10/27/25 so I've obviously watched the series a number of times, and SO MUCH of what's in the book made it to the drama. I'm not mad the drama added all the childhood entanglements with GTY. And they brought forward the QH stuff - kinda annoyed about it but not MAD. [And all the concubine Lin shit; feel like the drama dragged it out more ... and the added "vengeance for my mother" - though not mad about that either.] Seriously, the author needs to light incense to the scriptwriters. This is the thread of quotes from my reading https://bsky.app/profile/limecello.bs...
I'm trying to separate my feelings for the book from the drama ... it's a good book but it's not like that great, if that makes sense? Like I think I liked it more cuz my warm feelings for the book. The author I felt contradicted herself a lot, though I don't know if it was shit translation/MTL. Clearly the earliest posted stuff on NU ... it really seems person translated but JFC is it terrible and they at least definitely don't know English. Then the rest is [AI]MTL 😒 ... and I had to read the rest of it MTL, which is notorious about fucking up text/putting the opposite, and with the bad writing I had to question if I was getting what the author actually wrote/intended. So ... the story was a lot better than the writing itself. But I can see why it was so popular. I DNF'd LLTG, read her xianxia one, have no interest in her modern one. No idea if she's written more books. If it's a historical I might give it a try. Not sure about re-reading Minglan. Definitely not mad I read it, happy I did. Would re-read at least my favorites before picking up this one.
Solid C+ ~*~*~*~*~ Legend of Concubine’s Daughter Minglan
1 oh boy so in the book the old madam raised Lin but she was a white eyed wolf who climbed to FL’s dad. And he’s just as stupid as in the drama, treating her as well/better than his legitimate wife 1.2 FL is 4-5
2 real name is Yao Yiyi? … but now she’s Sheng Minglan. I wonder how old YYY was before transmigrating 2.1(?) … WTAF was that. And Y3 had an older brother? So WTF era of China was she from considering she was basically a judicial clerk? Court reporter?
3 Yay! Sheng Changbai! (Currently 12) Sheng Hualan is 13.5
4 skimmed/scrolled through concubine L’s shit. But lol FL seeing L’s acting skills inspiring her to live. hahahaha.
(5.4?) 🤷🏻♀️ skimming all the L; will the dad really change already? I doubt it. Fucking idiot tool. 5? This read like a book report of dream of the red chamber. Man this author is just really something.
6.1 3 sons 4 daughters 🤷🏻♀️
10 FL will now live with gma (didn’t expect book gma to be so poor; or is she hiding her wealth?)
13.2 I love Kong momo & gma ❤️
15.2 stupid as shit dad & fake ass cunt Molan; the comments were satisfying. The whole concept of collective punishment even for the innocent is still so frustrating.
17 is uncle Sheng Wei … (🤷🏻♀️) Well whatever. At least FL got presents
21 awww little 4-5 yo Sheng Changdong
22 was a bit incomprehensible/unreadable but 🤷🏻♀️
Qi Heng/Yuan Ruo appears, this second son of duke Qi
26 😹 the way FL hates Qi Heng
28 oh in the book, she made them legwarmers not knee pads
31 skimmed all the Molan/Lin shit. Fucking cunts.
33 All those fucking annoying maids
36 ok she’s 11 now
37 OK, but I love her relationship with Changbai in the book too yay. And ooo him wishing FL was his bio sister
38 this “translation” unfortunately really is shit. So bad that I felt it literally necessary to comment about it.
39 first mention of Gu! (And Yu Yanran)
40 oh? Gma has already decided FL’s future husband?
43 ugh Yu Yanran having to deal with ManNiang/FL driving that cockroach away. And Manniang even brought her two kids, freaking awful bitch.
45. Suddenly, she’s 12? Interesting all the stuff about He Hongwen also
49 Holy shit this cousin Yuelan (Sheng 3rd branch?) who literally took Minglan‘s hair pin out of her hair
50 yaaaas this visit to the ancestral home got Minglan registered under the legitimate mother’s name so now she’s technically a legitimate daughter! Yay!
65 WTH?! Qi Heng here is WAY more naughty - and forward! And how much older is he than FL?! Does he actually like her?! What’s up with tricking her over at this birthday banquet?! Or is he just nostalgic?! WHAT’S HAPPENING … oh ok so he definitely LIKE lies her
66 oof “Minglan sat there, her head bowed and hands cold. —He was at the center of the crowd, like a moon surrounded by stars; she sat alone at the corner, like a flower whose fragrance was known to no one. The road was wide enough for them to take separate paths.”
69 He Hongwen recaptured. Why and how did his personality change so much from the time that they were traveling by boat? Whatever
70 isn’t MingLan’s status technically higher than Molan’s right now because she’s now registered under Wong
73 oops I forgot to note her first time meeting GTY; this is the 2nd? 3rd? Glad she lowkey blew his mind pointing out ManNiang isn’t that great. (And lol the mud throwing; but here it’s at a temple)
75 lol the aftermath Huh seems she did like QH since she was sad when he got married. I liked he didn’t just get along with this forced wife
76 wow 6 days of rebellion; FL totally uninvolved (way more realistic). P4 tried to commit a coup, executed P3.
77 hm both QH & GTY’s wives are dead. Seems … GTY was somehow involved in the coup but on the bad side? 🤷🏻♀️ QH’s parents are interesting… Most the Shengs court involved got promoted 💪💯 (ugh Wang)
(89?) Yay! Shulan already married & just had Dragon Phoenix twins!
81 wow Shulan’s MIL is disgusting
83 interesting and almost entirely changed GTY. And he’s offering to help both Yan and FL if they ever need it? Seems he learned about how Manniang is evil. Also oh his wife died from illness and then his father died shortly later. What’s he been up to? So seems he wasn’t part of the coup. However, what’s up with his gray hair?
(87) This former P8 now emperor is interesting. (This Kang not cousin & her mom need to die in a slow fire) … same with Wang
90 finally Molan faces some consequences for destroying Milan‘s room hitting her. And even trying to disfigure her. Hopefully this is the end of Lin and stupid Changfeng too. Fucking hate that concubine and her kids. Poor MingLan & Changdong
93 Uhoh, ship attacked!! Though this time she’s sailing to her great aunt’s deathbed with her little brother, cousin Changwu, & his wife (Kang Yun’er seems okay so far… her little/half sister or whatever though, no). (Gma is already there - BAD CHOICE TO LEAVE MINGLAN, GMA) Damn MingLan sent everyone away to safety first (other than her/some maids)
94 oof lol did she kill the guy she stabbed? And the girls are jumped into the river! (Bitch - Who betrayed MingLan?!) and yaaay GTY/his crew saved her!
97 oof her convo w/ GTY
98 lol satisfying to see Sun Zhigao (poor cousin Shulan’s awful ex) in a bad situation. And damn girl Shulan having 2 sets of twins quickly, 3 boys 1 girl!
100 first Sheng Madam dies - angry deathbed words. Prince Jing rebelled.
102 😹 “Old Madam Sheng, who had just breathed a sigh of relief, now tensed again. She stared at her young granddaughter for a long time with mixed feelings and suddenly felt that she would live a long life with such a cunning girl by her side.” Her analysis of the rebellion!
103 interesting jump/promotion; GTY is the general quelling the rebellion.
106 JFC beyond Milan’s shameful mess (though slightly less shameful than in the drama, considering it *seems*, she was only held in dude‘s arms not that she fucked him) but Lin sent Sheng Hong the FUCKING shit ass dad a maid and he fucked her and not only that got her pregnant *during national mourning,* OMFG
Skimmed/scrolled 107 fucking Molan & Lin.
113 F He Hongwen’s mom & her Cao relatives
114 I seriously do not understand why MingLan gave Molan such a generous dowry gift. just what the fuck
120 ugh HHW. And MingLan just caught Rulan & Jing
124 oh wow in the novel HHW still has chances after that visit to the He family (will his mom really make Cao her adopted daughter?)
125 so now MingLan is 15. Who again is this Li Yu/Yi? The son of her oldest girl Sheng cousin from the first branch? Whatever
128 oh damn HHW agreed to marry his cousin Cao because she’s been sterilized? Stupid little bitch baby boy.
129 oh GTY really did want to marry Rulan in the book?
133 wait what!?! HHW declares his devotion to Minglan and this is the last time they ever meet? What?!
135 … So did GTY always mean to marry MingLan or not?
138 ahhh *teakettle noises* wait no really?!? He started having a *romantic* interest in her that time he saw her throw mud on Molan?! what?!
139 OK AUTHOR 😻 “And those eyes, those eyes. Gu Tingye looked at her silently. He had fallen in love with those eyes from long time ago. Those dark eyes were just like a quiet spring, but also had fantastic flames jumping out from the inside. The fire seemed to be her anger or her disappointment which entangled with each other. He was shocked by those mysterious eyes. And after that, he was completely intoxicated.” God DAMN he really sees her. Oh my god author have you won me over?! Interesting she still hates ancient times
140 oop gma has agreed
141 ooo GTY’s POV
143 …fucking poisonous Gu family step mom
145 Wang continues to be stroke inducingly stupid & awful. EVEN KNOWING what happens in the drama/it’ll take a long damn time, I’m still annoyed Seriously WTF Hualan better get her dowry back…
151 interesting that scene with QH & his “why not me?!” At Rylan’s wedding banquet
153 (154? 🤷🏻♀️) wedding ceremony complete! Was 154 a repeat of the last section? Ugh
155 lol charming rogue wedding night (GIVE US THE DEETS! Damn you censorship!) lol what did she want to tell him?!
163 ugh, he has concubines. And he’s mad that she’s unhappy? Why? Like what the fuck is she supposed to do. Like he said he already had them before. Fucking asshole like tell her what you expect. Jackass.
171 “Gu Tingyu was only twenty-eight years old and had no elder brothers. However, the eldest son of the fourth and the fifth family, which was Gu Tingxuan and Gu Tingyang were already around thirty-three or thirty four years old. So far, the only legal grandchild of the first family of the Gu family was the two-or-three-years-old Xiange’er, who was Gu Tingwei’s son.”
175 I hope steward Gongshan Baishi is an ally!
183 I wish their sex life was written better. Also, it’s interesting. He has no subtlely, which makes sense for a dude, but yeah. Yay he asked for an imperial edict for her!
184 a bit of word salad so does the emperor want the two of them married or not? Whatever I just it’s annoying.
Seems like 189 was cut off but 🤷🏻♀️ … ok at least 189-191; I went to read the raws myself (which was actually like c120)
199 (tbh wondering if I should just switch to the Ross’s) anyway I appreciated her plotting with her eldest sister. Here I’m actually mad at GYT a little bit because he throws his huge temper tantrum for no reason. It’s not her fault she’s trying to live her best life. She doesn’t know that she can depend on him and even though he says stuff he’s already proven himself to be like 75 to 80% dependable, but obviously not entirely, plus he already has at least two concubines plus that mistress who bore him two freaking children. And guy you’ve never told her that you love her I mean you scheme to marry her but that’s only just marriage. That’s only now.
200. I fucking hate the mother-in-law honestly, if chunks of what scheming she does is missing I don’t even care. Fuck her.
206 😹💯 Minglan and Hualan’s plan worked yay
208 😹😹 Minglan deciding/realizing that the woman in the opera the real historical figure in the story is determined to be in a fellow transmigrator lol
212 lists the Gu family
217 is actually just 128; switched to the newer translations which at least isn’t constantly word salad & the opposite of the text omfg
129 sigh the way he treats Rong in the book though I get it (but so many questions what was MingLan going to say?! Are those two his actual concubines?!)
131 😹☠️ I hope they do make Qiuniang copy that forever sutra, though I know they won’t
133 … is this Chang Nian actually GTY’s son?
134 ok probably not - but I really like Chang Nian! (lol and his ferocious gma)
136 GTY is only 26… how old is MingLan now?! lol he’s trying to guide this wooden blockhead she’s caught feelings. WOO BETTER, GUY 😹💯
138 😅🥹 I’M SO LOOKING FORWARD TO HIM RESOLVING THIS IMPERIAL ESTATE MESS.
140 almost all the Gu family is relentlessly awful
147.2 “His voice, deep and resonant like a drum, sounded in her ear. He murmured, “I want you. Within this mansion, beyond your boudoir, everything I possess and everything I can do: everything will be as you wish, to your heart’s desire.”” ❤️
I ~always forget GTY’s courtesy name is Zonghui
148 sorry Gu Tingyu but bye. “In the seventh month of that same year, an imperial edict formally conferred the title of Marquis of Ningyuan upon Gu Tingye, with a supernumerary second-rank noble rank. The court likewise granted his wife, Madam Sheng, the title of First-Rank Lady by imperial decree.”
151 Ugh saw “Here’s the line-edited text:” so I expect this is some sort of bullshit AI MTL
158 I’d bet MingLan is pregnant
159 BWAAAH “It was always good when a leftover daughter found a match. That proud and aloof woman, who knew which family had the fortune to take her in? In this sweltering heat, they wouldn’t even need ice with her around. Amitabha.” F cunt stepmom & her bitch snob daughter
160 wait Rong’er now calls her mother?!
163 I need Gu Tingcan to be slapped into the underworld. And her fuck shit mom to be crushed under her
164.2 Oh interesting; she was touched by the romantic things QH sent
165 lol pregnancy sex! 💪💯 she’s 6 months in
167 here it comes, the disgusting Qin & Kang. I’m so mad they just whatever. Need Ling BuYi to appear & torture them
174-175 poor baby (MingLan) to have to deal with relentless waves of shit. (Kang, the concubine/shu Kang daughter, the fucking shit A’Yu family, her cunt stupid ass MIL, bitch ass legitimate mother, all this other bullshit, ManNiang, and now the fucking fire.) But! Baby! 175.1 a boy! 😒 Still too nice to ManNiang
177 so Gu3 doesn’t admire his brother?
Jesus the evil MIL even tampered with the wet nurses
180.1 ❤��💯 “Gu Tingye stroked the little girl's soft hair, looked up at Minglan, and said firmly, "As long as we're together as a family, with our hearts united, that's better than anything else."” (Even the evil MIL knows this about them.) … but this is the time GTY starts getting frustrated cuz he doesn’t … well, Minglan is emotionally detached 180.3 well the truth comes out - it was GTY’s cousin in the 5th branch who raped his dad’s maid but everyone blamed him. Too bad this can’t be broadcast
Oh she’s “barely 18” now 🫠
184 🙊🙊🙊🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️ omfg did QH really basically name his kids after Minglan?! Like dude I get his gloomy wife but BITCH LEAVE MINGLAN ALONE SHE HAS NO PART OF THIS
187 oh “The most frustrating problem in the world is knowing the problem but not being able to solve it.
Facing her husband's stern expression, demanding she reveal her true feelings like a debt collector, Minglan was in a state of panic.”
189 spoken all out; though tbh … I dunno I feel she DOES have feelings for him?
191 fuck. Wong poisoned the grandma in the book too. Bitch. She & Kang need to die miserable deaths.
197. I am cackling at the way GTY appears and starts arguing with the old one mother-in-law. This is so awesome.
199 aha - I like she called out the depth of his sincerity/attachment to her
209. I kind of feel like I’m losing my mind because earlier the author said that there’s some sort of rule where if there are two or more brothers families are required to split. However, now with Molan’s whatever family everyone saying it’s not a good thing for families to split. Like what is happening here
215 don’t love Manniang bring back, & the son she poisoned
216 I don’t remember who Liu Zhengjie is but fuck his wife thinking MingLan is bad & ZMN is good Eek the fake imperial decree
(218?) Rong saving her little half brother, and all she went through has me literally tearing up I can’t understand why she treats Bisi so well And fuck Xia He too Bisi tried to kill Tuan and you want to help her?!?
lol her friend Zhang is even more awesome in the book! (The lady who had to marry the empress’s brother)
219 uh why does it suddenly call him Hu Zi? Also poor emaciated Minglan. Stupid GTY. Even her cheap dad visited her 219.2 Yay baby Yuan! I don’t really get what Liu said & all this mess - dunno if it’s back to the bad writing or MTL but it’s annoying Interesting GTW (3rd brother) really was evil here
220.1 HAH. (Also wait) he admits he didn’t treat MingLan sincerely the first time ManNiang tried to attack her?! ASSHOLE Hm, her fear… and yet “"Actually, I've known your feelings for a long time. You treat me well, not just because you want a wife who can manage the household and bear children. You truly love me, respect me, make me happy, and want me to live a carefree life... But I just pretend not to understand! Because I'm afraid, I'm afraid..."”
Huh he wanted to go guard the border. End main text
Extra 2: (meh on whatever Shen kid) embroidery Awww Xiuqiao & Changdong - though seems incomplete
… who the hell is this “second madam?” I thought it was Changbai’s wife but now I’m not sure? They’re grandparents?!?
E4; f Gu Tinglan
Extra 5 The Snow (everything before was jumbled & likely incomplete) He family mess
E6(?) whoa Changbai’s grandkid?! Ah. QH’s grandson gets what he wanted Final end (Ugh but I hate it ends with the Sheng family declining. How though didn’t it say Changbai’s kids were even better?!)
… ok or there’s E7… lol only in the Taiwanese edition?! Aww Che Sanniang & Xiaotao
Extra 7 shames … after the imperial exam?
E8(?) Jade bead … yeah pass on Qiu niang … read/skimmed more QH stuff. Even the ~encounter with young GTY
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.