Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Revolutions of 1848

Rate this book
This social history of Europe during 1848 selects the most crucial centers of revolt and shows by a vivid reconstruction of events what revolution meant to the average citizen and how fateful a part he had in it. A wealth of material from contemporary sources, much of which is unavailable in English, is woven into a superb narrative which tells the story of how Frenchmen lived through the first real working-class revolt, how the students of Vienna took over the city government, how Croats and Slovenes were roused in their first nationalistic struggle, how Mazzini set up his ideal republic Rome.

464 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 1952

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
17 (22%)
4 stars
36 (46%)
3 stars
21 (27%)
2 stars
2 (2%)
1 star
1 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews
Profile Image for Lauren Albert.
1,842 reviews203 followers
July 29, 2021
I thought this a very good analysis of the period, surprisingly even for a 60 year old book. Smart, even handed. In her conclusion, she discusses the disillusionment and how it helped to lead to WWI.
146 reviews2 followers
December 2, 2019
As a genealogy enthusiast I discovered many immigrant families that arrived in America in the 1850’s. Many of these were from the various principalities which eventually formed the nation we now know as Germany. I became curious about this. Why did so many German families leave their homes to resettle in the US in that particular era?
There are probably many answers to the question but when I asked someone at one of the historical societies where I was doing my research she mentioned the revolutions in Europe. This was something I had never heard about before. Many European monarchies experienced democratic rebellions in the late 1840’s and early 1850’s.
The wave of revolution began in 1848 in France and eventually spread to Italy, Germany, Hungary and many other nations. The desires were basically the same and the outcomes quite similar as well. In most cases the people wanted more freedom from oppression and more of a say in the way their countries were governed. Also in most cases the revolutions failed to totally replace the existing government but succeeded in winning concessions of autonomy from the monarchy. Even Great Britain had to do some political restructuring to give the people more power.
This book does a nice job of describing the progression towards rebellion in several European states and introduces the reader to the leaders of each rebellion explaining the personalities and motivations which drove events to an inevitable climax.
Profile Image for lukas.
363 reviews
October 17, 2022
Veľmi chutná doporučujem každému ľahká a plná infosiek, napriek tomu že je z 1950 stále modernejšia ako niektoré dnešné výtlačky, nebráni sa triednemu boju
Profile Image for Individualfrog.
211 reviews48 followers
October 7, 2026
What a wonderfully pleasant surprise this book was; "nonfiction for readers" in the best way, extremely entertaining and readable without sacrficing seriousness or courting pop-history nonsense the way that, say, The Devil in the White City: Murder, Magic, and Madness at the Fair That Changed America had to contaminate its delightful exploration of event planning, architecture, engineering, crowd control, gardening etc with barely-related true crime serial killer baloney for sales.

From the dedication ("To my father, Preserved Smith") to the bibliography, it is a collection of human quirks and oddities as much as a history of these failed revolutions, and by so being, neatly side-steps the problem of being, as it ought to be, incredibly depressing. While billing itself a "social history", concerned with the lives and conditions of people, it is the exact opposite of books like The Meiji Restoration or Reconstruction: America's Unfinished Revolution 1863-1877, full of statistics about incomes, life expectancy, size of plots of land, census results, with exactly zero indication that these abstracted facts are more than lists of numbers in an empty Cartesian space, that they represent things that can be smelled, heard, or even seen. Hardly a character appears in this cast of thousands without some sketch of their appearance, the quality of their conversation and personality as well as ideas, and an anecdote. whether amusing -- Roberston understands that any detail can be droll if it is specific enough -- or scandalous, or chilling, or tragic, that humanizes them. As with people, so with physical, social, historical conditions: little anecdotal details that illuminate in a flash, rather than undifferentiated piles of data to be mined by whoever ought to be writing books instead of the historians of today. Less scientific? No doubt, but books are not ore to be smelted, they should be finished silverware.

I found the German section somewhat dreary, although "a crown from the gutter" is an incredible example to prove both the fathomless differences between the ideals of the past and those of today, and the falsity of the "realist" axiom that power is its own reward. Of the others, I found Vienna quite entertaining, Italy most tragic, Hungary frustrating (Roberston does not hate Kossuth as much as Rebecca West did, but nevertheless does not make him come off well -- of course very few people do come off well here, outside of her particular favorites, like Caussidiere, Manin, and as with everyone, that striking heroine Anita Garibaldi) and France the most surprising. What is truly bewildering is how much something like the Provisional Government -- whose existence was a matter of weeks -- both managed to accomplish, and also was expected, impossibly, to accomplish. It is as though the Boston Tea Party, continuting the next morning, defeated the British at Trenton and drafted the Constitution, but was expected to also immediately implement the entire New Deal. And all of this while Washington, Adams, Jefferson, and Hamilton, as heads of their different branches of the government, all hated and distrusted each other, and each organized a separate army that they commanded. It's madness.

It's also a sobering reminder, despite so many reminders of how far it was from perfect, of just how radical the American republic actually was; as Robertson notes, things like freedom of speech, limited suffrage, a king-less republic, and the citizens' militia, which the radical liberals of 1848 were demanding, had been established in the United States for over 50 years. It's also, to my mind, quite striking how these eruptions of violence were so futile, so counterproductive, that a hundred years afterwards one could only just then say that the reaction against them had finally spent its last force. I agree with Roberston when she laments, in her conclusion, that "men lost confidence in freedom and imagined they had made a great advance is sophistication by turning from idealism to cynicism." I am glad once again to have the example before me of the practical, but utterly anti-cynical women like Jane Addams, who continued to believe in a better world, reachable without any violence at all.
Profile Image for Pete Dolack.
Author 4 books25 followers
August 13, 2019
This is the best work on the Revolutions of 1848 that I have read. The focus is on history from below (although there is plenty of material on monarchs, powers behind thrones and generals) to give a reader a good sense of what life was like for the average person, and why so many became involved in so many national uprisings.

Obviously this is not a book with happy endings; the author details the bitter, blood-soaked end of attempted revolutions across western and central Europe, and the ways that monarchs and generals were able to reassert their ancien régimes. But history is what it is, and this book does just what its subtitle says: a necessary social history from an author sympathetic to those attempting to create a better world.

A very lively written social history. I picked up this book at random in a used bookstore, and needed only a few minutes to decide I wanted to read it. I am glad I did.
Profile Image for Lucille Nguyen.
496 reviews25 followers
March 2, 2023
A rather dense social history of the revolutions of 1848 in France, Germany, the Austrian Empire, and Italy. Interesting to use social masses as the primary unit of analysis, yet it often fails to capture the spirit of the people and too often falls into "great man" history. Nonetheless, an admirable and engrossing effort about what might be termed a failed democratic wave.
Profile Image for Jake Berlin.
719 reviews9 followers
July 3, 2012
a fascinating tour of the major revolutions of '48: france, [germany], the austrian empire, and [italy]. full of incredible anecdotes (the upside of being a social history), but also occasionally missing the broader explanations that would help tie things together. the cast(s) of characters is large, but ultimately worth it for the detail.
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews