4.5 stars, rounded up
Pros
- everything Curious Archive hyped up (plus an acknowledgement to him for spreading the book to a wider audience—I’m so glad that included me!!)
- everything has an unsettling biological aspect, not just the “bad guys,” and the protagonists are (save Losté) just as mutated
- the alien worldbuilding is INSANE. The aliens are, well, alien. The different species with different customs—not only are they not just “human but green”, but very have their own culture. And they wear clothes!!! I very rarely see that in spec evo projects, so that was awesome. And caravan chantauri is adorable in their coat. But we get an anatomical look in the back of the book, too ;)
Overall this guy has risen to a place next to Alex Ries in my heart for spec evo inspo.
- on this topic, I LOVED the LOTR-style “everything is translated for its meaning, not exact wording” because it made all the action feel SO COOL and the aliens relatable and funny. (Again, caravan chantauri, we love ❤️)
- the art is so detailed and beautiful—I’d get to a page and spend minutes looking at every detail of the panel.
- plausible tech
Cons:
- the grammar was a little all over the place, to the point where it got distracting. I was actively fixing it in my head as I read, which kind of took me out of the flow. This book is absolutely amazing, but I think Diggle would really benefit from an editor so the grammar doesn’t take away from the rest of his work.
- there were like. No women. (Unless you count the all-mother, I guess?) Sci-fi seems to just do that sometimes and it’s quite frustrating. I can see how the modified humans might be all male (not that any of them really reproduce in the traditional sense) because of the parallels to a hive with a queen, but literally the only thing telling me that women weren’t like…extinct or something pre-All-Mother was sex ads, a (drunk?) woman in one panel fighting a (drunk?) guy, and one unnamed woman who sat next to the Wizard for six panels and said a grand total of 0 words. She also seems to be drawn in a weirdly different sort of style from the men, which is another pet peeve of mine—though we don’t really see her (or women in general) enough to know if this is true or just a one-off.
- WHERE DID BELFAST GO?? He went radio silent about halfway thru and I miss him
In conclusion, this book and its artist/writer are absolutely worth your time if you’re at all into spec evo or sci-fi (and even if you’re not). The amount of time and dedication Diggle puts in is just staggering, and it really shows in the product. There are a few shortcomings—various grammatical errors and lack of female characters, in particular—but they’re not significant enough (at least, for me) to be deterrents from the book. This book also doesn’t seem funded/published by a big company, so the grammar especially is excusable. This is a passion project, and it is amazing. I will absolutely be buying the sequel the second I can get my hands on it!!!