Rayleigh Mann in the Company of Monsters
Rating: 3.5
Thank you HarperCollins for providing an e-copy through NetGalley
Synopsis: Rayleigh Mann is a troublemaker, breaking things, disrupting teachers, and getting into detentions constantly. On Halloween, he decides to meet up with some classmates to get some candy and prank the neighborhood, but the night doesn’t go as planned. For starters, what Rayleigh thought were costumes turn out to be very, very real, and monsters walk the streets of London. Not only that, but the monsters seem to be after him! After sprinting home and watching a battle in his own living room, a monster named Thelonius reveals that the folklore stories his Nana tells are all true, and that he is Rayleigh’s uncle. Thelonius brings Rayleigh to Below-London, a place where monsters thrive and produce the energy needed for Above-London to survive, showing him the start of his new life and grow into his monster heritage. For Rayleigh’s father is the Bogey Man, the leader of the monsters, and the scariest of them all. But he is missing, and it is up to Rayleigh to find the father he never knew. And, while his tricks got him into trouble as a human, being a troublemaker as a monster just might help him navigate this new and dangerous world straight out of a storybook’s adventures…and nightmares.
What I Liked: Rayleigh Mann in the Company of Monsters is a delightfully fun adventure of monsters, secrets, and spectacular hijinks. We watch as Rayleigh learns to accept himself as a monster, solving riddles and trials with his own trickery, cunning, and mischief. The story showcases Caribbean folklore and monsterology and integrates them into the world building, which is simplistic yet fascinating as readers get to meet various shapeshifters, creatures, horrors, and beasts in Below-London. The writing is action-packed and humorous, with Rayleigh navigating the new world with skepticism, middle-school sass, and a sharp eye. The side characters are colorful and supportive. Rayleigh Mann and his family are Black.
What I Didn’t Like: The pacing is not the greatest. It can be really slow or blindingly fast depending on the chapter or scene. Dialogue tends to be slow and has lots of exposition, while action is quick and immediate. This can lead to some scenes dragging on/having much to be excited about, and then the good parts zipping by too quickly. It was hard to get through the novel many times. Also, readers won’t really know who Rayleigh is until ⅓ into the story. At the beginning, which goes by very quickly, readers are told through his inner thoughts that Rayleigh is a troublemaker - but we never actually see this happen, so his arc of accepting the monster within himself doesn’t hit as hard as it could. Rayleigh and his same-aged companions also tend to have jarring dialogue/thoughts, as they use words or phrases that seem too old for them - they sound like adults, taking the readers out of the story.
Review Date: November 29, 2023