“For many years the novelist Kay Dick…was at the centre of literary intrigue and gossip . She expended far more energy in pursuing personal vendettas and romantic lesbian relationships than in writing books…For crudity, vulgarity and foul language she had few equals, yet, at her best, she could switch on genuine charm…”
Author, editor and journalist Kay Dick’s obituary’s one of the most damming I’ve encountered. For many years Dick and partner Kathleen Farrell were prominent in circles that included Brigid Brophy, Olivia Manning and Sheena Mackay. Dick’s said to have influenced Orwell’s Animal Farm and was best known for her own, prize-winning, dystopian novel They, recently unearthed and due for republication. In her later years Dick was a notorious Brighton figure, frequently observed walking her dogs along the seafront, with her customary cigarette and eyeglass no doubt close at hand. I have no idea what kind of person Dick actually was but the glimpses I’ve had of her made her sound like a passionate eccentric, of the kind rarely seen in contemporary society, and her controversial persona reminded me of writers like Patricia Highsmith. What’s clear is that Dick was someone who struggled with personal relationships, and life in general - she’s known to have made at least one suicide attempt. So, when I finally came to read her semi-autobiographical novel The Shelf I was startled by how vastly different it is from the image of Dick I’ve pieced together from the few biographical details in circulation.
It’s the account of a relationship between novelist Cassandra (Cass) and a younger woman Anne, a fan of Cass’s work. Cass tells their story in flashback to an old friend Francis (likely a stand-in for novelist Francis King). There’s an element of mystery surrounding Anne’s apparent death but otherwise it’s an unexpectedly dry, stilted piece - apart from numerous unflattering digs at Olivia Manning, represented here by the character of Sophia. Its clipped, conventional tones are wildly at odds with its 1960s’ setting - even more so when you consider it was published in the early 1980s. What it does capture of that era is its casual homophobia, this is laced with it. The book jacket’s adorned with bizarre comparisons to Colette, Jean Rhys, Katherine Mansfield and even Ford Madox Ford, but their influence’s nowhere detectable in Dick’s narrative. However, there’s an almost Graham Greene-like quality both to the prose style and the subject matter - definite echoes here of his The End of the Affair. But unfortunately, there’s no sense of anything even approaching Greene’s skill or intensity. It’s also a very depressing portrait of a lesbian relationship: the exploitative power dynamic between older, world-weary Cass and younger, beautiful Anne is particularly off-putting, like a muted version of the appalling The Killing of Sister George. Anne’s character’s hazy, sketchily drawn, and Cass’s references paint her more as sensual creature than fully-realised individual. And despite Cass’s claim that she’s talking about a significant affair, her discussion of her time with Anne’s strangely dispassionate and unconvincing. Overall a very disappointing read, rounded off with a particularly improbable ending.