What do you think?
Rate this book


241 pages, Hardcover
First published October 8, 2013

-
-
-
Let me tell you this straight: straight and cisgender people have no idea how hurtful a hate crime is towards the lgbtq+ community. In this book, there is a shooting during an lgbtq+ group. And you know how this is handled? Do you know how the gay brother feels the next day after being shot? He feels fine. He is not scared. He is not upset. The only thing he feels is the pain from his wound. I know this was written before the terrible tragedy in Orlando, but do you know how I, an lgbtq+ teen, felt after the Orlando shooting? I was terrified. I was hurt. And I was angry.I wasn't even in the same country and my heart ached. Can you imagine how it would feel to be a victim/witness to a shooting? It would be horrifying. Can you imagine how it feels for the lgbtq+ people to know that not only was someone a disgusting enough person to shoot people, but that those people were targeted for being themselves? It was not just some random attack. It was a hate crime. The same thing happens in this book. And this character is written as if that event barely phased him. I wasn't even in Orlando, or the United States, and I was terrified. How was he not terrified after being shot? How did his heart not ache with the fact that there are still people who aren't accepting? It's unrealistic. And I'm pissed.This was not a story that a cishet gets to write (and, again, I'm sorry if the author truly is part of the lgbtq+ community. In that case: your writing is trash because there's no way anyone would be over a shooting in a day.) This was also not a story that should have been told from the POV of a cishet character.
It's a shame, because if it hadn't been for that, this book could have been enjoyable. Instead, I felt like punching something. The more I think about this novel, the angrier I get.