2.5/5 Stars
Although arguably the best book in the Deverry Cycle so far, mainly due to easily being one of the least flawed sequels in the series and using previously established things/characters better, I wouldn't call this book much more than "fine". But if Katherine Kerr's overly vague, character "quantity over quality" writing-style/story choice was improved, and the pacing generally improved, this could definitely be a pretty good series. I was debating between rating this a 3/5 or 2/5, but since Goodreads has such a limited rating system, I suppose I'll just give it a 2/5.
I will say, however, that things like character's direct thoughts generally being in italics for the FIRST time in this entire damn series makes it easier to read, and is a welcome change, one that I thought should have been done in the 1st book, not waiting until the 12th to even start this, but there you are...
Another first-time for this series (although it sounds very basic, lol), is the consistent use of border symbols the entire time to clearly mark when a scene ends/transitions to another character's "viewpoint"... even though this series is told by the viewpoint of some near-omnipotent narrator who somehow knows various character thoughts, but it ALSO kind of tries to tell it from different character's viewpoints at the same time part of the time...? Anyways, there are MUCH better fantasy authors out there, and Katherine Kerr's Deverry Cycle thus far (and I highly doubt this will suddenly change with books #13+) is not worth your time, unless you REALLY want to read a Celtic fantasy series largely about reincarnation, and are willing to overlook its flaws... in that case, go nuts, and you will probably enjoy it, or maybe even love it.
I could go back and write proper reviews for the previous books in this series, but at this point, why should I bother, especially considering almost all the books continue to repeat most of the same mistakes with minimal improvement...? There's not even THAT much new to talk about, besides plot and lore-specific things, which you have with ALL fantasy series, or books of any kind...
So, there you have it. Perhaps Kerr has learned from her mistakes in the first 12 books of the Deverry Cycle, and perhaps her other books ARE better; but, really...? I don't care enough to invest any more effort into reading her works, besides finishing the Deverry Cycle that I've already invested so much time into. Hopefully the last few books in the series continually improve...