I enjoyed this anthology and the variety of the stories, but there wasn't one that really stood out, in my opinion, even if each one of them had something unique.
Tree Topper by Jane Davitt.
Martin is a new Dom and his sub, Stan, seems more than he can handle. I liked this story. Martin is older, well meaning, concerned, but he doesn't seem to reach through Stan, who's not very obedient and who doesn't seem to take him seriously. We learn that Stan comes from an abusive relationship, his behavior makes slowly more sense and the two men decide to start over. The transition is compressed in few pages, it would have been great to see some more of the change of attitude. I even thought that the sex was almost unnecessary, because what the characters went through was satisfying for me and the result was clear even outside the bedroom (bedroom in a metaphorical sense, of course.)
'Twas the Night by Ava March.
Very good Regency story. Percy is the perfect submissive, and Michael would for once love to give Percy what he openly asks for. Percy was a fascinating character and I would love the whole novel about these two characters. Percy is not ambitious, his family would like for him to become a barrister, but Percy loves his humbler work as an office clerk. He is torn between his desires and the expectations of society, because his submission to another man is both unlawful and unworthy of a respectable gentleman. Michael is clearly a man who has come to terms with his inclination and he wants Percy to understand that what he feels is not wrong. It's a concern beyond that of a dominant, it's the concern of a man who cares for the other. There was maybe too much insistence on a few details, eyelashes and ink-stained fingers, but it's a minor flaw.
Fireworks by Katie Porter.
First story I read by this author and also my first f/f with a D/s theme. Emma, the sub, and Rachel, her Ma'am, are spending the last night together before Rachel leaves for Tokio, ending their relationship. Emma is in love with Rachel and she probably knows the other woman's heart better than Rachel does herself. Rachel is apparently strong, but she's a bit of a coward in matters of the heart. I confess that I was almost at a point where I felt I wouldn't finish it, because Rachel and Emma play at a level I'm uncomfortable with, but I was glad I read on, because the last part, when Emma was more vulnerable and open and easily hurt, really spoke to me, especially when she was confronted with how incapable Rachel was of taking a risk, of opening herself to Emma for once. I am surprised I liked it.
Candy Caning by L.A. Witt.
Nate, the sub, and Stephen, the Dom, have to face another Christmas at Nate's parents'. Nate would like for once to spare Stephen from his mother's insulting attitude, and at the same time Stephen wants to help Nate relax. A trip to the department store to buy the last presents sparks the promise of a kinky game with a candy cane. This was maybe the more funny story and the one with less emotional impact. It's not something bad, on the contrary, it was maybe the most Christmas-y of the whole anthology. I liked the snippets about Nate's family, about their domesticity in need of a little additional spark. It's the story of an ordinary Christmas with a pretty ribbon on top.
Submissive Angel by Joey W. Hill.
Another author I read for the first time. The beginning of the story was very good. Robert, the owner of a traditional Victorian toy shop, finds Ange in an alley and rescues him, or better, he heeds Ange's plea to be saved. Ange repairs things everyone has discarded. He is a sweet man, devoted to Robert, caring, talented. After six months of spending time with him, Robert can't deny his feelings for Ange anymore, and he can't help feeling Ange's desire to submit to him. At the end of the story though I felt that this story didn't deliver its full potential. Even if it's from Robert's point-of-view, his intentions and needs weren't so clear and a whole lot of his past emotional baggage was left unexplained. What was behind Ange's initial beating was also left unexplained for reasons that I didn't find convincing. There was a slight paranormal atmosphere, but nothing paranormal in the story, even if Robert and Ange's meeting seems that of two destined lovers. I was expecting for something that didn't happen. That's why I felt there was something sweet in the air, but the sex took its place. I enjoyed it, but it could have been much more.
Open Return by Elyan Smith.
My first time for this author too. Zach comes back from Australia and he meets the two people he left behind, Laura and Scott. Zach left his town as Hanna and comes back as Zach. He's different, he spent time trying to find himself, but Laura and Scott's dominance left a void in his soul that he hasn't been able to fill. When he returns, he doesn't know if he can fit in again, and he has to find out what has changed and what has stayed the same. The story is in Zach's point-of-view, and I had the impression it was a very narrow view on what's around him, very focused on his own needs, even when they involve other people. Probably that's what I had a problem with, the fact I couldn't get a clear read on Laura and Scott. My way of reading this is surely very shallow, but I wasn't able to find a sign of empathy. Zach was almost unreachable, that's also why I felt I was a spectator who couldn't get close, I felt very much at the outside of everything. Maybe Zach got what he wanted, but in my opinion it wasn't enough. And I know I've written in plenty of my reviews that we cannot judge what people look for in their quest for love, but this time I really have to impose myself my own conviction.
Ring Out the Old and In the New by Alexa Snow.
This is another story that maybe deserved a few more pages to be perfect. Evan has been attacked in the London Tube and he's been scarred. His face reminds him of the attack and he's too embarrassed to meet people again, because he feels ugly. Russell, his Dom, wants to help him get over his trauma. Evan is really in a complicated place in his head at the moment, and even if the author doesn't go too deep into his hurt, you can't help feeling Evan's insecurity and fear. His Dom is an assuring presence. There is maybe a bit of sexual healing, but it's well done, it draws from their relationship.
His Very Last Chance by Kim Dare.
This was my favorite, but I'm a Kim Dare's fangirl. Drew was overheard by Kingsley, his Dom, saying that his Dom doesn't have a romantic bone in his body. He meant it as a sort of compliment, but his Dom seems to resent him. Kingsley has summoned him in a hotel room to give him a last chance to remedy to his misstep. Drew is more terrified of losing his Dom than the punishment Kingsley will probably inflict on him, but he doesn't know that Kingsley is afraid of losing something in turn. The plot revolves around some sort of miscommunication. Drew misreads Kingsley's control for coldness and he's so caught up in himself that he doesn't see the small cracks in his Dom's armor. Kingsley, on the other hand, has to have the courage to be more open to Drew and take a small risk to be able to bring their relationship to another level. I think this is the most romantic story in the collection and I read it with a big smile on my face, enjoying Drew's blind panic and Kingsley's masked insecurity.
The last story had also my favorite quote of the book:
"Romance? Perhaps. But vanilla? Give me some credit, Drew."
If you're not looking for a vanilla Christmas, this is for you.