Having loved both authors’ realistic NIV books so very much (Red, White and Whole/The Magical Imperfect), I was quite nervous about reading a mixed format, more standard text fantasy book by the two of them. But by the end of the book, it was clear that both the partnership and the format change was very successful. Tripti, 11 year old from an Indian heritage, and Sam, a Jewish, geologist in the making, both attend a summer camp and come home with mysterious rocks that change temperature, color, and give every evidence that they move and have sentience. The two begin to correspondence by email, snail mail, “Miscord” and video chat an attempt to solve a mystery that seems to have ties to their favorite dragon fantasy series called Dragon Gems. Along the way,Sam and Tripti become friends, share friendship and school woes, describe family events that include much from their family’s cultural traditions and unravel the unbelievable truth—that their so-called rocks are really aliens who just want to go home. Older elementary readers will get drawn into the mystery and wonder and solve aspects as the story continues. Extra morsels included in this fantasy book are recipes from Jewish and Indian cuisine and a code that really astute students may understand before the solution is given. Additionally, many may begin to note similarities between the celebrations held by Sam’s Jewish family and Tripti’s Indian one and if they don’t, Sam does come right out and say as much leading me to wonder why it is that most of us look for the differences between people instead of searching for those things we hold in common?
No profanity, violence or sexual content.
My fear for this entertaining read is that the plot and the cover seem designed for the grades 3-5 crowd, but the 300+ length will be too much for the lower end of that range. The publisher gives the target age group to be grades 3-7 but there are few books that successfully appeal to 3-4-5 as well as those middle school 6th and 7th graders.
Thanks for the print arc, Yellowjacket/Little Bee Books.