3.5 stars
Kyle has recently been released from prison where he served a year sentence for drugs, and though he’s trying to find his footing in this new world, it’s not going as well as he needs. He is still grieving the break-up that drove him to drugs in the first place, and without being able to get past that, he decides to make an even cleaner break than he already has and ships off to Montana to learn how to be a cowboy. His demons follow him, though, and the self-destructive behavior he’d been exhibiting before manifests in new ways, even when Tad, the second in command at the ranch, warns him about it.
Though this is marked as a romance, I’m hesitant to go along with that label. This is much more of a character exploration about a young man desperate to erase everything from his life that might cause him to feel something via any means necessary. After the break-up, his tendencies drift to drugs and the oblivion that promises. A year in jail, however, teaches him he doesn’t really want to go back. The problem is, he hasn’t exorcised the demons that drove him to drugs in the first place.
So his addiction shifts to anonymous sex with a string of men that continues even after he goes to the ranch. During the day, he drives himself physically, and at night, he finds escape in the men he picks up. Tad, the second in command, catches his eye early on, but it’s not until he warns Kyle about being a little more temperate in his behavior or risk getting thrown off the ranch (or worse), that their relationship shifts from professional to more personal. This shift throws Kyle into a tailspin even more, his desperation rising to potent levels.
It’s the character of Kyle and his nihilism that forms the heart of this story. Feel for him, and it’s easy to feel for the entire arc. Told in 1st person/present tense, the story encourages the reader to live life in Kyle’s shoes as it progresses, which has the unfortunate side effect of diminishing the richness of other characters. Most are throwaways. Only Kyle’s friend Hazel back home and Tad are given enough page time to have the opportunity to come to life, but for me, Tad at least fell very short. He’s a figure in Kyle’s desperation rather than a man, even when he is spilling his heart out. Filtered through Kyle’s eyes, his characterization is cheated out of real depth to become instead a symbol in Kyle’s ongoing struggles.
I did enjoy this story, but the overabundance of gay men in Montana and on the ranch added a dissonance to the overall realistic feel of the work. The subject matter and its presentation felt too real world to easily buy into Kyle’s promiscuity in such a remote place. He gets sex on his very first day at the ranch, and then every day afterward, enough to gain a reputation. I couldn’t resolve this need for suspending my disbelief with the blunt treatment of his addictions.
In the end, it’s a thoughtful diversion. It’s not entirely sure what genre it wants to sit in, whether it’s literary, erotica, or erotic romance, but Kyle is interesting enough to deserve attention for the few minutes it would take to read his story.