Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Gene Illusion - Genetic Research in Psychiatry and Psychology Under the Microscope

Rate this book
In a provocative challenge to current genetic theories about mental health, a clinical psychologist practicing in the San Francisco Bay area critiques the research cited to support a biologically-based psychiatry. Joseph particularly questions the validity of twin studies in relation to psychiatric disorders, IQ, and criminal behaviors, and makes methodological recommendations. This is the revised North American edition of a book first published in the UK in 2003. Annotation ©2004 Book News, Inc., Portland, OR (booknews.com)

420 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 2003

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Jay Joseph

17 books6 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
4 (40%)
4 stars
3 (30%)
3 stars
1 (10%)
2 stars
2 (20%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews
Profile Image for Liquidlasagna.
3,307 reviews118 followers
July 10, 2021
amazon review

shooting down decades of biopsychiatry's puffery

Pick up virtually any text book on psychiatry or abnormal psychology, and you're sure to find confident assertions that schizophrenia has a "strong genetic component." Twin studies and adoption studies will be claimed to provide clear scientific evidence of this.

Jay Joseph has done something the authors of most such text books have not - he's actually looked at the studies themselves.

His own book is detailed, comprehensive and scholarly - and when he holds these studies up to the light, most of their authors' confident conclusions virtually crumble.

At the very least, Joseph shows how speculative and shakily supported these conclusions are.

But I think Joseph establishes more: if the twin and adoption studies stand for anything, they show how overwhelmingly important environment and experience are in schizophrenia.

This book is not light reading. But it methodically puts biopsychiatry to the test. And, as so often in its history, biopsychiatry does not fare well when looked at too closely.

Peter C. Dwyer
2 reviews
October 7, 2026
Excellent, thoroughly researched book.
Dr. Joseph traces the eugenical and national socialist roots of genetic psychiatry and shows that the field has as much scientific validity as it had back then. Still none.

The focus was twin studies, twins reared apart studies, adoption studies and other family studies pretending to be something else. The book can be a bit repetitive, since a bulk of it is going over these studies and pointing out methodological errors - and they all tend to make more or less the same "mistakes" over and over*. In this sense they are highly replicable. To the author's credit, he is sometimes tastefully sarcastic, which makes the text a bit less dry.

He also demonstrates how IQ testing has built-in biases (such as creating question sets to maximize race difference) and major scientific problems with the concept.

There was a short chapter discussing molecular research; I would love to read an updated edition devoting more space to this or maybe even a whole new book about it.

More people should read this, I recommend it to everyone interested in psychology and proper research methods. And anyone who doesn't want to live in Gattaca.

*e.g. p-hacking, Equal Environment Assumption, using reared-apart twins which were never actually reared apart, arbitrarily lumping various diseases into the "schizophrenia spectrum," and many more. More entertaining "mistakes" were when researchers apparently used homosexuality as a diagnostic criterion of schizophrenia (p. 219). They also possess powerful psychic abilities, such as diagnosing someone in a 5 minute conversation and interviewing dead people (p. 240).
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews