***Spoiler Alert!***
“It would make a good film!” To be honest, that is what this book immediately reminded me of – watching scenes at the movies that have been designed to visually titillate, shock, excite or provoke extreme reaction. The cynical part of me wondered if Ms Lamb secretly dreams of motion picture glory! To be fair, maybe it is just the first person narrative device she employs, where the reader experiences all events through Jeanne Stewart’s eyes, which makes the story seem sometimes episodic. There is a strange contrast throughout between no detail at all (cars & houses bought and sold within a mere sentence or two) and excessive detail regarding clothing, hosiery and shoes, which whilst maybe designed to be revelatory regarding Jeanne’s state of mind, actually made the story seem somewhat unbalanced at times.
The implausible plot was undoubtedly somewhat entertaining in a rather cheap and amoral way, but realism and probability play little part in this novel, unless the State of Oregon (which I have never been fortunate enough to visit) is actually populated entirely by societal extremes. This is a pure escapist fantasy novel, complete with a hunky, powerful, successful “prince” to (literally!) sweep Ms Stewart off her feet. All her “day-to-day” problems seem far too easily solved – she finds accommodation, employment and friendship effortlessly, and she has too many advantages in life (being both talented and rich) to be a truly sympathetic character, despite the tragedies in her past.
Whilst many of the characters had their own flaws, disasters and issues to contend with, they were often drawn with such broad brush strokes that it made it difficult for me to truly care about their fates. The anger management classes seemed ludicrous to my (perhaps overly-conventional, rather too English?) eyes, and surely in reality the likelihood of such sessions being entirely populated (after the departure of the unpalatable Drake) by characters obviously designed to appear “lovable” despite their faults, would be vanishingly small? The fact that some major and serious problems are discussed means that superficially the characters may appear deep, as they attempt to deal with them, but actually both they and the “treatments” that they receive are still fairly shallowly depicted – having read this book, I have no greater understanding about anger-management, drugs or useful therapy techniques than I had before. Admittedly this work of fiction made no claim to realism on such points, but I might have found it more engaging, though possibly also more depressing, had it given me greater insight.
I found Jeanne’s involvement as an accessory after the fact to a major crime unnecessary and unsettling, and even though her motives were irreproachable, her actions, and especially the fact that she kept those matters secret from her new husband, left a nasty taste in my mouth, and made me even less sympathetic towards her as a character. Her innate demeanour is very much the opposite to mine, and whilst her brash behaviour may well be an external defence mechanism covering up a softer and more approachable interior, I did not feel that I would particularly enjoy spending time with her, as she would probably be intolerant and scathing towards me as well! As this is undoubtedly a work of “chick-lit”, her obsession with shoes may well be of great interest to many readers, and it is thus probably not out of place, but as the proud owner of about 6 pairs of largely serviceable and entirely flat footwear, I personally found it profoundly irritating!
I enjoyed the brief insight into political campaigning strategies, probably mainly because it enabled me to compare and contrast with my own experiences in such matters in the UK, but given the escapist nature of the rest of the book, I was not confident that this aspect was treated in any more of a true-to-life manner than anything else. I was also left distracted by a few glaring grammatical errors – I felt the use of “imminently” instead of “eminently” on page one did not bode well for the quality of the writing!
Despite all these points, I would probably rate this book at a slightly grudging 2 stars out of 5 – largely because I managed to finish it in just a few reading sessions! The novel was easy and quick to work through, undemanding, and superficially entertaining. The courtroom scene in particular was moderately humorous, and there were odd moments that made me laugh throughout, though unfortunately more often AT characters than with them, which made me feel a bit uncomfortable. I could have done with a little less crude language in general, as despite it being “in context” I did not feel it particularly added anything to the reading experience, and may indeed put off some readers who might otherwise enjoy the story. Whilst I am sure that it has the potential to make a good and enjoyable film someday, I definitely do not feel that this novel will ever be rated as great literature, or that it will necessarily be remembered, or read by generations to come. When viewed as lightweight escapist fluff however, it fulfils its role admirably, and I would probably recommend it to anyone that I knew already enjoyed this genre, even though I was left somewhat underwhelmed by it myself.