I have to preclude this review with the statement: I first read this series while a high school. It was loaned to me (very slowly >.<) by an LDS ('Mormon') friend, and I was interested in the history of the LDS church. Much of the origins of the church are discussed throughout the series, as are the doctrines. As I learned more about both, I became interested in the church, met with the missionaries, and was ultimately baptized, though such had not been my original intent. As a result, this series holds a special place in my heart, which may bias my review. ;)
Pillar of Light is the first in a long and interesting series of historic novels that cover the origins of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, or Mormons, through the eyes of a fictional family. In this first volume, Lund draws liberally from written accounts of church history and scripture to put words regarding many of the events into the mouths of those who spake them. Unfortunately, he does not notate them, though he does so in future volumes, so for those who aren't familiar with many of the texts, they don't realize that these are the testimonies of the living men. Similarly, unless already familiar with the history, readers cannot tell the difference between people who existed in real life versus those who are purely fictional. However, as I mentioned, this is done in future novels in the series.
Lund tells the tale of a fictional family whose lives are intertwined with Joseph Smith almost from the start. As they hear his story of an angel and gold plates, they each reach different conclusions. Some believe immediately; some take time to feel it out in their heart; others scorn. Smith is part of the father-son tension that erupts in the novel (though not the whole part). We see him and his brother Hyrum through the eyes of this family, who know him first as hard-working, honest men before learning of the wild tales. We see members of the community mocking and ridiculing his story, and we see people who supported him at great financial (and emotional) costs.
Through it all, the reader is never forced to believe anything about Smith. We are never taken to see the gold plates or the angel, only to hear about it from him. As a result, readers are left with an unspoken invitation to determine what they think on their own - is Smith lying? Is he deceived?
Lund, of course, is an active member of the church, so the image he paints of Joseph Smith is obviously slanted toward his side. But Lund does present the realistic doubts of his characters - doubts which I, on original read, shared - thinking how 'convenient' it was that no one else saw the angel or the plates, and many other points. When one of the characters is invited to read the Book of Mormon and judge Smith's words by his fruits, the invitation could be said to be extended to the reader.
Although the series is clearly embraced predominantly by Mormons today, it does not exclude nonmember readers the same way some LDS texts do. Each new concept of LDS doctrine is explained to a character unfamiliar with it, making the reader feel as though they understand at least the concept. Reading it as a member, that did make it a little tedious in some respects. However, Lund clearly did his homework researching not only church historical documents but also the time period, explaining daily activities such as grinding flour at home and putting shingles on a roof in such a way that it is clear he has fully immersed his characters in the setting.
Whether you are reading it as a practicing Mormon or as someone curious about the history of a church that plays a significant role in American history, you will find the storyline compelling and interesting. The interactions between characters, both religious and non, keep the tale moving, and the family dynamics are very well done.