A cool anthology, with a wide range of stories. I didn't like most of the "slipstream" fiction. Perhaps I didn't understand the symbolism or themes Rosenbaum was trying to explore. The Ant King and The Orange were really the only two that I liked. The rest were pretty lame.
I enjoyed all of the author's actual science fiction stories. Start the Clock and Embracing-the-New were the best of the science fiction, but Falling was also pretty good. All of them were original and had thought-provoking themes. Start the Clock: what would the world be like if aging suddenly stopped? Embracing-the-New: how would an alien race function if its memories were literally passed on from one generation to the next by tick-like creatures. Falling: how would people react to a society that simply expects volunteerism.
His fantasy stories were pretty good, too, the best being Siege of Cranes.
My synopsis and individual review of the stories is below. Beware of spoilers.
"The Ant King: A California Fairy Tale" by Benjamin Rosenbaum published in the anthology The Ant King: and Other Stories. This was a surrealist (absurdist? slipstream?) story about a man whose girlfriend suddenly becomes a bunch of yellow gumballs and how, while his concept for selling yellow gumballs on the internet is sold to venture capitalists and his little business is turned into a huge corporate empire, he decides to go and rescuse his girlfriend from the Ant King, who has kidnapped her. The story had interesting characters (a formerly male, now female, six and a half foot tall corporate promoter, her uber-goth niece named Corpse, the Ant King himself, and even the girlfriend (who ends up getting saved, but running off with the CEO of the company that sells the gumballs). The whole thing was pretty strange, although I for some reason found it entertaining.
"The Valley of Giants" This was a post-apoctolyptic absurdist story about a grandmother whose family has all died and runs away to a valley of giants that take care of humans. I did'nt really like this one. I'm not sure I've understood any of the stories I've read in this anthology so far, but this was the first one that I didn't enjoy reading (good thing it was short).
"The Orange" Very short story about a very kind, benevolent orange that ruled the world, until it was eaten. Another absurdist story that I still found enjoyable to read. I read this one to my kids (leaving out the line about the lesbian daughter on Wall Street), and they asked for me to read it to them again immediately.
"Biographical Notes to 'A Discourse on the Nature of Causality, with Air-Planes,' by Benjamin Rosenbaum" This one went over my head. And yes, the title of the story included the phrase "by Benjamin Rosenbaum." The main character is Benjamin Rosenbaum in an alternate universe where travel is by Zepplin, and those Zepplins are attacked by pirates. There was some cool discussion of the philosophy of causation, but ultimately, I didn't really get this one.
"Start the Clock" Cool story about a future earth in which at some point everyone's age freezes, and people stop aging, even though they grow older. The story is told from the point of view of a nine-year-old girl, and focuses on her efforts to keep her group of Nines together, while they try to decide whether they will buy a house (built like a giant galleon in a neighborhood named "Pirateland"). This was the first story in the anthology that wasn't absurdist, but instead, read more like a true-blue science fiction story. I really liked it a lot. The story explored what such a world would be like (as well as Billings, Montana of the future, including high-flying slidewalks and all), and the issues that would arise as treatments to allow the aging process to continue were developed. He also explored what it would be like to hang out with a genetically and technologically enhanced toddler. Like I said, this one was pretty darn cool
"The Blow" A short story about a detective that gets hit in the head by the bad guy, causing the detective to become physically diabled. The detective's assistant and the bad guy then take care of the detective. A bizarre "slip stream" story.
"Embracing-The-New" Individuals of an alien race pass on their memories and skills by tick-like creatures embedded in their chests. A young alien is apprenticing to a "god carver" who makes the statues and amulets that represent the various characteristics and traits that the aliens worship. The young alien is competing with several other apprentices for the god carver's inheritance (the god carver is dying) but does not hold out much hope because of his poverty. The god carver (after displaying an astonishing lack of respect for "lesser" forms of life on the alien world) asks the young alien to carve a nice piece of jade into a new god. The young alien carves a large alien that has no ticks on his chest that is reaching for an orphan tick that apparently has had no former owners (and thus, would presumably not carry the memories of any older aliens). The god's name is "Embracing-The-New." The god carver changes the statute because it is blasphemous, and the young alien then sneaks in and vandalizes the statue. He is kicked out of the alien society, and his ticks are removed -- causing him to become a savage animal-like creature.
"Falling" Another cool SF story about a far future Germany where the cities are suspended kilometers in the air (apparently to allow living space for the world's enourmous population, allowing space for growing food, etc.). The economy is neither capitalist nor communist, but is instead driven by volunteerism -- people wanting to simply serve the government and other civic organizations. A man sees a woman jump off of one of the high walkways. She is of course rescued by a swarm of smart robots, and the man's freind, with whom he was walking when they see the woman, is appalled at the waste of resources and the selfishness of the woman's act. The main character is enthralled with the woman, however, and goes to talk with her, and discovers that he also wants to jump, even though it is a waste of resources.
"On the Cliff by the River" A woman in Africa jumps off a cliff with her baby to escape a tiger. The woman is able to grap a root and hang the baby on it before falling to her death. The story is told by a shape-shifting crocodile (?) in the river below the cliff, and it is revealed that the crocodile is telling the story to the baby, after it has grown older. This one was okay.
"Orphans" A woman falls in love with an elephant that is wandering through the city. She helps the elephant, and then is resentful when the elephant's relatives come to town to convince him to do elephant things again. I didn't really get this one.
"Fig" This one was probably the strangest story in the anthology yet about a cat that steals a girl's fig, causing the girl to stop growing up and the cat to feel bad and jealous, hiding the fig in a separate universe of trillions of figs that the cat breathes into a coffee can. A toy soldier falls in love with the girl and tries to get the fig, but the cat has booby-trapped the coffee can with harpees, who cause the toy's fellow soldiers to fall in love with and then marry them. The harpies then kill the soldiers. The toy soldier escapes and reports his failure to the girl. She then eats the soldier. This one was pretty bizarre. Good thing it was short.
"The Book of Jashar" This was a cool idea about the "translation" of a codex found by Rosenbaum's friends with the Qumran scrolls, but other wise kind of falls flat as a story: a demon (or maybe the follower of a demon?) is trying to kill David (after successfully killing Jonathan). The "Book of Jashar" is actually mentioned in the Old Testament.
"The House Beyond Your Sky" I actually read this one before on the Strange Horizons website. A highly stylized, almost metaphorical, look at the end of one universe and the beginning of another. An entity becomes hopelessly depressed by all the pain and suffering in the universes in his library, begins to create his own universe, and a part of the entity that created him tries to stop him. The entity ends up bringing into his universe a little girl to watch over his library (and the various souls that he has sprung free in his home from the worlds in which the souls realize that they are in a simulation). He has been watching the little girl, whose father is beating her mother, and worrying about how to save her when "the pilgrim" (the poriton of the entity that created him) shows up and tries to enter into the universe that he is creating. The story is a study of the cause of pain in life in general, and essentially speculates that it is possible for there to be a universe without suffering. A very interesting story. Nominated for the Hugo and several other awards in 2007. I enjoyed it (and I think understood it) more when I read it a second time in the anthology.
"Red Tassles" The worst story in the book. It's a stream of conscious telling of one absurd event after another. A man walks out of a business meeting because he's lost his shoes with red tassles, goes up on the roof, is carried away by birds, falls in love with a woman he sees below him, his wife finds out, and has an affair with a woodpecker to spite her husband. Lame. Really lame.
"Other Cities" I liked this one, even though it's not really a story; it simply describes various make believe cities (some of which aren't so make believe) around the galaxy. "The City of Peace" obviously describes Jeruselem and posits a reason for why the violence there won't end (both sides love the city too much to agree to give up any portion of the city to the other). "Bellur" is a city of censors. "Ponge: The White City" is supposed to be awful, and everyone is supposed to want to move to the better city, Strafrax, but the people make excuses for not leaving, and deep down obviously really like to live in Ponge. "Ahavah" is a mythical city that hoboes and transients search for as they ride the rails, but discover that, by being part of the hobo and transient network, they already live in Ahavah, whose citizens take care of one another and always share their food and love for free. "Amea Amaau" is a brand new, beautifully built city that no one ever actually lives in but just passes through. "Ylla's Choice" is a city inside a spherical space station that is throtteling toward destruction by a pulsar. Time has slowed for the citizens of the city, and everyone ponders what the ideal society is and try to implement it. "Zvlotsk" is a city where Lutgenmetzger has discovered how to completely eliminate crime by predicting where it will occur with 100% accuracy and then stopping it from happening. The description is a funny telling of how society would react if this actually occurred, with amateur detectives falling in an out of fashion, media companies encouraging murders by publishing books like "How to Tell if He's Cheating and Deserves to Die." "New-n Perch" is where the citizens of New-n-1 Perch are sent if they can't work out their differences with the majority of the citizens of New-n-1. The city has a conscience that is actually one of its original founders who agreed to be "eaten up" by the city. "Jouiselle-aux-Chantes" has a mushroom that causes its people to forget their past, so it is a place where couples can go to be like they are newly in love again. "Penelar of the Reefs" used to be very difficult to find, and was a place of refuge for those wanting to escape their lives, but now there is a highway that goes there. "Myrkhyr" is a city that I didn't really get -- people travelling and settling -- I'm not sure. "Stin" is a refuge city (?) -- another one I didn't really understand.
"Sense and Sensibility" Another nonsense story, this one based on the Jane Austin novel, except this one takes place on and in the body of a giant. Some funny parts, especially the asides about how an author hopes to communicate with a reader, who sometimes is nonexistant or can even disappear. Otherwise a lame story.
"A Siege of Cranes" A haunting story about a man whose wife and daughter mysteriously dissapear in the destruction of the man's village. The many is hunting down whatever has taken his wife and daughter, and ultimately finds a huge machine made out of the body parts of its victims (including his wife's arm). The man makes friends along the way (an Egyptian jakal man and a djinn with a flying carpet) who join him on his quest to defeat, what he comes to know as, the White Witch. The man defeats the White Witch by remembering who everyone in the giant machine is, discovering that the White Witch is a crazy girl who had previously lived in his village and to whom he had shown kindness when no one else would. He allows the djinn to take her, after tricking her into thinking that he will marry her.