What do you think?
Rate this book


288 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1880
This is one of those weird moments where the setting/timeperiod/worldview of the book is almost alien, but the struggles of the heroine are current. How to live in the world but not of it? How to hold yourself to higher standards than those around you (and possibly older and "wiser" than you) without being self-righteous? I actually think the content of the book deserves 4 stars, but the editing in this edition was atrocious! And I don't mean the dialect writing. Just read that phonetically and you'll be fine; no I mean the actual editing that missed reversed or repeated words that should not have been there, or incorrect tenses (like "had" instead of "have"), things that were very fixable and were in no way colloquialisms of the time so weren't there for period "flavor". In other editing weirdness, I'm pretty sure they changed all the slaves to be called servants; I honestly don't remember when the books were supposed to be set, I think pre-Civil War, but I first read The Elsie Dinsmore series very close to when I read The Little Colonel books, so elements of the stories tangle in my memory, including which one goes through the war... However, they treat them like servants (no whipping or selling away), but they still have strict social codes, so go into this ready to talk to youngsters about class society problems (it is more than racial prejudice, as the treatment of the governess shows, and it is never held up as "good behavior").
Content notes: No language issues, just be ready to read phonetically whenever the servants or the Scottish housekeeper speak. A married man is pursuing a wealthy girl (for her money); she doesn't believe he's married when she's warned about him, but says she would marry him anyway, in the end it works out. Threatened violence from the scoundrel, but no one is hurt, illnesses that end in death for a couple secondary characters and news reports of a man being lynched and hung, but no more details.