If you liked the first book in the trilogy, this one won’t disappoint, though the friendships are more fractured here and the girls are dealing with some heavier choices and losses.
This one mostly takes place in autumn and winter as the girls are in their last year of high school figuring out what’s next (though most scenes still happen at the orchard). Each girl is struggling and for the most part, rather than reach out to one another, they pull away and don’t necessarily deal well on their own.
Murphy, who’s always longed to escape the confines of her small town, is torn between an opportunity in New York and her love for Rex, a small town quiet life kind of guy.
Birdie’s torn, too, between her desire to broaden her horizons and life in her beloved orchard, fueling her angst is the forward motion of her relationship with Enrico and the niggling fear that her pseudo second mother, Poopie may want to go home to Mexico.
Leeda remains the least defined of the girls, though her identity crisis often makes her the most interesting in this sequel as her behavior is rarely predictable and she has some seriously dramatic moments with her mom, as well as a late night incident where she’s at achingly loose ends (though it wasn’t examined/addressed as thoroughly afterwards as I might have preferred, it still felt impactful in the moment).
There were times when the girls frustrated me, I didn’t like their decisions or behavior, but the author is really good at making you understand how these girls tick (even Leeda who doesn’t yet understand herself), so even when I don’t like their choices, they still make sense, it feels true to their personalities, and in the end, their flaws make for a much better story than whatever ideal way I had wanted that character to handle the situation.