Jodi Angel captures the voices of eleven boys on the cusp of childhood as they passively hack to pieces their innocence and identity. In “A Good Deuce”, the narrator and his best friend find numbing sex after his mother’s funeral. In “Cash or Trade”, the narrator and his father are both mesmerized by a blonde bombshell in cutoffs so short that her “the front pockets [hang] under the ragged bottoms like rabbit ears.” In “Field Dressing”, the narrator and his unhappy aunt find themselves in “about the deepest shit there could be” in the middle of a hunting trip. And in the title story, the narrator witnesses his friend’s grandeur war stories shrivel down to their real size. In all these stories, the reader encounters an abandoned, horny, aggrieved, teenage boy with a fantastic imagination despite being stuck in an unsolvable problem.
Her stories are quintessential examples of everything natural about storytelling. Each story starts in the middle of action, pulling the reader in to the very core of the narrator’s interiority before the breath reading the first sentence is completely exhaled at the period. Then introduces backstory, moves into climax, and ends by flashing forward to a time beyond the narrative moment.
She knows how to weave a sentence, a paragraph, and the story seamlessly flows out of a smart conscious—a conscious, perhaps more aware of itself than a teenager might be. Wise and witty lines such as “plans have as much substance as daydreams” age the narrators by giving them a subtle kind of wisdom only experience might teach. Other times, the teenager’s naiveté works in Angel’s favor, especially in places where she does not have to explicitly state what happens, but can, instead, suggest the action. For example, sexual affairs between a parent and a stranger are implied with subtle imagery rather than explicit statements:
“My mother was leaning into the open yawn of the hood of my car, pointing at colored wires with a filed nail, careful to poke without touching so she wouldn’t spoil her manicure with sticky grease. I didn’t have to look at her to know that she was doing this. There was a man standing beside her, a tall man in dirty jeans, and I knew what kind of show she’d be putting on for his benefit. I knew she was asking questions in her high-fret guitar-string voice, and that she wasn’t listening for the answers. What she knew about cars I could fit into the corner of my eye, pick out with my finger, and wipe across my pants…”
What she manages to show with such grace in her voice is emotional restraint. The narrators are calm, but not stoic; passive, but not without desires; both observant and judgmental.
Because the tonality of the stories is so consistent, each story can be read as a variation of the same story or a product of a slightly altered universe. In this way, it’s not difficult to imagine a cinematic version where each story is a dramatic scene in a completely different narrative arch. The writing is evocative and dramatically inspiring to consider a movie somewhere in the near future.
This is what brings about the major point of criticism for the collection. There seems to be no real artistic reason for keeping these stories disconnected. Individually, the stories wrap the reader in an intensely and deeply imagined world, but gathered together in a collection, the stories collapse in close proximity. The stories are not dissimilar enough to warrant being disconnected, and they are not the similar enough to be considered truly connected. Connecting this collection to some degree might have worked to deepen this world even more and make each individual story stronger by its association and dialogue with the other stories.
Nonetheless, with dead rabbits, borrowed underwear, nude mothers, and one too many guns, cars, cars and more cars, Angel’s stories leave the reader anxious, satisfied, and heartbroken.