I love Betsy Byars novels. Their subtext, subtlety, and poignant emotion capture the joys and tribulations of growing up, and The Cybil War does this as skillfully as some of Ms. Byars's most celebrated works. The story opens with Miss McFawn assigning roles to her students for a class play about food nutrition, but actually begins a few years earlier. When Simon Newton was in first grade, his father left the family with no warning. It took time and repeated explanations from Simon's mother for the boy to accept the truth, but he learned to cope. His father wrote a handful of letters over the years, updating Simon on his latest wilderness outing or business venture in South America or across the Atlantic, but practically speaking, Simon had no father. In second grade he met Tony Angotti, whose father died before Tony turned a year old, and the two became friends even as Simon's mother expressed misgivings over Tony's habitual lying. Fast-forward to Miss McFawn's class, and the boys are still best friends...until the events leading up to the nutrition play.
Simon has felt warmly toward Cybil Ackerman ever since she defended him in class a couple of years ago, so he's chagrined when a question she asks Miss McFawn leads to Simon losing his starring role in the play. He was so close to strutting the stage as Mr. Indigestion, but Simon is okay with yielding the part to Cybil, who will be Ms. Indigestion. After class Cybil sends Harriet Haywood over to make sure there are no hard feelings, but Tony never lets things die easy. He tells Harriet to pass along an insult to Cybil, claiming it came from Simon. Harriet storms off, but not before Tony insults her, too. Simon is in trouble; what if Cybil believes he made that provocative comment about her "popsicle stick" legs? Tony has a knack for putting his friend behind the eight ball.
Even after years of his father's absence, Simon's heart aches, and his mother is tuned in to his emotions. Whether he's had a spat with Tony, been scolded by a teacher, or enjoyed a great day, she can read it on his face, and she senses now that Simon is getting frustrated with Tony. Then Simon spots Tony at Cybil's front door, telling her a story designed to make Simon look foolish. The story is true, but why would Tony blab it to the one girl who's special to Simon? Tony has no particular feelings for Cybil, he just wants to prove she should like him. As Tony presses her to return his sudden affections, Simon's resentment grows, but he's not ready to cut the cord on his friendship with Tony, and surprisingly, his mother doesn't want him to. What happened to her disapproval of Tony's stretching the truth whenever it serves his purposes? A best friend is nearly impossible to replace, but that doesn't mean Simon has to let Tony have his way with Cybil. The sensible redhead may surprise Simon, though; she's not oblivious to reality, and just might be interested in spending more time with Simon. Life holds an infinite variety of possibilities for disappointment, but just as many avenues to happiness. Simon will reach that preferred destination eventually, even if his route takes longer than expected.
The Cybil War features lovely insights, uncommonly subtle ones for a children's novel. Tony's grandfather, Pap-pap, isn't ashamed to shed tears if there's a tug on his heartstrings; he cried the first time he heard that Simon's father left. Simon hadn't wept once over his father, but came close while watching Pap-pap's sincere emotional reaction to the story. Tony's interactions with Pap-pap let Simon see a new side of his friend, one of tender concern. Tony loves Pap-pap, but dismisses his tears because they flow so often. "It doesn't mean anything", he once told Simon in front of the old man. But Pap-pap disagreed. "It means something...It means I get so full I spill over." What wonderful commentary on the significance of having your emotions easily stirred, whether for reasons of sadness, joy, or beauty. Frequent tears are overflow from a heart brimming with the stuff of life. Should not such a person be envied? No one knows better than Simon the unpredictability of life, but retreating as his father did isn't the answer, a revelation that comes to Simon in the closing pages of The Cybil War: "Because in this world, with all its troubles, even if you had to sit by Harriet Haywood in the movies in the afternoon, you could still be riding beside Cybil Ackerman in the evening." It takes patience to ride out the bad days hoping for good, but a heart's wish fulfilled leaves little doubt that life is glorious. There's no telling what tomorrow will bring, so savor your halcyon days and don't be afraid to get so full of life that you "spill over." Pap-pap certainly is a wise man.
I'm torn on my rating for The Cybil War. Two and a half stars, yes, but I can't decide whether to round up or down. The promotional copy on the front and back covers is misleading, suggesting the story is about a mischievous girl playing two boys off each other so she can bask in their adoration. Perhaps other editions of the book don't miss the point so badly, but this Apple Paperbacks version could use an external rebranding. The story relies heavily on subtext, maybe too much, but I'll still round my rating up to three stars. The Cybil War is a quality novel by one of its generation's best authors for kids. Betsy Byars is an American original.