I decided to read this book because it is to be discussed (or rather a review of the book is to be discussed) on a parish council that I am joining on Liturgical Life. I had heard of the book before, but never heard much about it, just that it was out there for parishes who are 'struggling' for whatever reason.
The book was written by Father Michael White of the archdiocese of Baltimore, MD. He and his associate wanted to make their parish 'successful' and 'grow' it because of its lackluster condition when they arrived there. The fundamental problem that was occurring were that Catholics were leaving in droves, as is really the issue across American Catholicism. They wanted to combat that and they wanted to grow, which I think is the wrong mentality to have.
The book models almost all of its growing methodologies off of mainline Protestant megachurches. The issue with that is that the parish inadvertently become more and more Protestant and less and less Catholic in its identity. If the Catholic Church in America is to grow in its sanctity, it must remain true to its sacramental identity.
This entire book was focused on other Protestant churches and pastors throughout the country in an effort to create a "successful" Catholic church. What? Increasing numbers is not how one measures success within a parish. I would disagree with that. Yes, Christ did command to go out and baptize all nations and to convert the whole world. I will not deny that. But, to measure a church's success based off of growing numbers is silly and loses sight. We are called to be a holy people.
I know of a Catholic parish in Naperville, IL who has the Latin Mass, perpetual adoration, reverent Novus Ordo style Masses, very frequent confession times, and vibrant activity in the church. This is how you create a "successful" Church - not by simply adding numbers and calling it a day.
This particular book I think almost entirely misses the Catholic identity and sacramentality. First and foremost, there needs to be a centrality focusing on the Eucharist. There needs to be adoration and very frequent confession times. Adding TV screens and video service is not the way to increase in sanctity.
There are some things that I like the concept of in this book, such as having the parishioners get involved and be held accountable for various aspects of Parish life. To add value and give responsibility as a part of the flow of the church is fundamental and a great idea.
This book mentions that they avoid consumerism at all costs, but I'm afraid by reading the book I can see they've fallen victim to that very mindset and seem to have lost the way.
If this book is only about adding a bunch of people to the church and getting numbers up, I suppose this may be a good read, then. But if a book is designed to increase the Catholicity of a Catholic parish and it mentions the sacrament of reconciliation once, and doesn't dedicate any chapters to the Eucharist, then I'm concerned.