Some of these books are better than others. This is not one of those books. Two stars because it did have a couple of tips that I’m sure some people could find useful. But there were so many problems. She seems to get rid of things just for the sake of getting rid of things (we used the snow cone machine and my kids loved it, but it was big, so they’re just going to have to live without snow cones now because we wanted to fit the whole family into a one bedroom apartment!). She doesn’t own a TV, which is fine, but then goes on to say that after they cut out TV, they cut out…music? The book kept sounding more and more like they are working hard to intentionally live in a home without joy.
She advocates for ignoring the news. That can be good for your mental health in small doses, particularly if you’re the kind of person who obsesses over things outside of your control. But in the long run, ignoring news and politics is not good for society as a whole, and is a hell of a privilege that she doesn’t even acknowledge.
She advocates for Dave Ramsey. His methods are ok-ish at a surface level, but not sound advice in the long run. If you have a serious addiction to spending money you don’t have, his methods are a good start at fixing that. Otherwise, please ignore him.
She advocates AGAINST having long term goals. Too much pressure and stress or something. I don’t even know. It makes about as much sense as the rest of the book.
And then, halfway through the book, it suddenly turns incredibly religious. She mentions early on that she’s Christian. Ok, sure. So are like two and a half billion other people. But it seemed really misplaced in a book about decluttering.
My overall impression is that she’s privileged and holier-than-thou, but still somehow embarrassed by her own living situation, and working hard to isolate herself and her family from any sort of outside influence (no TV, music, news, public education, etc.).