What do you think?
Rate this book
Miller, I J [ Wuthering Nights: An Erotic Retelling of Wuthering Heights ] [ WUTHERING NIGHTS: AN EROTIC RETELLING OF WUTHERING HEIGHTS ] Apr - 2013 { Paperback }
Romantics everywhere have been enthralled by Emily Bronte's classic novel of the tragic love between beautiful, spirited Catherine Earnshaw and dark, brooding Heathcliff. The restrained desire between these two star-crossed lovers has always smoldered on the page. And now it ignites into an uncontrollable blaze.In WUTHERING NIGHTS, writer I.J. Miller reimagines this timeless story to reveal the passion between Catherine and Heathcliff--in all its forbidden glory.Set against the stark, raw beauty of the English moors, Heathcliff, an abandoned orphan, recognizes his soulmate in wild, impulsive Catherine, the only woman who can tame his self-destructive nature. And Catherine cannot deny the all-consuming desire she feels for him, despite his low birth. Together they engage in a fiery affair--one that will possess them, enslave them, and change their destinies forever...
Paperback
First published January 1, 2013
67 people are currently reading
1779 people want to read
About the author
I.J. Miller
8 books49 followersI.J. MILLER has published seven literary works of fiction and one book of non-fiction. SEESAW was translated into German and Spanish and sold over 132,000 copies in the Bantam paperback. WHIPPED is available in English and German. Next came the short story collection SEX AND LOVE, and the novella CLIMBING THE STAIRS. The audio version of WUTHERING NIGHTS was nominated for an Audie Award in 2014. In 2019, IMMACULATE CONCEPTION was published to rave reviews. Released in 2022 was PROMISE FULFILLED, A Memoir of Immigrant Success, with Miller as the co-author. And coming in 2024, the sexy thriller, SURVIVING THE STORM. Miller is also a screenwriter, with an MFA from the American Film Institute.
Visit I.J. at ijmiller.com.
Visit I.J. at ijmiller.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 29 of 102 reviews
June 21, 2018
mmmmokay, so i read this.
sometimes i am scrolling through the netgalley new releases and i shrug and think "why not??" because when things are free, there is no risk and it is too, too easy to just click.
but then you have to actually read them.
for while it is true i will read any retelling of wuthering heights that exists, i really only read erotica/romance because it makes me laugh. but it seems rude to accept a generous netgalley freebie and then make giggles at it.
so i am going to try to remain neutral.
if you are a fan of both erotica and wuthering heights, you will love this book, because it has both!
you will be treated to the erotic couplings of
*heathcliff and catherine
*catherine and edgar
*mrs. linton and a servant
*isabella and heathcliff
*heathcliff and nelly
*cathy and hareton
*heathcliff and isabella AND nelly
and "you" as you masturbate in the opening chapter in a bed with ghosts. you dirty bird...
here are some things that are different from the original:
heathcliff's got a well-stocked sex dungeon, there is a ton of anilingus and other butt-play, a strange preoccupation with armpit hair, and we learn the benefits of horseback riding upon the hymen and stomach muscles.
these scenes are not even in the cliffs notes! oversight!
there is one scene that made me laugh with appreciation and not with "tee-hee...sex..." immaturity.
and it comes in the middle of an intercourse scene between heathcliff and his new, despised wife.
He raised his left arm across her chest and neck again, making it difficult for her to breathe. He brought his right index finger, soaked with the deep need and passion he had inspired within her quim, around to the entrance of her bum, and began a gently caress [sic].
"Heathcliff, no, this is not a place for love."
"Precisely," he answered.
that just cracked me up. oh, heathcliff, you are such a dick. and speaking of that.... yeah. indeed.
i often wonder where the impulse to write these sauced-up versions of classics comes from. the cynical part of me thinks that it is just because all you have to do is write a couple of sex scenes and all the rest of the work is done for you. but i don't know. because it's not like heathcliff-as-sex-symbol has ever gone away, archetypically, and maybe it is intended as well-meaning homage, like "you think christian gray is a hot jerk? well, then check out heathcliff, ladies..."
i like to think it is just horny fanfic.
unfortunately, i prefer the original.
because i am a prude.
and how do you know i am a prude? because when you GIS "wuthering heights porn" you get this picture of me:
from this review:
http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...
and discovering that just made my day for real.
come to my blog!
sometimes i am scrolling through the netgalley new releases and i shrug and think "why not??" because when things are free, there is no risk and it is too, too easy to just click.
but then you have to actually read them.
for while it is true i will read any retelling of wuthering heights that exists, i really only read erotica/romance because it makes me laugh. but it seems rude to accept a generous netgalley freebie and then make giggles at it.
so i am going to try to remain neutral.
if you are a fan of both erotica and wuthering heights, you will love this book, because it has both!
you will be treated to the erotic couplings of
*heathcliff and catherine
*catherine and edgar
*mrs. linton and a servant
*isabella and heathcliff
*heathcliff and nelly
*cathy and hareton
*heathcliff and isabella AND nelly
and "you" as you masturbate in the opening chapter in a bed with ghosts. you dirty bird...
here are some things that are different from the original:
heathcliff's got a well-stocked sex dungeon, there is a ton of anilingus and other butt-play, a strange preoccupation with armpit hair, and we learn the benefits of horseback riding upon the hymen and stomach muscles.
these scenes are not even in the cliffs notes! oversight!
there is one scene that made me laugh with appreciation and not with "tee-hee...sex..." immaturity.
and it comes in the middle of an intercourse scene between heathcliff and his new, despised wife.
He raised his left arm across her chest and neck again, making it difficult for her to breathe. He brought his right index finger, soaked with the deep need and passion he had inspired within her quim, around to the entrance of her bum, and began a gently caress [sic].
"Heathcliff, no, this is not a place for love."
"Precisely," he answered.
that just cracked me up. oh, heathcliff, you are such a dick. and speaking of that.... yeah. indeed.
i often wonder where the impulse to write these sauced-up versions of classics comes from. the cynical part of me thinks that it is just because all you have to do is write a couple of sex scenes and all the rest of the work is done for you. but i don't know. because it's not like heathcliff-as-sex-symbol has ever gone away, archetypically, and maybe it is intended as well-meaning homage, like "you think christian gray is a hot jerk? well, then check out heathcliff, ladies..."
i like to think it is just horny fanfic.
unfortunately, i prefer the original.
because i am a prude.
and how do you know i am a prude? because when you GIS "wuthering heights porn" you get this picture of me:
from this review:
http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...
and discovering that just made my day for real.
come to my blog!
April 1, 2013
First Thought upon finishing the novel: What did I just read?
Obviously, I knew that this was an erotic retelling of the beloved Bronte classic, Wuthering Heights so I was expecting some steamy scenes between Heathcliff and Catherine, Heathcliff and Isabella, Catherine and Edgar, even possibly Hareton and Cathy.
What I wasn’t expecting was the following:
Mrs. Linton (as in the mother of Edgar and Isabella) and a servant— Not quite so shocking and actually would have been a bit funny if the servant would have been Joseph.
Heathcliff and Nelly- Seriously! Seriously? Seriously!—I could see Nelly and Hindley having it off as the 1970 film adaptation explored Nelly have feelings for Hindley but Heathcliff and Nelly…I don’t think so.
Heathcliff and Isabella and Nelly in Heathcliff’s dungeon of dirty tricks—This was so out there in left field that I skipped over it
While this claims to be a retelling, I found that the characters are mainly comprised of Mr. Miller’s reimagining of them, which, in a sense, has stripped them of their original qualities. It’s almost as if I have fallen down a naughty rabbit hole where the essence of Wuthering Heights has been made into a topsy-turvy porno.
As a lover of Wuthering Heights, I was curious to read Wuthering Nights. I truly wanted to love this book, or at least like it, and while there were parts that I liked such as Hareton and Cathy’s story being told at the end of the novel, I found that this was not the book for me.
I have to say that this was the worst book that I have ever read. I.J. Miller has taken Heathcliff, the idyllic Byronic hero, and turned him into a perverted nutcase that holds no trace of Emily Bronte’s Heathcliff save for his name. Perhaps Mr. Miller should reread Wuthering Heights and realize that Miss Bronte relied on the atmospheric moods of the tumultuous Yorkshire moors to tell the story of Heathcliff and Catherine rather than a dirty dungeon of doom. By taking out the atmosphere of Wuthering Heights, Wuthering Nights has lost its core. The only way for me to describe this book is 50 Shades of Wrong…
There are some books that you wish you could unread and, for me, Wuthering Nights is one of them.
Obviously, I knew that this was an erotic retelling of the beloved Bronte classic, Wuthering Heights so I was expecting some steamy scenes between Heathcliff and Catherine, Heathcliff and Isabella, Catherine and Edgar, even possibly Hareton and Cathy.
What I wasn’t expecting was the following:
Mrs. Linton (as in the mother of Edgar and Isabella) and a servant— Not quite so shocking and actually would have been a bit funny if the servant would have been Joseph.
Heathcliff and Nelly- Seriously! Seriously? Seriously!—I could see Nelly and Hindley having it off as the 1970 film adaptation explored Nelly have feelings for Hindley but Heathcliff and Nelly…I don’t think so.
Heathcliff and Isabella and Nelly in Heathcliff’s dungeon of dirty tricks—This was so out there in left field that I skipped over it
While this claims to be a retelling, I found that the characters are mainly comprised of Mr. Miller’s reimagining of them, which, in a sense, has stripped them of their original qualities. It’s almost as if I have fallen down a naughty rabbit hole where the essence of Wuthering Heights has been made into a topsy-turvy porno.
As a lover of Wuthering Heights, I was curious to read Wuthering Nights. I truly wanted to love this book, or at least like it, and while there were parts that I liked such as Hareton and Cathy’s story being told at the end of the novel, I found that this was not the book for me.
I have to say that this was the worst book that I have ever read. I.J. Miller has taken Heathcliff, the idyllic Byronic hero, and turned him into a perverted nutcase that holds no trace of Emily Bronte’s Heathcliff save for his name. Perhaps Mr. Miller should reread Wuthering Heights and realize that Miss Bronte relied on the atmospheric moods of the tumultuous Yorkshire moors to tell the story of Heathcliff and Catherine rather than a dirty dungeon of doom. By taking out the atmosphere of Wuthering Heights, Wuthering Nights has lost its core. The only way for me to describe this book is 50 Shades of Wrong…
There are some books that you wish you could unread and, for me, Wuthering Nights is one of them.
May 17, 2013
OMFG! WTF did I just read? Emily Bronte must be turning in her grave. I realised this wasn't for me when Heathcliff (*swoons*) and Nelly did "things" (I can't even write the words) to each other. HELL NO! Edgar Linton gave Catherine a sensual body massage. JESUS NO! Heathcliff described as having a "serpent" and saying "Fuck my cock". NO! NO! NO! This is just WRONG! I am mentally scarred for life. I am to blame for thinking that an erotic version of my all time favourite book was a good idea. NEVER AGAIN! Obviously, a did-not-finish.
If you want true, intense passion, read the original. I will be.
If you want true, intense passion, read the original. I will be.
October 19, 2019
DNF at page 41
I read Wuthering Heights last Christmas for the first time ever and it was so good, I loved the atmosphere, the emotional rollercoaster, the complexity of the characters' relationships and it made it onto my Best Books of 2018 list.
But, as I was reading it, I remember thinking "Yeah, this is nice, but what if we had more angst and more interactions between the two main characters?" and "Imagine if we were able to see what was going on between them those times they were alone."
I hoped this retelling would give me this.
But no.
I hoped that this would keep the amazing words of Emily Bronte or most of them anyways, and just spice it up a little. But boy was I wrong!
I don't consider myself a prude. And I don't have problems with sex in literature, as long as it is well done (for example, I liked the sex scenes in The Tea Rose )
The sex scenes in this one are C R I N G Y and so badly written. All of them seem empty of emotion, no matter how many times the author says otherwise. And you know why's that? Because he scrapped all character development and moved right to sex.
Even tho I made it only to page 41, there were 4 sex scenes. Too much and too soon for my liking.
Speaking of too much I don't think I have to talk about how annoying it was to see people thinking and describing Heathcliff's penis every 5 lines or so.
And what was that awful intro chapter, where you, the reader, lie on the bed and masturbate while thinking of people long since dead having sex?
I have difficulties DNFing books, I think judging by how many books I've given low ratings to, one could easily see that.
But after finding no redeeming qualities to this book, I decided to DNF it once I reached the 100th page.
What made me decide against it, was a sex scene between Heathcliff and Nelly, and the frightening realisation that this may affect my love for the original.
So this is the end.
If you made it this far, congratulations!
'Til next time, take care :) :) :)
I read Wuthering Heights last Christmas for the first time ever and it was so good, I loved the atmosphere, the emotional rollercoaster, the complexity of the characters' relationships and it made it onto my Best Books of 2018 list.
But, as I was reading it, I remember thinking "Yeah, this is nice, but what if we had more angst and more interactions between the two main characters?" and "Imagine if we were able to see what was going on between them those times they were alone."
I hoped this retelling would give me this.
But no.
I hoped that this would keep the amazing words of Emily Bronte or most of them anyways, and just spice it up a little. But boy was I wrong!
I don't consider myself a prude. And I don't have problems with sex in literature, as long as it is well done (for example, I liked the sex scenes in The Tea Rose )
The sex scenes in this one are C R I N G Y and so badly written. All of them seem empty of emotion, no matter how many times the author says otherwise. And you know why's that? Because he scrapped all character development and moved right to sex.
Even tho I made it only to page 41, there were 4 sex scenes. Too much and too soon for my liking.
Speaking of too much I don't think I have to talk about how annoying it was to see people thinking and describing Heathcliff's penis every 5 lines or so.
And what was that awful intro chapter, where you, the reader, lie on the bed and masturbate while thinking of people long since dead having sex?
I have difficulties DNFing books, I think judging by how many books I've given low ratings to, one could easily see that.
But after finding no redeeming qualities to this book, I decided to DNF it once I reached the 100th page.
What made me decide against it, was a sex scene between Heathcliff and Nelly, and the frightening realisation that this may affect my love for the original.
So this is the end.
If you made it this far, congratulations!
'Til next time, take care :) :) :)
September 23, 2015
If you are a regular Seductive Musings reader, you may recall that I've reviewed two previous books which sexed up a classic romance novel with less than successful results. After the most recent one, I actually went on Twitter to beg someone for an example of this writing trend that was actually done well and a pleasure to read. I am quite pleased and more than a bit surprised to report that I.J. Miller’s “Wuthering Nights” is that book.
I have to admit that the original “Wuthering Heights” was never one of my favorite romances. Heathcliff may be the quintessential dark brooding alpha male which always appeals to me, but neither of the Catherine Earnshaws were heroines I particularly liked. The secondary characters were no better, with the Earnshaw men as almost laughably over-the-top villains and the Linton siblings so passive and whiny that I was actually pleased to see them suffer.
Perhaps this cynical attitude is part of why I was so receptive to I.J. Miller’s new erotic version, but I wouldn't have enjoyed it as much as I did if it wasn't so well developed and executed. What was once a classic tale of doomed love and thwarted revenge is now a relentless story of true erotic horror, with Heathcliff recast as the merciless Dominant who will use anyone and anything in his quest to possess his beloved Catherine completely and forever. Along the way, we see how each person in Heathcliff’s path becomes his pawn, most often through his exploitation of their own erotic desires. “Wuthering Nights” does not hesitate to show the full spectrum of erotic horror, but never in a way that does not fit fully with how the characters in the original story were presented and understood. It makes sense that Catherine would never fully submit to Heathcliff, regardless of his intent and overwhelming Dominance. It also makes sense that Catherine would explore her own nascent Dominance when married to the simpering Edgar, and their sexual encounters radiate the appropriate amount of creepy discomfort. Yet the most extreme examples of erotic horror in “Wuthering Nights” involve two characters who were more off to the sidelines in the original, but are now front and center in this version.
When Isabella Linton falls in love with Heathcliff and elopes with him to be married in the original, we don’t see much of her again, other than a few scenes later where it’s clear she is just as abused and mistreated as the other members of Heathcliff’s sorry household. In I.J. Miller’s version, we see the true nature of Isabella’s married life with Heathcliff, and what I read there actually made me feel sorry for her in a way the original had never inspired. How terrible to have a true love exploited and perverted so cruelly, regardless of the reason. Again, this alteration would have been unbearable to read if the writing had less than spot on. Like any good horror story, it may frighten and disgust, but you can’t look away.
The Earnshaw’s housekeeper, Nelly, served as a narrator in the original, providing background and context to the visiting traveler staying at Wuthering Heights. In “Wuthering Nights” she is all that and more, providing the reader greater access to the young Heathcliff, for whom she would do anything, including providing physical comfort when Catherine is unavailable to him. As the story progresses, Nelly is the one person who truly sees Heathcliff for the monster he is, yet also loves him and ultimately allows herself to be exploited along with everyone else, just for the opportunity to have him with her one more time. And if Nelly, the voice of reason and common sense in this story, can be seduced and broken by a man whom she knows to be merciless, what hope do the young Cathy and Hareton have to resist?
I.J. Miller’s “Wuthering Nights” is definitely not for everyone. It is, however, the book I had wished for and the example that others should follow in this type of writing endeavor. I only hope it is not the exception that proves the rule. I would love to read more sexed-up classic romance novels if they are half as well written as this one.
Ratings:
Overall: 4.5
Sensuality level: 5 (hardcore BDSM, non-consent, M/F/F)
I have to admit that the original “Wuthering Heights” was never one of my favorite romances. Heathcliff may be the quintessential dark brooding alpha male which always appeals to me, but neither of the Catherine Earnshaws were heroines I particularly liked. The secondary characters were no better, with the Earnshaw men as almost laughably over-the-top villains and the Linton siblings so passive and whiny that I was actually pleased to see them suffer.
Perhaps this cynical attitude is part of why I was so receptive to I.J. Miller’s new erotic version, but I wouldn't have enjoyed it as much as I did if it wasn't so well developed and executed. What was once a classic tale of doomed love and thwarted revenge is now a relentless story of true erotic horror, with Heathcliff recast as the merciless Dominant who will use anyone and anything in his quest to possess his beloved Catherine completely and forever. Along the way, we see how each person in Heathcliff’s path becomes his pawn, most often through his exploitation of their own erotic desires. “Wuthering Nights” does not hesitate to show the full spectrum of erotic horror, but never in a way that does not fit fully with how the characters in the original story were presented and understood. It makes sense that Catherine would never fully submit to Heathcliff, regardless of his intent and overwhelming Dominance. It also makes sense that Catherine would explore her own nascent Dominance when married to the simpering Edgar, and their sexual encounters radiate the appropriate amount of creepy discomfort. Yet the most extreme examples of erotic horror in “Wuthering Nights” involve two characters who were more off to the sidelines in the original, but are now front and center in this version.
When Isabella Linton falls in love with Heathcliff and elopes with him to be married in the original, we don’t see much of her again, other than a few scenes later where it’s clear she is just as abused and mistreated as the other members of Heathcliff’s sorry household. In I.J. Miller’s version, we see the true nature of Isabella’s married life with Heathcliff, and what I read there actually made me feel sorry for her in a way the original had never inspired. How terrible to have a true love exploited and perverted so cruelly, regardless of the reason. Again, this alteration would have been unbearable to read if the writing had less than spot on. Like any good horror story, it may frighten and disgust, but you can’t look away.
The Earnshaw’s housekeeper, Nelly, served as a narrator in the original, providing background and context to the visiting traveler staying at Wuthering Heights. In “Wuthering Nights” she is all that and more, providing the reader greater access to the young Heathcliff, for whom she would do anything, including providing physical comfort when Catherine is unavailable to him. As the story progresses, Nelly is the one person who truly sees Heathcliff for the monster he is, yet also loves him and ultimately allows herself to be exploited along with everyone else, just for the opportunity to have him with her one more time. And if Nelly, the voice of reason and common sense in this story, can be seduced and broken by a man whom she knows to be merciless, what hope do the young Cathy and Hareton have to resist?
I.J. Miller’s “Wuthering Nights” is definitely not for everyone. It is, however, the book I had wished for and the example that others should follow in this type of writing endeavor. I only hope it is not the exception that proves the rule. I would love to read more sexed-up classic romance novels if they are half as well written as this one.
Ratings:
Overall: 4.5
Sensuality level: 5 (hardcore BDSM, non-consent, M/F/F)
March 24, 2023
I lie in bed listening to the winds sweep over the moors, the delicate fragrance of heather slipping in through a crack in the casement and perfuming the inky air with a sigh of passion. Feeling a heavy presence settle next to me, I turn and gaze into eyes - dark, dangerous, a bit wild. As I roll toward him, he leans in, places his lips against the shell of my ear, and whispers, “My Darling, love IS pain …”
Wait, sorry; sorry! Woke up a bit groggy with a bit of a book hangover and still mesmerized by visions of Heathcliff. Deep breaths and ... focus.
Now while this is the same Heathcliff we all know and hate to love, here he is made even more tantalizing with his perversions and dirty dominance added by I.J. Miller. Emily Brontë’s original, a mix of Victorian and Gothic Romance, swells with the repressed sexuality of the times. This, however, is a beautifully dark obsession with lots of savage kink.
Miller has taken the original text and added in what so many of us have craved all along: Sex - glorious, hedonistic, and abundant.
All of the tormented tragedy of Brontë remains. We witness the obsessive passions between Heathcliff and Catherine rot them from the inside until the unavoidable end. Heathcliff’s love for Catherine and desire for revenge inevitably lead to her death, causing him to destroy the only thing he ever valued. Tragedy personified, Heathcliff is the anti-hero all women want. And Catherine is the same spoiled, pampered, vitriolic shrew all women wish they were.
But really, let’s talk about the sex. Oh yes, the S-E-X. Because it's why WE'RE here, and IT'S here in more ways than even I can imagine. It’s depraved, wicked, immoral, and corrupt. It’s deviant and debauched and filthy. It’s smoldering, aberrant, and absolutely delicious. I felt a thrilling sense of voyeurism throughout and in need of multiple coolings down.
For those who are fans of songwriter Jim Steinman, who has created some of the most romantic and over the top songs of the last half century, he cites the original as one of his favorite novels and wrote some of his best work while under the influence of its dark seduction. I truly hope Steinman has read this sexed-up version because I feel it would feed directly into his fantasies - as it did mine.
But remember: The mind cannot discern between fantasy and reality, so let yours soar and decide how many hands you really need to hold that Kindle while reading.
Wait, sorry; sorry! Woke up a bit groggy with a bit of a book hangover and still mesmerized by visions of Heathcliff. Deep breaths and ... focus.
Now while this is the same Heathcliff we all know and hate to love, here he is made even more tantalizing with his perversions and dirty dominance added by I.J. Miller. Emily Brontë’s original, a mix of Victorian and Gothic Romance, swells with the repressed sexuality of the times. This, however, is a beautifully dark obsession with lots of savage kink.
Miller has taken the original text and added in what so many of us have craved all along: Sex - glorious, hedonistic, and abundant.
All of the tormented tragedy of Brontë remains. We witness the obsessive passions between Heathcliff and Catherine rot them from the inside until the unavoidable end. Heathcliff’s love for Catherine and desire for revenge inevitably lead to her death, causing him to destroy the only thing he ever valued. Tragedy personified, Heathcliff is the anti-hero all women want. And Catherine is the same spoiled, pampered, vitriolic shrew all women wish they were.
But really, let’s talk about the sex. Oh yes, the S-E-X. Because it's why WE'RE here, and IT'S here in more ways than even I can imagine. It’s depraved, wicked, immoral, and corrupt. It’s deviant and debauched and filthy. It’s smoldering, aberrant, and absolutely delicious. I felt a thrilling sense of voyeurism throughout and in need of multiple coolings down.
For those who are fans of songwriter Jim Steinman, who has created some of the most romantic and over the top songs of the last half century, he cites the original as one of his favorite novels and wrote some of his best work while under the influence of its dark seduction. I truly hope Steinman has read this sexed-up version because I feel it would feed directly into his fantasies - as it did mine.
But remember: The mind cannot discern between fantasy and reality, so let yours soar and decide how many hands you really need to hold that Kindle while reading.
May 17, 2013
Initial reaction: “Umm… ok… wow.”
I requested this book because I love the classics and read this one in high school, wanting to see how “reimagined” it was… One theme that I.J. Miller definitely kept is this:
In both Wuthering Heights and Wuthering Nights, I love the books whilst also wanting to cause major bodily harm to the majority of the main characters. Vain, selfish, hateful, spoiled and spiteful creatures, the lot of them.
What I found interesting is that, though somewhat shocking, I can TOTALLY see this all actually happening. That somehow this is real. Brontë wrote a PG or PG-13 rated book and Miller just uncovered the sordid underbelly and turned it NC-17.
Beware: This book is NOT for the faint of heart. If you felt uncomfortable reading 50 Shades of Gray (which, in my personal opinion, should NEVER be the “authoritative” book or baseline for BDSM novels), then don’t read this book.
I, personally, have read worse… and oddly, out of all the “taboo” things committed in this book (and others), the instance of a woman suckling a man’s breast is what disturbed me the most (I’m not saying who was involved and when but… ) … in this reviewer’s humble opinion, the word “suckling” should only be used in the instance of a child to its mother’s breast… men doing it to women… ok, but use a different word… a woman suckling at the man’s breast, whether or not he is her master, just bothers me. But I digress…
If you’ve read the original book, Wuthering Heights, by Emily Brontë, and are prepared to go dark, you’ll enjoy this book, as I did. If you haven’t read the original, first off, shame on you, and secondly, be prepared to want to slap the characters. But that’s part of what makes these books so compelling. You dislike the characters so much, yet you keep reading to see what happens next and if they will or can redeem themselves.
The tale is one of forbidden love, revenge, selfishness, jealous, vanity, pain and, ultimately, sacrifice – or punishment, depending on how you look at it.
Either way, I was a huge fan and recommend it to those up to the task.
A tip of the hat to I.J. Miller for “reimagining” a book so well.
I requested this book because I love the classics and read this one in high school, wanting to see how “reimagined” it was… One theme that I.J. Miller definitely kept is this:
In both Wuthering Heights and Wuthering Nights, I love the books whilst also wanting to cause major bodily harm to the majority of the main characters. Vain, selfish, hateful, spoiled and spiteful creatures, the lot of them.
What I found interesting is that, though somewhat shocking, I can TOTALLY see this all actually happening. That somehow this is real. Brontë wrote a PG or PG-13 rated book and Miller just uncovered the sordid underbelly and turned it NC-17.
Beware: This book is NOT for the faint of heart. If you felt uncomfortable reading 50 Shades of Gray (which, in my personal opinion, should NEVER be the “authoritative” book or baseline for BDSM novels), then don’t read this book.
I, personally, have read worse… and oddly, out of all the “taboo” things committed in this book (and others), the instance of a woman suckling a man’s breast is what disturbed me the most (I’m not saying who was involved and when but… ) … in this reviewer’s humble opinion, the word “suckling” should only be used in the instance of a child to its mother’s breast… men doing it to women… ok, but use a different word… a woman suckling at the man’s breast, whether or not he is her master, just bothers me. But I digress…
If you’ve read the original book, Wuthering Heights, by Emily Brontë, and are prepared to go dark, you’ll enjoy this book, as I did. If you haven’t read the original, first off, shame on you, and secondly, be prepared to want to slap the characters. But that’s part of what makes these books so compelling. You dislike the characters so much, yet you keep reading to see what happens next and if they will or can redeem themselves.
The tale is one of forbidden love, revenge, selfishness, jealous, vanity, pain and, ultimately, sacrifice – or punishment, depending on how you look at it.
Either way, I was a huge fan and recommend it to those up to the task.
A tip of the hat to I.J. Miller for “reimagining” a book so well.
March 3, 2015
*Book source ~ A review copy was provided in exchange for an honest review.
Wuthering Nights is a retelling of the classic Wuthering Heights but with erotica added to it.
I will start by saying I have read Wuthering Heights and I hated it. The characters were detestable, the plot crappy and I finished it only so I could say I had read it. When I saw this retelling of the story but with erotica added, it had been many years since I read the original, so I decided to give it a go. From what I remember, Miller does a good job of retelling Brontë’s book very well. The characters are still detestable and the plot ridiculous, but I kept reading because I wanted to see what other naughtiness would be added to the story. And naughtiness there definitely is! While Heathcliff is still a total asshat I did enjoy the things the author had him doing as far as BDSM goes. They seemed completely in character with a jerkwad like him. Catherine and the other women in this story panting after Heathcliff are total twats. I especially hate Catherine, spoiled, selfish, self-centered, little bitch that she is. Yeah, I remember these characters from the original. Love story?! I think not! There is no love in any of the relationships in this or the original. Obsession is more the word I would use, not love. Ugh! Anyway, the erotica is skillfully woven into the fabric of the story so it doesn’t seem out of place or shoehorned in for dramatic effect.
If you are the type of person who is faithful to the original then you’ll probably hate this story. If you’re looking for a classic retelling with much naughtiness added then this should fit the bill nicely.
Wuthering Nights is a retelling of the classic Wuthering Heights but with erotica added to it.
I will start by saying I have read Wuthering Heights and I hated it. The characters were detestable, the plot crappy and I finished it only so I could say I had read it. When I saw this retelling of the story but with erotica added, it had been many years since I read the original, so I decided to give it a go. From what I remember, Miller does a good job of retelling Brontë’s book very well. The characters are still detestable and the plot ridiculous, but I kept reading because I wanted to see what other naughtiness would be added to the story. And naughtiness there definitely is! While Heathcliff is still a total asshat I did enjoy the things the author had him doing as far as BDSM goes. They seemed completely in character with a jerkwad like him. Catherine and the other women in this story panting after Heathcliff are total twats. I especially hate Catherine, spoiled, selfish, self-centered, little bitch that she is. Yeah, I remember these characters from the original. Love story?! I think not! There is no love in any of the relationships in this or the original. Obsession is more the word I would use, not love. Ugh! Anyway, the erotica is skillfully woven into the fabric of the story so it doesn’t seem out of place or shoehorned in for dramatic effect.
If you are the type of person who is faithful to the original then you’ll probably hate this story. If you’re looking for a classic retelling with much naughtiness added then this should fit the bill nicely.
April 27, 2013
I wanted to read this book since the author occasionally is a featured presenter at my Erotic Literary Salon. First a confession, I have never read "Wuthering Heights," so I'm reviewing as a stand-alone novel.
Couldn't put it down, definitely a page-turner and the first time using my Kindle, so I just kept clicking faster and faster. Read it before sleep and had the most glorious of dreams.
I'm certain none of the heated scenes were in the original; otherwise the book would surely have been banned during the Comstock era. The sex scenes were beautifully written, most believable, and definitely put a smile to my face.
Yes, yes, buy this book you will not be disappointed.
Couldn't put it down, definitely a page-turner and the first time using my Kindle, so I just kept clicking faster and faster. Read it before sleep and had the most glorious of dreams.
I'm certain none of the heated scenes were in the original; otherwise the book would surely have been banned during the Comstock era. The sex scenes were beautifully written, most believable, and definitely put a smile to my face.
Yes, yes, buy this book you will not be disappointed.
May 11, 2013
Dirty and Dominant. THAT is the Heathcliff you can expect to get in this classic retelling, WUTHERING NIGHTS. The tale that is told is exhilarating and at times totally exhausting. Author I.J. Miller takes this classic story and makes it his own by incorporating scenes of fiery passion we wish we had in the original.
WUTHERING NIGHTS, like the original, is not a sweet love story full of goodness and light; it is a somewhat melancholy tale of forbidden love and all the trappings that entails.
From the beginning, I loved Heathcliff and loathed Catherine. Catherine is a conniving, spoiled little brat, leading Heathcliff around like a puppy for her amusement. Their love was destined to be epically tragic – a poor gypsy boy could never end up with this little girl who aspires to one day be the wife of some fine, upstanding gentleman. No, she keeps him as her dirty little secret, torturing them both with her wicked ways.
❝. . . for he realized that death with Catherine would be no different than life, as long as they were together.❞
Heathcliff behaved much like the puppy Catherine treated him as for most of their lives; loyal and loving to a fault. He was treated as a second-class citizen for the better part of his life, only truly being treated properly by Nelly, the housemaid and Mr. Earnshaw, Catherine’s father. A series of unfortunate events eventually drives Heathcliff from the only home he has ever known, Wuthering Heights, only to return six months later a changed man.
❝I know now our love can survive anything.❞
But can it?
The man he has become in the few short months away from Wuthering Heights is astounding. Gone is the meek and mild young man they once knew and in his place is a slightly more refined and infinitely more dominant man, determined to force those who wronged him to cower in his wake. And cower they do! Heathcliff is back to show everyone who is boss!
❝Whispering now, soft, but with the sense of aggression Heathcliff was capable of, he said in her ear as he also licked and bit her lobe, “You must always do as I say. If you do not know it now then I will soon teach it to you. It was my mistake not to take what is mine, but I will atone for that mistake and have you at last.❞
WUTHERING NIGHTS follows a path similar to the original, with the main exception being that Heathcliff is a sexual dominant, one who relishes in the humiliation of his submissives and the power he has over them – that power being a combination of the “monster in his pants” and his finely tuned sexual skills and though they might hate themselves for craving his touch, they seek it out nonetheless.
❝You are mine, completely. You will lick my feet as well as my boots. You will bathe me when I ask, take pleasure in servicing my every need. For you are my whore, a mere receptacle, not worthy of beholding my presence without permission.❞
WUTHERING NIGHTS is a great new spin on an old classic that is sure to delight a wide range of readers. Fans of the original WUTHERING HEIGHTS will love the level of heat that was missing from the original. Readers who skipped the classic will be delighted to learn the basic tragic story, but spiced up for today’s erotic reading pleasure.
✳✳ Copy provided by the author/publisher for an honest review.
✳✳ Reviewed on I ♥ Bookie Nookie Reviews
___________________________________________________
If you like this type of book, you might enjoy one of these groups. Check us out!
Menage Readers
Erotic Enchants
Bookie Nookie's Erotic Lending Group
WUTHERING NIGHTS, like the original, is not a sweet love story full of goodness and light; it is a somewhat melancholy tale of forbidden love and all the trappings that entails.
From the beginning, I loved Heathcliff and loathed Catherine. Catherine is a conniving, spoiled little brat, leading Heathcliff around like a puppy for her amusement. Their love was destined to be epically tragic – a poor gypsy boy could never end up with this little girl who aspires to one day be the wife of some fine, upstanding gentleman. No, she keeps him as her dirty little secret, torturing them both with her wicked ways.
❝. . . for he realized that death with Catherine would be no different than life, as long as they were together.❞
Heathcliff behaved much like the puppy Catherine treated him as for most of their lives; loyal and loving to a fault. He was treated as a second-class citizen for the better part of his life, only truly being treated properly by Nelly, the housemaid and Mr. Earnshaw, Catherine’s father. A series of unfortunate events eventually drives Heathcliff from the only home he has ever known, Wuthering Heights, only to return six months later a changed man.
❝I know now our love can survive anything.❞
But can it?
The man he has become in the few short months away from Wuthering Heights is astounding. Gone is the meek and mild young man they once knew and in his place is a slightly more refined and infinitely more dominant man, determined to force those who wronged him to cower in his wake. And cower they do! Heathcliff is back to show everyone who is boss!
❝Whispering now, soft, but with the sense of aggression Heathcliff was capable of, he said in her ear as he also licked and bit her lobe, “You must always do as I say. If you do not know it now then I will soon teach it to you. It was my mistake not to take what is mine, but I will atone for that mistake and have you at last.❞
WUTHERING NIGHTS follows a path similar to the original, with the main exception being that Heathcliff is a sexual dominant, one who relishes in the humiliation of his submissives and the power he has over them – that power being a combination of the “monster in his pants” and his finely tuned sexual skills and though they might hate themselves for craving his touch, they seek it out nonetheless.
❝You are mine, completely. You will lick my feet as well as my boots. You will bathe me when I ask, take pleasure in servicing my every need. For you are my whore, a mere receptacle, not worthy of beholding my presence without permission.❞
WUTHERING NIGHTS is a great new spin on an old classic that is sure to delight a wide range of readers. Fans of the original WUTHERING HEIGHTS will love the level of heat that was missing from the original. Readers who skipped the classic will be delighted to learn the basic tragic story, but spiced up for today’s erotic reading pleasure.
✳✳ Copy provided by the author/publisher for an honest review.
✳✳ Reviewed on I ♥ Bookie Nookie Reviews
___________________________________________________
If you like this type of book, you might enjoy one of these groups. Check us out!
Menage Readers
Erotic Enchants
Bookie Nookie's Erotic Lending Group
April 8, 2013
When I saw the title of this one, and that it was an erotic retelling of the classic novel, Wuthering Heights, my interest was grabbed. There are a number of authors who go about adding his or her own spin to stories from the literary canon. Wuthering Nights stuck out from many other similar titles out there.
What I found in this novel is that Miller made use of a well-written characters and a story line but really made it a story of its own. From the start, I was drawn into the setting of the Heights and later on the Grange, as well as the beauty and dangers at the moors. I feel that the way the characters were written in with these settings made it all stick in my mind even better. For a reader like me, a reader who doesn’t read many historical novels due to the language style used, to enjoy the writing of this book, I think that is the icing on the top of this novel. Without the accessibility a more “modern” reader like me found in this novel coupled with writing more true to Brontë herself than Miller’s contemporaries, I may have been less interested through to the end than I was.
Another thing I enjoyed about Wuthering Nights is the way the erotic element was thrown in. It never once felt out-of-place. There were a lot of steamy moments between all of the characters. I liked that there was also a great deal of romance mixed in. This wasn’t a book that was to add “smut” to a classic. Miller worked descriptive sex scenes that only enhanced the emotions between the characters, as well as pushed much of the plot along in Miller’s own way, making this story the author’s own without following a straightforward blueprint set up by Brontë.
If you’re looking to relive a classic or to experience the Wuthering Heights story for the first time, or just looking for an enjoyable erotic novel that’s a little different than others out there, Wuthering Nights might be a novel to check out.
What I found in this novel is that Miller made use of a well-written characters and a story line but really made it a story of its own. From the start, I was drawn into the setting of the Heights and later on the Grange, as well as the beauty and dangers at the moors. I feel that the way the characters were written in with these settings made it all stick in my mind even better. For a reader like me, a reader who doesn’t read many historical novels due to the language style used, to enjoy the writing of this book, I think that is the icing on the top of this novel. Without the accessibility a more “modern” reader like me found in this novel coupled with writing more true to Brontë herself than Miller’s contemporaries, I may have been less interested through to the end than I was.
Another thing I enjoyed about Wuthering Nights is the way the erotic element was thrown in. It never once felt out-of-place. There were a lot of steamy moments between all of the characters. I liked that there was also a great deal of romance mixed in. This wasn’t a book that was to add “smut” to a classic. Miller worked descriptive sex scenes that only enhanced the emotions between the characters, as well as pushed much of the plot along in Miller’s own way, making this story the author’s own without following a straightforward blueprint set up by Brontë.
If you’re looking to relive a classic or to experience the Wuthering Heights story for the first time, or just looking for an enjoyable erotic novel that’s a little different than others out there, Wuthering Nights might be a novel to check out.
December 1, 2023
If you want to read about people eating each other's asses, read this book.
April 24, 2013
Miller, I.J. and Emily Bronte. “Wuthering Nights: An Erotic Retelling of Wuthering Heights”, Grand Central Publishing, 2013.
Adding the Erotic
Amos Lassen
We will never know how Emily Bronte would feel about I.J. Miller’s retelling of her story about the love between Heathcliff and Catherine but I think it is a wonderful read. When the book arrived, I showed it to one of my neighbors who remarked, “They can’t find anything new to write about, so they ruin our classics”? I simply replied “Nothing is ruined, it is simply added to. Besides, Hollywood does it all the time”.
I decided to make this read a two book event. First I reread the original (I was surprised how much I enjoyed it when I read it this time—I had not read it since my undergraduate days when it was required reading for a course I took) and then I would read Miller’s version. The two go hand in hand and complement each other. We can only imagine how difficult it must be to step into another author’s shoes and rework a novel that has thrilled readers for so long.
In Bronte’s original we read of the tragic love between the beautiful Catherine and the mysterious and brooding Heathcliff. Their feelings were restrained but were a step away from being carnal and we felt that. Miller brings us that carnality.
“Heathcliff pushed Catherine to her back and began to lick and kiss her neck, tasting her. She arched her throat and moaned softly. He licked down while cupping her full breasts in his hands and began nuzzling and sucking her nipples”…
Catherine and Heathcliff’s love was doomed from the very get-go. Heathcliff had been abandoned as a child and was an orphan of low birth. Catherine was impulsive and wild but could tame the man who sees her as his “beshert”, his soul-mate. (I doubt that Bronte was aware of the Yiddish concept of soul-mate). The love they shared was possessive and would change them forever.
Miller does more than just re-imagine their story. She uses Bronte’s characters and character sketches and updates Bronte’s language so that we, in the twenty first century, can enjoy the read without having to get through the original’s language style. She adds the eroticism and the original romance bursts into life with the addition of sex scenes (which are never tawdry or smutty) that truly enhance the emotions between the lovers and propelled the plot forward as if this is her own story.
Miller frames her telling with the story of a modern traveler to the moors and the scene of the original novel. Herein I understood exactly what Miller was doing. She was not just adding sex to Bronte; she has written a new novel that is inspired by the original. As we read we recognize the original characters and Bronte’s original emotional stress. We read of the awakenings of sexual feelings in the two lovers and we gain a foreboding sense as Heathcliff realizes that sex and power are connected. He becomes more sexual and more dominant as the novel continues and soon the emotions of envy and manipulation enter the plot and Heathcliff uses these sexually. The original was not a happy love story and neither is this. Negativity is expressed through sex but passion still reigns supreme. By risk of writing a spoiler, I will simply say that the love between Catherine and Heathcliff becomes dark but compelling.
When Bronte wrote the book it was considered controversial because of its depictions of mental and physical cruelty and here is where Miller lets us see the novel in a different light by adding the erotic. Her eroticism replaces the dark parts of Bronte and her totally integrated into the text. Nothing is gratuitous and I wondered how the original could have lasted without them. Literary purists may take issue with Miller but so what. Recreational readers get a story that they enjoy and let’s face it—it is all about pleasing those who read for pleasure.
Adding the Erotic
Amos Lassen
We will never know how Emily Bronte would feel about I.J. Miller’s retelling of her story about the love between Heathcliff and Catherine but I think it is a wonderful read. When the book arrived, I showed it to one of my neighbors who remarked, “They can’t find anything new to write about, so they ruin our classics”? I simply replied “Nothing is ruined, it is simply added to. Besides, Hollywood does it all the time”.
I decided to make this read a two book event. First I reread the original (I was surprised how much I enjoyed it when I read it this time—I had not read it since my undergraduate days when it was required reading for a course I took) and then I would read Miller’s version. The two go hand in hand and complement each other. We can only imagine how difficult it must be to step into another author’s shoes and rework a novel that has thrilled readers for so long.
In Bronte’s original we read of the tragic love between the beautiful Catherine and the mysterious and brooding Heathcliff. Their feelings were restrained but were a step away from being carnal and we felt that. Miller brings us that carnality.
“Heathcliff pushed Catherine to her back and began to lick and kiss her neck, tasting her. She arched her throat and moaned softly. He licked down while cupping her full breasts in his hands and began nuzzling and sucking her nipples”…
Catherine and Heathcliff’s love was doomed from the very get-go. Heathcliff had been abandoned as a child and was an orphan of low birth. Catherine was impulsive and wild but could tame the man who sees her as his “beshert”, his soul-mate. (I doubt that Bronte was aware of the Yiddish concept of soul-mate). The love they shared was possessive and would change them forever.
Miller does more than just re-imagine their story. She uses Bronte’s characters and character sketches and updates Bronte’s language so that we, in the twenty first century, can enjoy the read without having to get through the original’s language style. She adds the eroticism and the original romance bursts into life with the addition of sex scenes (which are never tawdry or smutty) that truly enhance the emotions between the lovers and propelled the plot forward as if this is her own story.
Miller frames her telling with the story of a modern traveler to the moors and the scene of the original novel. Herein I understood exactly what Miller was doing. She was not just adding sex to Bronte; she has written a new novel that is inspired by the original. As we read we recognize the original characters and Bronte’s original emotional stress. We read of the awakenings of sexual feelings in the two lovers and we gain a foreboding sense as Heathcliff realizes that sex and power are connected. He becomes more sexual and more dominant as the novel continues and soon the emotions of envy and manipulation enter the plot and Heathcliff uses these sexually. The original was not a happy love story and neither is this. Negativity is expressed through sex but passion still reigns supreme. By risk of writing a spoiler, I will simply say that the love between Catherine and Heathcliff becomes dark but compelling.
When Bronte wrote the book it was considered controversial because of its depictions of mental and physical cruelty and here is where Miller lets us see the novel in a different light by adding the erotic. Her eroticism replaces the dark parts of Bronte and her totally integrated into the text. Nothing is gratuitous and I wondered how the original could have lasted without them. Literary purists may take issue with Miller but so what. Recreational readers get a story that they enjoy and let’s face it—it is all about pleasing those who read for pleasure.
June 14, 2013
A fan of kinky sexed up reinterpretation of classics, I looked forward to this book. I've never read Wuthering Heights, but I've always been told of the story's intense repressed sexual undertones. Since the Victorian age seemed to be filled with these sublimated perversions, it would be a treat to have them completely brought to light in an erotic tale.
In this retelling, it just didn't work for me. While Ms. Miller did try hard to keep the tension and the star-crossed lover feel, it came across as a melodramatic soap opera for me. I didn't like any of the characters. I felt pity for Heathcliff at first. Then it turned into disgust. Even his quasi-BDSM didn't arouse me. He's not a Dom. He's a sexual abusive asshole. While there are probably many men and women who think Heathcliff's brand of BDSM is how it is, and maybe some even practice it this way, it's not how I know it or experience it. This was just not my kink. Because to me, Heathcliff's intent before, during and after are a heinous mockery of a good Dom. He is a poster boy of what not to do. The execution of the BDSM scenes were okay. They didn't really pull me in.
Now to be clear, this story is supposed to be a historical erotica of a plausible situation. This isn't supposed to be a non-con or dub-con book which is why the BDSM in here doesn't do it for me. I have read a reinterpretation of Jane Eyre which it completely kinked out and it's clear it's supposed to be dub-con and non-con upfront. I loved that book.
The difficulty for me in this book is the lack of appealing characters. Even the next generation of kids who are all kissing first cousins doesn't do it for me. Every character in here is dysfunctional and comes off mentally unbalanced. Even Nelly the servant is mentally ill. Why she stayed so long with these loonies just baffled me. Yes, it's hard to find a new job without good references back then, but seriously, this was a bit extreme. Some of it had to do with the fact that she was enamoured with Heathcliff. What female in this book other than Cathy didn't want a lick of his manhood? Just bizarre since Heathcliff was not what I consider romantic, heroic or alpha.
Catherine in this book is a perfect example of a woman diagnosed with "hysteria" back then. I'm surprised she wasn't committed to a psych ward. She came across as a spoiled brat and ended up as a pathetic pussy. It was very frustrating to read about her decline. Basically, without a man she's hopeless.
This book felt dragged out for me. There were many scenes which cluttered the story. It's as if there were unnecessary details to build more of a plot or a better character development. For me, it had an adverse effect. The plot felt more clunky and the characters fell flat. I would recommend characters to be designed with at least one appealing characteristic. The engaging characteristic should not be "martyr for love". In addition, sticking to just one or two point of views would help. If one really needs to show from different character's perspective, write separate books. Other authors do this very successfully - Ms. Anne McCaffrey and Ms. Annabel Joseph are great examples. Regretfully this book did not appeal to me.
*provided by NetGalley
In this retelling, it just didn't work for me. While Ms. Miller did try hard to keep the tension and the star-crossed lover feel, it came across as a melodramatic soap opera for me. I didn't like any of the characters. I felt pity for Heathcliff at first. Then it turned into disgust. Even his quasi-BDSM didn't arouse me. He's not a Dom. He's a sexual abusive asshole. While there are probably many men and women who think Heathcliff's brand of BDSM is how it is, and maybe some even practice it this way, it's not how I know it or experience it. This was just not my kink. Because to me, Heathcliff's intent before, during and after are a heinous mockery of a good Dom. He is a poster boy of what not to do. The execution of the BDSM scenes were okay. They didn't really pull me in.
Now to be clear, this story is supposed to be a historical erotica of a plausible situation. This isn't supposed to be a non-con or dub-con book which is why the BDSM in here doesn't do it for me. I have read a reinterpretation of Jane Eyre which it completely kinked out and it's clear it's supposed to be dub-con and non-con upfront. I loved that book.
The difficulty for me in this book is the lack of appealing characters. Even the next generation of kids who are all kissing first cousins doesn't do it for me. Every character in here is dysfunctional and comes off mentally unbalanced. Even Nelly the servant is mentally ill. Why she stayed so long with these loonies just baffled me. Yes, it's hard to find a new job without good references back then, but seriously, this was a bit extreme. Some of it had to do with the fact that she was enamoured with Heathcliff. What female in this book other than Cathy didn't want a lick of his manhood? Just bizarre since Heathcliff was not what I consider romantic, heroic or alpha.
Catherine in this book is a perfect example of a woman diagnosed with "hysteria" back then. I'm surprised she wasn't committed to a psych ward. She came across as a spoiled brat and ended up as a pathetic pussy. It was very frustrating to read about her decline. Basically, without a man she's hopeless.
This book felt dragged out for me. There were many scenes which cluttered the story. It's as if there were unnecessary details to build more of a plot or a better character development. For me, it had an adverse effect. The plot felt more clunky and the characters fell flat. I would recommend characters to be designed with at least one appealing characteristic. The engaging characteristic should not be "martyr for love". In addition, sticking to just one or two point of views would help. If one really needs to show from different character's perspective, write separate books. Other authors do this very successfully - Ms. Anne McCaffrey and Ms. Annabel Joseph are great examples. Regretfully this book did not appeal to me.
*provided by NetGalley
April 25, 2013
NOTE: I received a copy of this book from the author in exchange for an honest review
WHAT I LIKED:
Before I begin, I must admit to having never read the original Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte. To be perfectly honest, I had a hard time reading any of the classics. They generally bored me, much as it shames me to admit that. If only they'd been written like this one...
I jumped on the chance to review this solely because it was a new author and I was curious to read an erotic historical romance. I'm a bit dense in that it didn't really occur to me that it would be a retelling of the classic novel. Once I realized what it was, I was a bit apprehensive thanks to my dubious track record with classical novels. Man was I wrong.
I can't speak to how closely this follows the original Bronte book. I do know the general plot and it hit the major points as best as I can tell. The style was certainly very similar to the time period with the exception of the prologue and epilogue. These are written in a modern voice and designed to draw you into the story, achieving it with admirable success.
Despite having issues in the past with staying interested in classical books, I expected this to be written in that style since it was not a modern retelling. I was quite impressed with the author's ability to mimic the style without making it dull. As for the content? Holy hell is it scorching, explicit, and at times, a bit depraved. All I can say is that if more of the classics had been written like this, I sure as hell would have been more excited to read them lol.
The sex in this book is graphic and frequent, but it enhances the story. The author doesn't just drop sex scenes into Bronte's novel to make it an erotic book. I.J. uses the sex scenes to show the descent of Heathcliff into increasingly erratic behavior. To show his proclivities and need to dominate as well as to illustrate the tumultuous relationship with Catherine. All in all, I really felt the scenes added to the tale in a way that can be hard to achieve with some erotic books.
WHAT I DIDN'T LIKE:
There really isn't anything.
OVERALL VERDICT: 5/5 Blue Duckies!!
If you're like me and weren't necessarily a fan of the classics back in school, you must give this a try. It's truly unlike anything I've ever read. This book is not for the faint of heart, but damn was it engrossing. Be warned, this is one of the most graphic erotic romances I've read in a while and includes group masturbation, some BDSM, domination, and plenty of scorching sex. I highly recommend this book and author.
WHAT I LIKED:
Before I begin, I must admit to having never read the original Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte. To be perfectly honest, I had a hard time reading any of the classics. They generally bored me, much as it shames me to admit that. If only they'd been written like this one...
I jumped on the chance to review this solely because it was a new author and I was curious to read an erotic historical romance. I'm a bit dense in that it didn't really occur to me that it would be a retelling of the classic novel. Once I realized what it was, I was a bit apprehensive thanks to my dubious track record with classical novels. Man was I wrong.
I can't speak to how closely this follows the original Bronte book. I do know the general plot and it hit the major points as best as I can tell. The style was certainly very similar to the time period with the exception of the prologue and epilogue. These are written in a modern voice and designed to draw you into the story, achieving it with admirable success.
Despite having issues in the past with staying interested in classical books, I expected this to be written in that style since it was not a modern retelling. I was quite impressed with the author's ability to mimic the style without making it dull. As for the content? Holy hell is it scorching, explicit, and at times, a bit depraved. All I can say is that if more of the classics had been written like this, I sure as hell would have been more excited to read them lol.
The sex in this book is graphic and frequent, but it enhances the story. The author doesn't just drop sex scenes into Bronte's novel to make it an erotic book. I.J. uses the sex scenes to show the descent of Heathcliff into increasingly erratic behavior. To show his proclivities and need to dominate as well as to illustrate the tumultuous relationship with Catherine. All in all, I really felt the scenes added to the tale in a way that can be hard to achieve with some erotic books.
WHAT I DIDN'T LIKE:
There really isn't anything.
OVERALL VERDICT: 5/5 Blue Duckies!!
If you're like me and weren't necessarily a fan of the classics back in school, you must give this a try. It's truly unlike anything I've ever read. This book is not for the faint of heart, but damn was it engrossing. Be warned, this is one of the most graphic erotic romances I've read in a while and includes group masturbation, some BDSM, domination, and plenty of scorching sex. I highly recommend this book and author.
March 5, 2013
It's difficult today to encounter certain 19th-century literary characters without thinking there's a med for that. Case in point: Emily Bronte's Wuthering Heights. Controversial in its time for its unflinching portrayal of brutish mental and physical cruelty, the novel served as a tipping point for me. After it, I wouldn't willingly read another novel of its temperament unless a professor's syllabus demanded it.
But now comes an erotic retelling of the classical, Wuthering Nights, and it does the original justice--and one better. Author I.J. Miller expertly drapes the new version in the over-arching oppressive and obsessive tenor of the original and he casts its prose in perfect cadence as well. Bronte's characters and all their foibles come alive again in Miller's hands, their flourishes as dramatic and tragic as ever. But that's where the homage ends and the erotic begins...
For all its moodiness, Miller's Wuthering Nights is incredibly sensual and sexual. Its erotic scenes are as unflinching in their detail as the original was in its harshness, and the characters' sexual appetites are as unrestrained as their dysfunctional passions. And if you're skeptical about how Heights could become Nights, let me assure you: the erotic passages are so smoothly integrated into the tale, it's hard to remember the original without them.
Miller does take certain liberties with the plot, tweaking its plot in ways that might well surprise you, and he does give Heathcliff an opportunity for redemption (a moment that gave me an emotional payoff the original never did). But if ever a novel deserves another (and better) look, its Wuthering Heights. I.J. Miller deftly accomplishes it with Wuthering Nights.
But now comes an erotic retelling of the classical, Wuthering Nights, and it does the original justice--and one better. Author I.J. Miller expertly drapes the new version in the over-arching oppressive and obsessive tenor of the original and he casts its prose in perfect cadence as well. Bronte's characters and all their foibles come alive again in Miller's hands, their flourishes as dramatic and tragic as ever. But that's where the homage ends and the erotic begins...
For all its moodiness, Miller's Wuthering Nights is incredibly sensual and sexual. Its erotic scenes are as unflinching in their detail as the original was in its harshness, and the characters' sexual appetites are as unrestrained as their dysfunctional passions. And if you're skeptical about how Heights could become Nights, let me assure you: the erotic passages are so smoothly integrated into the tale, it's hard to remember the original without them.
Miller does take certain liberties with the plot, tweaking its plot in ways that might well surprise you, and he does give Heathcliff an opportunity for redemption (a moment that gave me an emotional payoff the original never did). But if ever a novel deserves another (and better) look, its Wuthering Heights. I.J. Miller deftly accomplishes it with Wuthering Nights.
February 25, 2014
**I was privileged to received an ARC copy from the author in exchange of an honest review.**
Well in all honesty I was a bit apprehensive with this story, I always found the original version so full of drama and at times I found Catherine infuriating and bratty, obviously the author follows the original story but I now realised that what the original was lacking was a release of all the sexual tension that the leads hadn't been able to fully explore.
Of course is an adaptation so the essence cannot be changed and one must remember that this is not your happy go lucky story but a dark powerful one that deals with an emotional and doomed outcome, and of course in this retelling we see a proper transformation in the character of Heathcliff, after his absence he comes back as a completely changed man, domineering and a confident one that totally abuses his power, at times in a very humiliating way, oh yes revenge is sweet.
One thing I have to admire the author for is for not turning this into a cheap version of the original but on the contrary to actually give it a deeper level and a feeling of completeness, I loved the level of eroticism, and the scenes are carried out in a magnificent way.
The writing is to the standard of the prosaic style from Brontes which was done to perfection and was achieved flawlessly.
I Loved the descriptive surrounding the scenery and I was able to be transported to the era.
In conclusion, Wuthering Nights is a tale packed with passion, obsession, desire, drama, in general all the attributes that make this a fabulous and a very enjoyable read.
Read
August 21, 2018I've long thought sex is the elephant in the room in Wuthering Heights. That Heathcliff has a sort of unchained male energy and is sexy in a dangerous, abusive way is made clear in the text without need for actual depiction of intercourse or anything verging on it. Its not being mentioned gives it an added forcefulness.
So I.J. Miller's artistic decision to intersperse large chunks of Wuthering Heights's words and scenes with detailed descriptions of BDSM sexual congress, while gratuitous, has an intertextual logic that doing the same thing in Pride & Prejudice (as people have!) does not. It even does at times strike me as an actual missing part of Wuthering Heights, such as on Healthcliff and Isabella's wedding night.
It's more often comical, though. When people in the original text would be having a conversation, in this alternate Wuthering Heights they've loosened their nether garments and are licking and stroking each other off. When interrupted -- as they always are -- they straighten out their clothes and resume the scene where it left off in the actual Wuthering Heights. The varied ways the author finds to describe Heathcliff's heroically large endowment reduced me to helpless laughter on a commuter train.
But that Hollywood ending! The way I.J. Miller has dragged everything into the bright light of obviousness to impose certaintitude on the brilliant and uncompromising ambiguities of the original text! I can forgive everything, except that.
So I.J. Miller's artistic decision to intersperse large chunks of Wuthering Heights's words and scenes with detailed descriptions of BDSM sexual congress, while gratuitous, has an intertextual logic that doing the same thing in Pride & Prejudice (as people have!) does not. It even does at times strike me as an actual missing part of Wuthering Heights, such as on Healthcliff and Isabella's wedding night.
It's more often comical, though. When people in the original text would be having a conversation, in this alternate Wuthering Heights they've loosened their nether garments and are licking and stroking each other off. When interrupted -- as they always are -- they straighten out their clothes and resume the scene where it left off in the actual Wuthering Heights. The varied ways the author finds to describe Heathcliff's heroically large endowment reduced me to helpless laughter on a commuter train.
But that Hollywood ending! The way I.J. Miller has dragged everything into the bright light of obviousness to impose certaintitude on the brilliant and uncompromising ambiguities of the original text! I can forgive everything, except that.
June 4, 2013
Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte is my favorite novel, but this didn't stop me from checking out L.J. Miller's version of the beautiful and tragic tale. I have to admit that L.J. Miller is a very good writer and that there is a good balance between describing the erotic scenes and the rest of the plot. However, there are certain scenes that really bugged me and got under my skin after awhile. I couldn't help labeling the Heathcliff in this version as a sexual predator, a rapist. Perhaps that's a little too harsh, but there is definitely some forced sex in this book and unfortunately it is glorified, something which I find very disturbing in romance novels lately. While I have no problem with romance or erotica, I do find trouble in scenes where the man forces himself upon the woman and 'eventually' her body tells her yes but her mind is telling her no. That is forced sex, and that is rape. There is nothing sexy in that. Originally I was going to give this three stars, but I just can't overlook these disturbing forced sex scenes. When a person says no or stop, that should be the end of it. I don't care if it's a man or a woman uttering those words. Coerced sex is just not sexy to me. It never will be. Thanks to 50 Shades of Grey, though, we get a lot of romance that has this disturbing trend.
January 16, 2014
I'd been wanting to read/reread Wuthering Heights because I couldn't remember it and it seemed like a good time to get a refresher. So imagine my joy when it turned out my library had it available as a dloadable audio book!
And then imagine my horror when I realized that I hadn't downloaded Wuthering HEIGHTS, but Wuthering NIGHTS instead. I had even thought that the cover seemed weird, but that hadn't stopped me in progressing towards disappointment. And, oh, a disappointment it was.
Honestly, I spent most of the book making D: D: face and railing about all the things that were just gross or off putting (do we really need a 'PS - PEDO TIME!' reminder in the middle of a sex scene? How is referring to a gent's member as his 'boyhood' [because he's not 9 inches of MAN LOVE] not off putting? WHY IS GALLONS OF SEMEN EVERYWHERE CONSIDERED ATTRACTIVE? Why does it have to be in every sex scene? How are these people not massively dehydrated from the amount of sex juice they're CONSTANTLY churning out??).
I went into it knowing it was going to be bad, and in that stead it did not disappoint. But that still didn't make it enjoyable by any stripe.
And then imagine my horror when I realized that I hadn't downloaded Wuthering HEIGHTS, but Wuthering NIGHTS instead. I had even thought that the cover seemed weird, but that hadn't stopped me in progressing towards disappointment. And, oh, a disappointment it was.
Honestly, I spent most of the book making D: D: face and railing about all the things that were just gross or off putting (do we really need a 'PS - PEDO TIME!' reminder in the middle of a sex scene? How is referring to a gent's member as his 'boyhood' [because he's not 9 inches of MAN LOVE] not off putting? WHY IS GALLONS OF SEMEN EVERYWHERE CONSIDERED ATTRACTIVE? Why does it have to be in every sex scene? How are these people not massively dehydrated from the amount of sex juice they're CONSTANTLY churning out??).
I went into it knowing it was going to be bad, and in that stead it did not disappoint. But that still didn't make it enjoyable by any stripe.
November 26, 2013
I won a copy of this book through First Reads.
For those who enjoy romantic classics and often wish that it was socially acceptable to go into further detail, this book will certainly please you. I.J Miller kept the spirit of the book alive and gently wove her touches along its pages, blending both modern and classic elements without going overboard. The language was kept true to the period, something that often breaks a novel for me no matter how engaging the plot and characters may be.
I only have one negative, and it’s really something of personal preference. I found the erotic scenes occurring far too much between chapters which made it rather bland in some areas. I would have loved to have more of the story with dabs of erotica here and there.
For those who enjoy romantic classics and often wish that it was socially acceptable to go into further detail, this book will certainly please you. I.J Miller kept the spirit of the book alive and gently wove her touches along its pages, blending both modern and classic elements without going overboard. The language was kept true to the period, something that often breaks a novel for me no matter how engaging the plot and characters may be.
I only have one negative, and it’s really something of personal preference. I found the erotic scenes occurring far too much between chapters which made it rather bland in some areas. I would have loved to have more of the story with dabs of erotica here and there.
February 9, 2013
Hey, all! My name's Codey and I'm only an occasional reader of erotica, but I have to say this is one of the more exciting and interesting ones that I've read. I read the original awhile ago in college, but this book brought it all back. I thought the whole thing was super sexy and also thought-provoking (something you don't often see in erotica). It wasn't a run of the mill romance with all sweetness and fluff. Miller explores some dark and deep issues and has a vivid, captivating style. He knows Bronte's characters well and gives them a hot edge that's sharp with sexual energy. A great read!
February 9, 2013
I really, really enjoyed this book. I was a big Bronte fan growing up as well as a lover of romance novels, so the combination of the two was quite the treat. I think Miller does a great job intertwining his style with Bronte's. I also think he takes a really creative spin on the characters. It's also just a really fun read. I also liked his take on Heathcliff. It was also cool how he focused on the next generation within the book, which is something you didn't get to see as much in the original. Overall, I would definitely recommend this book as an exciting and interesting read!
February 19, 2013
Talk about intense. Kind of expecting the usual mashup, but this book takes you on a very passionate journey. There are times you want to kick Heathcliff in the ass and give Catherine a good shake. But their love is true and the story never lets go of that. The eroticism has extra sizzle because it seems so real, so appropriate to the story. No doubt if Bronte was looking for the Fifty Shades audience she would have gone this route. Only this chick can write! And so can Miller. Hard to figure out what was new, what was old. Doesn't matter. A must read!
May 10, 2013
This book was one of the hottest retellings of literature that I have ever read. It was dark, erotic and haunted my dreams for many nights. Heathcliff and Cathy are portrayed true to their characters. The story offers a much deeper insight to the psychological workings behind the scenes of all the players and gives new life to the loves and lusts of each of them. Even at the darkest parts of the story, I was enraptured by I.J. Miller's retelling of this epic novel. Forever more I will have them entwined in my mind and heart. An excellent read I can't recommend higher! Scorcher!!
February 17, 2013
umm...........
August 15, 2013
I have not read Wuthering Heights and need to do so, however this as a stand alone was great! Heathcliff and Catherines story rivals Romeo and Juliet in my book! Great read
December 8, 2015
Makes 50 Shades seem like a masterpiece.
April 27, 2016
Steamy as f*ck
Displaying 1 - 29 of 102 reviews