What do you think?
Rate this book


480 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published June 1, 2014


Certainly the characters are put through some gruelling situations – though this time, it's mainly John (Xuan Wu) who's put through the wringer, not Emma. The demon kings continue to be evil, scheming, and genuine threats. The characters all come across to me as very real, and very human in nature and still fallible, despite whatever exalted rank they may hold. I also like the grandness of the plot, too: Hell attacking Heaven to take control of everything. Hell's strategic plan to achieve all this also seems sound, to me, which makes the stakes plausible: gain control of the Courts in Hell (thus preventing the return of any slain Immortal), subvert humans by fomenting hatred in areas of political unrest, use wealth to gain Earthly power and influence, and develop an army capable of defeating the Celestial forces in Heaven. Partly they do this through their ingenuity and willingness to adopt and develop new technologies (no matter how much suffering or inhuman torture it entails), and partly through using the good guys' nobility against them. There are some nicely drawn-out (but not too drawn out) dramatic tensions – like, will John's Turtle and Serpent halves ever rejoin, will Emma be able to overcome a sexual squeamishness which over 99% of people would deeply share, and others – and of course there's the whole big drama of Hell making war on Heaven to drive everything along.
A continued strength of the series is the realism of the depiction of Hong Kong and the novelty of the setting provided by the Chinese mythology. Again, there are some good surprises, and some awful positions into which the evil characters delight in putting the good guys, and the book ends with a nice hook for the next in the sequence. Definitely a fun read.