What do you think?
Rate this book
Loving Miss Tilney
She’s forbidden to wed a nobody. He’s nothing in society’s eyes. Will their desperate schemes backfire before they find a way to be together?
Northanger Abbey. Eleanor Tilney can’t bear her lonely life any longer. Distraught when her tyrannical father throws her friend out of the house because the girl lacks an inheritance, the long-suffering general’s daughter decides anything is better than a future all alone. So in a frantic bid for freedom, she puts aside her tender feelings for a man of no standing to pursue a wealthy husband.
Philip Brampton understands that fortune is against him. And he tries gallantly to bury his distress and support his lonely beloved, even after she starts pursuing an arrogant buffoon. But when he catches the fellow about to kiss her, their resulting harsh words cause a heartbreaking rift.
Stiffening her spine in a world that refuses to acknowledge her value, Eleanor attempts to navigate the impossible situation without quashing her desires. And though his shy nature abhors a scene, Philip braces himself for a confrontation with her cruel and abusive patriarch. Do these childhood sweethearts have any hope of achieving lasting happiness?
Northanger Abbey. Eleanor Tilney can’t bear her lonely life any longer. Distraught when her tyrannical father throws her friend out of the house because the girl lacks an inheritance, the long-suffering general’s daughter decides anything is better than a future all alone. So in a frantic bid for freedom, she puts aside her tender feelings for a man of no standing to pursue a wealthy husband.
Philip Brampton understands that fortune is against him. And he tries gallantly to bury his distress and support his lonely beloved, even after she starts pursuing an arrogant buffoon. But when he catches the fellow about to kiss her, their resulting harsh words cause a heartbreaking rift.
Stiffening her spine in a world that refuses to acknowledge her value, Eleanor attempts to navigate the impossible situation without quashing her desires. And though his shy nature abhors a scene, Philip braces himself for a confrontation with her cruel and abusive patriarch. Do these childhood sweethearts have any hope of achieving lasting happiness?
196 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 1, 2023
5 people are currently reading
36 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 23 of 23 reviews
August 1, 2023
A Northanger Abbey variation
When her father becomes nothing less than unbearable, Eleanor finds herself desperate to leave Northanger Abbey and find some independence. With the help of a friend, she decides to attempt to attach herself to someone of whom her father would approve, even if there is no love between them. Sadly for Philip, she does this in his presence, breaking his heart and her own. Will she be able to accept a proposal from a baronet she has worked to obtain? What will that do to Philip if she does?
I believe I’ve only read one other variation for Northanger Abbey, and that one was a bit of a romp, focusing on Catherine and Henry. While that couple are mentioned in this book and are the catalyst for Eleanor’s determination to leave the house of her father, Eleanor and Philip are the main protagonists. I was drawn to these unfortunate lovers, empathising with Eleanor’s seemingly hopeless situation, but not always agreeing with her plans, just as Philip couldn’t. Poor, shy and reserved Philip lacks the status and courage to stand up to the General, believing that even if he were to offer for Eleanor, he would not be granted permission. How will these two ever find a happy ending? Be assured there is one.
A very good, well-written story, as are all of Heather Moll’s books. None have disappointed me and I’m happy to recommend this one too. This was a refreshing diversion from the Pride and Prejudice variations I usually read.
Mature content
I received an ARC of this book from the author and am voluntarily providing an honest review. I also purchased the published version for my Kindle library.
Audiobook Review:
Stevie Zimmerman skillfully brings Heather Moll’s creative story about Eleanor Tilney’s friendship and forbidden romance with Philip Brampton to life. Her performance of the father tyrant, General Tilney, was perfection. The audiobook beautifully portrays Eleanor and Philip’s struggles, as Eleanor seeks independence and makes difficult choices that break both their hearts. This book is a captivating variation of Northanger Abbey. The excellent narration and well-written story make it a highly recommended listen, offering a refreshing diversion from the typical Pride and Prejudice variations. In Northanger Abbey, Jane Austen didn’t provide too much information about Eleanor Tilney’s love interest—not much more than him being an impoverished man who inherits a viscountcy. Heather Moll has changed that for us in her latest novel, Loving Miss Tilney. In this book, he is identified, and the author weaves an interesting story about Eleanor and her long time friend, Philip Brampton. While it is never declared out loud, they love each other, but both know they can never marry because Philip only has a meagre income of five hundred pounds a year—hardly enough to satisfy Eleanor’s tyrant of a father, General Tilney, who is determined to have his children marry for money and connections. Full book review follows.
***
When her father becomes nothing less than unbearable, Eleanor finds herself desperate to leave Northanger Abbey and find some independence. With the help of a friend, she decides to attempt to attach herself to someone of whom her father would approve, even if there is no love between them. Sadly for Philip, she does this in his presence, breaking his heart and her own. Will she be able to accept a proposal from a baronet she has worked to obtain? What will that do to Philip if she does?
I believe I’ve only read one other variation for Northanger Abbey, and that one was a bit of a romp, focusing on Catherine and Henry. While that couple are mentioned in this book and are the catalyst for Eleanor’s determination to leave the house of her father, Eleanor and Philip are the main protagonists. I was drawn to these unfortunate lovers, empathising with Eleanor’s seemingly hopeless situation, but not always agreeing with her plans, just as Philip couldn’t. Poor, shy and reserved Philip lacks the status and courage to stand up to the General, believing that even if he were to offer for Eleanor, he would not be granted permission. How will these two ever find a happy ending? Be assured there is one.
A very good, well-written story, as are all of Heather Moll’s books. None have disappointed me and I’m happy to recommend this one too. This was a refreshing diversion from the Pride and Prejudice variations I usually read.
Mature content
I received an ARC of this book from the author and am voluntarily providing an honest review. I also purchased the published version for my Kindle library.
Audiobook Review:
Stevie Zimmerman skillfully brings Heather Moll’s creative story about Eleanor Tilney’s friendship and forbidden romance with Philip Brampton to life. Her performance of the father tyrant, General Tilney, was perfection. The audiobook beautifully portrays Eleanor and Philip’s struggles, as Eleanor seeks independence and makes difficult choices that break both their hearts. This book is a captivating variation of Northanger Abbey. The excellent narration and well-written story make it a highly recommended listen, offering a refreshing diversion from the typical Pride and Prejudice variations. In Northanger Abbey, Jane Austen didn’t provide too much information about Eleanor Tilney’s love interest—not much more than him being an impoverished man who inherits a viscountcy. Heather Moll has changed that for us in her latest novel, Loving Miss Tilney. In this book, he is identified, and the author weaves an interesting story about Eleanor and her long time friend, Philip Brampton. While it is never declared out loud, they love each other, but both know they can never marry because Philip only has a meagre income of five hundred pounds a year—hardly enough to satisfy Eleanor’s tyrant of a father, General Tilney, who is determined to have his children marry for money and connections. Full book review follows.
***
December 28, 2023
Is a Loveless Marriage Worse Than Oppressed Tyranny?
Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
Source: Review Copy from Author
TYPE OF NOVEL: Northanger Abbey Secondary Character
THE PREMISE: Eleanor marries and becomes a Viscountess at the end of Northanger Abbey. But what is her story? Who is the gentleman she partial to? How do they both deal being attached but knowing the General would never sanction their match? Heather Moll provides some answers…
WHAT I LOVED:
- It’s Northanger Abbey: We need more Northanger Abbey books published! I feel like Northanger Abbey and Mansfied Park are the two major Austen works we see significantly less Austenesque works published. So needless to say, I’m grateful to Heather Moll for picking up her pen to help correct the deficit.
- It’s Eleanor: And not only is Ms. Moll giving readers a story about one of Jane Austen’s more neglected works, she is choosing to write about a secondary character! And not just any secondary character – but one who readers are already endeared towards and who very much deserves to be the heroine of her own story. There is so much to admire about Eleanor – she is sensible, sensitive, and a steadfast friend.
- Realistic and Troubling Limitations: As the cover suggests, Heather Moll portrays Eleanor as “the real gothic heroine of Northanger Abbey.” And to be sure Eleanor’s life seems to be a horrifying nightmare. The general is tyrannical, unfeeling, harsh, and demeaning. And as a dependent woman of her time, Eleanor has precious little she can do about it. Her predicament and choices illustrate the oppression, the suffering, the hopelessness, and the desperation a woman can feel in this situation. I felt such sympathy and compassion for Eleanor. Her decisions to try and steer her life in new directions felt justifiable and credible.
- The Anonymous Viscount: A steady, thoughtful, and uncomplicated type of hero – Philip Barlow is a gentleman with a small income and no profession. He lives simply and enjoys occupying his time with the study of advance mathematics. I appreciated Philip’s evolution of emotions throughout this novel. His feelings of disappointment and anger felt authentic and understandable. However, I loved seeing his sincere regard and respect for Eleanor and his brotherly devotion and admiration for his cousin Lord Vaughn even more.
- Eleanor’s Thoughts: I love how Heather Moll showed us the inner workings of Eleanor’s mind as she tries to cope with her even bleaker living conditions and contemplates marrying someone she doesn’t love. Her words are incredibly poignant and eloquent:
“I think my feelings are too oppressed now even for tears.”
“How much of myself do I have to suppress to be around my father.”
“I am a strong woman even if I have no power.”
That last one… what a mantra to live by. 😮
WHAT COULD HAVE BEEN BETTER:
Balance: The scenes of General Tilney’s cruelty are so painful to witness and bring about such darkness and negativity, that to balance such ugly energy a few more scenes of love and light are needed. In addition, a lot of Eleanor’s and Philip’s romance is told to the reader (since their relationship predates this novel). I wouldn’t have minded more showing – maybe with some flashbacks to pivotal moments of them falling in love? I think that would have brought about an even stronger emotional connection for the reader.
FINAL THOUGHTS:
✨ One of Jane Austen’s most intiguing and worthy secret heroines steps onto center stage.
👿 I didn’t know it was possible, but somehow General Tilney can become even more atrociously loathsome.
💪🏼 A sympathetic exploration of a dependent woman’s limited liberties, challenging choices, and enduring strength.
Austenesque Reviews
Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
Source: Review Copy from Author
TYPE OF NOVEL: Northanger Abbey Secondary Character
THE PREMISE: Eleanor marries and becomes a Viscountess at the end of Northanger Abbey. But what is her story? Who is the gentleman she partial to? How do they both deal being attached but knowing the General would never sanction their match? Heather Moll provides some answers…
WHAT I LOVED:
- It’s Northanger Abbey: We need more Northanger Abbey books published! I feel like Northanger Abbey and Mansfied Park are the two major Austen works we see significantly less Austenesque works published. So needless to say, I’m grateful to Heather Moll for picking up her pen to help correct the deficit.
- It’s Eleanor: And not only is Ms. Moll giving readers a story about one of Jane Austen’s more neglected works, she is choosing to write about a secondary character! And not just any secondary character – but one who readers are already endeared towards and who very much deserves to be the heroine of her own story. There is so much to admire about Eleanor – she is sensible, sensitive, and a steadfast friend.
- Realistic and Troubling Limitations: As the cover suggests, Heather Moll portrays Eleanor as “the real gothic heroine of Northanger Abbey.” And to be sure Eleanor’s life seems to be a horrifying nightmare. The general is tyrannical, unfeeling, harsh, and demeaning. And as a dependent woman of her time, Eleanor has precious little she can do about it. Her predicament and choices illustrate the oppression, the suffering, the hopelessness, and the desperation a woman can feel in this situation. I felt such sympathy and compassion for Eleanor. Her decisions to try and steer her life in new directions felt justifiable and credible.
- The Anonymous Viscount: A steady, thoughtful, and uncomplicated type of hero – Philip Barlow is a gentleman with a small income and no profession. He lives simply and enjoys occupying his time with the study of advance mathematics. I appreciated Philip’s evolution of emotions throughout this novel. His feelings of disappointment and anger felt authentic and understandable. However, I loved seeing his sincere regard and respect for Eleanor and his brotherly devotion and admiration for his cousin Lord Vaughn even more.
- Eleanor’s Thoughts: I love how Heather Moll showed us the inner workings of Eleanor’s mind as she tries to cope with her even bleaker living conditions and contemplates marrying someone she doesn’t love. Her words are incredibly poignant and eloquent:
“I think my feelings are too oppressed now even for tears.”
“How much of myself do I have to suppress to be around my father.”
“I am a strong woman even if I have no power.”
That last one… what a mantra to live by. 😮
WHAT COULD HAVE BEEN BETTER:
Balance: The scenes of General Tilney’s cruelty are so painful to witness and bring about such darkness and negativity, that to balance such ugly energy a few more scenes of love and light are needed. In addition, a lot of Eleanor’s and Philip’s romance is told to the reader (since their relationship predates this novel). I wouldn’t have minded more showing – maybe with some flashbacks to pivotal moments of them falling in love? I think that would have brought about an even stronger emotional connection for the reader.
FINAL THOUGHTS:
✨ One of Jane Austen’s most intiguing and worthy secret heroines steps onto center stage.
👿 I didn’t know it was possible, but somehow General Tilney can become even more atrociously loathsome.
💪🏼 A sympathetic exploration of a dependent woman’s limited liberties, challenging choices, and enduring strength.
Austenesque Reviews
June 26, 2023
The question isn’t who’s going to let me — it’s who’s going to stop me. ~ Ayn Rand
Tyrant; Despot; Autocrat; Bully; Dictator; Oppressor.
All these words can be applied to General Tilney, father of two sons and a daughter who have lived under his rule. The opening scene of “Loving Miss Tilney” sets the stage for the conflict in the story.
Quote from the book: As soon as the words were spoken, Eleanor wished them unsaid. Her father turned on his heel and pierced her with a stare. She was twenty-two, she was mistress of his house, but it was a nominal role.
I have no power here.
Eleanor Tilney is the daughter of General Tilney, who rules his household and his children with threats and willingly follows through with any punishment he chooses.
He learns that Eleanor’s friend, Catherine Morland, is not the heiress he had believed her to be and throws her from the house. His son, Henry, disobeys him by proposing marriage to Catherine, and the General disowns him. Eleanor has every reason to be afraid.
As in canon Northanger Abbey, Eleanor is in love with a childhood friend, a distant relation, Philip Brampton, honourable but definitely not rich enough to suit her father.
The General and Eleanor visit Lord and Lady Longtown at their home seat. Several eligible gentlemen will attend the house party. One ineligible gentleman will also attend: Philip Brampton.
It’s easy to be independent when you’ve got money. But to be independent when you haven’t got a thing, that’s the Lord’s test. ~ Mahalia Jackson
Eleanor has desperately wanted independence from her father for many years. Unfortunately, at her time in history, the only independence possible for a gentlewoman was to become attached to another man via marriage. Eleanor knows she will never be allowed to marry her love. She will choose another and marry as soon as possible.
Philip must witness Eleanor’s flirtations. Only two possible futures remain.
Will Eleanor and Philip fail the Lord’s test?
I am no bird; no net ensnares me: I am a free human being with an independent will. ~ Charlotte Bronte
As you might guess from my choice of quotes about independence, I was a little uneasy about the resolution of this story. Looking at it from my life experience as a Baby Boomer who lived through the sexual revolution and women’s movement, I had hoped Eleanor and Philip would be a bit bolder. This is unfair of me. Eleanor and Philip were much more restricted and did the best they could.
That said, this is a great story, well-told, and unusual in the world of JAFF.
Behind every strong independent woman lies a broken little girl who had to learn how to get back up and to never depend upon anyone. ~ Author Unknown
I received a free copy of this book from the author. I am voluntarily leaving a review.
Tyrant; Despot; Autocrat; Bully; Dictator; Oppressor.
All these words can be applied to General Tilney, father of two sons and a daughter who have lived under his rule. The opening scene of “Loving Miss Tilney” sets the stage for the conflict in the story.
Quote from the book: As soon as the words were spoken, Eleanor wished them unsaid. Her father turned on his heel and pierced her with a stare. She was twenty-two, she was mistress of his house, but it was a nominal role.
I have no power here.
Eleanor Tilney is the daughter of General Tilney, who rules his household and his children with threats and willingly follows through with any punishment he chooses.
He learns that Eleanor’s friend, Catherine Morland, is not the heiress he had believed her to be and throws her from the house. His son, Henry, disobeys him by proposing marriage to Catherine, and the General disowns him. Eleanor has every reason to be afraid.
As in canon Northanger Abbey, Eleanor is in love with a childhood friend, a distant relation, Philip Brampton, honourable but definitely not rich enough to suit her father.
The General and Eleanor visit Lord and Lady Longtown at their home seat. Several eligible gentlemen will attend the house party. One ineligible gentleman will also attend: Philip Brampton.
It’s easy to be independent when you’ve got money. But to be independent when you haven’t got a thing, that’s the Lord’s test. ~ Mahalia Jackson
Eleanor has desperately wanted independence from her father for many years. Unfortunately, at her time in history, the only independence possible for a gentlewoman was to become attached to another man via marriage. Eleanor knows she will never be allowed to marry her love. She will choose another and marry as soon as possible.
Philip must witness Eleanor’s flirtations. Only two possible futures remain.
Will Eleanor and Philip fail the Lord’s test?
I am no bird; no net ensnares me: I am a free human being with an independent will. ~ Charlotte Bronte
As you might guess from my choice of quotes about independence, I was a little uneasy about the resolution of this story. Looking at it from my life experience as a Baby Boomer who lived through the sexual revolution and women’s movement, I had hoped Eleanor and Philip would be a bit bolder. This is unfair of me. Eleanor and Philip were much more restricted and did the best they could.
That said, this is a great story, well-told, and unusual in the world of JAFF.
Behind every strong independent woman lies a broken little girl who had to learn how to get back up and to never depend upon anyone. ~ Author Unknown
I received a free copy of this book from the author. I am voluntarily leaving a review.
August 3, 2023
Review also posted on my blog
https://myjaffobsession.blogspot.com/...
Heather Moll has long been a skilled weaver of pride and prejudice variations.
When she introduced her new book, a Northanger Abbey variation, I was keen to read it.
We are quickly drawn into Eleanor Tilney’s desperate need to escape the tyranny and abuse of her father, General Tilney.
A marriage of affection is denied her, as Philip, the man she loves, lacks fortune.
A marriage of convenience, while unattractive, has to be better than remaining under the General’s control.
Unfortunately, Philip is forced to witness Eleanor seeking the attention of a wealthy (and rather unpleasant man).
The pain for a Philip and Eleanor is acute.
The story is well written with a large dollop of angst!
Will Eleanor escape the Abbey? Can there be a happy ever after?
I highly recommend this book.
I received a free copy of this book from the author and am voluntarily leaving a review. All views expressed are my own.
https://myjaffobsession.blogspot.com/...
Heather Moll has long been a skilled weaver of pride and prejudice variations.
When she introduced her new book, a Northanger Abbey variation, I was keen to read it.
We are quickly drawn into Eleanor Tilney’s desperate need to escape the tyranny and abuse of her father, General Tilney.
A marriage of affection is denied her, as Philip, the man she loves, lacks fortune.
A marriage of convenience, while unattractive, has to be better than remaining under the General’s control.
Unfortunately, Philip is forced to witness Eleanor seeking the attention of a wealthy (and rather unpleasant man).
The pain for a Philip and Eleanor is acute.
The story is well written with a large dollop of angst!
Will Eleanor escape the Abbey? Can there be a happy ever after?
I highly recommend this book.
I received a free copy of this book from the author and am voluntarily leaving a review. All views expressed are my own.
November 27, 2023
“Fathers should make you feel safe.” –Karen Cushman, The Loud Silence of Francine Green
SPOILER ALERT: This review may contain *** SPOILERS ***
>>Rating: teen: for most audiences
>>Angst Level: somewhat stressful or frustrated at the actions of a controlling tyrannical father
>>Source: I won a personal paperback copy in a random drawing from the author with no expectations of a review. I volunteered to express my thoughts and opinions.
“The truth is that if my father weren’t my father, he would be one of the men he hates; he is incorrigibly faithless and thoroughly narcissistic, to such an extent that I tend to forget he’s also capable of being a real peach.” –Nora Ephron, Heartburn
I have watched several movie versions of this story over the years. Jane Austen didn’t tell her readers what happened at Northanger Abbey after General Tilney expelled Catherine Morland into the night. Miss Tilney was horrified by the actions of her father as he forced her friend to travel home unchaperoned and by post. He had been duped by Mr. Thorpe into thinking Miss Morland was an heiress to the wealthy Mr. Allen. When he discovered that was not the case, he hurried home and threw out the trash, or the scheming fortune-hunter as he considered her.
“I should no longer define myself as the son [daughter] of a father who couldn’t or hasn’t or wouldn’t or wasn’t.” –Cameron Conaway, Caged: Memoirs of a Cage-Fighting Poet
This story centered around Miss Tilney and the man she loved. Her father wanted her to have a title and refused to consider any other, regardless of her sentiments. Her opinion didn’t count. Marriage was simply a business that focused on wealth and connections. He considered the heart had no place in such dealings.
Women had no rights in the era of the Regency. They were chattel [property] of a father or husband and had no control over their lives or property. General Tilney’s control of his daughter was absolute. He could hold and withhold her dowry and any money directed to her from her mother. She would do his bidding or he would withhold any funds slated for her. This story was about her struggle between a rock and a hard place. Obey her father’s wishes or follow her heart.
SPOILER ALERT: This review may contain *** SPOILERS ***
>>Rating: teen: for most audiences
>>Angst Level: somewhat stressful or frustrated at the actions of a controlling tyrannical father
>>Source: I won a personal paperback copy in a random drawing from the author with no expectations of a review. I volunteered to express my thoughts and opinions.
“The truth is that if my father weren’t my father, he would be one of the men he hates; he is incorrigibly faithless and thoroughly narcissistic, to such an extent that I tend to forget he’s also capable of being a real peach.” –Nora Ephron, Heartburn
I have watched several movie versions of this story over the years. Jane Austen didn’t tell her readers what happened at Northanger Abbey after General Tilney expelled Catherine Morland into the night. Miss Tilney was horrified by the actions of her father as he forced her friend to travel home unchaperoned and by post. He had been duped by Mr. Thorpe into thinking Miss Morland was an heiress to the wealthy Mr. Allen. When he discovered that was not the case, he hurried home and threw out the trash, or the scheming fortune-hunter as he considered her.
“I should no longer define myself as the son [daughter] of a father who couldn’t or hasn’t or wouldn’t or wasn’t.” –Cameron Conaway, Caged: Memoirs of a Cage-Fighting Poet
This story centered around Miss Tilney and the man she loved. Her father wanted her to have a title and refused to consider any other, regardless of her sentiments. Her opinion didn’t count. Marriage was simply a business that focused on wealth and connections. He considered the heart had no place in such dealings.
Women had no rights in the era of the Regency. They were chattel [property] of a father or husband and had no control over their lives or property. General Tilney’s control of his daughter was absolute. He could hold and withhold her dowry and any money directed to her from her mother. She would do his bidding or he would withhold any funds slated for her. This story was about her struggle between a rock and a hard place. Obey her father’s wishes or follow her heart.
September 18, 2023
4,5 Rounded Up to 5
Review Published at:
https://frompemberleytomilton.wordpre...
Everyone knows Eleanor Tilney as a quiet secondary character from Northanger Abbey who exists only to support Catherine Morland’s character, but what if she was the real gothic heroine? How far would she go to escape her father’s domineering figure?
Loving Miss Tilney gives Eleanor Tilney the main role in a beautiful romance that starts shortly after General Tilney has banished Catherine Morland from Northanger Abbey. While desperate to escape Northanger’s loneliness, Eleanor finds herself in a house party in the presence of her father, friends, and eligible gentleman who start paying her some attention. The only problem is that the only man she ever loved is also present and he is not an eligible match in the eyes of her father.
This book is a refreshing break from the Pride & Prejudice variations I usually read because it brought me a regency romance with characters I do not know and reactions I did not expect. The surprise factor in this book was uplifting and made me very interested in the characters.
The main characters were indeed very unique and different from what I am used to seeing, and I believe the reason I enjoyed this book so much was the fact that both of them made me equally hate and love them at different times in the book. Their reactions are either infuriating or engaging, and if at times I couldn’t cope with their lack of courage and vision, other times I could relate with what they were feeling. I believe this is one of the greatest achievements for an author, to make the reader engaged in the story because the characters provoke in them a roller-coaster of emotions. Heather Moll kept me interested in the story not because I loved the characters, but because she was able to incite in me strong feelings towards them.
As mentioned before not all decisions these characters took were what I would expect or like, and sometimes the lack of propriety displayed by Eleanor annoyed me, but her quest to be freed of her father while simultaneously debating if freedom is more important than love was definitely very well played by the author. Moll was able to transmit to the reader the lack of independence and difficulties women had in regency times in a very vivid manner, she definitely masters the art of showing not telling and I appreciate that.
Another aspect I enjoyed in this book was the jealousy created while Philip was forced to witness Eleanor seeking the attention of another man, while I hated Eleanor for doing it, and Phillip for allowing it, I did love the way he reacted to such a difficult situation and the turbulence of emotions he faced. It was when his jealousy got the best of him that I loved him the most 🙂
Summing up, Loving Miss Tilney is an angsty regency romance that will enchant readers. It is very well written, engaging and presents itself as the perfect Saturday afternoon read. I recommend it to readers who enjoy regency romances.
Review Published at:
https://frompemberleytomilton.wordpre...
Everyone knows Eleanor Tilney as a quiet secondary character from Northanger Abbey who exists only to support Catherine Morland’s character, but what if she was the real gothic heroine? How far would she go to escape her father’s domineering figure?
Loving Miss Tilney gives Eleanor Tilney the main role in a beautiful romance that starts shortly after General Tilney has banished Catherine Morland from Northanger Abbey. While desperate to escape Northanger’s loneliness, Eleanor finds herself in a house party in the presence of her father, friends, and eligible gentleman who start paying her some attention. The only problem is that the only man she ever loved is also present and he is not an eligible match in the eyes of her father.
This book is a refreshing break from the Pride & Prejudice variations I usually read because it brought me a regency romance with characters I do not know and reactions I did not expect. The surprise factor in this book was uplifting and made me very interested in the characters.
The main characters were indeed very unique and different from what I am used to seeing, and I believe the reason I enjoyed this book so much was the fact that both of them made me equally hate and love them at different times in the book. Their reactions are either infuriating or engaging, and if at times I couldn’t cope with their lack of courage and vision, other times I could relate with what they were feeling. I believe this is one of the greatest achievements for an author, to make the reader engaged in the story because the characters provoke in them a roller-coaster of emotions. Heather Moll kept me interested in the story not because I loved the characters, but because she was able to incite in me strong feelings towards them.
As mentioned before not all decisions these characters took were what I would expect or like, and sometimes the lack of propriety displayed by Eleanor annoyed me, but her quest to be freed of her father while simultaneously debating if freedom is more important than love was definitely very well played by the author. Moll was able to transmit to the reader the lack of independence and difficulties women had in regency times in a very vivid manner, she definitely masters the art of showing not telling and I appreciate that.
Another aspect I enjoyed in this book was the jealousy created while Philip was forced to witness Eleanor seeking the attention of another man, while I hated Eleanor for doing it, and Phillip for allowing it, I did love the way he reacted to such a difficult situation and the turbulence of emotions he faced. It was when his jealousy got the best of him that I loved him the most 🙂
Summing up, Loving Miss Tilney is an angsty regency romance that will enchant readers. It is very well written, engaging and presents itself as the perfect Saturday afternoon read. I recommend it to readers who enjoy regency romances.
September 3, 2023
Heartbreaking, then glorious
The torment the heroine was subjected to was only bearable to read through because of the love her hero had for her and I knew it must have a happy ending. It is a novel after all.
I have always loved this side character, Eleanor Tilney, from Jane Austen’s Northanger Abbey. Loved her gentle sad friendship with Catherine Moreland before she married her brother Henry. Wished her a happy ending. She wasn’t given a lot of page time in the original story but she had a quiet bravery to be admired. NA has never been my favorite novel of Austen’s but there are definitely memorable characters from it.
Heather Moll has given these characters a tough journey with a triumphant ending. Their happy ending reflects the quiet passion they have had to endure for so many years. I won’t spoil the climactic moments in their story. We know early on what will happen to bring them together but we don’t know how our author is going to that. So well written.
I loved Eleanor and Phillip’s story and highly recommend it. Trigger warnings for mental abuse though.
The torment the heroine was subjected to was only bearable to read through because of the love her hero had for her and I knew it must have a happy ending. It is a novel after all.
I have always loved this side character, Eleanor Tilney, from Jane Austen’s Northanger Abbey. Loved her gentle sad friendship with Catherine Moreland before she married her brother Henry. Wished her a happy ending. She wasn’t given a lot of page time in the original story but she had a quiet bravery to be admired. NA has never been my favorite novel of Austen’s but there are definitely memorable characters from it.
Heather Moll has given these characters a tough journey with a triumphant ending. Their happy ending reflects the quiet passion they have had to endure for so many years. I won’t spoil the climactic moments in their story. We know early on what will happen to bring them together but we don’t know how our author is going to that. So well written.
I loved Eleanor and Phillip’s story and highly recommend it. Trigger warnings for mental abuse though.
September 26, 2025
After her friend Catherine and her brother Henry are banned from Northanger Abbey Eleanor is left alone with her father, the tyrannical and cruel General Tilney. To escape her father she sees only one opportunity: she needs to marry. She would dearly like to marry Philip, her childhood friend with whom she is in love for many years. But unfortunately Philip is not rich enough to get the General's approval. Thus, when they were in company at mutual friends, Eleonor decides to encourage a rich and titled gentleman to make her an offer of marriage. She has no affection for him but marrying him would mean to get a life of her own. Is she willing to set aside all chances of happiness and a future with Philip only to escape her father? Is there even a way out of her distressing situation?
The book is very well written by Heather Moll and left me with many different feelings. I could feel Eleanor's hopelessness and despair to not be able to escape her cruel father and to live the life she wants. That she has to sacrifice her love for Philip to potentially gain a little more freedom. I found the thought very depressing that someone is forced to make such considerations. I also felt sad that Eleanor and Philip are not allowed to be together although they love each other and would be contant with their situation. And I really hated the General. He is such a cruel man and I often hoped for something to occur that would stop him treating Eleanor that way. But I understand that no one dared stand up to him because of the consequences, mostly for Eleanor.
I really liked the strength Eleanor discovered in herself during the book and that she and Philip got their happy end (hey, it's a romance, so it's definitely no spoiler 😉).
For me it was for a long time the first book that was not about Pride and Prejudice. But I'm so glad I was able to read it. The story captured me right from the beginning and I was hardly able to put it down.
If you like a good love story and a woman discovering her strength and her ability to find her way in life despite her cruel father you should definitely read Heather Moll's new book.
I received a free copy of the book from the author and am voluntary leaving a review.
______________________
Addition for the audiobook:
The story is narrated by Stevie Zimmerman. As always, she voices the characters so that each has their own individual voice. Because of this the story becomes even more lively and the emotions are even better communicated. I love her style of narrating very much, she is one of my favorite narrators. A story, narrated by her definitely never disappoints.
I received a free copy of the audiobook from the author and am voluntary leaving a review.
The book is very well written by Heather Moll and left me with many different feelings. I could feel Eleanor's hopelessness and despair to not be able to escape her cruel father and to live the life she wants. That she has to sacrifice her love for Philip to potentially gain a little more freedom. I found the thought very depressing that someone is forced to make such considerations. I also felt sad that Eleanor and Philip are not allowed to be together although they love each other and would be contant with their situation. And I really hated the General. He is such a cruel man and I often hoped for something to occur that would stop him treating Eleanor that way. But I understand that no one dared stand up to him because of the consequences, mostly for Eleanor.
I really liked the strength Eleanor discovered in herself during the book and that she and Philip got their happy end (hey, it's a romance, so it's definitely no spoiler 😉).
For me it was for a long time the first book that was not about Pride and Prejudice. But I'm so glad I was able to read it. The story captured me right from the beginning and I was hardly able to put it down.
If you like a good love story and a woman discovering her strength and her ability to find her way in life despite her cruel father you should definitely read Heather Moll's new book.
I received a free copy of the book from the author and am voluntary leaving a review.
______________________
Addition for the audiobook:
The story is narrated by Stevie Zimmerman. As always, she voices the characters so that each has their own individual voice. Because of this the story becomes even more lively and the emotions are even better communicated. I love her style of narrating very much, she is one of my favorite narrators. A story, narrated by her definitely never disappoints.
I received a free copy of the audiobook from the author and am voluntary leaving a review.
August 12, 2023
Loving Miss Tilney is author Heather Moll’s Northanger Abbey variation that focuses on Eleanor Tilney’s story. It explores Eleanor’s struggle to escape her oppressive father’s control, her feelings for Phillip Brampton, and the challenges faced by women in the Regency era.
I appreciated the characters’ development, the emotional tension, and the Regency setting. The author’s ability to immerse me in the Regency world and bring out the difficulties and choices faced by characters in that time period really shines a light on the constraints women faced in their pursuit of happiness and independence.
Although the story has a few steamy scenes, it captures the essence of Jane Austen’s world well while expanding upon other characters and their dilemmas.
First Line (Prologue): “I want her gone in the morning, Eleanor!”
Genre: Regency Romance
Author: Heather Moll
Page Count: 196
#CoverLoverBookReview received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions are 100% mine.
I appreciated the characters’ development, the emotional tension, and the Regency setting. The author’s ability to immerse me in the Regency world and bring out the difficulties and choices faced by characters in that time period really shines a light on the constraints women faced in their pursuit of happiness and independence.
Although the story has a few steamy scenes, it captures the essence of Jane Austen’s world well while expanding upon other characters and their dilemmas.
First Line (Prologue): “I want her gone in the morning, Eleanor!”
Genre: Regency Romance
Author: Heather Moll
Page Count: 196
#CoverLoverBookReview received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions are 100% mine.
September 8, 2023
A secret of Northanger finally revealed
This is one of the few non-P&P JAFF that I have read. If other stories are as well-written and fascinating as Ms Moll's, I will have to search out more of them. This book expounds upon the last four paragraphs of the original novel in a way that makes the personalities of the characters vividly leap from the pages. I didn't like Eleanor's thinking and actions whilst she was in Herefordshire, but her epiphany redeemed her in my eyes. I enjoyed reading this story, and hope that Ms. Moll might write about Henry Tilney's journey in the future.
This is one of the few non-P&P JAFF that I have read. If other stories are as well-written and fascinating as Ms Moll's, I will have to search out more of them. This book expounds upon the last four paragraphs of the original novel in a way that makes the personalities of the characters vividly leap from the pages. I didn't like Eleanor's thinking and actions whilst she was in Herefordshire, but her epiphany redeemed her in my eyes. I enjoyed reading this story, and hope that Ms. Moll might write about Henry Tilney's journey in the future.
July 30, 2023
🎭 Loving Miss Tilney 📜
A Forbidden Love Regency Romance
✒️ Heather Moll
https://www.facebook.com/HeatherMollA...
Release Date 08/01/2023
Publisher Excessively Diverted Press
➪ https://a.co/d/bg48QcB
𝗕𝗹𝘂𝗿𝗯
She's forbidden to wed a nobody. He's nothing in society's eyes. Will their desperate schemes backfire before they find a way to be together?
Northanger Abbey. Eleanor Tilney can't bear her lonely life any longer. Distraught when her tyrannical father throws her friend out of the house because the girl lacks an inheritance, the long-suffering general's daughter decides anything is better than a future all alone. So in a frantic bid for freedom, she puts aside her tender feelings for a man of no standing to pursue a wealthy husband.
Philip Brampton understands that fortune is against him. And he tries gallantly to bury his distress and support his lonely beloved, even after she starts pursuing an arrogant buffoon. But when he catches the fellow about to kiss her, their resulting harsh words cause a heartbreaking rift.
Stiffening her spine in a world that refuses to acknowledge her value, Eleanor attempts to navigate the impossible situation without quashing her desires. And though his shy nature abhors a scene, Philip braces himself for a confrontation with her cruel and abusive patriarch.
Do these childhood sweethearts have any hope of achieving lasting happiness?
This is a full length forbidden love regency romance inspired by Jane Austen
𝗥𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄
I read only two of Jane Austen novels as a teens, Pride and Prejudice and Sense and Sentiment. So the characters from Northanger Abbey were all strangers to me.
And having the habit of reading about a willful Elizabeth Bennet and an equally taking matters in hand even if it is wrongly done Darcy did not prepare me for Eleanor and Philip.
They are very opposite, thus I tried to step into both of their shoes to understand they actions and reactions.
Sure Eleanor’s father is unforgiving abusive man, he uses his wealth and the fear he induced in other to control those under his thumb. So leaving such a despotic fellow would be anyone’s priority.
What I did not like was her choice of action, to marry is the obvious reason, but after years why the hurry. She could at the very least seeks someone she could admire and feels a modicum of chemistry, why the urgency, instead she runs after the first man with the minimum requested by her father. Not really acknowledging she will have to share his life, bed and go from one tyrant to an unknown entity who could be as much oppressive than her sire.
Philip is quick to give advices, but like many, he never stood up for her and confronted the general.
And while he will never be a good party for Eleanor, he still has an income and a place to live while as a woman she has no right, no mean to sustain herself, being completely despondent. Living in a limbo, allowed some luxury but barred from anything that might comfort her.
Still it was much rude for Eleanor to pursue a potential spouse in front of Philip, and while his words were harsh, it was understandable as they came from his wounded hurt and his will to see her somewhat happy.
So in some way, this is a tale of maturing, sort of coming of age as Eleanor learns from her mistakes and must decide what prevails in her heart.
What she is ready to sacrifice to get out of her father’s household, love, pride…
The general Tilney is really a character I loved to hate, he is such a vile domineering being, I would have liked to see him put down one notch or two.
4.5 stars
𝗦𝘁𝗲𝗮𝗺 𝗹𝗲𝘃𝗲𝗹 onscreen lovemaking scene
I have been granted an advance copy by the author, here is my true and unbiased opinion.
https://m.facebook.com/story.php?stor...
#bookstagram #historicalromance #romance #romancebookblog #romancebookblogger #bookblog #romanceauthor #bookblogger #2023read #bookstagrammer #bookreview #romancebookreviewer #arcreader #heathermoll #romancestagram #readersofinstagram
A Forbidden Love Regency Romance
✒️ Heather Moll
https://www.facebook.com/HeatherMollA...
Release Date 08/01/2023
Publisher Excessively Diverted Press
➪ https://a.co/d/bg48QcB
𝗕𝗹𝘂𝗿𝗯
She's forbidden to wed a nobody. He's nothing in society's eyes. Will their desperate schemes backfire before they find a way to be together?
Northanger Abbey. Eleanor Tilney can't bear her lonely life any longer. Distraught when her tyrannical father throws her friend out of the house because the girl lacks an inheritance, the long-suffering general's daughter decides anything is better than a future all alone. So in a frantic bid for freedom, she puts aside her tender feelings for a man of no standing to pursue a wealthy husband.
Philip Brampton understands that fortune is against him. And he tries gallantly to bury his distress and support his lonely beloved, even after she starts pursuing an arrogant buffoon. But when he catches the fellow about to kiss her, their resulting harsh words cause a heartbreaking rift.
Stiffening her spine in a world that refuses to acknowledge her value, Eleanor attempts to navigate the impossible situation without quashing her desires. And though his shy nature abhors a scene, Philip braces himself for a confrontation with her cruel and abusive patriarch.
Do these childhood sweethearts have any hope of achieving lasting happiness?
This is a full length forbidden love regency romance inspired by Jane Austen
𝗥𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄
I read only two of Jane Austen novels as a teens, Pride and Prejudice and Sense and Sentiment. So the characters from Northanger Abbey were all strangers to me.
And having the habit of reading about a willful Elizabeth Bennet and an equally taking matters in hand even if it is wrongly done Darcy did not prepare me for Eleanor and Philip.
They are very opposite, thus I tried to step into both of their shoes to understand they actions and reactions.
Sure Eleanor’s father is unforgiving abusive man, he uses his wealth and the fear he induced in other to control those under his thumb. So leaving such a despotic fellow would be anyone’s priority.
What I did not like was her choice of action, to marry is the obvious reason, but after years why the hurry. She could at the very least seeks someone she could admire and feels a modicum of chemistry, why the urgency, instead she runs after the first man with the minimum requested by her father. Not really acknowledging she will have to share his life, bed and go from one tyrant to an unknown entity who could be as much oppressive than her sire.
Philip is quick to give advices, but like many, he never stood up for her and confronted the general.
And while he will never be a good party for Eleanor, he still has an income and a place to live while as a woman she has no right, no mean to sustain herself, being completely despondent. Living in a limbo, allowed some luxury but barred from anything that might comfort her.
Still it was much rude for Eleanor to pursue a potential spouse in front of Philip, and while his words were harsh, it was understandable as they came from his wounded hurt and his will to see her somewhat happy.
So in some way, this is a tale of maturing, sort of coming of age as Eleanor learns from her mistakes and must decide what prevails in her heart.
What she is ready to sacrifice to get out of her father’s household, love, pride…
The general Tilney is really a character I loved to hate, he is such a vile domineering being, I would have liked to see him put down one notch or two.
4.5 stars
𝗦𝘁𝗲𝗮𝗺 𝗹𝗲𝘃𝗲𝗹 onscreen lovemaking scene
I have been granted an advance copy by the author, here is my true and unbiased opinion.
https://m.facebook.com/story.php?stor...
#bookstagram #historicalromance #romance #romancebookblog #romancebookblogger #bookblog #romanceauthor #bookblogger #2023read #bookstagrammer #bookreview #romancebookreviewer #arcreader #heathermoll #romancestagram #readersofinstagram
August 1, 2023
What secondary character from a favorite novel would you like to see get their own story? I was so excited to read this novel where Eleanor Tilney from Northanger Abbey finally gets her own story.
Loving Miss Tilney starts at the point where Catherine Morland has been thrown out of Northanger Abbey by General Tilney. Eleanor also sees her beloved brother Henry leave to follow Catherine. She decides that she can no longer stand to live with her father General Tilney. He whisks her away to a house party and she decides she will find a rich husband among the gentleman attending the house party. Complicating matters is that her second cousin, Philip Brampton is also attending the house party. Eleanor loves Philip, but he is unacceptable to her father because he does not have money. How can Eleanor find happiness for herself?
I enjoyed both Eleanor and Philip as characters. I loved how they enjoyed the same things and had great conversations. Eleanor and Philip had such great chemistry too. They had a very passionate kiss after an argument about the choices Eleanor had for the future.
It was hard to see Eleanor looking for another husband with Philip right there, but it was also understandable with the limited choices that women had at that time. It made me really think again about the impossible situation that many women found themselves in during that time period where marriage was your only option, and you had no choice of your own.
I liked that Philip was a mathematician. I love it when math, science, or engineering show up in novels.
General Tilney is one of Austen’s best villains and he is really brought to life in this novel. He would be a very difficult man to live with. He doesn’t appear to care for his children except for how their success reflects onto him.
Heather Moll’s writing really brings the Regency world to life. I have enjoyed her novels in the past. I really liked that this book was a Northanger Abbey variation. I have always wondered about what happened to poor Eleanor and this book gives the reader the details. As much as I love Pride and Prejudice variations, I love to read variations for her other novels as well.
I would say the steam level is medium as there is one steamy scene in this novel.
Book Source: Review Copy from author Heather Moll. Thank-you! I received a complimentary copy of this book as part of the book tour. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
This review was first posted on my blog at: https://lauragerold.blogspot.com/2023...
Loving Miss Tilney starts at the point where Catherine Morland has been thrown out of Northanger Abbey by General Tilney. Eleanor also sees her beloved brother Henry leave to follow Catherine. She decides that she can no longer stand to live with her father General Tilney. He whisks her away to a house party and she decides she will find a rich husband among the gentleman attending the house party. Complicating matters is that her second cousin, Philip Brampton is also attending the house party. Eleanor loves Philip, but he is unacceptable to her father because he does not have money. How can Eleanor find happiness for herself?
I enjoyed both Eleanor and Philip as characters. I loved how they enjoyed the same things and had great conversations. Eleanor and Philip had such great chemistry too. They had a very passionate kiss after an argument about the choices Eleanor had for the future.
It was hard to see Eleanor looking for another husband with Philip right there, but it was also understandable with the limited choices that women had at that time. It made me really think again about the impossible situation that many women found themselves in during that time period where marriage was your only option, and you had no choice of your own.
I liked that Philip was a mathematician. I love it when math, science, or engineering show up in novels.
General Tilney is one of Austen’s best villains and he is really brought to life in this novel. He would be a very difficult man to live with. He doesn’t appear to care for his children except for how their success reflects onto him.
Heather Moll’s writing really brings the Regency world to life. I have enjoyed her novels in the past. I really liked that this book was a Northanger Abbey variation. I have always wondered about what happened to poor Eleanor and this book gives the reader the details. As much as I love Pride and Prejudice variations, I love to read variations for her other novels as well.
I would say the steam level is medium as there is one steamy scene in this novel.
Book Source: Review Copy from author Heather Moll. Thank-you! I received a complimentary copy of this book as part of the book tour. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
This review was first posted on my blog at: https://lauragerold.blogspot.com/2023...
June 30, 2023
An excellent exploration of the impact of desperation and helplessness
Who is Miss Tilney? Jane Austen gives us the briefest of glimpses into the character and world of Miss Eleanor Tilney, sister to the charming Henry Tilney of Northanger Abbey. Eleanor is a shadow a character but it is clear that she is far from content.
In "Loving Miss Tilney", the author has taken this tiny glimpse into Eleanor Tilney's life and has crafted a beautiful and intensely romantic story. When the tyrannical General Tilney banishes her brother Henry after he refuses to give up on his preferred choice of wife, Eleanor gives up on any hope of happiness with the man she loves. He is not a wealthy man and she knows that her father will not permit the marriage. She is driven by desperation and helplessness to find a way to escape her pale imitation of a life at Northanger Abbey with just the General and his constant criticisms and demands. As a gentlewoman at the close of the 18th century Eleanor has only one means of escape - marriage. Eleanor decides to use a house party as a means to find a husband, almost any husband will do as long as he meets with her father's approval. Unfortunately the man she truly loves is also at the house party and so she has to seek to charm another man into proposing to her right under her true love's nose.
The author does not pull any punches when it comes to the emotional strain this untenable situation is putting on both Eleanor and her true love, Philip. They both despise the situation whilst understanding its necessity. Their distress is captured beautifully and their anger with the General, the helplessness of it all and even at times with each other is extremely well written. The writing flows smoothly and is empathetic throughout but at no point strays into the overdramatic. The ending is exquisitely romantic and poignant. This is not a book to be put down easily.
This is a highly recommended book. I received an advance copy of this book from the author.
Who is Miss Tilney? Jane Austen gives us the briefest of glimpses into the character and world of Miss Eleanor Tilney, sister to the charming Henry Tilney of Northanger Abbey. Eleanor is a shadow a character but it is clear that she is far from content.
In "Loving Miss Tilney", the author has taken this tiny glimpse into Eleanor Tilney's life and has crafted a beautiful and intensely romantic story. When the tyrannical General Tilney banishes her brother Henry after he refuses to give up on his preferred choice of wife, Eleanor gives up on any hope of happiness with the man she loves. He is not a wealthy man and she knows that her father will not permit the marriage. She is driven by desperation and helplessness to find a way to escape her pale imitation of a life at Northanger Abbey with just the General and his constant criticisms and demands. As a gentlewoman at the close of the 18th century Eleanor has only one means of escape - marriage. Eleanor decides to use a house party as a means to find a husband, almost any husband will do as long as he meets with her father's approval. Unfortunately the man she truly loves is also at the house party and so she has to seek to charm another man into proposing to her right under her true love's nose.
The author does not pull any punches when it comes to the emotional strain this untenable situation is putting on both Eleanor and her true love, Philip. They both despise the situation whilst understanding its necessity. Their distress is captured beautifully and their anger with the General, the helplessness of it all and even at times with each other is extremely well written. The writing flows smoothly and is empathetic throughout but at no point strays into the overdramatic. The ending is exquisitely romantic and poignant. This is not a book to be put down easily.
This is a highly recommended book. I received an advance copy of this book from the author.
July 3, 2023
If you love Jane Austen, you should read Loving Miss Tilney
Loving Miss Tilney by Heather Moll is a wonderful canon-compliant extension of Jane Austen’s Northanger Abbey. In the original, we know some of Eleanor Tilney’s story, and this book delightfully fills in all of the details. The book begins with Catherine Morland’s banishment, and takes us through the point in Northanger Abbey where Eleanor and her viscount husband work on General Tilney to accept Catherine and Henry’s engagement. Jane Austen didn’t give a lot of detail how this happened, so Ms. Moll gives us a lovely tale.
It has been awhile since I read Northanger Abbey, so I decided to re-read it before starting Loving Miss Tilney. I do not know if the re-read was necessary, but I do believe it added to my enjoyment. I am a fan of all of Ms. Moll’s books, particularly her flair for delving into the characters and their lives, and making the reader care deeply for her main characters. I wasn’t sure whether I wished to read a Northanger Abbey book, but knowing Ms. Moll was the author convinced me to give it a shot. I am very happy I did. I highly recommend this book for all Jane Austen fans, especially those who, like me, may need some encouragement to read something other than Pride and Prejudice variations. You will not regret it.
I received an ARC of this book, and I am voluntarily leaving a review.
Loving Miss Tilney by Heather Moll is a wonderful canon-compliant extension of Jane Austen’s Northanger Abbey. In the original, we know some of Eleanor Tilney’s story, and this book delightfully fills in all of the details. The book begins with Catherine Morland’s banishment, and takes us through the point in Northanger Abbey where Eleanor and her viscount husband work on General Tilney to accept Catherine and Henry’s engagement. Jane Austen didn’t give a lot of detail how this happened, so Ms. Moll gives us a lovely tale.
It has been awhile since I read Northanger Abbey, so I decided to re-read it before starting Loving Miss Tilney. I do not know if the re-read was necessary, but I do believe it added to my enjoyment. I am a fan of all of Ms. Moll’s books, particularly her flair for delving into the characters and their lives, and making the reader care deeply for her main characters. I wasn’t sure whether I wished to read a Northanger Abbey book, but knowing Ms. Moll was the author convinced me to give it a shot. I am very happy I did. I highly recommend this book for all Jane Austen fans, especially those who, like me, may need some encouragement to read something other than Pride and Prejudice variations. You will not regret it.
I received an ARC of this book, and I am voluntarily leaving a review.
August 19, 2023
Eleanor Tilney lives alone with her tyrannical father, General Tilney, who controls every aspect of her life. He alienated her brother, Henry, when he cruelly banished Catherine Moreland from his house, after discovering that she had no fortune.
At Lord and Lady Longtown's house party, Eleanor is unsettled to find that her longtime love, Philip Bramton, is also in attendance. He's a shy, mathematical genius who has known Eleanor for most of his life. His cousin, Viscount Vaughn, is also there, along with the Longtown's son, and a couple of other guests. Eleanor and Philip both know that the general would never agree to a marriage between them. He would withhold her dowry and ruin the reputation of both of them. With that in mind, she decides to marry any wealthy man, rather than to live under her father's thumb. She begins to flirt with Sir Charles Sudbury, a lascivious and arrogant man with aspirations for parliament.
The central premise of the story, that Eleanor and Philip cannot marry because of her controlling father, and that she cannot continue suffering at Northanger Abbey, is reiterated a thousand different ways. It became repetitious.
Fate intervenes, however, when circumstances change drastically for Philip. I was disappointed that General Tilney never got any comeuppance, and that Philip never really grew a spine.
The cover is lovely. That model could easily represent Jane Bennet in P&P variations.
At Lord and Lady Longtown's house party, Eleanor is unsettled to find that her longtime love, Philip Bramton, is also in attendance. He's a shy, mathematical genius who has known Eleanor for most of his life. His cousin, Viscount Vaughn, is also there, along with the Longtown's son, and a couple of other guests. Eleanor and Philip both know that the general would never agree to a marriage between them. He would withhold her dowry and ruin the reputation of both of them. With that in mind, she decides to marry any wealthy man, rather than to live under her father's thumb. She begins to flirt with Sir Charles Sudbury, a lascivious and arrogant man with aspirations for parliament.
The central premise of the story, that Eleanor and Philip cannot marry because of her controlling father, and that she cannot continue suffering at Northanger Abbey, is reiterated a thousand different ways. It became repetitious.
Fate intervenes, however, when circumstances change drastically for Philip. I was disappointed that General Tilney never got any comeuppance, and that Philip never really grew a spine.
The cover is lovely. That model could easily represent Jane Bennet in P&P variations.
August 4, 2023
Miss Tilney finally gets the love story she deserves! I was so thrilled when I first learned that Heather Moll was coming out with a new Northanger Abbey story. Not only are Northanger Abbey fics altogether too rare, but I have long thought that Eleanor Tilney deserved to have her story told. Heather did a beautiful job in giving life to that titled gentleman mentioned so briefly in the original novel with her creation of Phillip Brampton. I thought that the calm, mathematically-gifted Phillip was a perfect fit for Eleanor’s gentle temperament, and a patient and forbearing hero.
Such torture as Eleanor and Phillip had to endure made my heart ache for them, and only the assurance of their happily ever after made the anguish endurable. General Tilney is a brute- far worse even than he was in the original novel. Many times I wanted to punch him! Through Eleanor’s eyes, we see the full extent of his abuse and cruelty to her, and I wonder how Eleanor’s mother was ever fooled into marrying him.
The story, as a whole, is clean. There are a couple of steamy scenes, but nothing explicit, and all of it tasteful. A discerning reader could choose to skip over those parts if they want.
I loved this story so much, and I heartily recommend it to all fans of Jane Austen variations and sequels.
Such torture as Eleanor and Phillip had to endure made my heart ache for them, and only the assurance of their happily ever after made the anguish endurable. General Tilney is a brute- far worse even than he was in the original novel. Many times I wanted to punch him! Through Eleanor’s eyes, we see the full extent of his abuse and cruelty to her, and I wonder how Eleanor’s mother was ever fooled into marrying him.
The story, as a whole, is clean. There are a couple of steamy scenes, but nothing explicit, and all of it tasteful. A discerning reader could choose to skip over those parts if they want.
I loved this story so much, and I heartily recommend it to all fans of Jane Austen variations and sequels.
September 27, 2023
Northanger Abbey happens to be my favorite of all of Austen’s novels. I know that makes me an outlier as most lean towards Pride and Prejudice. But no, the one I liked was one of her lessor known works. But that’s OK – we all like what we like.
This book, Loving Miss Tilney, was a relatively quick and very entertaining read. It contained all of the angst you would hope to find in a novel of this type with a very satisfying ending. I doubt I’m spoiling anything by writing that.
Our heroine has a strict, overbearing and demanding father who insists she marry a rich and titled man but she has found her love and he is neither. She is forbidden to marry the man she loves and afraid to disobey her father she agrees to marry a man she does not love.
But sometimes fate has a way of getting in the way of best laid plans. And True Love tends to win out, doesn’t it? At least in romance novels. As it should.
This was a very well written and very entertaining twist on familiar themes and characters. I was delightfully immersed in this world as Eleanor and Philip find their way towards each other and their happily ever after. It was a quick and immersive read.
This book, Loving Miss Tilney, was a relatively quick and very entertaining read. It contained all of the angst you would hope to find in a novel of this type with a very satisfying ending. I doubt I’m spoiling anything by writing that.
Our heroine has a strict, overbearing and demanding father who insists she marry a rich and titled man but she has found her love and he is neither. She is forbidden to marry the man she loves and afraid to disobey her father she agrees to marry a man she does not love.
But sometimes fate has a way of getting in the way of best laid plans. And True Love tends to win out, doesn’t it? At least in romance novels. As it should.
This was a very well written and very entertaining twist on familiar themes and characters. I was delightfully immersed in this world as Eleanor and Philip find their way towards each other and their happily ever after. It was a quick and immersive read.
July 2, 2023
Living Miss Tilney
We all know a coin has always two sides: a factual one, representing its value, and a picturesque one, often with a “historical” background as we have in Switzerland with the Fünfliber: 5 Swiss francs and Wilhelm Tell, a mythical figure.
I started reading Loving Miss Tilney from the factual point of you to evaluate the book for me and I was impressed by its intensity. And soon I changed to the other side of the coin, the picturesque one, in this case the emotional one, internalizing what Eleanor Tilney - and others – had to go through “thanks” to a despotic man, in her case her father.
Several times I wondered if she would say “stop” to him, but I personally felt that she could not. The dependency, the powerlessness was too immense. My own throat felt like chocked.
Of course, there will be a good ending!
If you are interested in a book where the impact of a tyrannical person on his/her surroundings is excellently described but you don’t want to read a scientific book about this, try “Loving Miss Tilney”.
I got a copy in advance, thank you, Heather
We all know a coin has always two sides: a factual one, representing its value, and a picturesque one, often with a “historical” background as we have in Switzerland with the Fünfliber: 5 Swiss francs and Wilhelm Tell, a mythical figure.
I started reading Loving Miss Tilney from the factual point of you to evaluate the book for me and I was impressed by its intensity. And soon I changed to the other side of the coin, the picturesque one, in this case the emotional one, internalizing what Eleanor Tilney - and others – had to go through “thanks” to a despotic man, in her case her father.
Several times I wondered if she would say “stop” to him, but I personally felt that she could not. The dependency, the powerlessness was too immense. My own throat felt like chocked.
Of course, there will be a good ending!
If you are interested in a book where the impact of a tyrannical person on his/her surroundings is excellently described but you don’t want to read a scientific book about this, try “Loving Miss Tilney”.
I got a copy in advance, thank you, Heather
July 23, 2023
Loving Miss Tilney: A Forbidden Love Regency Romance is the first book I have had the pleasure of reading by Heather Moll. I thought this was a beautiful book to read. I adored Eleanor right from the start. I admired her courage and bravery all throughout. The scenes between her and Philip were pure delightful. I loved every single page of this story and at just under two hundred pages, it was easy to sit down to take a break from life and have the whole book read in one sitting.
Loving Miss Tilney: A Forbidden Love Regency Romance will be getting a very well deserved five plus stars from me. I highly recommend it for readers who enjoy reading historical romance, particularly for fans of Jane Austen's writings. I would be interested in reading more by Heather Moll in the future.
I received a paperback copy of Heather Moll's Loving Miss Tilney: A Forbidden Love Regency Romance from the publisher, but was not required to write a positive review. This review is one hundred percent my own honest opinion.
Loving Miss Tilney: A Forbidden Love Regency Romance will be getting a very well deserved five plus stars from me. I highly recommend it for readers who enjoy reading historical romance, particularly for fans of Jane Austen's writings. I would be interested in reading more by Heather Moll in the future.
I received a paperback copy of Heather Moll's Loving Miss Tilney: A Forbidden Love Regency Romance from the publisher, but was not required to write a positive review. This review is one hundred percent my own honest opinion.
February 1, 2024
All in all a pretty solid continuation of Northanger Abbey following Eleanor Tilney. I think the author did a good job balancing the character as we know her from NA with what her life could look like.
December 4, 2023
Eleanor Tilney my beloved ❤️
January 12, 2024
Loved it!!!
March 1, 2024
This was the first Northanger Abbey variation I have ever read. I am not a big fan of Northanger Abbey but the fact that this variation was written by Heather Moll compelled me to read it. And I wasn’t disappointed.
The book is well written, filled with an interesting plot and many new characters. And there is even a small mention of some beloved characters from Pride and Prejudice!
The book is about Eleanor Tilney and her wish to be rid of her father and the oppressive life she lives at Northanger Abbey. She is determined to create her own destiny, even if she can’t marry the man she loves. I was moved by her courage, determination and strength. It wasn’t easy being a woman at that time, and Eleanor had it even worse with a father like General Tilney. The author describes him so well and it is difficult to picture anyone being happy or even remotely content living near him. So we understand Eleanor’s dilema and her will to find a husband as soon as possible.
I won’t give any spoilers about how things unfold, but of course there is a happy ending. I recommend this book (as well as any others from the author). You will sure to have a wonderful time while reading it.
The book is well written, filled with an interesting plot and many new characters. And there is even a small mention of some beloved characters from Pride and Prejudice!
The book is about Eleanor Tilney and her wish to be rid of her father and the oppressive life she lives at Northanger Abbey. She is determined to create her own destiny, even if she can’t marry the man she loves. I was moved by her courage, determination and strength. It wasn’t easy being a woman at that time, and Eleanor had it even worse with a father like General Tilney. The author describes him so well and it is difficult to picture anyone being happy or even remotely content living near him. So we understand Eleanor’s dilema and her will to find a husband as soon as possible.
I won’t give any spoilers about how things unfold, but of course there is a happy ending. I recommend this book (as well as any others from the author). You will sure to have a wonderful time while reading it.
Displaying 1 - 23 of 23 reviews