What do you think?
Rate this book
The Culper Ring #2
Whispers from the Shadows
Treachery causes Gwyneth Fairchild's world to crumble. The daughter of a British general, she barely saves her life by fleeing London aboard a ship to America. Her goal is to find refuge with the Lane family in Maryland, having been told by her father she could trust Winter and Bennet Lane implicitly, even though their nations are once again at war. After meeting their son Thad, she wonders how safe she truly is when she discovers that the Lanes trade in a dangerous commodity—espionage.
Not long after Gwyneth finds refuge in his city, Thad Lane experiences the tug of love, though he fears it may blur the lines of loyalty. With family playing the part of enemies and enemies proving themselves friends, a future with Gwyn is uncertain. But at this moment, with the British advancing on Washington and Baltimore, they have only their shared faith in God as a shield.
Not long after Gwyneth finds refuge in his city, Thad Lane experiences the tug of love, though he fears it may blur the lines of loyalty. With family playing the part of enemies and enemies proving themselves friends, a future with Gwyn is uncertain. But at this moment, with the British advancing on Washington and Baltimore, they have only their shared faith in God as a shield.
352 pages, Paperback
First published August 1, 2013
44 people are currently reading
1127 people want to read
About the author
Roseanna M. White
58 books3,782 followersRoseanna M. White is a bestselling, Christy Award nominated author who has long claimed that words are the air she breathes. When not writing fiction, she’s homeschooling her two kids, editing, designing book covers, and pretending her house will clean itself. Roseanna is the author of a slew of historical novels that span several continents and thousands of years. Spies and war and mayhem always seem to find their way into her books…to offset her real life, which is blessedly ordinary. She and her family make their home in the beautiful mountains of West Virginia. You can learn more about her and her stories at www.RoseannaMWhite.com.
see also Roseanna White
see also Roseanna White
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 152 reviews
June 15, 2020
First read: 10/14/2013
Rating: 5 stars
Second read: 6/14/2020
Rating: 5 stars
This was a fantastic story with a heroine who struggled with insomnia (like me!). I don’t see many stories that actually feature insomnia as a large challenge for one of the leads, so it was refreshing to see it used so beautifully here.
As with all the Roseanna M. White books I’ve read, this one contained emotion (that early death just about did me in!), an overall tense tone (which I loved), and a mysterious air throughout (which, again, I loved). This lovely book had a wonderful plot and great twists, but it was the characters and their trials and struggles that I really connected with.
Gwyneth and Thaddeus were so relatable and charming and human. Their journeys were ones worth riding along for, and I’m so glad Mrs. White shared them with us. I especially enjoyed the fact that Gwyneth was basically on her own in the world yet found reliable, trustworthy people upon whom she could depend when life brought even more troubles her way.
One moment that hit me hard in a very positive way was when one character wasn’t able to help another. As much as this person wanted to help, that was completely impossible, and that spiritual tugging toward the truth of God’s capability is something not often highlighted because it’s radical. It’s a radical faith these characters lived out on the pages, and it’s a radical faith I want to walk every day of my life. Faith is an action, folks, and this book displayed that beautifully.
Rating: 5 stars
Second read: 6/14/2020
Rating: 5 stars
This was a fantastic story with a heroine who struggled with insomnia (like me!). I don’t see many stories that actually feature insomnia as a large challenge for one of the leads, so it was refreshing to see it used so beautifully here.
As with all the Roseanna M. White books I’ve read, this one contained emotion (that early death just about did me in!), an overall tense tone (which I loved), and a mysterious air throughout (which, again, I loved). This lovely book had a wonderful plot and great twists, but it was the characters and their trials and struggles that I really connected with.
Gwyneth and Thaddeus were so relatable and charming and human. Their journeys were ones worth riding along for, and I’m so glad Mrs. White shared them with us. I especially enjoyed the fact that Gwyneth was basically on her own in the world yet found reliable, trustworthy people upon whom she could depend when life brought even more troubles her way.
One moment that hit me hard in a very positive way was when one character wasn’t able to help another. As much as this person wanted to help, that was completely impossible, and that spiritual tugging toward the truth of God’s capability is something not often highlighted because it’s radical. It’s a radical faith these characters lived out on the pages, and it’s a radical faith I want to walk every day of my life. Faith is an action, folks, and this book displayed that beautifully.
March 31, 2016
Another excellent Culper Ring story! I love this series...and Roseanna White is definitely a favorite author. This story focuses on the children of the characters in the first book and novella. My only complaint is that I'd have liked another chapter! I really wanted to hear a few more details, such as hearing about Polly's baby.
August 4, 2022
Umm… wow. Depths, layers, such consistently solid writing and storytelling throughout this book’s entirety!! Just like the previous book in the series, there's no way this book deserves anything less than 5 ⭐'s!
I became really emotionally invested in Thad and Gwyn’s relationahip; it was deep and emotional. Their relationship development was so realistic and relatable. Not to be redundant with what I said about the last book, Ring of Secrets (💗) but I’m blown away by Roseanna White’s creativity and ability to take a story in an unpredictable direction — especially in regards to Thad and Gwyn’s relationship and how they responded to each other when things were hard —they act like real people who love each other and handle circumstances accordingly, with maturity & communication— they ask questions, they listen, they pray about situations they’re in, they seek the Lord for guidance, they read their Bible.
The characters in this book really rely on the Lord and allow Him to guide them in their decision-making. So refreshing and unique to see how the Lord’s guidance was woven through the lives; making the story beautiful.
I can’t believe I was sleeping on this series!! Romantic, mysterious, emotional, entertaining and so well written. I’m learning too! Lots of historical facts.
… So happy to have another to read…on to the next one! 😁
I became really emotionally invested in Thad and Gwyn’s relationahip; it was deep and emotional. Their relationship development was so realistic and relatable. Not to be redundant with what I said about the last book, Ring of Secrets (💗) but I’m blown away by Roseanna White’s creativity and ability to take a story in an unpredictable direction — especially in regards to Thad and Gwyn’s relationship and how they responded to each other when things were hard —they act like real people who love each other and handle circumstances accordingly, with maturity & communication— they ask questions, they listen, they pray about situations they’re in, they seek the Lord for guidance, they read their Bible.
The characters in this book really rely on the Lord and allow Him to guide them in their decision-making. So refreshing and unique to see how the Lord’s guidance was woven through the lives; making the story beautiful.
I can’t believe I was sleeping on this series!! Romantic, mysterious, emotional, entertaining and so well written. I’m learning too! Lots of historical facts.
… So happy to have another to read…on to the next one! 😁
August 2, 2013
Gwyneth Fairchild has been sent by her father, Isaac, to stay with his old friends from America, Winter and Bennet Lane. Never mind that it’s 1814 and England is at war with America, and never mind that she doesn’t want to go. As she is leaving, she is intercepted with a marriage proposal from the handsome Sir Arthur, but when she goes back inside to speak to her father, she unwittingly witnesses his murder at the hands of her Uncle Gates, so she knows she must leave, immediately, before her uncle realises what she has seen.
She suffers from dreadful seasickness on the voyage, and doesn’t improve even after arriving at the Baltimore home of Thaddeus Lane, son of Winter and Bennet. But they are determined to care for her, even without knowing why she is so afraid. When they find out, they are even more determined to protect her, especially Thad, who finds himself falling for the beautiful artist.
I didn’t enjoy Whispers from the Shadows as much as Ring of Secrets or Fairchild’s Lady (a novella), because the focus was more on the relationship and the suspense around Gates and Sir Arthur, rather than on the activities of the Culper Ring, which were much more a focus of Ring of Secrets. This could be because it was rather slow to get going. Gwyneth sees her father murdered, falls to pieces mentally, and doesn’t really recover until almost the halfway point. Yet Thad falls for her almost immediately, despite the fact that she’s just not herself.
And Thad is hiding his own secrets. He’s been married before, but no one talks about it, which seems very strange. We realise why when there is a huge argument at the halfway point, and it’s at this point that Whispers in the Shadows really starts to get going and pile on the suspense. Danger is coming, both from the inevitable war with the British, and from Uncle Gates. The second half of the novel is excellent, as is the unexpected finish, and I was impressed by the historical research and the way the historical events make the war between the North and the South inevitable.
Although this is part of a series, it can easily be read as a stand-alone novel—the parts of the story that are confusing in the first half are confusing even to someone who has read the previous books, and the questions are answered in the second half. I will look forward to the next in the series, but I hope it returns to more of a focus on the Culpers, and maintains the pace all the way through.
Thanks to Harvest House and NetGalley for providing a free ebook for review.
She suffers from dreadful seasickness on the voyage, and doesn’t improve even after arriving at the Baltimore home of Thaddeus Lane, son of Winter and Bennet. But they are determined to care for her, even without knowing why she is so afraid. When they find out, they are even more determined to protect her, especially Thad, who finds himself falling for the beautiful artist.
I didn’t enjoy Whispers from the Shadows as much as Ring of Secrets or Fairchild’s Lady (a novella), because the focus was more on the relationship and the suspense around Gates and Sir Arthur, rather than on the activities of the Culper Ring, which were much more a focus of Ring of Secrets. This could be because it was rather slow to get going. Gwyneth sees her father murdered, falls to pieces mentally, and doesn’t really recover until almost the halfway point. Yet Thad falls for her almost immediately, despite the fact that she’s just not herself.
And Thad is hiding his own secrets. He’s been married before, but no one talks about it, which seems very strange. We realise why when there is a huge argument at the halfway point, and it’s at this point that Whispers in the Shadows really starts to get going and pile on the suspense. Danger is coming, both from the inevitable war with the British, and from Uncle Gates. The second half of the novel is excellent, as is the unexpected finish, and I was impressed by the historical research and the way the historical events make the war between the North and the South inevitable.
Although this is part of a series, it can easily be read as a stand-alone novel—the parts of the story that are confusing in the first half are confusing even to someone who has read the previous books, and the questions are answered in the second half. I will look forward to the next in the series, but I hope it returns to more of a focus on the Culpers, and maintains the pace all the way through.
Thanks to Harvest House and NetGalley for providing a free ebook for review.
July 25, 2022
The first book in the Culper Ring series focused on the Culper Ring that existed during the Revolutionary War. Now we are looking at the children of those spies who have formed a Culper Ring of their own as the War of 1812 progresses. Gwyneth Fairchild is the daughter of a British General. He has arranged for her to go to family in Baltimore as he fears for his life. Just before she is to leave, she witnesses her uncle murder her father; and she is forced to head for America to save her own life.
I thoroughly enjoyed the first book in this series, and this one is equally as well written. I never knew that there was another Culper Ring that existed during the War of 1812, so found this story quite intriguing as once again the Americans were attempting to keep the British from taking over the country. White's historical research is obvious, her characters are richly developed, and her plot line well done. I look forward to reading the novellas and final book in this series.
I thoroughly enjoyed the first book in this series, and this one is equally as well written. I never knew that there was another Culper Ring that existed during the War of 1812, so found this story quite intriguing as once again the Americans were attempting to keep the British from taking over the country. White's historical research is obvious, her characters are richly developed, and her plot line well done. I look forward to reading the novellas and final book in this series.
August 24, 2022
I loved the first book, Ring of Secrets, so I immediately started listening to this one.
Whispers from the Shadows starts with a bang! The gripping start and the story will keep you reading long after bedtime! I loved everything about this story. It is about 30 years (could be off a few) later than the first book, and it is a continuation of the families from Ring of Secrets. Therefore, I HIGHLY recommend reading this series in order.
This has one of the sweetest romances that I have read. It is so clean and precious. Thad is a wonderful, swoon-worthy hero! The care he shows Gwyneth is amazing! This story is heartbreaking, achingly beautiful, continues with spy secrets and coding, has a lot of family drama (not exaggerated, it's a nice balance) and an engaging plot.
I highly recommend this book and series to fans of historical fiction!
Whispers from the Shadows starts with a bang! The gripping start and the story will keep you reading long after bedtime! I loved everything about this story. It is about 30 years (could be off a few) later than the first book, and it is a continuation of the families from Ring of Secrets. Therefore, I HIGHLY recommend reading this series in order.
This has one of the sweetest romances that I have read. It is so clean and precious. Thad is a wonderful, swoon-worthy hero! The care he shows Gwyneth is amazing! This story is heartbreaking, achingly beautiful, continues with spy secrets and coding, has a lot of family drama (not exaggerated, it's a nice balance) and an engaging plot.
I highly recommend this book and series to fans of historical fiction!
January 6, 2016
Another interesting look into the Culper Spy Ring!! Winter and Bennett arrive in this read again and they are still my favorite to read about thus far. Gwyneth and Thad are also quite likeable but this read has a good bit more romance in it than I prefer. All in all it was another great read from Roseanna White.
August 17, 2013
I loved this historical romance by Roseanna M. White! The War of 1812 was an interesting time period. Great sequel to book 1 in this series, "Ring of Secrets."
Full review:
http://booksmusicandlife.blogspot.com...
Full review:
http://booksmusicandlife.blogspot.com...
September 8, 2024
I loved Thad's determination to protect everyone around him, but I also appreciated how it showed that as a detriment. And Jack was sweet, and Gwyn was really great.
August 10, 2022
Whispers from the Shadows by Roseanna M. White
Timeframe: War of 1812
Location: Baltimore, MD (a bit in London)
Main Characters:
Gwyneth Fairchild: Daughter of Isaac Fairchild from Fairchild's Lady
Thad Lane: Captain of The Masquerade
Uncle Gates: Gwyneth's uncle who killed her fathersxxx
Sir Arthur: Asked Gwyneth's to marry him in London
Wow! What a complicated book. Murder, a form of PTSD, an unusual draw to one person for mental peace, slave trade, marriage to a wife the husband was thought dead, cold-hearted evil, secret notes in false bottoms, surprise relatives, espionage, broken people, chasing for love and ill intent, impressed servitude, trust issues, love, romance, keys to cryptic letters, past and present art to solve mysteries, truth and secrets. Did I mention romance?
I read the Culper Ring series totally out of sequence. Even though what I read was chronologically out of order, the characters in each were from different historical eras, so they were complete books in themselves. One thing I noticed in this series was a common theme of an evil person pursuing a woman, at least in two of the books and the novella. But they were well done.
Synopsis:
Gwyneth Fairchild witnesses a murder and given a warning to run. She's already packed to go to America so she just leaves immediately. Nearing America her ship is overtaken by an American privateer ship. She shows the captain the note her father gave her in the event this very thing happens. In it the captain is asked to deliver her to Thaddeus Lane, the most famous American captain, and trusted by her father.
Her life is forever altered by these events. As hard as it is for her to hold onto her sanity, suffering from nightmares and lack of sleep, she finds solace in the family to which her father entrusted her. Thad has some sort of calming effect on her, and her draw to him is mysterious as well as one God seems to use.
Secrets abound and little by little are revealed. Meanwhile, her uncle from London, and the man who considers himself her betrothed, are on their way to America in search of her, both for very different reasons. Her life is in danger and Thad has made it his mission to protect her at any cost.
Very complex book. But it works. Maybe not my favorite Roseanna M. White book, but still worth a read.
Timeframe: War of 1812
Location: Baltimore, MD (a bit in London)
Main Characters:
Gwyneth Fairchild: Daughter of Isaac Fairchild from Fairchild's Lady
Thad Lane: Captain of The Masquerade
Uncle Gates: Gwyneth's uncle who killed her fathersxxx
Sir Arthur: Asked Gwyneth's to marry him in London
Wow! What a complicated book. Murder, a form of PTSD, an unusual draw to one person for mental peace, slave trade, marriage to a wife the husband was thought dead, cold-hearted evil, secret notes in false bottoms, surprise relatives, espionage, broken people, chasing for love and ill intent, impressed servitude, trust issues, love, romance, keys to cryptic letters, past and present art to solve mysteries, truth and secrets. Did I mention romance?
I read the Culper Ring series totally out of sequence. Even though what I read was chronologically out of order, the characters in each were from different historical eras, so they were complete books in themselves. One thing I noticed in this series was a common theme of an evil person pursuing a woman, at least in two of the books and the novella. But they were well done.
Synopsis:
Gwyneth Fairchild witnesses a murder and given a warning to run. She's already packed to go to America so she just leaves immediately. Nearing America her ship is overtaken by an American privateer ship. She shows the captain the note her father gave her in the event this very thing happens. In it the captain is asked to deliver her to Thaddeus Lane, the most famous American captain, and trusted by her father.
Her life is forever altered by these events. As hard as it is for her to hold onto her sanity, suffering from nightmares and lack of sleep, she finds solace in the family to which her father entrusted her. Thad has some sort of calming effect on her, and her draw to him is mysterious as well as one God seems to use.
Secrets abound and little by little are revealed. Meanwhile, her uncle from London, and the man who considers himself her betrothed, are on their way to America in search of her, both for very different reasons. Her life is in danger and Thad has made it his mission to protect her at any cost.
Very complex book. But it works. Maybe not my favorite Roseanna M. White book, but still worth a read.
May 11, 2018
This book for some reason took me a really long time to read and I'm not sure why. It was a good book, but it really didn't pull me in.
What I liked:
So first I really liked the time period. I'm a huge historical fiction fan and the war of 1812 is a time I don't see too often in fiction books. Also, I enjoyed reading more about the Culpers and their possible involvement in stopping the British yet again.
I liked visiting the characters from the first book and seeing where they are and what they are up to.
The spiritual aspect was strong and natural.
The secondary characters added a lot of depth to the story and I liked them a lot.
I loved the banter between the characters. The family dynamic was strong and I enjoyed seeing the characters interact with each other.
I also loved that the characters grew a lot in the story - from Gwyn learning to trust and rest in a God who is constant and loves her dearly, to Thad who had to learn to let go and trust God to handle his problems. I, as the reader, could relate to them and learn from their struggles.
Ok so what I didn't like:
Full honesty here: I didn't really care for the main characters... Yes I could relate to their struggles, but I couldn't really relate to much else and that is one reason I don't think I could really get into the story. First, I didn't like how Gwyn treated Sir Author. She claims she barely knew him, but clearly something happened for her to accept his marriage proposal and then for him to search so hard to find and save her. I really felt bad for him! I didn't agree with his decisions, but I feel like his intentions were good.
I felt that things kind of slowed down in the middle of the book and that is another reason it was hard for me to read.
There were a few other little things I didn't care for such as the main characters giving each other massages before they were in any type of relationship. They barely even realized themselves that they liked each other, had not told each other of their feelings, and Thad was giving Gwyn a massage. I just felt that should have waited till they were at least courting. Maybe that's just me.
All that aside, I still enjoyed the story and will definitely be finishing the series. I have read and enjoyed several of Mrs. White's books now. This one just wasn't my favorite.
What I liked:
So first I really liked the time period. I'm a huge historical fiction fan and the war of 1812 is a time I don't see too often in fiction books. Also, I enjoyed reading more about the Culpers and their possible involvement in stopping the British yet again.
I liked visiting the characters from the first book and seeing where they are and what they are up to.
The spiritual aspect was strong and natural.
The secondary characters added a lot of depth to the story and I liked them a lot.
I loved the banter between the characters. The family dynamic was strong and I enjoyed seeing the characters interact with each other.
I also loved that the characters grew a lot in the story - from Gwyn learning to trust and rest in a God who is constant and loves her dearly, to Thad who had to learn to let go and trust God to handle his problems. I, as the reader, could relate to them and learn from their struggles.
Ok so what I didn't like:
Full honesty here: I didn't really care for the main characters... Yes I could relate to their struggles, but I couldn't really relate to much else and that is one reason I don't think I could really get into the story. First, I didn't like how Gwyn treated Sir Author. She claims she barely knew him, but clearly something happened for her to accept his marriage proposal and then for him to search so hard to find and save her. I really felt bad for him! I didn't agree with his decisions, but I feel like his intentions were good.
I felt that things kind of slowed down in the middle of the book and that is another reason it was hard for me to read.
There were a few other little things I didn't care for such as the main characters giving each other massages before they were in any type of relationship. They barely even realized themselves that they liked each other, had not told each other of their feelings, and Thad was giving Gwyn a massage. I just felt that should have waited till they were at least courting. Maybe that's just me.
All that aside, I still enjoyed the story and will definitely be finishing the series. I have read and enjoyed several of Mrs. White's books now. This one just wasn't my favorite.
February 6, 2017
4.5 stars. This is the 2nd book of the Culper Ring trilogy by Roseanna M White. It is fantastic! The reader is introduced to new characters along with catching up on some of the characters from the 1st book and the novella. The writing style makes history come alive and makes the reader feel like all of the characters are real people.
SPOILER:
[spoiler]I literally cried at the end when the Fort McHenry battle ends, and Thad notes the flag still flying. As an American who sometimes takes the national anthem for granted, the writing leading up to that scene had me emotionally invested in these characters. So to know they made it through a pivotal battle that would then inspire Francis Scott Key to write the national anthem was amazing for me.[/spoiler]
SPOILER:
[spoiler]I literally cried at the end when the Fort McHenry battle ends, and Thad notes the flag still flying. As an American who sometimes takes the national anthem for granted, the writing leading up to that scene had me emotionally invested in these characters. So to know they made it through a pivotal battle that would then inspire Francis Scott Key to write the national anthem was amazing for me.[/spoiler]
September 13, 2021
RMW’s writing is excruciatingly wordy. It got so bad, I just skimmed whole passages yet I could still follow the story.
Example:
“The river of tears hit a bank of rocks within her, making rapids. Gasps. She could only shake her head and bury her face in his chest, letting the floodwaters empty her. Letting them spill out until there was nothing left within. Not a torrent, not a trickle, not a tear.”
Also, Gwyneth was hard to admire. Her fears were justified, but I didn’t find her likable. I suspect she is written that way to show the reader how her faith in God will strengthen her, but it won’t change her basic character which was too preoccupied with herself.
Example:
“The river of tears hit a bank of rocks within her, making rapids. Gasps. She could only shake her head and bury her face in his chest, letting the floodwaters empty her. Letting them spill out until there was nothing left within. Not a torrent, not a trickle, not a tear.”
Also, Gwyneth was hard to admire. Her fears were justified, but I didn’t find her likable. I suspect she is written that way to show the reader how her faith in God will strengthen her, but it won’t change her basic character which was too preoccupied with herself.
December 31, 2020
Fantastic story! I thoroughly enjoyed this exciting and romantic mystery. Couldn’t put it down. Can’t wait for book 3 which is my next read!
October 10, 2023
❝ 𝙵𝚘𝚛 𝚠𝚎 𝚍𝚘 𝚗𝚘𝚝 𝚠𝚛𝚎𝚜𝚝𝚕𝚎 𝚊𝚐𝚊𝚒𝚗𝚜𝚝 𝚏𝚕𝚎𝚜𝚑 𝚊𝚗𝚍 𝚋𝚕𝚘𝚘𝚍, 𝚋𝚞𝚝 𝚊𝚐𝚊𝚒𝚗𝚜𝚝 𝚙𝚛𝚒𝚗𝚌𝚒𝚙𝚊𝚕𝚒𝚝𝚒𝚎𝚜, 𝚊𝚐𝚊𝚒𝚗𝚜𝚝 𝚙𝚘𝚠𝚎𝚛𝚜, 𝚊𝚐𝚊𝚒𝚗𝚜𝚝 𝚝𝚑𝚎 𝚛𝚞𝚕𝚎𝚛𝚜 𝚘𝚏 𝚝𝚑𝚎 𝚍𝚊𝚛𝚔𝚗𝚎𝚜𝚜 𝚘𝚏 𝚝𝚑𝚒𝚜 𝚊𝚐𝚎, 𝚊𝚐𝚊𝚒𝚗𝚜𝚝 𝚜𝚙𝚒𝚛𝚒𝚝𝚞𝚊𝚕 𝚑𝚘𝚜𝚝𝚜 𝚘𝚏 𝚠𝚒𝚌𝚔𝚎𝚍𝚗𝚎𝚜𝚜 𝚒𝚗 𝚝𝚑𝚎 𝚑𝚎𝚊𝚟𝚎𝚗𝚕𝚢 𝚙𝚕𝚊𝚌𝚎𝚜. ❞ ~𝙴𝚙𝚑𝚎𝚜𝚒𝚊𝚗𝚜 𝟼:𝟷𝟸
❀ This book was unlike any other Roseanna M. White book I've read before. It started out quite eventful (in a different kind of way). I quite enjoyed myself with the first book in this series and was pleased to see our mc's family return into this book. Mrs. White has a splendid cast of characters once again, and once I got into the book I lost myself in the streets of Maryland in the times of 1812. ❀
» The plot, I'll be honest, had it's slow moments imo. But I've learned with Roseanna's books that the endings always make up for any trouble. It took me some time to warm up to Gwyneth but it was well worth it to watch the character growth and spiritual growth that followed.
» The only thing I didn't love about this book was that for some reason I found it a bit slow for a while but that could fully be me hehe
» But the relationships were very cute and I enjoyed the plot twists :)
» I enjoyed that Christianity was discussed openly, we got to see such important spiritual growth, and that the faith shown was important to remember in any relationship we may have.
» Overall it was a great book, it didn't hold me to the edge of my seat like I may have liked, but it was still a great read <3
Content:
Language: None spoken
Violence: This is set in wartimes so deaths of war are mentioned, a man is murdered and revolved around in the pages to come (nothing real gory), a woman is slapped, a man was thought dead and then sold into slavery, two friends wrestle, a murder is mentioned (not detailed), pistols are locked on individuals a few times, a threat is said to be shot, a man is shot
Sexual: Sleeping in bed as a couple is mentioned (not detailed), waking up in bed with a spouse (non detailed), a man realizes he only wanted to marry a woman for the thoughts of his bed, a man is described as a rake, lots of kissing (none too described)
Alcohol/drugs: Spies use the pub as a place to find information
TWs: Murder
˚₊‧✩ 𝙷𝚊𝚙𝚙𝚢 𝚁𝚎𝚊𝚍𝚒𝚗𝚐 ✩‧₊˚
❀ This book was unlike any other Roseanna M. White book I've read before. It started out quite eventful (in a different kind of way). I quite enjoyed myself with the first book in this series and was pleased to see our mc's family return into this book. Mrs. White has a splendid cast of characters once again, and once I got into the book I lost myself in the streets of Maryland in the times of 1812. ❀
» The plot, I'll be honest, had it's slow moments imo. But I've learned with Roseanna's books that the endings always make up for any trouble. It took me some time to warm up to Gwyneth but it was well worth it to watch the character growth and spiritual growth that followed.
» The only thing I didn't love about this book was that for some reason I found it a bit slow for a while but that could fully be me hehe
» But the relationships were very cute and I enjoyed the plot twists :)
» I enjoyed that Christianity was discussed openly, we got to see such important spiritual growth, and that the faith shown was important to remember in any relationship we may have.
» Overall it was a great book, it didn't hold me to the edge of my seat like I may have liked, but it was still a great read <3
Content:
Language: None spoken
Violence: This is set in wartimes so deaths of war are mentioned, a man is murdered and revolved around in the pages to come (nothing real gory), a woman is slapped, a man was thought dead and then sold into slavery, two friends wrestle, a murder is mentioned (not detailed), pistols are locked on individuals a few times, a threat is said to be shot, a man is shot
Sexual: Sleeping in bed as a couple is mentioned (not detailed), waking up in bed with a spouse (non detailed), a man realizes he only wanted to marry a woman for the thoughts of his bed, a man is described as a rake, lots of kissing (none too described)
Alcohol/drugs: Spies use the pub as a place to find information
TWs: Murder
˚₊‧✩ 𝙷𝚊𝚙𝚙𝚢 𝚁𝚎𝚊𝚍𝚒𝚗𝚐 ✩‧₊˚
June 24, 2024
Breathtakingly beautiful story. Reread summer 2024.
Original Review:
This book was my favorite book of 2013.
I don't say that lightly. I really, really loved this story. Gwyneth definitely fits the bill for a damsel in distress, and Thaddeus Lane (isn't that an awesome name?) is a one-of-a-kind hero. But more than that, the strong theme of whispers, secrets, and enduring love tied this book to the top of my favorites list.
Gwyneth witnesses her father's murder and flees for her life. Insomnia wracks her on the voyage from England to America until she is extremely unwell, but then in Thad's presence, she realizes she is safe, that he can be trusted. That was the sweetest scene. I just loved how Thad put her immediately at ease.
The danger is not over, however. Far from it. I hesitate to say too much; I'd much rather you buy this book and experience the adventure for yourself! The pacing was just right; I could hardly put it down. The moments of realization in the middle of the book made my jaw drop and jazz hands happen.
And the ending. Well. I'll leave that for you to discover, but, rest assured, it is the most beautiful, sigh-worthy romance I've read in a long time. Thad's decision was the heroic ultimate. Gwyneth's growth was awesome to behold.
And she's an artist! The way that is worked into the plot and how things fall into place was genius!
These characters became friends, and I was sorry to see their story end. Thankfully, it doesn't--there's more in the series! Yay!
Why I Recommend This Book
Readers of historical fiction will thoroughly enjoy Roseanna M. White's latest release--may it glue to your hands as it did mine and become a bookshelf favorite! Whispers from the Shadows is sure to wrap its way around your heart!
Watch for the inspirational message, too. I want to be more like Gwyneth--who learned that the Lord is trustworthy and true.
Original Review:
This book was my favorite book of 2013.
I don't say that lightly. I really, really loved this story. Gwyneth definitely fits the bill for a damsel in distress, and Thaddeus Lane (isn't that an awesome name?) is a one-of-a-kind hero. But more than that, the strong theme of whispers, secrets, and enduring love tied this book to the top of my favorites list.
Gwyneth witnesses her father's murder and flees for her life. Insomnia wracks her on the voyage from England to America until she is extremely unwell, but then in Thad's presence, she realizes she is safe, that he can be trusted. That was the sweetest scene. I just loved how Thad put her immediately at ease.
The danger is not over, however. Far from it. I hesitate to say too much; I'd much rather you buy this book and experience the adventure for yourself! The pacing was just right; I could hardly put it down. The moments of realization in the middle of the book made my jaw drop and jazz hands happen.
And the ending. Well. I'll leave that for you to discover, but, rest assured, it is the most beautiful, sigh-worthy romance I've read in a long time. Thad's decision was the heroic ultimate. Gwyneth's growth was awesome to behold.
And she's an artist! The way that is worked into the plot and how things fall into place was genius!
These characters became friends, and I was sorry to see their story end. Thankfully, it doesn't--there's more in the series! Yay!
Why I Recommend This Book
Readers of historical fiction will thoroughly enjoy Roseanna M. White's latest release--may it glue to your hands as it did mine and become a bookshelf favorite! Whispers from the Shadows is sure to wrap its way around your heart!
Watch for the inspirational message, too. I want to be more like Gwyneth--who learned that the Lord is trustworthy and true.
September 18, 2013
This Second in the Culper Ring Series is as wonderfully inspiring and intriguing as the first!
General Fairchild has uncovered a fatal secret. He sends his daughter Gwyneth from their home in England to friends in America in the nick of time, but not before she sees one of her mother's brothers kill her father. The ship's rocking and her horror over what she's seen send her into a frightful state. The servants who accompany her to America and her father's friends fear for her sanity.
Why did her father so trust Thaddeus Lane, a young man he hadn't seen in many years, especially during this horrid war? She didn't know, but now she finds Thad is also the only one she trusts. She cannot sleep unless he is in the house, nor did she sleep on the ship on her way to this land at war with her country.
Thad finds himself drawn to the haunted wraith thrust so suddenly into his and his parents' care. The young woman is a talented artist, but what are the shadows in her drawings? Why does she act so frightened? She's hiding secrets, but she's letting no one in on them--not even him, not even though it's so obvious she trusts him with her life.
General Fairchild has uncovered a fatal secret. He sends his daughter Gwyneth from their home in England to friends in America in the nick of time, but not before she sees one of her mother's brothers kill her father. The ship's rocking and her horror over what she's seen send her into a frightful state. The servants who accompany her to America and her father's friends fear for her sanity.
Why did her father so trust Thaddeus Lane, a young man he hadn't seen in many years, especially during this horrid war? She didn't know, but now she finds Thad is also the only one she trusts. She cannot sleep unless he is in the house, nor did she sleep on the ship on her way to this land at war with her country.
Thad finds himself drawn to the haunted wraith thrust so suddenly into his and his parents' care. The young woman is a talented artist, but what are the shadows in her drawings? Why does she act so frightened? She's hiding secrets, but she's letting no one in on them--not even him, not even though it's so obvious she trusts him with her life.
October 13, 2022
I loved the first book, Ring of Secrets, by Roseanna M. White, so I had to immediately start Whispers from the Shadows.
Whispers from the Shadows starts with a bang! The gripping start and the story will keep you reading long after bedtime! I loved everything about this story. It is about 30 years (could be off a few) later than the first book, and it is a continuation of the families from Ring of Secrets. Therefore, I HIGHLY recommend reading this series in order.
Whispers from the Shadows has one of the sweetest romances that I have read. It is so clean and precious. Thad is a wonderful, swoon-worthy hero! The care he shows Gwyneth is amazing! This story is heartbreaking, achingly beautiful, continues with spy secrets and coding, has a lot of family drama (not exaggerated, it's a nice balance) and an engaging plot.
I highly recommend this book and series to fans of historical fiction!
- Reviewed by Cindy D. (UCL Volunteer)
Whispers from the Shadows starts with a bang! The gripping start and the story will keep you reading long after bedtime! I loved everything about this story. It is about 30 years (could be off a few) later than the first book, and it is a continuation of the families from Ring of Secrets. Therefore, I HIGHLY recommend reading this series in order.
Whispers from the Shadows has one of the sweetest romances that I have read. It is so clean and precious. Thad is a wonderful, swoon-worthy hero! The care he shows Gwyneth is amazing! This story is heartbreaking, achingly beautiful, continues with spy secrets and coding, has a lot of family drama (not exaggerated, it's a nice balance) and an engaging plot.
I highly recommend this book and series to fans of historical fiction!
- Reviewed by Cindy D. (UCL Volunteer)
September 4, 2013
Whispers from the Shadows was such a wonderful book! Roseanna White is truly such a gifted writer! I found myself getting lost in the words, felt myself right there with the characters, experiencing their joys and sorrows, their ups and downs. I truly felt as if I were visiting early 1800's America. There were a couple of really surprising reveals that I did not see coming; I loved being shocked like I was. Definitely one of the best books I've read this year, I can't recommend Whispers from the Shadows enough!
May 3, 2019
4.5 stars
This started out solid 5 stars, I was surprised a sequel could be just as good as the first book. Around 3/4 through I thought it slowed down some and there was a bit more of the preaching spirit in this one than I like. Definitely read this series in order, as you won't know all the characters as well if you don't. Overall, I'm very impressed with this series and I'm looking forward to the next e-novella and the final book!
This started out solid 5 stars, I was surprised a sequel could be just as good as the first book. Around 3/4 through I thought it slowed down some and there was a bit more of the preaching spirit in this one than I like. Definitely read this series in order, as you won't know all the characters as well if you don't. Overall, I'm very impressed with this series and I'm looking forward to the next e-novella and the final book!
July 26, 2024
I enjoyed this historical mystery and suspense, involving spies and a time sensitive between the Americans and British.
I love Thad and little Jack and it was great to see Thad’s parents were the main characters from Ring of Secrets. Thad was a great dashing hero. Gwyneth’s was a strong heroine who found her inner strength more and more as the story unfolded.
The plot was intriguing and filled with mystery.
I listed to the audiobook which was very entertaining and pinned the characters’ voices very well.
I love Thad and little Jack and it was great to see Thad’s parents were the main characters from Ring of Secrets. Thad was a great dashing hero. Gwyneth’s was a strong heroine who found her inner strength more and more as the story unfolded.
The plot was intriguing and filled with mystery.
I listed to the audiobook which was very entertaining and pinned the characters’ voices very well.
June 13, 2023
4.5 stars
I am so relieved because I was sure my worst fear would be realized and it didn’t!!!
The beginning was sad. I was looking forward to a continuation of 1.5 but okay. And the whole book had a lot of loss. Wow. This led to some great discussions of fear and trust amidst loss. It really touched me.
The drawing talent of Gwyn’s is really cool and I liked how Roseanna showcased spiritual warfare.
There is a crazy surprise plot twist and a fabulous ending!! I really liked this book.
I am so relieved because I was sure my worst fear would be realized and it didn’t!!!
The beginning was sad. I was looking forward to a continuation of 1.5 but okay. And the whole book had a lot of loss. Wow. This led to some great discussions of fear and trust amidst loss. It really touched me.
The drawing talent of Gwyn’s is really cool and I liked how Roseanna showcased spiritual warfare.
There is a crazy surprise plot twist and a fabulous ending!! I really liked this book.
August 5, 2020
Another great Culper Ring Series Book. Historical fiction at its best!
July 21, 2013
I LOVED THIS BOOK!!
Do I have your attention now? Yes? Good!
Roseanna White takes the reader back to 1814, to the war of 1812, where we meet again with the main characters from the first book in this series Ring of Secrets—Winter and Bennet Lane. Their son Thaddeus Lane is our hero and he also is Mr. Culper now.
Our heroine is the daughter of the British General Fairchild—we met him in the first book as Colonel Fairchild. Gwyneth Fairchild is being sent away by her father to America. He believes their lives are in danger and he wants Gwyn to leave immediately. He sends her to his American friends—the Lanes. Just before she enters the carriage to leave, her British suitor – Sir Arthur Hart – asks for her hand in marriage. Excitedly Gwyn runs back to the house to talk to her father. But instead of talking to him she is a witness to his murder. Panicked, she runs back to the waiting carriage and leaves England and Sir Arthur behind.
After a long and horrendous sea journey, Gwyn finally arrives in America. She has been sick and has had terrible nightmares. She did not tell anyone that she saw her father being murdered. Fear that the killer might follow her to America, has kept her awake and made her sick. Her servants thought she was seasick, but she cannot tell anyone what is really plaguing her.
When she finally meets Thad – the only person she knows she can trust because her father trusted him – she falls asleep in his arms.
Captain Thaddeus Lane – or Thad – has received a letter from General Fairchild, but the content doesn’t make any sense. He assumes there must be a hidden message in it, but he can’t figure it out. Not even his parents can break the code—if there is one.
When Gwyn arrives at his doorstep, he doesn’t know what to do with her. Can he trust her? She is British after all…and America is at war with England.
Back in England Sir Arthur and Gwyn’s uncle are looking for Gwyn, but they don’t know where she went. When Arthur finds a letter from the Lanes in General Fairchild’s study, her uncle believes that is where the general has sent her. Together they follow Gwyn to America—Arthur in hopes to claim her as his bride and Uncle with another purpose.
Gwyn’s trust for Thad – because her father trusted him – runs deep. She will have to learn to put her trust in Someone else to find peace and healing from the monsters in her nightmares.
Thad is a widower, but doesn’t talk much about his deceased wife. For some reason it is a sensitive subject. While he starts to care more and more for Gwyn – and his feelings are returned – he neglects to tell her why it is such a sensitive topic. When his best friend, Alain, spills it all out during a fight, Gwyn is shocked to learn what happened and runs away to hide in her bedroom. Before he has a chance to talk to Gwyn, Thad is called away on a dangerous sea journey to spy on the British fleet approaching America.
Can an American Captain and the daughter of a British General find love?
Will Gwyn understand that he had to leave before they could talk it all out? Will she forgive him?
And what about Sir Arthur? Will he find Gwyn to claim her for his own?
Will her father’s killer find Gwyn?
And General Fairchild’s letter…will they ever break the code and learn what secret message is hidden inside it?
There’s a lot of suspense and intrigue in this fabulous book. Murder, spies, secrets, war, love, grief, forgiveness, faith... There’s so much to enjoy in this story. The characters and plot were very well developed and the writing is clear and exciting. I’m already looking forward to the next book in this series. Fantastic job, Roseanna!
*Thanks to the publisher for providing me with a review copy through NetGalley.*
Do I have your attention now? Yes? Good!
Roseanna White takes the reader back to 1814, to the war of 1812, where we meet again with the main characters from the first book in this series Ring of Secrets—Winter and Bennet Lane. Their son Thaddeus Lane is our hero and he also is Mr. Culper now.
Our heroine is the daughter of the British General Fairchild—we met him in the first book as Colonel Fairchild. Gwyneth Fairchild is being sent away by her father to America. He believes their lives are in danger and he wants Gwyn to leave immediately. He sends her to his American friends—the Lanes. Just before she enters the carriage to leave, her British suitor – Sir Arthur Hart – asks for her hand in marriage. Excitedly Gwyn runs back to the house to talk to her father. But instead of talking to him she is a witness to his murder. Panicked, she runs back to the waiting carriage and leaves England and Sir Arthur behind.
After a long and horrendous sea journey, Gwyn finally arrives in America. She has been sick and has had terrible nightmares. She did not tell anyone that she saw her father being murdered. Fear that the killer might follow her to America, has kept her awake and made her sick. Her servants thought she was seasick, but she cannot tell anyone what is really plaguing her.
When she finally meets Thad – the only person she knows she can trust because her father trusted him – she falls asleep in his arms.
Captain Thaddeus Lane – or Thad – has received a letter from General Fairchild, but the content doesn’t make any sense. He assumes there must be a hidden message in it, but he can’t figure it out. Not even his parents can break the code—if there is one.
When Gwyn arrives at his doorstep, he doesn’t know what to do with her. Can he trust her? She is British after all…and America is at war with England.
Back in England Sir Arthur and Gwyn’s uncle are looking for Gwyn, but they don’t know where she went. When Arthur finds a letter from the Lanes in General Fairchild’s study, her uncle believes that is where the general has sent her. Together they follow Gwyn to America—Arthur in hopes to claim her as his bride and Uncle with another purpose.
Gwyn’s trust for Thad – because her father trusted him – runs deep. She will have to learn to put her trust in Someone else to find peace and healing from the monsters in her nightmares.
Thad is a widower, but doesn’t talk much about his deceased wife. For some reason it is a sensitive subject. While he starts to care more and more for Gwyn – and his feelings are returned – he neglects to tell her why it is such a sensitive topic. When his best friend, Alain, spills it all out during a fight, Gwyn is shocked to learn what happened and runs away to hide in her bedroom. Before he has a chance to talk to Gwyn, Thad is called away on a dangerous sea journey to spy on the British fleet approaching America.
Can an American Captain and the daughter of a British General find love?
Will Gwyn understand that he had to leave before they could talk it all out? Will she forgive him?
And what about Sir Arthur? Will he find Gwyn to claim her for his own?
Will her father’s killer find Gwyn?
And General Fairchild’s letter…will they ever break the code and learn what secret message is hidden inside it?
There’s a lot of suspense and intrigue in this fabulous book. Murder, spies, secrets, war, love, grief, forgiveness, faith... There’s so much to enjoy in this story. The characters and plot were very well developed and the writing is clear and exciting. I’m already looking forward to the next book in this series. Fantastic job, Roseanna!
*Thanks to the publisher for providing me with a review copy through NetGalley.*
August 7, 2013
Whispers from the Shadows by Roseanna White was a book that started off little slow, but picked up to a good pace. The story was interesting and on a subject I didn't know anything about, The Culper Ring. The Culper Ring was the first spy organization in the US, that was around during the Revolutionary War. (I will be researching more about this now.)
This story follows Gwyneth Fairchild, the daughter of a distinguished British General. She has no idea why, but her father is sending her away. His rushing of it has her questioning a lot of things and she feels lost. Trying one last time to plead for more time, Gwyn watches as her uncle kills her father from the library door. Gwyn flees as fast as she can without a backwards glance with her two elderly servants, who had been holding the carriage for departure. In shock over what has happened, Gwyn retreats inside of herself and confides in no one. Fear and sadness lead her to insomnia through her several week trek across the ocean to America.There doesn't seem to be any more light in Gwyneth Fairchild's life, until an encounter on the sea leads her to Thadeus Lane.
Thadeus Lane is a guy who knows everyone. He makes it his job to know everyone in his city and at times it seems his country, which is important since he and his family are in The Culper Ring. He cares very much for his family and with war looming, to see that they are safe, he asks them to stay at his house in Baltimore, Maryland. It isn't long after his parents arrival, when a new house guest arrive, Gwyneth Fairchild. The Fairchild's and the Lane's have been family friends since the Revolutionary War. Unlike most people of the time, Gwyneth's father and Thad's parents had struck a friendship during the hostile times. And because of this, Gwyn's father believed her safest there. During their time together, Gwyn and Thad try to figure out the last bit of information Gwyn's father sent with her.
Whispers from the Shadows was an interesting story. The plot revolved more around Gwyn and her struggles to over come the fear she had growing in her, than The Culper Ring. I would have loved to see more into the secret society that was formed through close friends and family. The ways of communication during that time was fun to see. Technology has come a long way.
There was one small thing that I found didn't fit that well into the story. In a contemporary story, I could see it easy, but for a book set in 1814, it was a bit off for me. The speed at which Thad started calling Gwen "Sweet". This was a time of propitiatory and having a term of endearment like that when not courting or engaged seemed a little off. Other than that small bit, it was a good story.
Thank you to Harvest House Publishers, I received a copy of the book for free in exchange for an honest review.
This story follows Gwyneth Fairchild, the daughter of a distinguished British General. She has no idea why, but her father is sending her away. His rushing of it has her questioning a lot of things and she feels lost. Trying one last time to plead for more time, Gwyn watches as her uncle kills her father from the library door. Gwyn flees as fast as she can without a backwards glance with her two elderly servants, who had been holding the carriage for departure. In shock over what has happened, Gwyn retreats inside of herself and confides in no one. Fear and sadness lead her to insomnia through her several week trek across the ocean to America.There doesn't seem to be any more light in Gwyneth Fairchild's life, until an encounter on the sea leads her to Thadeus Lane.
Thadeus Lane is a guy who knows everyone. He makes it his job to know everyone in his city and at times it seems his country, which is important since he and his family are in The Culper Ring. He cares very much for his family and with war looming, to see that they are safe, he asks them to stay at his house in Baltimore, Maryland. It isn't long after his parents arrival, when a new house guest arrive, Gwyneth Fairchild. The Fairchild's and the Lane's have been family friends since the Revolutionary War. Unlike most people of the time, Gwyneth's father and Thad's parents had struck a friendship during the hostile times. And because of this, Gwyn's father believed her safest there. During their time together, Gwyn and Thad try to figure out the last bit of information Gwyn's father sent with her.
Whispers from the Shadows was an interesting story. The plot revolved more around Gwyn and her struggles to over come the fear she had growing in her, than The Culper Ring. I would have loved to see more into the secret society that was formed through close friends and family. The ways of communication during that time was fun to see. Technology has come a long way.
There was one small thing that I found didn't fit that well into the story. In a contemporary story, I could see it easy, but for a book set in 1814, it was a bit off for me. The speed at which Thad started calling Gwen "Sweet". This was a time of propitiatory and having a term of endearment like that when not courting or engaged seemed a little off. Other than that small bit, it was a good story.
Thank you to Harvest House Publishers, I received a copy of the book for free in exchange for an honest review.
November 10, 2013
I was unprepared to be blown away--swept away into a time and place apart from my normal historical romance escape. I confess, the characters, setting, plot, and writing as superb as they were, came secondary to the powerful theme and message. Faith overcoming fear. Trust trouncing suspicion. Mercy triumphing over judgment. And the all-staying hand of a sovereign Lord who does indeed take human affairs into His loving hand.
Gwyneth Fairchild witnesses the unthinkable, and must flee her home in London--straight into the arms of her political enemy. The War of 1812 has been raging, and treachery abounds in her circles with a father who serves as one of Britain's leading generals. Alone and filled with terrors that only come out in her paint and canvas, she must adapt to a new life with strangers, in America where her father has sent her. Can she trust her father's wisdom? Can she trust her new guardians, the Lanes, whose clandestine activities would make her and her family suspect them under ideal situations?
Thad Lane, a merchant and so much more than meets the eye, has sworn to protect his Baltimore and his America from British threats. When he receives this special care package from London in the form of the beguilingly beautiful Miss Fairchild, his mission takes on new dimensions. Can he reconcile his involvement with his parents' espionage ring while remaining true to his heart and to the leading of the spirit within? As his feelings for the lovely and mysterious young lady deepen, can he trust himself?
A page turning journey kept me in its grips these past weeks as Gwyn, Thad, and a host of fascinating characters reveal secrets, unfold the will of God, and yield surprises as told by only a master craftsman in plotting and pacing. This is my first Roseanna White novel, and though it was the second in the Culper Ring series, it read seamlessly. I am eager to go back and read the first, detailing the elder Lanes' romance and intrigue during the American Revolution. And I eagerly await the next story, set in the American Civil War amid the Knights of the Golden Circle.
This book's depiction of the historically accurate events surrounding the British invasion of Washington and attack on Baltimore showed in a beautiful way how the miraculous hand of the Divine preserved our young nation. At every level, powers unseen vie for the upper hand--at the national, local, and deeply personal . . . Comparable to the groundbreaking work of Frank Peretti for showing spiritual warfare in authentic ways, this book plays between the seen and unseen world with fine brushstrokes and vivid sensory depiction. A must read for lovers of history, spiritual truths, mystery, and romance.
Gwyneth Fairchild witnesses the unthinkable, and must flee her home in London--straight into the arms of her political enemy. The War of 1812 has been raging, and treachery abounds in her circles with a father who serves as one of Britain's leading generals. Alone and filled with terrors that only come out in her paint and canvas, she must adapt to a new life with strangers, in America where her father has sent her. Can she trust her father's wisdom? Can she trust her new guardians, the Lanes, whose clandestine activities would make her and her family suspect them under ideal situations?
Thad Lane, a merchant and so much more than meets the eye, has sworn to protect his Baltimore and his America from British threats. When he receives this special care package from London in the form of the beguilingly beautiful Miss Fairchild, his mission takes on new dimensions. Can he reconcile his involvement with his parents' espionage ring while remaining true to his heart and to the leading of the spirit within? As his feelings for the lovely and mysterious young lady deepen, can he trust himself?
A page turning journey kept me in its grips these past weeks as Gwyn, Thad, and a host of fascinating characters reveal secrets, unfold the will of God, and yield surprises as told by only a master craftsman in plotting and pacing. This is my first Roseanna White novel, and though it was the second in the Culper Ring series, it read seamlessly. I am eager to go back and read the first, detailing the elder Lanes' romance and intrigue during the American Revolution. And I eagerly await the next story, set in the American Civil War amid the Knights of the Golden Circle.
This book's depiction of the historically accurate events surrounding the British invasion of Washington and attack on Baltimore showed in a beautiful way how the miraculous hand of the Divine preserved our young nation. At every level, powers unseen vie for the upper hand--at the national, local, and deeply personal . . . Comparable to the groundbreaking work of Frank Peretti for showing spiritual warfare in authentic ways, this book plays between the seen and unseen world with fine brushstrokes and vivid sensory depiction. A must read for lovers of history, spiritual truths, mystery, and romance.
June 18, 2017
I like Roseanna White's storytelling. It's engaging and clean. I enjoyed the Ladies of the Manor series quite a bit. However, I think that writing a historical (spy) romance must be really hard. All aspects of the story must create a seamless, balanced story, without one aspect falling through the cracks. Because then it would just be a historical romance. Or a spy romance. Neither of which I was expecting.
Along those lines of thinking, I might have just pinpointed the problem I've had with the novels of this series. The espionage aspect was very realistic (i.e. slow and quiet) and the romance was too understated. The historical setting and details were strong, but they also made for a little bit of a dull book. I don't mind reading history books. Really, I don't. But if I pick up a book marketed as historical romance, I'm expecting it to be more than just the author's interpretation of events that have already occurred with a few fictional characters added to the mix.
So that brings me to the romance and the MCs. The h spent most of this book fainting, feeling unwell, exhausted, and basically depending on others (namely the H) to feel protected and safe. And while I understand what the author was doing, crafting a character who relied on others in the beginning of the story but then more wisely started relying on God, the transformation was boring to read. And honestly, I wasn't judging, but her weakness lasted way longer than my patience did. Thank goodness I'm not God. :)
I also didn't understand the romance between the MCs as in why they cared for each other. The author could have had the MCs struggle in trusting each other, given their loyalties to their respective mother countries, but the author didn't commit to that route. There was little physical attraction, but instead a weird, fatalistic "we're meant for each other" spiritual connection. Now, I'm not discounting that at all. I believe in the Holy Spirit and God speaking to our spirits. It does seem like a flimsy premise for a relationship, though, when the only other thing the MCs have in common was propinquity. And all the drama with the H and his friend rubbed me the wrong way. I understand the circumstances and that they were realistic given this time period, but they made me uncomfortable nonetheless.
Overall, this was a readable historical romance, but I didn't enjoy the story too much.
Along those lines of thinking, I might have just pinpointed the problem I've had with the novels of this series. The espionage aspect was very realistic (i.e. slow and quiet) and the romance was too understated. The historical setting and details were strong, but they also made for a little bit of a dull book. I don't mind reading history books. Really, I don't. But if I pick up a book marketed as historical romance, I'm expecting it to be more than just the author's interpretation of events that have already occurred with a few fictional characters added to the mix.
So that brings me to the romance and the MCs. The h spent most of this book fainting, feeling unwell, exhausted, and basically depending on others (namely the H) to feel protected and safe. And while I understand what the author was doing, crafting a character who relied on others in the beginning of the story but then more wisely started relying on God, the transformation was boring to read. And honestly, I wasn't judging, but her weakness lasted way longer than my patience did. Thank goodness I'm not God. :)
I also didn't understand the romance between the MCs as in why they cared for each other. The author could have had the MCs struggle in trusting each other, given their loyalties to their respective mother countries, but the author didn't commit to that route. There was little physical attraction, but instead a weird, fatalistic "we're meant for each other" spiritual connection. Now, I'm not discounting that at all. I believe in the Holy Spirit and God speaking to our spirits. It does seem like a flimsy premise for a relationship, though, when the only other thing the MCs have in common was propinquity. And all the drama with the H and his friend rubbed me the wrong way. I understand the circumstances and that they were realistic given this time period, but they made me uncomfortable nonetheless.
Overall, this was a readable historical romance, but I didn't enjoy the story too much.
March 28, 2023
Just as the War of 1812 was fought differently from the American Revolution - more by sea than by land - so the methods of spying differed. Most intelligence was gathered by American privateers; there was little worry about it falling into wrong hands, and so the old invisible inks were out of style. As an official Culper, Thad works as a privateer and spends hours gathering information in public houses, though we do not get to see much of the actual spying since so much time was taken up with Gwyn. Because of his personable nature and reliance on the Holy Spirit, Thad is well liked by all and able to give them what they need at the moment. However, in his desire to be that help for Gwyn, he oversteps the leading of the Spirit. How easy is it to be doing what God wants us to do, but then we rush ahead of His plan? Like for Thad, it can pretty easily land us in hot water.
Gwyn has never had to question her safety before, growing up with a general for her father in upper class England where she never knew want, she never had to worry about who to rely on. However, when her father is killed, she no longer has that reliable safety net; she turns to Thad for her security, but as a man, he makes mistakes and cannot be there always for her. After battling the hallucinations and whispers she hears in her state of insomnia, she finally realizes who should be her security and rest - the Lord. Where does your strength and rest lie? In yourself, in your spouse? Or do you you place your trust in God, the Alpha and Omega, Beginning and the End, who is, was, and is to come, the Almighty? Man is fallible and will disappoint, but God is a rock that cannot be moved.
I admit to knowing little about insomnia, but Gwyn's ability to sleep in the Lane house seems a bit far-fetched, though it is rather romantic. On the other hand, Thad's "intuition," or rather, listening to the Spirit, is documented thoroughly throughout the bible and still exists today for those who listen - that little nudge that sends one in a direction one would not normally take, or to talk to someone to whom one has never spoken. Good reminder to listen to the Spirit!
While I liked the more active intrigue of "Ring of Secrets" better, "Whispers from the Shadows" is still an excellent novel - romantic, suspenseful, and a strong message of keeping faith in God. 5 out of 5 stars
Gwyn has never had to question her safety before, growing up with a general for her father in upper class England where she never knew want, she never had to worry about who to rely on. However, when her father is killed, she no longer has that reliable safety net; she turns to Thad for her security, but as a man, he makes mistakes and cannot be there always for her. After battling the hallucinations and whispers she hears in her state of insomnia, she finally realizes who should be her security and rest - the Lord. Where does your strength and rest lie? In yourself, in your spouse? Or do you you place your trust in God, the Alpha and Omega, Beginning and the End, who is, was, and is to come, the Almighty? Man is fallible and will disappoint, but God is a rock that cannot be moved.
I admit to knowing little about insomnia, but Gwyn's ability to sleep in the Lane house seems a bit far-fetched, though it is rather romantic. On the other hand, Thad's "intuition," or rather, listening to the Spirit, is documented thoroughly throughout the bible and still exists today for those who listen - that little nudge that sends one in a direction one would not normally take, or to talk to someone to whom one has never spoken. Good reminder to listen to the Spirit!
While I liked the more active intrigue of "Ring of Secrets" better, "Whispers from the Shadows" is still an excellent novel - romantic, suspenseful, and a strong message of keeping faith in God. 5 out of 5 stars
September 30, 2013
This exciting and adventurous romantic spy novel is the second book in a new series from Roseanna M. White. Whispers from the Shadows combines fascinating cloak-and-dagger secrets with a tale of love and intrigue during the War of 1812.
Treachery causes Gwyneth Fairchild's world to crumble. The daughter of a British general, she barely saves her life by fleeing London aboard a ship to America. Her goal is to find refuge with the Lane family in Maryland, having been told by her father she could implicitly trust Winter and Bennet Lane, even though their nations are once again at war. After meeting their son, Thad, she wonders how safe she truly is when she discovers that the Lanes trade in a dangerous commodity--espionage.
Not long after Gwyneth finds refuge in his city, Thad Lane experiences the tug of love, though he fears it may blur lines of loyalty. With family playing the part of enemies and enemies proving themselves friends, a future with Gwyneth is uncertain. But at this moment, with the British advancing on Washington and Baltimore, they have only their shared faith in God as a shield about them.
My Review:
Gwyneth and Thad were simply amazing characters. I know I've said I loathe perfect romances, but while their romance was beautiful, sweet, and tender, it very believable. I am a huge history lover, so the backdrop of a war won me over from the opening chapter. The settings and places were described by White in intricate detail, and I didn't get bored with any characters and their complex emotions and problems. Their faith was important and well portrayed, not at all overdone or dramatically flaunted.
While the romance was wonderful, my favorite element of this novel lay with the codes and encrypted letters. The aspect of espionage really just set the perfect backdrop, and I enjoyed the element of danger and vulnerability of such perilous endeavors. The historical accuracy was wonderful (I admit, reading this book got me researching!) and taught me a lot about the time period and what life could have been like. A recommended read to anybody who likes a combination of good spy novel and plenty of romantic suspense.
This book was provided by the publisher for free in exchange for an honest review.
Treachery causes Gwyneth Fairchild's world to crumble. The daughter of a British general, she barely saves her life by fleeing London aboard a ship to America. Her goal is to find refuge with the Lane family in Maryland, having been told by her father she could implicitly trust Winter and Bennet Lane, even though their nations are once again at war. After meeting their son, Thad, she wonders how safe she truly is when she discovers that the Lanes trade in a dangerous commodity--espionage.
Not long after Gwyneth finds refuge in his city, Thad Lane experiences the tug of love, though he fears it may blur lines of loyalty. With family playing the part of enemies and enemies proving themselves friends, a future with Gwyneth is uncertain. But at this moment, with the British advancing on Washington and Baltimore, they have only their shared faith in God as a shield about them.
My Review:
Gwyneth and Thad were simply amazing characters. I know I've said I loathe perfect romances, but while their romance was beautiful, sweet, and tender, it very believable. I am a huge history lover, so the backdrop of a war won me over from the opening chapter. The settings and places were described by White in intricate detail, and I didn't get bored with any characters and their complex emotions and problems. Their faith was important and well portrayed, not at all overdone or dramatically flaunted.
While the romance was wonderful, my favorite element of this novel lay with the codes and encrypted letters. The aspect of espionage really just set the perfect backdrop, and I enjoyed the element of danger and vulnerability of such perilous endeavors. The historical accuracy was wonderful (I admit, reading this book got me researching!) and taught me a lot about the time period and what life could have been like. A recommended read to anybody who likes a combination of good spy novel and plenty of romantic suspense.
This book was provided by the publisher for free in exchange for an honest review.
December 1, 2016
Mrs. White's books always makes me a little uncertain of how to review them. :) As an author, she is one that I greatly admire! I love her writing style, her interesting plots, her deep faith. Her way with words is just amazing, and almost every page of the story interests me like almost no other author's. But she's a little more on the romance side that I personally prefer. How does one say that they loved a book *except* for the romance, which is kind of the heartbeat of this novel?
So, when it comes to writing style and storyline, I heartily give a 5+ star!! There was a great, solid message on searching your heart for where your trust lies: In a person or in God?
When it comes to romance, my personal rating for the content is 3 stars. There was a lot of physical affection mentioned -- whether longing for it or kissing, etc. I would give a spoiler if I detailed the main thing I didn't like, but there was a past marriage mentioned that was horrifying (no, it wasn't anything obscene -- just, disconcerting). At the same time, this very thing helped one of the characters to learn a valuable lesson that he couldn't fix everything and instead had to trust in God.
All things considered, I'd definitely say 18+ for the conservative reader.
Quote:
"Suffer she did, but not for Him. Not for His glory, but for her own misery, and that, it seemed, was a crucial difference. Because the grief that consumed her, while understandable, had kept her fixated on herself, not on Him. She had not been like Papa, who turned ever more to the Lord in the face of mourning. She had been like...a child."
So, when it comes to writing style and storyline, I heartily give a 5+ star!! There was a great, solid message on searching your heart for where your trust lies: In a person or in God?
When it comes to romance, my personal rating for the content is 3 stars. There was a lot of physical affection mentioned -- whether longing for it or kissing, etc. I would give a spoiler if I detailed the main thing I didn't like, but there was a past marriage mentioned that was horrifying (no, it wasn't anything obscene -- just, disconcerting). At the same time, this very thing helped one of the characters to learn a valuable lesson that he couldn't fix everything and instead had to trust in God.
All things considered, I'd definitely say 18+ for the conservative reader.
Quote:
"Suffer she did, but not for Him. Not for His glory, but for her own misery, and that, it seemed, was a crucial difference. Because the grief that consumed her, while understandable, had kept her fixated on herself, not on Him. She had not been like Papa, who turned ever more to the Lord in the face of mourning. She had been like...a child."
Displaying 1 - 30 of 152 reviews