Time of the Witches, by Anna Myers
"Mama, I want to charge Rose as a witch."
[...:]
"That is ridiculous my dear," said her mother. "Rose cannot be a witch. The girl still owes us a year of service. Maybe next year (Time of the Witches, p. 162)."
Welcome to the absurdity of the Salem Witch trials, a dark period in America's history. Nineteen innocent men and women were killed as witches; killed without proof other than the flimsy accusations of a group of young girls. "Time of the Witches" is an attempt to consider the possible causes of the trials, and just how an entire town could have been caught up in a witch frenzy.
Drucilla, the protagonist of "Time of the Witches," is born as her mother dies. She is first fostered with another family, which includes her best friend, Gabe. The two were born at the same time, and were raised as brother and sister. But when Gabe's parents die as well, the two are orphans and live with other families in Salem Village. When they are twelve, the two are separated, and Dru goes to live with the Putnams. Ann Putnam's behavior is quite odd, as is her daughter's, but she accepts Dru as a member of the family and even has the girl call her "mother."
Ann Putnam's puzzling behavior (crying fits, suicide attempts, etc.) is attributed to the loss of several children. Early in Dru's time with the family the woman loses yet another baby, sending her spiraling into a deep depression, convinced that someone is murdering her babies. While Dru knows that the Putnam family is abnormal, she does her best to make Ann Putnam feel better - after all, the woman calls Dru her daughter. The relationship between the two sometimes made me say "enough already, I can't believe that Dru is falling for this," but then I also thought to myself that perhaps if Dru had had a better mother figure in her life she wouldn't have fallen for Ann's machinations.
Ann's behavior soon ratchets up quite a few notches when a new reverend moves into town. She is convinced that his servant, Tituba, can tell her who is behind the deaths of her babies. She sends her daughter and Dru to the reverend's house, among a group of girls who flock to the exotic servant who tells fortunes and stories of witches. But then the reverend's daughter, scared of the stories, falls into a stupor and the madness begins. Woman after woman is arrested, each accused of being a witch.
At the first trial, Dru sits with the girls, and is drawn into their antics, of feeling ghostly fingers pulling their hair and touching their necks. She isn't sure...did she feel something? Or didn't she? Almost unwittingly she agrees with the others and condemns a woman to death.
The cover is what drew me to "Time of the Witches," and for a while, I thought it was the best part of the book, due to the very slow start. I kept at it though, because I was curious what approach Myers would take to the Salem Witch Trials. She considers groupthink and mass hysteria as a possible explanation for what happened. The imagined character of Drucilla is caught between her conscience and the constrictions of threats - she could be the next witch if she spoke against what was happening.
Myers has an interesting idea, but the execution is a little off. The setup for the main event is far too long. Many of the interactions between Drucilla and Ann Putnam could have been condensed; the relationship between the two is established early on, and doesn't need to be continually thrust at the reader. But the relationship between Drucilla and Gabe, her childhood friend, is done very well, and is a great plot device to examine Dru's loyalties to her friend, and her adoptive family.
After I finished "Time of the Witches" I sat back for a while and thought about it. Although the book started slowly, as I've said, in the end I'm glad I stuck with it. It was worth it.
4/5.