It was supposed to be a holiday. In New York City. A chance for Tom to do some drawing, and for Charlie to see the sights.
The streets of the city seem safe and clean. Everyone is friendly, and the doughnuts are to die for.
Charlie and Tom have an unexpected encounter with the past in a piano bar, but it’s OK. They’ve got the Atlantic Ocean between them and the troubles of the last year. It’s all behind them.
Until they get asked for help in an unexplained death.
I wish I'd liked this as much as I did the first two.
It's something of a switch in genres: still a murder mystery, and still with Charlie solving the murder(s), but in the mood of action-adventure rather than police procedural, and the trouble with setting action-adventure in NYC is that you not only have to keep your plot straight, you also have to be intimately familiar with the city. Well, you do if you want realism.
I should say that Ripley does a better job with NYC than 9 out of any 10 writers: her version of the city is at least recognizable to someone who lives here. I did a certain amount of wincing at the edges -- it's not often that street traffic in Manhattan will enable a speedy getaway in a car (a bicycle or motorbike would be a whole lot quicker), for instance, and there's a point where . I had a couple more nits to pick with respect to the Manhattan landscape and geography: constant sirens (nah -- frequent, sure, but not constant by any means), a hospital with a food court that has every existing fast-food restaurant (nah; source: I have done a lot of time in various NYC hospitals and there might be an Au Bon Pain); Charlie at one point "not recognizing" street numbers, which, what?
There's also a moment when Charlie "sinks onto the floor" of an elevator in a housing project, and this tells me that neither Ripley nor anyone she knows has ever set foot in a housing-project elevator. (Yes, I speak from experience.)
But the bigger problems here were the plot holes, the weird factual errors, and, secondarily, some lazy writing:
- Charlie has his own phone, and Tom's, with him while he's on the run. He mainly uses a brand-new phone supplied by a secondary character, but not a word is said about locations even being turned off, never mind that my speedy Googling informs me it's possible to track a phone anyway. He does take the SIM card out of his own phone, but I don't think he ever turns Tom's phone off.
- Charlie also uses Tom's credit card at least once while he's on the run. Again, tracking.
- At one point, the aforementioned secondary character is following Charlie in a car as Charlie walks along the street, but . Driving in Manhattan is slow, but it's not that slow. Nor is it explained how .
- One of the murder victims works for the FBI; Charlie, on seeing the guy's apartment, wonders whether the FBI knew where he was living. Uh ... yeah, Charlie, odds are they did.
- Charlie knows that US Marshals have "almost unlimited powers." Well ... I guess they do, in the sense that LEOs tend to do whatever with total impunity, but as a matter of their official role, no, they don't. It's a completely irrelevant detail that goes nowhere, so why Ripley included it, and without checking for accuracy, I can't imagine.
- A crucial secondary character lies to Charlie and withholds information throughout, for no reason that's ever explained . We also never learn how this guy missed the boat when .
- There are three, count 'em, three, toxic mothers in this book: Charlie's, Tom's, and one other. A subtle pattern begins to emerge, etc.
So all in all this was something of a disappointment after the first two books. I'll give the series another chance whenever #4 appears.
I'll start off by saying I love Ripley Hayes, and I love Charlie Rees. I enjoyed this book, but it may have been my least favorite of the 3 - since it takes place in NYC, there isn't the strong sense of place that's so present in the books set in Wales that adds depth and complexity to the characters and stories. In many ways Wales is another character in Ripley's books, and I missed that here. It was enjoyable, and quite different in that it was more like an action-packed thriller than her typical mysteries. As someone who works in healthcare in the US, I was also irritated by the whole only-family-can-visit issue in the hospital (I won't go into more detail to avoid spoilers) - it was so outside the norm of what would actually happen under those circumstances and such an outdated concept that I found it annoying and distracting. Maybe in the 90s, but not in 21st century progressive NYC. I really hope we see more of Charlie and Tom, and that they make a safe and speedy return home to Wales!
A shockingly violent act covered within the first couple of chapters heralds a fast-paced, action-packed murder procedural set in NYC far from Charlie Rees' territory. No-one is who they appear to be and poor Charlie has to avoid injury/death by his wits and sheer gutsy-ness without much help from his little policing team; TG Mal Kent makes a brief appearance! 4.5 stars.
So firstly I want to say. I loved this series. Every single one of these books shocked me. Each one gives you so much information you find yourself guessing what happened, I have not once guessed completely correctly. The funny thing is once its all revealed you look back and it makes total sense and there were so many clues. Im not the biggest mystery fan in general but I loved these books and would definitely recommend them. However the reason this book lost stars is because though it still had all those things I mentioned there was just too much filler for me. There is a character who is unconscious for most of this book an yet they still get chapters told from their perspective.... why? It's such a waste of ink in my opinion and adds nothing whatsoever to the story.
Really enjoyed this book. Tom and Charlie are in New York for a vacation and for Tom to do some of his art. The pair are caught up in a shooting in a bookstore and Tom is badly injured and although Charlie is a hero, the Feds are after him as they believe he was the shooter. Charlie has his own idea as to who the intended victim was and starts his own investigation.
I am hoping there will be further books in this series.
I usually love this author but I was really disappointed in this one. It felt forced, like it was trying too hard to be a commentary on the times. There’s enough real news about the cult of maga, they don’t need to be the main characters in a mystery.
After a couple of books set in Wales, Ripley Hayes moves book 3 to New York as Charlie Rees tries to investigate a shooting that resulted in Tom being shot in the crossfire. With different scenery and different law enforcement, this book has a distinctly different feel to it than the previous two. Now that’s not a bad thing as I always loved how Ripley Hayes made each one of the Daniel Owen books feel very different and original. However what isn’t different is her gloomy writing of Charlie Rees’s character. He comes across in these books as a completely different character to the one we met in the Daniel Owen series. In fact she may as well have just introduced a completely new character for this series rather trying to do some sort of crossover.
However there are some great twists and turns in this book, making it more exciting than the previous ones. Unfortunately the side characters are a bit more forgettable and there are quite a few times you have to suspend belief in order to accept some of the plot threads, but on the whole it’s a good addition to the series. One of the other things I like about this book was how she wrote from Tom’s point of view whilst he was in a coma… very original. Those scenes were particularly effective to me and offered a perfect balance between dreamscape and reality. Plus the opening really kicked off the book with a powerful punch, flipping the drama on its head by starting the book with one almighty crescendo.
But as the book drew to a close it was hard to know whether the author intended to continue with this series as there really wasn’t much of an emotional arc to warrant another book in this series. That’s not to say I wouldn’t want another book, but I feel less invested in Charlie and Tom’s relationship and career than I did with Daniel and Mal’s. And I think that is mainly down to Charlie and Tom being fairly boring characters. In fact I really missed Eddy in this one. Now there’s a character who offered more life and engagement in his one short story than we’ve had from Charlie and Tom in 3 whole books! Still, if you’ve enjoyed how Charlie has been written in this series, you’ll love this book.
Murder in Shades of Red (DS Rees 3) By Ripley Hayes Published by the author, 2023 5 stars
I have really liked all the books (three, plus the prequel) in this series by Welsh author Ripley Hayes. Hayes establishes Charlie Rees (Detective Sargeant Rees) as a funny, complicated, and profoundly good person, caught up in circumstances beyond his control—and somehow managing to rise above the worst situation.
Shades of Red, set in New York City, starts off hard, at the scene of a mass shooting as seen through Charlie’s eyes. The two important things about this scene (about which the author offers a trigger warning at the beginning) are that (1) Charlie is a hero and (2) he cannot prevent terrible things from happening. The rest of the book alternates between Charle’s point of view and that of his art-school-principal boyfriend Tom. Coping with trauma and fear, Charlie is nonetheless sucked into a mad, Kafkaesque crime drama in which he finds he can’t seem to trust anybody. Even his close friends appear to be going against him; and the strangers in the tale, well forget about it.
Somehow, Hayes manages to keep the action light-hearted, even when it’s grim. I don’t know how that is accomplished, but maybe it’s because Charlie’s character is gentle and humorous, even when teetering on the edge of despair. Hayes imparts a great sense of place in the New York City of today, its surreal grittiness and sublime beauty, looming around Charlie in the wake a vacation with Tom turned nightmare.
It's not just readable, but, like the previous volumes in this series, is crisp and clever, human goodness contrasted with the worst of human nature. There is some pretty overt political commentary, which I personally loved, and which is very much tuned to the moment we’re living in here in the USA.
Here’s wishing Charlie Rees and his adventures a long life.
There’s an intensity to this installment of Charlie’s adventures: it’s dark and gritty and unrelenting from the start, and the stakes are deeply personal and scarily high (think life, death, liberty and loss of all happiness level high). It’s an adrenaline rush to be sure, but I ended up feeling as much wrung out as relieved by the time I got to the “all's well that ends well” part of the story. I love Charlie and Tom as characters, and their developing relationship is a bright light that, at least in previous books, nicely balances the darkness and danger that goes with the intrigue and mystery. In this book, however, the peril is constant and deeply personal, the relationship is under threat from pretty much every possible angle, and everyone is an inch away from death (figuratively and even sometimes literally) at any given moment. I love where this story ends, but getting there is…a lot. Still, readers looking to see some interesting plot threads from previous books in the series to be woven into some deeply dramatic new patterns in this one will not be disappointed— there are some familiar faces along with a new setting (New York, a stark contrast to Wales). All in all, this book is well written, immersive, and impossible to put down: here’s hoping that this won’t be the last readers see of Charlie, Tom, and co.
*I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book.
Firstly, I received an ARC of this book from the author. I have read all of Ripley Hayes' books and I happily recommend them. All stories have been good and I love the Welsh setting and the actual stories themselves. This time though the setting is NYC. The story is much darker than normal and there is plenty of action. Tom and Charlie are in NYC for a holiday and to support their friend who is there for a book launch. There is gun attack at the bookstore and people are injured, including Tom. Charlie wants to be with Tom but he wants to know what is going on. He isn't allowed to be with Charlie as it is family only and their relationship is not recognised so he starts asking awkward questions. He does not believe the official explanation. There is so much action in this book and Ripley conveys so much emotion. I was on the edge of my seat during the kidnapping and the beating. I could feel Charlie's pain and desperation as he tries to get back to his hotel and I could feel his longing for Tom. I also enjoyed looking into Tom's mind as tries to come out of the coma. I started this book last night and stayed in this morning so I could finish the story. I am sure that I saw that this is the last book in this series so I am eagerly awaiting a new title. Murder in Shades of Red is highly recommended.
As much as I am enjoying this series, and I am tremendously, I feel I must start with this. Living outside of the US, as this author does, and having such negative feelings and disrespecting a former president is rather tacky, in my opinion, and didn’t make the story any better; the fact of the matter is it kind of discredited it a bit. Living in the US, myself, I would never think to disrespect a Wales dignitary. Forgive me but I feel this passionately. Now to the actual writing, storyline and story telling, this author, once again, wrote a story that jumped off the pages. Returning characters, just as before, grabbed the reader, held them in suspense until they were ready for the big reveal. Naturally the villain was a surprise, as they have been every time. The creation of this series is terrific, unfortunately the character bashing of a person, ie former president, is troubling. This author is very talented and their ability to create is amazing, I just wish that personal feelings or personal grievances, whether real or make believe, were left out and for once an author would be impartial and simply tell their story, respectfully. I voluntarily reviewed an arc of this book.
Charlie travels with Tom to New York City. Tom plans on working on his art while Charlie plans on seeing the city. Going to a reading changes everything when a mass shooting occurs. Tom is badly injured while Charlie does what he can to save attendees. He gives his statement, but for some reason the FBI have a warrant for his arrest and Charlie goes on the run to prove both his innocence and that law enforcement should be concentrating on a different victim. Tom is in the hospital with his mother striving to keep Charlie out while Charlie is on the streets trying to find a killer.
This was quite different then the first two set in Wales while this one is set in New York City, putting Charlie at a distinct disadvantage. He does know how to solve murders and that is what he plans to do. There were quite a few twists and some surprises. Charlie proves himself to be tenacious and resourceful and more than a match for those twist and turns that are thrown at him. Another engaging and intriguing story, I know I hope for more in this series.
One minute Charlie and Tom and a lot of other people are at a bookstore waiting for a reading and the next thing they know they are living the nightmare of one second normal and the next the thing that we least expect. There is a mass shooting and the trauma that follows. What was especially powerful about the way this story unfolded was the fact that Charlie is a cop and he was heroic and focused as he tried to save the day but still people got hurt and people died. The worst thing for him is the fact that Tom, his boyfriend, is seriously wounded but the police and other law enforcement keep him contained at the scene while they investigate. His frustration and impatience along with his analytic skills as an investigator was so well written. He was both professional and survivor, vulnerable partner and skeptical cop. The back and forth in perspectives between Tom and Charlie was fascinating and it made the vacation that became a trauma event such a quick and satisfying read. I received an ARC from GRR and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I like Charlie and Tom and I was really looking forward to this book and their adventures/mystery in New York.
This story isn’t what I expected and I didn’t enjoy the mystery. I didn’t give one single fuck about Kaylan Scully or who shot him. Why go back to that story? I also had no interest in anything to do with trump. The only way Charlie’s investigation was interesting to me was to see him prove the FBI wrong.
Though I hated that Tom was shot, the most interesting parts of this book are Tom’s coma dreams.
Orianna got on all my nerves. She kept saying she’d call Charlie but he always had to call her. Her partner the college secretary is an idiot. Why would you give out the next of kin info knowing Tom did not get along with his parents. Why hadn’t Tom listed Charlie as his next of kin having been in life and death situations previously? And especially going to another country where something dangerous could happen.
Hopefully there’s another book coming with Charlie and Tom.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I loved this, from the bits of red herring to the nods to one of my favorite songs from the 1980s. Charlie and Tom take a vacation in NYC, only to have the crime that brought them together come back to try and split them apart. The mystery is strong, straightforward, but strong. I read a lot of these, I figured it out sooner than Charlie, but he was highly stressed. However, some of those “bits” were confusing since I ignored the warning and read the trilogy out of order. And I use the word romance sparingly - the duo is already together, and spend most of the time in this book apart, but it’s the love for each other that keeps them going through what’s probably the grimmest of the books but also, for me, the best. Fingers crossed that Charlie (and Tom!) are able to have more mysteries and we get to read them.
Oh man, this is the third book in the DS Charlie Rees series and even after the murders and crime in the first two books I was not as prepared as I thought I was for this book. Plus, it’s in New York City, a place I know and could visualize…warts and all. No escaping to an idyllic Welsh countryside for me in this one!
I appreciated the author’s trigger warning at the beginning of the story, I nearly skipped the shooting but decided at the last minute to just go for it. My heart broke for Charlie (as it seems to do in all the books), for me he one of those characters that I want to wrap in a cozy blanket and bring lots of tea 🫖😅
I feel like I could’ve done with a wee bit more Charlie and Tom being domestic and just enjoying their lives and love for one another, but generally it was another great book in this already excellent series.
I feel bad, as I previous reviewed a book from the Daniel Owen's series, and I wasn't cruel, in fact I enjoyed the book, but felt something missing. But Ripley Hayes has schooled me for sure, because that series kept getting better and better. Then she spun off a minor character from that series into an even better series. Charlie Rees is such a well developed character, and this series is really really good. I loved this trip to New York, loves the whole spy angle built into the mystery, and the twists and turns at the end. I would give this 4.5 stars. It just needed maybe a few extra pages explaining or going into a bit more detail with some of plot points, as there is a large cast, and would have been nice to see the tie in to the murder plot a bit more. Can't wait to continue with this series.
Charlie and Tom travel to NYC to support a poet and explore the city. They got so much more!
A shooting at the bookstore, in which Tom is wounded and Charlie is a witness, turns into the city police, the FBI and Tom's parents conspiring to keep the lovers apart.
There are multiple threads to follow as Charlie struggles to stay alive, solve several crimes and stay out of police/FBI custody.
So many interesting characters.
A fast paced, emotional and tightly woven clues provide a wonderful story while you sprint through NYC...especially Harlem. I'd advise you do it from street level, though.
If you haven't been, be sure to add Grand Central Station to your list!
I've read the entire series and it is not to be missed!
For me this is the perfect series. It has love, romance, intrigue and mystery. Book three raise the bar on the life and romance of Tom and Charlie. What was supposed to be a fun time exploring NYC suddenly turns dark due to a mass shooting and things get more interesting when the case has a connection to the case that brought this wonderful couple together. This one is more mystery than romance but shows how true love can overcome any odds. I was on the edge of my seat through most of this book and changed my mind many times as to where it was headed. Be sure to read the books in order to get full impact. I cannot recommend this book highly enough. I did receive an ARC and leave this honest review.
4.5⭐️ This series keeps getting better and I love seeing Tom and Charlie evolve individually and as a couple. I enjoyed the plot and the change of setting, this one taking place while Charlie and Tom are visiting New York. The opening is really tense and was a great way to grab the reader’s attention, it’s also unfortunately very timely- involving a mass shooter. This one has quite good emotional impact, I really felt for Charlie as he is on the run when all he wants is to be at Tom’s hospital bedside. I also loved how the author skillfully revisits the first book by reintroducing Kaylan Scully in a pretty creative way. Great series, absolutely loved the character growth.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book.
Murder in Shades of Red is book three in the DS Charlie Rees series and is a great addition to it. When Charlie and Tom travel to NYC to support a poet and explore the city they get so much more than they bargained for. A shooting at the bookstore, in which Tom is wounded and Charlie is a witness, turns into the city police, the FBI and Tom's parents conspiring to keep the lovers apart. This one is more mystery than romance but shows how true love can overcome any odds. I was on the edge of my seat through most of this book and changed my mind many times as to where it was headed. All told, though, I'm all in on this series and will eagerly await more.
Charlie and Tom head to New York for a vacation and obviously there will be murder, mayhem and lies. There is just to political nonsense going on even in every aspect is about money. Its always about money, corruption begins and ends there. Charlie, far from home does not know who he can trust. Not the FBI not the police its just one big mess. He can trust his own people and Kent come through for him again. Kayland has been a thorn in his side since the beginning and making enemies wherever he goes and someone has had enough of him. Charlie has to make this right for him and Tom and to move forward with their life.
Oh my ! Talk about the past coming back to haunt you. This does that in spades. What starts out as a wonderful holiday in New York, becomes a nightmare in the worst way for Charlie and Tom. A character from the past is killed and suddenly Charlie becomes the chief suspect. With Tom in a hospital bed fighting for his life and Charlie unable to be by his bedside, for several distressing reasons, life is pretty intense. Shadowed by a local cop (who Charlie is pretty certain is not a local cop), getting beaten up, threatened, warned off and lied to, Charlie has his work cut out for himself. This series is so awesome !!! Love it
I've been looking forward to this book ever since reading the others in the series, and it didn't disappoint much. I missed Wales as a setting, and I found a lot of things confusing , and then all of a sudden it was wrapping up! I expect this is one of those books I'll enjoy more the second time around. All told, though, I'm all in on this series and will eagerly await more.
My thanks to Gay Romance Reviews for an advance copy of this book.
4.5* Much more intense story, as Charlie is a dectective out of water in NYC. Highlighting issues with access to patients if you are not family, and toxic families as well as the toxic obsession with guns in america. Charlie and Dan again don’t spend a lot of time together but we see the story from both perspectives. Charlie is definitely caught up in all sorts of power struggles and indeed has to struggle to stay out of prison. With the help or otherwise of one FBI man, he does finally solve the shootings and why Kaylan was the target.
Every DS Charlie Rees book gets better and better!
Book 1 (Murder in Blue and Green) was excellent. Book 2 (Murder in Wood and Stone) was even better! Murder in Yellow, a sort of prequel to the series was a short but well-written novella. Book 3 (Murder in Red) kept me on the edge of my seat for the better part of a day! Each DS Charlie Rees book gets better and better!
Every character is well developed. Each book feels like I’m stepping into Charlie Rees’ world! On to Book 4…!
The story grabbed my attention from the beginning and kept it throughout the story. The first 4 chapters are disturbing, but all too real for those of us that live in the US. I have always enjoyed this series and I continue to, but this book was different and I agree with another author that this book will require re-reading due to the twists and turns of the story. Definitely recommend reading.
This is another good addition to the series, the setting for this one is nyc where Charlie and Tom have went on holiday to support a friend who has a book signing, this is an action packed story from the beginning that will keep you on the the edge of your seat, it’s a bit darker than the previous books in the series, (please read trigger warnings) but again it’s well written with just the right amount of twists when needed, looking forward to reading more from this author in the future.