I've been reading Gardner's Perry Mason books off and on for many years. Many years ago, I was an intense fan of the series, and read them all, at least once. Now, after a lot of water over the dam, I'm looking at them again.
Those who are used to really fine mystery writers (with the emphasis on "writer"), such as Ross Macdonald, may find the writing style here off-putting. It can be stiff and mechanical. Nonetheless, I still love the general setting: the characters of Perry, Della, Paul, Lt. Tragg, and Hamilton Berger. That, and the ingenious plots, are why I read Perry Mason.
On the whole, the ones written by 1950 are the best. This one was written in 1953, and is an exception to the rule: it's excellent. It begins unusually, with a courtroom scene. Perry is defending a poor older man who is accused of armed robbery. Two wealthy people were in their car stopped at a red light when suddenly a man jerked open the driver's door, pointed a gun, and held them up. He made off with a purse, jewelry, and a wallet. The purse and wallet were later found in the trash can of the defendant, who lives in a trailer. The case was given to Perry as an assigned case.
The book opens late on a Friday afternoon with him cross-examining the woman who was there, Mrs. Lavina, who owns three restaurants. She and the rich man who was driving, Mr. Archer, have positively
identified the defendant. She says that after the robbery, she was driven home by an employee of hers who came to pick her up, one Inez Kaylor, who works as a hostess. Paul Drake has tracked down Inez Kaylor in Las Vegas, and Perry is going to introduce her as a surprise witness to refute Mrs. Lavina's testimony -- but Inez Kaylor has suddenly disappeared! Perry manages to stall until court is adjourned. Perry has until Monday morning to find Inez Kaylor or surely the defendant will be found guilty.
This book is unusual in that organized crime figures prominently in the plot. Mrs. Lavina's restaurants are tied in with illegal gambling. In trying to hunt for Inez Kaylor, Perry is taken for a ride (literally) to a gambling den and a beautiful hostess tries to seduce him! Is it Inez Kaylor, or does she have a sister who is also a hostess?
The defendant's neice, Mary Brogan, shows up to help. She's a spunky attractive young woman, a recurring character in the Perry Mason novels. Paul Drake warns Perry that some bad criminals are involved in all of this. Every move that Perry makes seems to be countered by an organized opposition. They think they have found Ms. Kaylor, only to have her spirited away somewhere. Then suddenly the defendant is accused of a murder that took place the same night as the holdup! It's a frame-up for sure. As the plot thickens, Della comes under jeopardy of physical harm. Lt. Tragg plays a positive role.
There are some truly excellent courtroom scenes, unfortunately not with Hamilton Burger but an assistant DA named Fritch. These are surely some of the very best courtroom scenes in all the Perry Mason novels.
A recurring theme is that at one point Perry and Della fly off to Las Vegas, apparently to get married. The Fan Dancer's Horse also has two attractive young women who get confused with one another. Another recurring theme in the novels is abuse of power by the wealthy, against the hard working honest people of modest means whom Perry Mason champions. The Green-eyed Sister, also from 1953, is also excellent. It also has important characters named Brogan and Fritch.
This one is a real page turner! Most of the earlier Perry Mason books are, but not all. Of all the Mason books, I would put it in the top 15%. Highly recommended.