Where do I begin? It's hard to say that this is a "good" book or that this is a "bad" book. This is a diagnostic manual used to diagnose mental disorders. But maybe I should not be so quick to conclude that this is all the DSM is. The DSM is also a cultural artifact. It is the product of a so-called scientific community, largely the psychiatric profession, that for better and/or worse, has powerful effects. One of the biggest shortcomings of the DSM is that it fails to understand the ethical imperative to recognize the necessary connection between observer and observed. To see that its mental disorders say more about the diagnosticians than the so-called patients that they are diagnosing. Except for a handful of the mental disorders in the DSM (e.g., schizophrenia) which may some day be more clearly understood as brain disorders, most of the diagnoses in this manual are social constructions. I teach psychopathology in Masters level courses for a counseling program and encourage students to challenge taken-for-granted assumptions about diagnosis, pathology, and traditional hierarchical relationships between clinicians and clients. I also suggest, however, that in a society where a medical model prevails, there are good reasons to use the DSM, including insurance reimbursement. I say, what's all the fuss? The DSM, itself, points out that its manual does not diagnose people but, rather, conditions. Moreover, I recommend that one view any given diagnosis as a set of if-then criteria. If you accept that an individual meets such criteria, then they have that diagnosis. Simple, right? Well, not really. Our biases, assumptions influences what we do and do not observe; hence, some clinicians will look for and observe some criteria, whereas others will observe other criteria. Mental health counseling is not like drawing blood for a medical test. Inter-rater reliability, from my experience, is not very good when it comes to the DSM. It could be said that a mental health diagnostic interview is often a projective test--for the therapist!