I have climbed Mt Monadnock a number of times. I actually took it for granted, it was a satisfying climb not to long not too short. At the top you were rewarded with a breathtaking view and many others to share it with.
I never knew what a complex history it had, and was deemed magical and mysterious to some, until I read Craig Brandon's book.
The mountain is not just there. It took the efforts of many people in order to preserve it. I never new there were streams of visitors from Boston who took the train into Troy. That it became a resort area for the wealthy, with a number of hotels surrounding it. Their was a toll road leading to a populalar half-way lodge off the trail.
Brandon points out Monadnock is the second most climbed mt. in the world behind Mt. Fuji in Japan.
Monadnock attracted a lot of intellectuals including artist, poets and writers, and had a nearby artist colony.
The popularity of Monadnock is mine boggling with estimates of 125,000 a year, 1700 people on trails at the same time 4500 visitors on a weekend. Though I don't think it is as popular now, as it was in the earlier years.
Thoreau and Emerson were climbers of the mt. Thoreau climbed Monadnock 4X. and camped on the Mt. I thought the author was unfair to Thoreau quoting a source that: "some thought" Thoreau had an affair with his best friend Emerson's wife, while contradicting this by quoting another source that Thoreau was a repressed homosexual, based on the assumption he had male friends and used writing and love of nature to sublimate his hidden desires? Another weak and nebulous claim that Thoreau was ant-social-In what sense? He didn't drink, he was vegetarian, he had many friends, he was certainly not violent. He did live alone in a cabin on Walden ponder two years, but he had many visitors and visited friends. He wasn't a hermit.
Aside from these debatable conclusions that didn't belong in a hikers guide. I thought the book was very interesting and thoroughly researched. I would recommend it to anyone planning on hiking Monadnock and anyone who has already had the experience.