The Russian Revolution is complicated, and understanding the lives of its major figures is equally complicated. A short graphic biography isn’t likely to tell the whole story of Trotsky, or any of the other figures or events.
Of course, it doesn’t, but I think that’s okay. It’s a start for the reader.
I think the author and illustrator, Rick Geary, does the right thing by starting with the stark contrasts in how Trotsky is remembered — a crusading idealist, the “brain behind the Russian Revolution”, fighting for the people of Russia against not only the tyrannical Tsar but also the tyrannical Stalin, or the power-mad “satanic purveyor of bloody revolution”, a tyrant in his own right.
With the fall of the Soviet Union Westerners, maybe Americans in particular, are in danger of simply plowing over everything that happened as a nightmare, something that happened, is over, and we bid good riddance.
But there was a reason the Russian Revolution happened, there were ideals behind it, and there are lessons to be learned in what went wrong. You get enough here of Trotsky’s story, at the center, to appreciate the intellectual and political turmoil of the revolution and its aftermath. Trotsky’s life is a path through the twists and turns — you’ll see a great deal of what there is to see by walking it.
It’s also entertaining, and Geary’s art evokes a time and feel — the old imperial feel of tsarist Russian, the repetition of life in exile and imprisonment for Trotsky (and others), the exuberance of revolution, and the quandary of power in its aftermath. He conveys all of that in a very direct style and relatively simple drawings. He captures the mood, and he keeps his art behind the story.
You won’t, hopefully, learn everything you want to know about Trotsky and the Russian Revolution here, but it could get you going on a good path.