reflect the terrible circumstances of this Native American mental health institution. Personally I found this story very difficult to read and I found it not a story I wanted to continue reading because of the terrible bad treatment these people experienced and extremely poor medical procedures made me cringe. The story was written well and the story needs to be told and remembered but this is not the type of book I care to use as entertainment. The ending left me with a bit of gratitude to Dr. Barry and Dr. Silk. I thank the author for that little bit of sunshine.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Not for the faint of heart. This story is a gut-twister, evoking anger at man’s inhumanity to his fellow man. The story must be told, but it is also depressing how some will brutalize others that are powerless to retaliate, just because they can. It is a far reaching scenario that plays out in many areas and levels of society, those who disbelieve, those who can not see the truth of the situation, and those who discern the truth but are too afraid of either landing in the same situation or losing their livelihood to do any thing about what they know. You will have to read the story to see if humanity wins out or not.
This is a very powerful book so many people do not understand what the Native Americans went through. From the schools setting out to destroy their culture to the institution in this story, these people were treated in horrible ways. The book is honest and will open your eyes to a very forgot piece of history. This is not a sugar-coated piece and I highly recommend this book to those that want to understand and learn about this time in history. I did receive a free copy of this book and voluntarily chose to review it.
This is possibly the best book covering this aspect of our history that I have ever read. I am Cherokee myself and am always seeking information on the plight of the Native American both in history and today. I love the information in this book and thank the author for sharing it.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
this book broken my heart and educated me, because after I was done reading, I looked up the Canton Indian Insane Asylum, and to my horror, it was a real place. That said, Dr. Silk was a real person and saved the patients.
Sometimes difficult to read because of its brutal honesty, Fallen Hopes, Taken Dreams illustrates a tragic, yet important, chapter in American history regarding the horrific treatment of Native Americans and the eradication of their culture. The novel centers around Tesqua, an Apache, who has been sent to the Canton Insane Asylum after being convicted of violent behavior. There he befriends other Native Americans, some genuinely mentally ill while others have been falsely placed there. The asylum is run by the ambitious, yet uncompassionate Doctor Wallace who secretly experiments on patients using electric shock therapy. A sadistic orderly named Nathan abuses patients- particularly the women. The result is that patients die regularly - just as they did in the real facility in which one-third of the patients died over the thirty-two year period that the asylum was open. Contrarily, Doctor Barry and Nurse Thompson show compassion when able, yet are powerless to make any permanent changes to enrich the lives of those under their care. Tesqua's prior life is revealed through his memories. Though he is fictional, I was left wanting to know more about reservation life and about legislation that controlled the Native Americans and left them disenfranchised. The novel is enjoyable to read; however, I would suggest a couple edits if there are any re-writes. First, "mortar and pistol" needs replaced by the correct term "mortar and pestle" when describing the making of medicine. Secondly, I find a discrepancy between Nurse Thompson's noted disapproval of cursing and her repeated exclamations of "bloody" throughout the novel.
I was pleasantly surprised by the fact that I really enjoyed this book, given the dark subject matter. Set in the 1920's, it tells the story of young, mentally healthy Native Americans who are locked up against their will in the Canton Insane Asylum.
The positives: I loved the plot of the book and the many twists and turns it took me on as a reader. The story of Tesqua, Mana, Evey and the people tasked with looking after their well-being is a truly heart-wrenching tale filled with suspense, romance, and horror. It's hard to believe that this story is derived from what actually took place not so long ago.
The negatives: I wasn't a huge fan of the cover art but we all know you shouldn't judge a book by its cover. And I found it a little jarring when the story switched from Jimmy (Tesqua's) viewpoint to another character's viewpoint after ten chapters in.
Overall, this was truly one of the most satisfying books I've read in quite some time. I highly recommend this book.
*I won this book through the Firstreads giveaway program.
This is the story of 4 young Native Americans trapped inside an insane asylum during the 1920s. Tesqua, Mana, Evey and Sam were all placed there for different reasons and had been there for varying lengths of time. Tesqua rises as a pillar of strength to defy the brutal treatment from some of the asylum's despicable staff. There were times you couldn't help but weep for these people. There were those staff (a doctor and a nurse) that genuinely cared about the Indians locked away in there, but they are kept from doing anything to help them. The intimate relationships between the major characters keeps you riveted to the story. The book does not delve deeply in the Bureau of Indian Affairs so it becomes difficult to understand why these things were allowed to exist. I don't want to give away any spoilers, which makes a proper review of this book very difficult. Knowing anything in advance in this story, to me, deprives you of the story's great impact. It isn't until the end that you fully come to realize the true depth of this tale.
I highly recommend this book for those who want to read something that is different and meaningful. This is no puff piece.
I received a copy of this book in the goodreads giveaway. This book is one of the best books I have read in a long time!! So realistic that I am still not exactly sure how much of this book is fiction. I had to check several times to see that I was reading a fictional novel. I am almost certain that some of the events were probably true events. It is a tragic story of an Indian insane asylum that not only houses the insane but any Indian that might somehow have been viewed as a problem to someone. The Indians suffered severe abuse and were never ever meant to be released from this asylum that was more of a prison than a medical facility. J.M. Barlog did a fantastic job in conveying the way these Indians must have felt. I look forward to reading more written by him.
Took me a long time to get into this book, it was not what I was expecting I guess. How the main character ends up being admitted to the asylum is confusing if you are unaware of the fact that people can be held in there for little or no reason. I enjoyed the characters of Mana(Charley) and Grano(Harold), much more than the story of the main character Tesqua(Jimmy). Was not a bad book, just not a book for me.
I got this on a friend's recommendation and I'm really glad I did. At times it was funny, but mostly it was heart-wrenching. The terrible things these people endured stays with you. The entire time I was reading I pictured this story being played out on the big screen. If you're a fan of Native American reading, you have to read this book. Not so much because it's a romance of a different kind, but because it's unforgettable.
I must say this is an excellent book that does not follow any standard fictional formula. The characters are very well developed and the plot holds you in its grip. One can only wonder what really happened in that terrible place. This is one book that's definitely worth its price. If you like Native American books, read this one!
I am grateful to have won this very interesting book. It was definitely a page turner. I found myself caring about the patients and rooting for them to win. It is unfortunate that people were actually treated this way. Well written J.M. Barlog!
Received a free copy of this book. It's a story that needed to be told and reminds me a lot of the stories of the residential schools in Canada. It shows that despite the horrors, you can't lose faith in all of humanity and must remain hopeful.
An emotionally powerful tale of native hardship. Parts of this novel hurt me deeply and yet other parts left me stunned, speechless even. I would definitely recommend this novel.
The proofreading must have been a little spotty (self-published) and some parts were a little confusing to figure out what was happening with who, but this was a an easy and good educational read.