What do you think?
Rate this book
Daredevil: Redemption #1-6
Devil : Redenzione
Redemption Valley, Alabama. Un omicidio rituale. Una comunità sconvolta e atterrita. Uno dei sospettati ha confessato il delitto. Il caso è chiuso e non resta che il tribunale pronunci una condanna alla pena capitale. Ma un famoso avvocato è giunto dalla Grande Mela, e l'eroe mascherato conosciuto col nome di Devil sta indagando.
Una storia completa ispirata a un vero fatto di cronaca scritta da David Hine e disegnata da Michael Gaydos.
Una storia completa ispirata a un vero fatto di cronaca scritta da David Hine e disegnata da Michael Gaydos.
160 pages, Paperback
First published November 2, 2005
5 people are currently reading
212 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 79 reviews
March 28, 2017
In 1995, due to the constant harassment and hostility thrown her and her family's way from their outraged community, a desperate mother named Emily Flood flew all the way from Alabama to New York to personally plead to highly acclaimed lawyer Matt Murdock to defend her son, local misfit Joel Flood, who's been accused (along with his girlfriend Adrienne Bowen and her brother Saul Bowen) of brutally murdering nine-year-old Bradley Gideon. Foggy insists to Matt to not accept the case. Every parent thinks their child could never be a monster. The reputation of Nelson & Murdock will be sullied if they defend a supposed Satanist accused of child murder. And, even if Joel Flood is innocent, they are plenty of innocent people in New York who need help. But Matt won't be swayed. Emily Flood's heartbeat was steady when she assured them her boy would never do such a thing. And, unlike New York, Alabama has the death penalty.
So he sets off to the south, with Daredevil costume (foolishly) in tow, away from the graffiti covered alleys and urban sprawl of Hell's Kitchen to the humid, backwoods country of the small, insulated, God-fearing town of Redemption Valley, Alabama for what ends up being the most important case of his career.
Inspired by the West Memphis Three, this six-issue self-contained miniseries by David Hine and Michael Gaydos (colored by Lee Loughridge and lettered by Cory Petit, with some of the most striking covers I've ever seen from Bill Sienkiewicz) encapsulates the sharp dichotomy between Matt Murdock's life as a lawyer and his life as a vigilante and just how he's able to reconcile his two diametrically opposite selves with himself. Hine and Gaydos accomplish this by thrusting Matt Murdock into a all too real environment of evangelical hypocritical hate and self-righteousness, proud backwater ignorance and small-mindedness, physical, emotional, and sexual abuse, and small town corruption to confront one of the largest injustices of our heavily flawed criminal court system.
Their Southern Gothic tale of crime and prejudice can come across a bit too melodramatic at times with the number of common, mundane ills and evils Matt encounters during his stay in Redemption Valley, but then I would remind myself of, say, the number of articles about corrupt law enforcement that pop up on my news feed, or the fact that something as innocent as Harry Potter was considered Satanic and even burned in some extremely Christian and conservative places during the late 90s-early 2000s, for two examples. As unbeatable as supervillains and organized crime can be in the world of superheroes, the nastiness inside an ordinary person, the ignorance of a close-minded upbringing, and the judgement of a small community will always be the more insurmountable challenge, as many people's online horror stories of growing up somewhere similar to Redemption Valley can attest.
4 1/2 stars
July 8, 2019
Daredevil really does have the best stories. This is easily one of my new favorite Daredevil stories.
So a little kid is brutally murdered in a backwoods area called Redemption. They blame all of it on a young kid, saying he's been evil since birth, and want him to get the death penalty. So Matt Murdock comes from NYC to this country side area and soon learns this religious ruled area is really fucked up. As Matt plays both enforcer with the daredevil suit, and lawyer during the day, can he save this man from getting convicted?
What works is the atmosphere and dialogue here. Finally we have a story of Matt being in court most of the time. On top of that the mystery of who's a killer and who isn't is great. The feeling of dread is perfect for this type of story and Matt's hopeless battle is hard to watch. The ending is a gut punch and made me so mad but that's the point of a great sad tale.
This is a must read for Matt Murdock fans. A 5 out of 5.
So a little kid is brutally murdered in a backwoods area called Redemption. They blame all of it on a young kid, saying he's been evil since birth, and want him to get the death penalty. So Matt Murdock comes from NYC to this country side area and soon learns this religious ruled area is really fucked up. As Matt plays both enforcer with the daredevil suit, and lawyer during the day, can he save this man from getting convicted?
What works is the atmosphere and dialogue here. Finally we have a story of Matt being in court most of the time. On top of that the mystery of who's a killer and who isn't is great. The feeling of dread is perfect for this type of story and Matt's hopeless battle is hard to watch. The ending is a gut punch and made me so mad but that's the point of a great sad tale.
This is a must read for Matt Murdock fans. A 5 out of 5.
January 27, 2022
This was a really good story and wow its dark.
It involves Matt going to a town called Redemption and well the people there are god fearing and they think that Joel Flood has murdered the boy Bradley along with his friends and believe them to be satanists and wlel the trial starts and we have Matt defending Joel but its just such an interesting story as we see twists and turns and focus on Bradley's father Howard Gideon and well Matt believes him to be the culprit and then we follow the inclusion of Daredevil in the story but mostly its the trials and the twists and turns and witness interrogations, character changing their stances and closing statements and the result of the trials.. will Matt be able to apprehend the killer? Will Joel get justice or not and what darkness awaits?
Its such a good story and sure its less daredevil and more of a court story, trust me when I say its one of the best Matt stories like the way the emphasis is on trial, I love it! Its dark sure but it also has that epic factor and suspense and mystery which makes the whole thing a great read and even by the end you don't get resolutions you want, its a twist in a great way and also philosophical if you think about it. Certainly one of the best Daredevil stories ever.
It involves Matt going to a town called Redemption and well the people there are god fearing and they think that Joel Flood has murdered the boy Bradley along with his friends and believe them to be satanists and wlel the trial starts and we have Matt defending Joel but its just such an interesting story as we see twists and turns and focus on Bradley's father Howard Gideon and well Matt believes him to be the culprit and then we follow the inclusion of Daredevil in the story but mostly its the trials and the twists and turns and witness interrogations, character changing their stances and closing statements and the result of the trials.. will Matt be able to apprehend the killer? Will Joel get justice or not and what darkness awaits?
Its such a good story and sure its less daredevil and more of a court story, trust me when I say its one of the best Matt stories like the way the emphasis is on trial, I love it! Its dark sure but it also has that epic factor and suspense and mystery which makes the whole thing a great read and even by the end you don't get resolutions you want, its a twist in a great way and also philosophical if you think about it. Certainly one of the best Daredevil stories ever.
July 12, 2014
Wow. I am very surprised by how much I enjoyed this. David Hine has written some Grade A Stinkers in the past, so I was kind of dreading how he would approach my favorite character in all of comic books. Turns out, he did an almost-perfect job!
While this isn't strictly a "Daredevil" story as much as it is a "Matt Murdock" story, Daredevil's direct influence is felt throughout. Hine does terrific work here with Murdock's character, showing him to be the troubled, almost bipolar hero he is both in and out of costume, always struggling to balance his law-abiding lawyer side with his mask-wearing vigilante side. Matt's flaws cause some real problems in this story, and his screwups, while maddening, are completely believable for a person in his position. The only thing I wanted to see a little more of was Matt's remorse at these problems he causes, because ultimately they are pretty phenomenal errors, and we never really see him deal with that emotionally. Otherwise, all the other character stuff is spot on.
As for the plot, this feels kind of like a modern-day To Kill A Mockingbird (well, the court portions anyway), mixed with True Detective. Set in a small, dingy town in Alabama, the whole story reads as dirty and depressing, aided greatly by Michael Gaydos's excellent art (I mean, the guy who penciled Alias is tackling Daredevil? Perfect!). I was a little perturbed by the depiction of Alabama (my home state), as it kind of implied that the whole state is just a garbage dump full of completely insane religious nuts and violent, hateful dummies, which is just not true, but for the purposes of this story, I'm willing to forgive it. The story does such a great job of balancing small-town fear and gossip with that other stuff that I'm willing to tell myself "Hine just meant that THIS weird town in Alabama is like this, not everywhere else."
My one major hangup, which is why this isn't getting five stars, is my problem I have with almost every superhero book that ever takes place in a different location than normal: the dumb superhero puts on his superhero costume. I mean, come on. Matt Murdock shows up in Redemption, Alabama at the exact same time as Daredevil, and everyone is like "He must've BROUGHT Daredevil with him!" No. No no no. OBVIOUSLY HE IS DAREDEVIL. Don't wear the suit, you idiot! If you HAVE to go out at night and prowl around, just wear all black or something. Don't dress as the superhero who is from the exact same town as you (I'm looking at you, Bruce Wayne).
The good thing is, this doesn't factor into the story too much, and Hine does a good job justifying the problems this causes with the story. The fact that this book is set before Brian Michael Bendis's run (in which Daredevil's secret identity is outed to the public), also eases some of that burden.
In the end, this is just a great, thrilling courtroom drama, with tight plotting and a very fulfilling ending. The twists and turns are at times heart-wrenching, and I found this hard to put down. Definitely worth checking out if you see it out there on the shelves.
While this isn't strictly a "Daredevil" story as much as it is a "Matt Murdock" story, Daredevil's direct influence is felt throughout. Hine does terrific work here with Murdock's character, showing him to be the troubled, almost bipolar hero he is both in and out of costume, always struggling to balance his law-abiding lawyer side with his mask-wearing vigilante side. Matt's flaws cause some real problems in this story, and his screwups, while maddening, are completely believable for a person in his position. The only thing I wanted to see a little more of was Matt's remorse at these problems he causes, because ultimately they are pretty phenomenal errors, and we never really see him deal with that emotionally. Otherwise, all the other character stuff is spot on.
As for the plot, this feels kind of like a modern-day To Kill A Mockingbird (well, the court portions anyway), mixed with True Detective. Set in a small, dingy town in Alabama, the whole story reads as dirty and depressing, aided greatly by Michael Gaydos's excellent art (I mean, the guy who penciled Alias is tackling Daredevil? Perfect!). I was a little perturbed by the depiction of Alabama (my home state), as it kind of implied that the whole state is just a garbage dump full of completely insane religious nuts and violent, hateful dummies, which is just not true, but for the purposes of this story, I'm willing to forgive it. The story does such a great job of balancing small-town fear and gossip with that other stuff that I'm willing to tell myself "Hine just meant that THIS weird town in Alabama is like this, not everywhere else."
My one major hangup, which is why this isn't getting five stars, is my problem I have with almost every superhero book that ever takes place in a different location than normal: the dumb superhero puts on his superhero costume. I mean, come on. Matt Murdock shows up in Redemption, Alabama at the exact same time as Daredevil, and everyone is like "He must've BROUGHT Daredevil with him!" No. No no no. OBVIOUSLY HE IS DAREDEVIL. Don't wear the suit, you idiot! If you HAVE to go out at night and prowl around, just wear all black or something. Don't dress as the superhero who is from the exact same town as you (I'm looking at you, Bruce Wayne).
The good thing is, this doesn't factor into the story too much, and Hine does a good job justifying the problems this causes with the story. The fact that this book is set before Brian Michael Bendis's run (in which Daredevil's secret identity is outed to the public), also eases some of that burden.
In the end, this is just a great, thrilling courtroom drama, with tight plotting and a very fulfilling ending. The twists and turns are at times heart-wrenching, and I found this hard to put down. Definitely worth checking out if you see it out there on the shelves.
November 3, 2012
Matt Murdock is called out to a podunk town named Redemption in order to see whether a teenager accused of murder really did it and like a lot of these small towns they hide secrets of their own. Unlike most Daredevil pieces this focuses more on the case and very little on Daredevil in action. Some have expressed their wish that this be a 100% Murdock the lawyer story but that didn't happen.
Artwork is somewhat good to good with a lot of shadow play. Lots of focuses on the character heads as they speak and such. Some might call it severe.
There are strong themes of child abuse in this piece so steer clear if that bothers you. Based on a true tale, West Memphis Three.
Written by David Hine. Artwork by Michael Gydos and coloring by Lee Loughridge.
ARTWORK PRESENATION: B minus to B; CHARACTERS/DIALOGUE: B; STORY/PLOTTING: B minus; WHEN READ: end of October 2012; OVERALL GRADE: B minus to B.
Artwork is somewhat good to good with a lot of shadow play. Lots of focuses on the character heads as they speak and such. Some might call it severe.
There are strong themes of child abuse in this piece so steer clear if that bothers you. Based on a true tale, West Memphis Three.
Written by David Hine. Artwork by Michael Gydos and coloring by Lee Loughridge.
ARTWORK PRESENATION: B minus to B; CHARACTERS/DIALOGUE: B; STORY/PLOTTING: B minus; WHEN READ: end of October 2012; OVERALL GRADE: B minus to B.
August 20, 2025
Baseado na história real conhecida como “Três de West Memphis”, a qual 3 adolescentes do Arkansas foram acusados de matar 3 crianças e condenados à prisão perpétua – e um dos adolescentes recebendo a pena de morte - Demolidor Redenção trabalha com uma narrativa muito semelhante, em que 3 adolescentes são acusados de assassinar uma criança no Alabama, e a polícia mesmo não tendo tantas provas concretas, prendem os 3 jovens por serem “satanistas” e servirem como ótimo bode expiatório.
Nesse ensejo, a mãe de um dos adolescentes acusados, recorre a Matt Murdock, que aceita o caso, e inicia sua investigação na pequena cidade do estado do Alabama ( que não é nada receptiva com o advogado). Nesse sentido, é interessante notar a construção da atmosfera de cidade do interior, por exemplo os vizinhos fofocando e comprando uma narrativa facilmente para condenar alguém que não é bem-quisto na cidadezinha. A fama da família do jovem, bem como a do próprio jovem, influencia no julgamento e opinião dos demais, fazendo com que não pensem duas vezes antes de acusarem os jovens. Apesar de parecer algo estereotipado de cidade pequena e “caipira”, posso atestar com experiencia própria que é assim que funciona uma cidade pequena do interior, principalmente aquelas em que os ricos mandam e moldam as narrativas e compram pessoas e cargos importantes,
Se tratando do caso em que Matt se torna o advogado de defesa, ao longo dos 6 capítulos, nós o acompanhamos – juntamente de sua estagiária – fazendo o possível e impossível para encontrar uma saída para o caso. Em alguns momentos, parece que a investigação realizada pelo Demolidor, que encontrou algo em suas saídas noturnas, irá resultar em algo bom, mas não consegue somar em nada para um caso que já está praticamente definido. Em outros momentos, Matt e sua estagiária escolhem uma narrativa que pode ser sustentada com base em argumentos científicos e explorando falhas dos depoimentos dos acusados, no entanto, a batalha judicial travada contra eles, somado a toda opinião sobre o caso não ter outro desdobramento se não acusar os jovens, fazem todo esse esforço ser em vão. A sensação de agonia e frustração percorrem a HQ do início ao fim, deixando o leitor instigado a querer saber o que irá acontecer.
Além disso, é importante destacar que o Demolidor é um personagem que quase não aparece na trama, sendo específico de momentos da investigação. A trama joga os holofotes no Matt Murdock e em seu entorno jurídico, sendo um quadrinho totalmente focado em investigação e trama policial.
Outro aspecto interessante da HQ, que me fisgou muito a atenção e me fez refletir bastante sobre o tema, é toda a narrativa criada entorno dos jovens: satanistas, que escutam heavy metal e bebem/usam drogas. Somados a isso, há todo o discurso de um padre (que facilmente também poderia ser um pastor) alegando que rock, rpg, certos livros e afins, seriam coisas do diabo e que as famílias deveriam proibir que seus filhos utilizassem e usufruíssem de tais coisas do demônio, para proteger o lar e as famílias de Deus. Todo esse discurso me lembrou muito a nossa sociedade, que infelizmente ainda sofre com tais alegações de líderes religiosos. Embora muitas vezes pensamos que Yu-Gi-Oh ser taxado como cartas do demônio e Naruto ser do diabo sejam coisas do passado, atualmente temos fundamentalistas religiosos e líderes/militantes da extrema direita pautando sobre a “agenda woke”, que pode ser vista da mesma forma, é uma narrativa que visa criminalizar e menosprezar certos conteúdos que “ferem” os ideais conservadores pautados por eles.
Ademais, recomendo demais esse quadrinho, é uma trama incrível do Matt Murdock, mostrando o quanto ele é um advogado incrível, que se importa com as pessoas e como ele lida com a atuação do Demolidor influenciar ou não suas ações como advogado.
Nesse ensejo, a mãe de um dos adolescentes acusados, recorre a Matt Murdock, que aceita o caso, e inicia sua investigação na pequena cidade do estado do Alabama ( que não é nada receptiva com o advogado). Nesse sentido, é interessante notar a construção da atmosfera de cidade do interior, por exemplo os vizinhos fofocando e comprando uma narrativa facilmente para condenar alguém que não é bem-quisto na cidadezinha. A fama da família do jovem, bem como a do próprio jovem, influencia no julgamento e opinião dos demais, fazendo com que não pensem duas vezes antes de acusarem os jovens. Apesar de parecer algo estereotipado de cidade pequena e “caipira”, posso atestar com experiencia própria que é assim que funciona uma cidade pequena do interior, principalmente aquelas em que os ricos mandam e moldam as narrativas e compram pessoas e cargos importantes,
Se tratando do caso em que Matt se torna o advogado de defesa, ao longo dos 6 capítulos, nós o acompanhamos – juntamente de sua estagiária – fazendo o possível e impossível para encontrar uma saída para o caso. Em alguns momentos, parece que a investigação realizada pelo Demolidor, que encontrou algo em suas saídas noturnas, irá resultar em algo bom, mas não consegue somar em nada para um caso que já está praticamente definido. Em outros momentos, Matt e sua estagiária escolhem uma narrativa que pode ser sustentada com base em argumentos científicos e explorando falhas dos depoimentos dos acusados, no entanto, a batalha judicial travada contra eles, somado a toda opinião sobre o caso não ter outro desdobramento se não acusar os jovens, fazem todo esse esforço ser em vão. A sensação de agonia e frustração percorrem a HQ do início ao fim, deixando o leitor instigado a querer saber o que irá acontecer.
Além disso, é importante destacar que o Demolidor é um personagem que quase não aparece na trama, sendo específico de momentos da investigação. A trama joga os holofotes no Matt Murdock e em seu entorno jurídico, sendo um quadrinho totalmente focado em investigação e trama policial.
Outro aspecto interessante da HQ, que me fisgou muito a atenção e me fez refletir bastante sobre o tema, é toda a narrativa criada entorno dos jovens: satanistas, que escutam heavy metal e bebem/usam drogas. Somados a isso, há todo o discurso de um padre (que facilmente também poderia ser um pastor) alegando que rock, rpg, certos livros e afins, seriam coisas do diabo e que as famílias deveriam proibir que seus filhos utilizassem e usufruíssem de tais coisas do demônio, para proteger o lar e as famílias de Deus. Todo esse discurso me lembrou muito a nossa sociedade, que infelizmente ainda sofre com tais alegações de líderes religiosos. Embora muitas vezes pensamos que Yu-Gi-Oh ser taxado como cartas do demônio e Naruto ser do diabo sejam coisas do passado, atualmente temos fundamentalistas religiosos e líderes/militantes da extrema direita pautando sobre a “agenda woke”, que pode ser vista da mesma forma, é uma narrativa que visa criminalizar e menosprezar certos conteúdos que “ferem” os ideais conservadores pautados por eles.
Ademais, recomendo demais esse quadrinho, é uma trama incrível do Matt Murdock, mostrando o quanto ele é um advogado incrível, que se importa com as pessoas e como ele lida com a atuação do Demolidor influenciar ou não suas ações como advogado.
April 7, 2025
A short and sweet daredevil story - Matt Murdock goes to Alabama to defend three people who are accused of murdering a young boy- they’re being mishandled and assumed guilty because they like metal and have long hair - total satanic panic. But what makes this story great is that Matt fails- the ending is sad but it fits in with the marvel knights line where it all feels more real, the good guy doesn’t always save the day :/
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 29, 2022
Woo hoo! It's been a long time since I've read a good Daredevil comic book! If you've been following me for a while you may know that I've been disappointed with quite a few of the last runs I've read of my so called favorite character. Daredevil: Redemption has finally broken the bad streak for me!
I think many of the best DD runs really utilize his alter ego Matt Murdock. Murdock is obsessed with being lawful good, DD is chaotic good, they get to battle it out for how the law should be enforced and it's never been done better than in this short run.
to continue to the full review please visit https://amanjareads.com/2022/04/19/da...
I think many of the best DD runs really utilize his alter ego Matt Murdock. Murdock is obsessed with being lawful good, DD is chaotic good, they get to battle it out for how the law should be enforced and it's never been done better than in this short run.
to continue to the full review please visit https://amanjareads.com/2022/04/19/da...
March 26, 2017
Loosely based on the case of the West Memphis Three, Daredevil: Redemption is a perfect example of what make Daredevil one of the most interesting superhero/vigilantes around.
This story arc focuses more on Matt Murdock's career as a lawyer and his trouble navigating the justice system as a licensed lawyer as well as the masked vigilante, Daredevil. Murdock experienced the conflict of knowing that his client was innocent, yet having to perform within the law in order to prove it. It is one of the seemingly rare instances where his alter-ego has no place in investigations, which is something that Murdock struggles with.
Matt Murdock in this arc is completely realistic. All of his flaws and mistakes that he makes are laid out for all to see, as he struggles with the case. The courtroom scenes were well done, thrilling, and realistic. I was completely riveted by this story and the characters.
Daredevil: Redemption is a perfect example of why I hold Marvel Comics so dear to my heart. The have perfected the use of real life problems and social issues in a fantastical way, involving superheroes and extreme personalities. Like with all media, comic books can, and should, be taken seriously. They have the ability to turn humanity's flaws, prejudices, and tragedies around on us and make us face what we are capable of. The gross inhumanity and injustice that is shown in this arc speaks volumes to the reader. It has been quite some time since I was this distraught and invested due to a story. A huge thank you to David Hine for reminding me just how amazing this platform of media can be and what it can accomplish.
This story arc focuses more on Matt Murdock's career as a lawyer and his trouble navigating the justice system as a licensed lawyer as well as the masked vigilante, Daredevil. Murdock experienced the conflict of knowing that his client was innocent, yet having to perform within the law in order to prove it. It is one of the seemingly rare instances where his alter-ego has no place in investigations, which is something that Murdock struggles with.
Matt Murdock in this arc is completely realistic. All of his flaws and mistakes that he makes are laid out for all to see, as he struggles with the case. The courtroom scenes were well done, thrilling, and realistic. I was completely riveted by this story and the characters.
Daredevil: Redemption is a perfect example of why I hold Marvel Comics so dear to my heart. The have perfected the use of real life problems and social issues in a fantastical way, involving superheroes and extreme personalities. Like with all media, comic books can, and should, be taken seriously. They have the ability to turn humanity's flaws, prejudices, and tragedies around on us and make us face what we are capable of. The gross inhumanity and injustice that is shown in this arc speaks volumes to the reader. It has been quite some time since I was this distraught and invested due to a story. A huge thank you to David Hine for reminding me just how amazing this platform of media can be and what it can accomplish.
January 14, 2019
This was definitely too dark for me... And made me uncomfortable to read, and it's also so real and violent... Probably my least favorite Daredevil comic, from the ones I've read...
You may like it, it just really wasn't my thing...
You may like it, it just really wasn't my thing...
March 12, 2023
Emotionally brutal, the way Daredevil should be.
July 13, 2022
3'75⭐. Una dramática historia, ambientada casi en su totalidad en Redemption Valley, Alabama, apareciendo Hell's Kitchen, New York, solo al principio.
Aunque esa no es la única diferencia apreciable al compararla con otras obras del diablo guardián, ya que recae un mayor protagonismo en el abogado Matt Murdock, cuyo alter ego, Daredevil, es por todos los seguidores marvelitas bien conocido, pero que en este cómic en concreto apenas hace acto de presencia.
Eso no impide el disfrutar de una obra con mucha intriga en el que el pijameo es anecdótico no solo por lo comentado antes, sino también porque no aparece ninguno de los archi-enemigos de Daredevil, y en la que los "villanos malvados" no son lo que aparentan ser en realidad.
En conclusión, no es una obra maestra como "Born Again", pero es muy disfrutable, aunque te deje con un poso de melancólica tristeza en su final, que por otro lado viene siendo habitual que se dé este tipo de tramas oscuras cuando se trata de nuestro único súper héroe con ceguera. Y es que encierra mucha denuncia y crítica social, incluso siendo un final injusto con cierto regusto amargo, pues algunas veces unos pocos tienen que pagar con la ceguera, falta de escrúpulos y prejuicios de muchos.
Nota aclaratoria final: Muy recomendable, sobre todo ahora que se puede disfrutar en la colección Marvel Dark por solo 2'99€ junto a otro arco de Daredevil, "Sospechosos excepcionales".
Aunque esa no es la única diferencia apreciable al compararla con otras obras del diablo guardián, ya que recae un mayor protagonismo en el abogado Matt Murdock, cuyo alter ego, Daredevil, es por todos los seguidores marvelitas bien conocido, pero que en este cómic en concreto apenas hace acto de presencia.
Eso no impide el disfrutar de una obra con mucha intriga en el que el pijameo es anecdótico no solo por lo comentado antes, sino también porque no aparece ninguno de los archi-enemigos de Daredevil, y en la que los "villanos malvados" no son lo que aparentan ser en realidad.
En conclusión, no es una obra maestra como "Born Again", pero es muy disfrutable, aunque te deje con un poso de melancólica tristeza en su final, que por otro lado viene siendo habitual que se dé este tipo de tramas oscuras cuando se trata de nuestro único súper héroe con ceguera. Y es que encierra mucha denuncia y crítica social, incluso siendo un final injusto con cierto regusto amargo, pues algunas veces unos pocos tienen que pagar con la ceguera, falta de escrúpulos y prejuicios de muchos.
Nota aclaratoria final: Muy recomendable, sobre todo ahora que se puede disfrutar en la colección Marvel Dark por solo 2'99€ junto a otro arco de Daredevil, "Sospechosos excepcionales".
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 17, 2022
Я прочитав лімітку "Daredevi Redemption" і це тепер один з моїх улюблених коміксів про цього персонажа. Сюжет серії розповідає про те як Метт Мердок береться захищати хлопця якого звинувачують в убивстві дитини.
Девід Гайн тут видав дуже похмуру історію яку було дуже цікаво читати. Фінал історії так взагалі вийшов неймовірно депресивним та неочікуваним (хоча можливо це просто я очікував на якийсь щасливий фінал). Сама історія також показує те як релігія та життя в невеликому містечку впливає на сприйняття людини. З цікавого виділю те, що це більше історія про Метта Мердока, він тут нехай і вдягає костюм, однак відбувається це не часто і приносить лиш шкоду для самої справи. Також я хочу похвалити художника серії Майкла Ґейдоса. Його арт просто чудово задає тутешню атмосферу.
Загалом я дуже і дуже сильно рекомендую ознайомитися з цією ліміткою, особливо якщо ви фанат персонажа.
Девід Гайн тут видав дуже похмуру історію яку було дуже цікаво читати. Фінал історії так взагалі вийшов неймовірно депресивним та неочікуваним (хоча можливо це просто я очікував на якийсь щасливий фінал). Сама історія також показує те як релігія та життя в невеликому містечку впливає на сприйняття людини. З цікавого виділю те, що це більше історія про Метта Мердока, він тут нехай і вдягає костюм, однак відбувається це не часто і приносить лиш шкоду для самої справи. Також я хочу похвалити художника серії Майкла Ґейдоса. Його арт просто чудово задає тутешню атмосферу.
Загалом я дуже і дуже сильно рекомендую ознайомитися з цією ліміткою, особливо якщо ви фанат персонажа.
May 20, 2023
Pues me ha gustado mucho. No sabía de la existencia de Daredevil y es un personaje que puede dar mucho juego. No sé cómo serán el resto de comics, pero este juega mucho con el rollo policíaco y detectivesco que queda guay.
January 6, 2025
Com uma história mais focada no lado civil de Matt como advogado a trama se destaca pela efetividade do thriller jurídico.
May 14, 2011
When I review a book or graphic novel, I try to pick something that is underrepresented or is deserving of attention. When I saw the rating and complete lack of reviews, I knew duty called.
Inspired by a true true story, this book is absolutely incredible and is my favorite Daredevil story. While Matt dons the suit a few times, this story is as much a legal procedural as anything else. In Daredevil: Redemption he travels to the deep south to represent three kids accused of a gruesome murder of a child. They are metal heads and have embraced rebelling against Christianity and other "unacceptable" religions. The town is populated by conservative Christians who have a hang 'em high attitude. While that sounds somewhat predictable, if you've ever felt like an outcast or are against the death penalty, you are likely to connect with the character and plot.
What David Hine gets that Bendis (who did a great job) and Brubaker (who did a good job) don't, is that Daredevil is the underdog of superheroes. He's always had a tough time, but he perseveres. That's what makes him so cool and why people who don't like superhero comics (including myself) find Daredevil worth reading. While it is all too often absent from his main title, the underdog status is in full effect here.
Whether you've read much Daredevil or not, you owe it to yourself to pick this graphic novel up before it goes out of print. It truly is some of the best you'll ever find.
Inspired by a true true story, this book is absolutely incredible and is my favorite Daredevil story. While Matt dons the suit a few times, this story is as much a legal procedural as anything else. In Daredevil: Redemption he travels to the deep south to represent three kids accused of a gruesome murder of a child. They are metal heads and have embraced rebelling against Christianity and other "unacceptable" religions. The town is populated by conservative Christians who have a hang 'em high attitude. While that sounds somewhat predictable, if you've ever felt like an outcast or are against the death penalty, you are likely to connect with the character and plot.
What David Hine gets that Bendis (who did a great job) and Brubaker (who did a good job) don't, is that Daredevil is the underdog of superheroes. He's always had a tough time, but he perseveres. That's what makes him so cool and why people who don't like superhero comics (including myself) find Daredevil worth reading. While it is all too often absent from his main title, the underdog status is in full effect here.
Whether you've read much Daredevil or not, you owe it to yourself to pick this graphic novel up before it goes out of print. It truly is some of the best you'll ever find.
July 9, 2022
MONUMENTAL miniserie para el Diablo Guardián. Se nota totalmente deudora y conectada a la era Alias de Marvel Knights (comparte incluso dibujante). Una pegajosa e insondable trama judicial "American Gothic" donde vale más el retorcido puritanismo que la razón y la verdad. David Hine no duda en aprovechar la oportunidad para lanzar semejante devastación argumental y personal a un personaje que siempre se ha caracterizado por sufrir cada golpe a pie de calle adoptando el manto de Daredevil o cada pérdida o injusticia en su vida como defensor ante las cortes legales. Pero Matt Murdock no conocerá justicia más Ciega como la que se da en el pueblecito de Redemption con el caso de un asesinato infantil para el que hay unos sospechoso claros: unos adolescentes tildados de satánicos.
Por supuesto no es una lectura agradable o lo que podría esperar alguien que busque una lectura rápida y directa de Daredevil. El autor de hecho acaba revelando de forma totalmente devastadora que si el justiciero cornudo actuase como se esperaría de él en el grueso de sus historias, no c0nseguiría realmente nada. El sobrenombre de Diablo Guardián cobra un sentido más desolador si cabe en las últimas páginas.
Por supuesto no es una lectura agradable o lo que podría esperar alguien que busque una lectura rápida y directa de Daredevil. El autor de hecho acaba revelando de forma totalmente devastadora que si el justiciero cornudo actuase como se esperaría de él en el grueso de sus historias, no c0nseguiría realmente nada. El sobrenombre de Diablo Guardián cobra un sentido más desolador si cabe en las últimas páginas.
October 22, 2017
I was an advocate of the Marvel Knight Line--which was an attempt to tell evergreen comic stories that were not tied to continuity and canon. Usually with higher production value on art and of a mini-series status.
As such, David Hine wrote a story that was more of a Matt Murdock Crime Thriller ala John Grishmam then a standard Daredevil story. Hine is a very hit-or-miss writer for me. While his Bulletproof Coffin is one of my favorite comics, and his Spawn run is probably one of the better runs of the entire series, most of his work-for-hire stuff have been duds.
This would be a great introduction for people who like aren't traditional superhero fans, but liked the Netflix series. It's loosely inspired by the West Memphis Tree, where Matt Murdock is needed to help prove these children's innocence.
As such, David Hine wrote a story that was more of a Matt Murdock Crime Thriller ala John Grishmam then a standard Daredevil story. Hine is a very hit-or-miss writer for me. While his Bulletproof Coffin is one of my favorite comics, and his Spawn run is probably one of the better runs of the entire series, most of his work-for-hire stuff have been duds.
This would be a great introduction for people who like aren't traditional superhero fans, but liked the Netflix series. It's loosely inspired by the West Memphis Tree, where Matt Murdock is needed to help prove these children's innocence.
April 28, 2020
this was some pretty heavy stuff and I suppose it makes sense that they used Daredevil as the medium to tell this particular story. It's really more of a legal battle, and thus is in the realm of Matt Murdock more than his alter ego Daredevil. But both come into play in this complex tale of small-town justice and family secrets.
And while it'll always be a mystery how people didn't connect the presence of Daredevil outside New York just as Matt Murdock was in town and despite there being clear rumors linking the two, the piece plays out well both in the courtroom and beyond.
I really enjoyed this mini-series and the second half of the collection really shines as some clever writing and great narrative devices put to good effect.
And while it'll always be a mystery how people didn't connect the presence of Daredevil outside New York just as Matt Murdock was in town and despite there being clear rumors linking the two, the piece plays out well both in the courtroom and beyond.
I really enjoyed this mini-series and the second half of the collection really shines as some clever writing and great narrative devices put to good effect.
December 5, 2015
I liked David Hine's story in the sense that he took Daredevil/Matt Murdock out of his familiar NYC. In fact, this is primarily a Matt Murdock story, him being out of costume for most of it. What I don't get is why he (Matt) felt the need to dress up as Daredevil to investigate the case - won't people put two and two together? Oh wait - I forgot: this is a comic book. Silly me.
Kudos to Michael Gaydos for the art.
Kudos to Michael Gaydos for the art.
February 14, 2017
This was one of the most interesting Daredevil stories I've ever read (which, at this point, is saying a lot). It's a true crime story blended with a superhero story, and it works...because it's Daredevil. A lot is fictionalized, obviously, but the case was real. And David Hine weaves a really good story using Matt Murdock as the lawyer.
The art was strong too, fitting the story well, thought the three suspects looked too similar.
The art was strong too, fitting the story well, thought the three suspects looked too similar.
August 19, 2016
This wasn't really too much Daredevil action but it was mostly a court case and investigation. This was very good, and worth checking out even if you are not a fan of the series.
https://youtu.be/ch20x7t8WFY
https://youtu.be/ch20x7t8WFY
October 21, 2020
A phenomenal Daredevil story; if anything, more of a Matt Murdock story. A heartbreaking story, especially *the* part in the last issue, but very well-written and containing more great artwork from Gaydos, especially the last page. Anyone who enjoyed the Bendis and Brubaker runs will enjoy this.
January 6, 2013
preso in biblioteca
Storia un po' sottotono, esterna al filone principale "Devilistico" e disegni in uno stile che non riesce a piacermi.
Storia un po' sottotono, esterna al filone principale "Devilistico" e disegni in uno stile che non riesce a piacermi.
October 29, 2018
Un buen comic con un final agridulce. He disfrutado leyéndolo.
November 5, 2018
Well...that was depressing. I do love seeing Matt in the courtroom, though. Probably more than I like seeing him hit people. It’s no wonder he prefers wearing a red suit than a 3-piece.
November 25, 2018
An excellent and absolutely gutting story.
July 25, 2022
Devastador y amargo cómic que no busca ser una historia entretenida o disfrutable sino más bien una amarga crítica donde Matt Murdock (que no Daredevil, porque en esta historia el alter ego del protagonista queda demostrado que bien poco puede hacer) debe hacer de, nunca mejor dicho, abogado del diablo y afrontar un caso imposible.
Es una gran historia que deja muy mal cuerpo en algunos puntos, llegando a rozar el horror psicológico, la violencia tanto implícita como explícita y una crítica social afilada y cruda.
He disfrutado mucho sin embargo del Matt abogado y no he echado tanto en falta a Daredevil, aunque hace las justas apariciones esparcidascon mucho acierto aquí y allá para apoyar y remarcar la trama. La verdad es que aparece poco pero está metido en la justa medida para que sea efectivo y diga mucho más en un par de viñetas que si hubiera aparecido durante todas las páginas. Absolutamente brillantes las apariciones del justiciero, al igual que Murdock, que con elegancia y profesionalidad demuestra ser un noble abogado y defensor de la verdad y la justicia.
Gaydos comparte serie con Jessica Jones, donde aparece Daredevil también. En esta serie lucen más sus ilustraciones que en la de la investigadora privada, pero creo que en ambos hace buenos trabajos y resoluciones ilustrativas.
Es una gran historia que deja muy mal cuerpo en algunos puntos, llegando a rozar el horror psicológico, la violencia tanto implícita como explícita y una crítica social afilada y cruda.
He disfrutado mucho sin embargo del Matt abogado y no he echado tanto en falta a Daredevil, aunque hace las justas apariciones esparcidascon mucho acierto aquí y allá para apoyar y remarcar la trama. La verdad es que aparece poco pero está metido en la justa medida para que sea efectivo y diga mucho más en un par de viñetas que si hubiera aparecido durante todas las páginas. Absolutamente brillantes las apariciones del justiciero, al igual que Murdock, que con elegancia y profesionalidad demuestra ser un noble abogado y defensor de la verdad y la justicia.
Gaydos comparte serie con Jessica Jones, donde aparece Daredevil también. En esta serie lucen más sus ilustraciones que en la de la investigadora privada, pero creo que en ambos hace buenos trabajos y resoluciones ilustrativas.
February 12, 2019
La storia è certamente potente e ogni tanto arrivano dei pugni nello stomaco che lasciano senza fiato. L'atmosfera del "profondo Sud" degli States, con tutto il suo fanatismo religioso, poteva essere un ottimo contraltare a un personaggio che fa della fede cattolica il suo motore etico.
Peccato che questa non sia una storia di Devil.
Non è una storia di Devil perché tradisce il primo comandamento del personaggio, che si può riassumere così: Devil porta la giustizia dove la legge che esercita Matt Murdock non può arrivare.
Qui Matt Murdock si prodiga nel tentativo di salvare un imputato sia da una condanna ingiusta che dal pregiudizio dei concittadini, fallendo miseramente. Devil si limita a qualche sparuta apparizione, ma non muove mai le mani, non pesta come si deve i cattivi, non assicura alla giustizia i criminali, non fa nulla.
Ci troviamo davanti a un tentativo di riscrittura de "Il buio oltre la siepe" in chiave supereroistica, peccato che il supereroe non esista.
Anche la disposizione delle tavole è molto classica, se non banale.
Peccato che questa non sia una storia di Devil.
Non è una storia di Devil perché tradisce il primo comandamento del personaggio, che si può riassumere così: Devil porta la giustizia dove la legge che esercita Matt Murdock non può arrivare.
Qui Matt Murdock si prodiga nel tentativo di salvare un imputato sia da una condanna ingiusta che dal pregiudizio dei concittadini, fallendo miseramente. Devil si limita a qualche sparuta apparizione, ma non muove mai le mani, non pesta come si deve i cattivi, non assicura alla giustizia i criminali, non fa nulla.
Ci troviamo davanti a un tentativo di riscrittura de "Il buio oltre la siepe" in chiave supereroistica, peccato che il supereroe non esista.
Anche la disposizione delle tavole è molto classica, se non banale.
April 19, 2023
Vaya sorpresa más buena me he llevado con éste cómic. Todo lo que sea sacar a héroes de su contexto habitual me suele gastar bastante, siendo este un caso paradigmático de ello. Hine nos propone aquí una historia crimino-judicial muy bien presentada, desarrollada y concluida. Hay muchos personajes nuevos fuera de la mitología de Daredevil y todos son creíbles y están bien construidos. La ambientación religiosa en pueblo paleto, que recuerda al arco de Salvación de Predicador, también está bien lograda. Mucho crédito de esto a Gaydos, que tiene un estilo que me encaja con Daredevil. Narrativamente está fantástico y hace que la lectura fluya con agilidad, con composiciones de página muy acertadas para una historia de estas características. Aunque está muy lejos, por estilo me recuerda un poco a Maleev y eso es bueno.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 79 reviews