I was one of many that eagerly anticipated this sequel and I was not disappointed. After reading a few reviews, I wanted to add one as well, because I got something different from The Art of Endings. Quite often, I end up wanting a sequel so bad that once I read it, I am highly disappointed because it did not live up to the high from the first read. When I started reading The Art of Endings, I didn't know what to expect. A few pages in, I realized that this was not a Trey and Shayla story, it was about Trey coming to terms with monogamy along with his love for Shayla and Trey's best friend Darren discovering he has a heart and it belongs to someone from his past.
"Secret" had a few loose ends that left me biting my nails anticipating what would happen next. For one, I made it quite clear that I did not want Trey to end up fathering that woman's baby. I mean, I made that abundantly clear. So I bought The Art of Endings just to find out if he was the father or not. I also wanted to see more of Shayla's freedom journey, as she was finally rid of her "secret" - a rape that traumatized her well into her relationship with Trey. Yet once I got into The Art of Endings, there were new focal points to explore and I enjoyed not staying stuck in the past (although there were a few story lines that reflected past actions, but they were all new to the reader).
Reading a few reviews, I can understand why a few readers felt the Secret story lines were lacking. Then I remember why I like Nia Forrester's novels. She writes about reality, not drama. When Trey approached the baby dilemma in "Secret," Shayla responded as a woman that was crushed but also knew that this child was conceived before she met Trey. There was no need for drive by cuss outs or constant reminders for the remaining trimesters. Shayla, being who Shayla is, was also a runner and not a confronter. Shayla handled the baby ordeal in a way that suited her and I got that. So did Trey. In fact, Trey impressed me with the handling of the whole situation in comparison to how he dealt with it in Secret.
Shayla was also a supporting role in this novel. Perhaps that is why many readers are a little put off because she took a back seat in this one. I wish there was a little more of Shayla, but quite frankly, I think her character was where she needed to be. Well not necessarily, because she did not need to be with the professor either... We forget that Shayla was released from the woman she used to be when she finally told Trey what Justin had done. That was her moment to truly heal, but like some assault victims, they will always have their moments where the past haunts them. Shayla demonstrated it on occasion, but she was no longer the same girl that moved into Trey and Tessa's basement. She was free of Justin, so that story was not what defined her any more. Her close encounters were another thing. I don't think Shayla would seek out Justin and if Justin had the guts to go to her, then I would imagine Shayla would have handled it the best way she could. I held my breath once it was said they would be in close proximity of each other because I wanted Shayla to keep moving forward and I think that the hardest part of her past was closed in Secret, with the help of Trey. There was no need to reopen it back up, but Nia Forrester demonstrated the reality that the scars will always be there.
Trey was also maturing and we watched him go from selfish, charming player to a man that loves a woman. That's a big step for anyone that does not do relationships and what we witnessed with Trey reflected his growth. I loved his struggle as a possible father, as a mate, as a friend, professionally and even as a brother. Trey grew up in The Art of Endings, so who Trey was in Secret is no more.
Part of that growth rubbed off on Darren, a minor character in Secret that had a big role in The Art of Endings. Trey was not pleased by some of Darren's behavior and Darren recognized that. Their shift was subtle, but again, another thing that made me see The Art of Endings as its own separate novel and not a duplicate of Secret. Darren walked into the novel as a class-A jerk, but Nia Forrester took us through Darren's thought process and experiences, helping us to see him differently by the end. Just as I was about to yell to Paige, "Girl, he doesn't deserve you!" Nia turned it around and I ended up wanting them together.
The stages of Paige and Darren's relationship was hard to read and it did make me look at Paige skeptically for a while. I mean what woman puts up with a grown man's blatant disrespect like she did. Then as I recognized Darren's struggle, I became cognizant of Paige's awareness of it as well. And it became another reminder of that Nia Forrester realism many of us love and don't even realize it.
And Tessa. She was in the background, too. Trey needed her to help him be the man we saw at the end. A man that was finally free of his own secrets and a man that was finally ready to love.
I would have given it a full five stars, but I was a little upset with a few scenes. Paige was drawn to Darren in ways many of us are drawn to things we know can't be good for us, but we want it anyway. It hurt to see her constantly playing with fire and subsequently getting burned. I did not care for Shayla's relationship with the professor, nor did I like the direction Trey and his coworker went in. They all made sense and worked for the story, but they made me upset with the character's actions.
When it all came to an end and the paternity was revealed, I felt closure with these characters. I will miss them, but I am content with where Nia Forrester took us.