My first books outside of chapter books for kids were the ones I took off my grandpa's shelf... his Louis L'amour books. Since I was eight, I've had a secret penchant for the genre, despite the fact that it gets little love from the literary circles. And most of the time, modern writers of westerns are way too violent for my taste.
Well, The Circuit Rider was way too violent for my taste, But what was good about it made up for it in my opinion and I thought it was a great book. I've read a lot of westerns, but never one where the woman was the drinking gunslinger and the man was the one who needed a body guard. Pretty interesting premise.
What I liked: The characters were well developed and the plot kept me reading. Obviously I liked to read about a capable woman from that time period, although all her strength came from the wounds she received at the hands of a sadistic man. I loved Tower, but it seemed like there was little development of him, except for one big reveal. I would have been interested in his story, how he turned to God after everything he'd been through. I would have liked to know more about how he ministered to people instead of just having it alluded too. It would have given me a better idea of who he was as a man.
Disliked: Well, all the gory violence. Yeah, it was a violent time when things were settled violently, but it was pretty graphic. Also, it bothered me that there was not really any women in the book that weren't being killed or abused in some way. Maybe the innkeeper? She was so brief she doesn't count. It was not a fun time to be a woman, I get that, but not one woman who can take care of herself and who isn't a victim of some sort. Boo :(
I think the story suffered from being brought out as a serial. At times it lacked a cohesiveness, a wholeness. I was sad that there weren't more interactions between Tower and Bird outside their murder investigations and the other action scenes. For two people who spent weeks on the trail and saved each other's lives, they didn't have a lot to say. The end was left wide open for a continuation for their story and I hope these gaps will be addressed, for I certainly plan on reading them.