Shadow Dance book is clearly a 10.
For me, it has all it needs for a book to be a good one: characters and situations that make you feel something.
Now, getting a little bit on depth (and forgive my expressions as English is my third language).
At numerous points I wanted to grab Saga from the shoulders and shake her empty head off 😂. That's not a bad thing. As I said, it made me feel that way for all the book, in a cohesive way. I just found that some of her reasoning was doubtful, but that's her way of being so it's fine.
Garren it's the golden retriever archetype. He can be charming and playful, but will indeed bark and bite to protect what his heart loves.
Kailunn is sassy and mysterious. You never know his truly intentions.
Sandro... in my opinion is a bit flat. He's charming and all, but I didn't feel that connection as with the other characters, maybe because he was introduced late on the book, or maybe because the lack of a stronger personality.
Cinaéd is the big forgotten character. Cinaéd appears really early on the book, giving dangerous vibes, placing himself as a kind-of-villan (as Garren is his enemy), then he threatens Saga... but then his plot merges on a more secondary layer. I WANT MORE OF THEM. How he met his partner? What is Cinaéd past/lore? I feel that there's a lot of game still for this character!
Lysander, on the other hand, it's the BBEG, of course. The book keeps spinning around his figure, showing more and more of this enigmatic character. On each encounter, we learn something more about his power, and that kind of cool.
Now, about all that happens on the book.
It can be easily split in two books: one that covers the part on which they are on Whitekeep, and the second one that covers the latter part -in fact, the second could start with Sandro's appearance.
The first part is beautiful. It's just day-to-day things, we see Saga develop her character, learn, fail, and all this. I really like the parts on which we see that Saga is human, that she does not know everything, that she can fail, she's not the typical teenager that dominates every skill one one week.
As a WoW player, I saw Stormwind all around (despite I'm 100000% Horde Lok'tar Ogar), so maybe that also played on favour, but I think it's a clever move to use this nostalgia, ngl.
On this part there was one thing I find a bit "too much coincidence" (it's just my opinion), and that's the fact that magic transmits better with kisses.
Now we reach the turning point.
They left the city to wander the forest.
Sandro is presented to the reader.
Here I want to add that Sandro's introduction felt a bit abrupt, in the sense that the king is describing him on the first page of the chapter, like if he saw him for the first time. I think that CK here had the chance to play around a bit: as the king knew Sandro -for at least centuries-, the chapter could skip most of the descriptions, giving only a few hints (for example, curled hair, third eye). Then, once Sandro meets Saga, she slowly discover his features, and that discovery is more than enough to let us make a full impression of him.
Again, that's just my opinion, I'm not saying that is a bad thing.
After the turning point, we see Saga, Garren, Cinaéd, Xerxi and the rest of the party suffer. We can see how Saga trains with her sword, how she made some firends, and how most of the party seems to look her weird. Again, more character development; good development indeed.
We can see how Saga tries to clear her head, now it seems more full and I wanted less to shake her. She seems more thoughtful, realising she's not probably on a videogame but rather on another reality. She tries to forget her previous knowledge of Kailunn, and she bonds even stronger with Garren.
The part that happens on Kailunn castle is awesome. How the mother plot twist unravels is really good.
At this point, I felt that the "wander on the forest" part was a bit fast (in a sense that from one chapter to another several days passed), and then the three last chapters begin.
Although the ending is brutal and left me on a cliffhanger, I felt a bit off-guard by the sudden rise of power of Saga. I'm sure there's an explanation on the second book, but at that moment I felt that I skipped one or two chapters (I'm really picky with this topics, but I understand that there will be a valid explanation later). I would love to maybe have an epiloge with what happened on that time, why she was able to control all that power at once as if nothing.
Overall, it's a very good book.
Totally recomendable.
(The time spent on reading was because of external issues!)