“… the night wind comes to shiver the water of the pond …”
I may be wrong, of course, (and I’ll readily admit that I’m not a big fan of the horror genre), but it seems to me that every horror short story every written contains certain common traits and literary devices – generous use of symbolism; references to death, violence, fear, terror, fright, murder; unexpected sounds or ominous silence; atmospheric, moody writing; darkness and shadows; onomatopoeia and pathetic fallacy; foreshadowing; suspense; irony; hyperbole; mystery; and, invariably, the clever, entirely unexpected twist ending that is intended to tingle your spine and raise the hairs on the back of your neck. Many writers are more than capable of creating the mood, of drawing the reader into a compelling story and giving the reader a delicious expectation of having their pants scared off with the final paragraph!
In that sense, Terry Dowling’s BASIC BLACK anthology is completely typical. His creation of that shivery, tense, mood of expectation driving the reader to continue ranges anywhere from workmanlike to exceptional. Dowling’s plan – to demonstrate that the typical, the mundane, the everyday object or situation is not always as it seems on the surface – is a clever one and, indeed, it often works. For me, there were two or three truly thrilling stories that made it easily to that 5-star plateau and simply knocked the breath out of me leaving my heart beating so loudly, I was sure my wife would hear it in the next room. On the other hand, there were also several that simply left me flat, entirely deflated … with that disenchanted reader’s “so what?”, or “I don’t get it!” kind of response.
My favourites (by a very wide margin) were, THE DAEMON STREET GHOST-TRAP, THE BONE SHIP, and THE MAZE MAN. It is perhaps unfortunate that THE DAEMON STREET GHOST-TRAP, a positively brilliant and entirely novel characterization of ghosts and ghost-hunting, was the very first story in the anthology because it set up a bar that the balance of the stories simply couldn’t clear. I’m glad that I read it but I’m not a convert to horror yet and I’m not running out to find anything else by Mr Dowling.
Horror fan? Almost certainly an enjoyable, if not entirely consistent, read.
Paul Weiss