My Toughts Before I read Choices and Changes:I didn't realize that this premise of boy meets girl who is a boy was so popular in the m/m genre until recently. I just read "Plan B" by SJD Peterson whose plot is almost identical to this, and then also the plot of the online free story "The Girl For Me" is almost identical to this too. Also similar sounding to the free story "Louder than Sirens, Louder than Bells."
But as I Loved those stories, I will probably read this too. Lol. But how uncanny?
My Thoughts After I Read Choices and Changes:
3.5-4 stars
Ahh.. This book really had so much potential from my point of view. I really absolutely loved the first half of it.
This is the story of Bo, a 24 year old "straight" construction worker and Erick, a gay graduate student, who meet one night at a frat party. Erick is rather feminine looking, but is not in female clothing or makeup, and Bo thinks Erick is a girl at first. However, Bo realizes that Erick is in fact male, and then tries to avoid Erick at the frat party. However, Erick then meets Bo outside and they begin talking and talk for hours and hours, not just making small talk, bur having a really insightful and meaningful conversation.
And thats what I loved about the first part of this book. It felt really romantic - the characters hung out and talked and talked on the phone, and although they were physically attracted to each other, they didn't jump the gun. They talked and built an emotional connection before they started anything physical. And it just felt right to read.
However, all the talking, in the second half of the book, is what turned me off a bit. The relationship between Bo and Erick was going so well and I felt like it was really romantic and charming, but then I feel like the second half of the book is a completely different book altogether. (Also, when the characters do decide to get physical with each other, I thought it would feel more romantic, like the first half of the story, but it just felt rushed to me and a bit off,even though not described in extremely explicit detail like some m/m reads.)
In the second half of the story, or there about, at one point Erick says something to Bo and Mac about his and Bo's relationship that is just plain stupid to say. I mean, I know this is a review, but I don't know what other word to say than stupid. Basically he said something that hurt Bo and from then on, I really felt like this couple lost their spark altogether. Also, there is a domestic and sexual abuse aspect to this story that I didnt see coming. I don't think it was over the top in anyway, but want to alert the reader in case it is a trigger.
In addition, when the sexual/physical abuse is being discussed, I feel like Bo's words in this conversation are way off base. At one point, Bo keeps making comparisons of himself to Erick's abuser and even apologizes to Erick for interfering in the abusive situation, even though he very may well have saved Erick's life. Also, the reason why Erick refused to call the police after the dangerous situation made absolutely no sense. And this was all annoying to me.
And all this talking about the abuse, and since this all happened after the little incident with Erick saying something stupid, again, in the second half of the book, I feel like this book really dropped off and all the talking that I loved at the first half of the book turned into long, drawn out, overly convuluted conversations where I feel like the characeters lost their spark and their joy. Which was too bad. I feel like Bo was so into the relationship and I feel like Erick just couldn't fight for it. I know Erick, emotionally had some problems, but he was so strong and Bo really admired him and Erick just felt like a different character to me towards the end. They both did in a way. And their relationship just fizzled out for me and I feel like there needed to be more time towards the end to settle it all out rather than just end the story when the characters' relationship just felt so off.
I wonder if this book was written almost in two pieces, months apart and maybe that is why it felt very disjointed between the first half and second half of the book.
So I feel like this is a shame, I really loved the first half of the book and really thought I'd put it on my favorites list, but after reading the second half of the book and the lousy, tiny epilogue, i really have to bump this down from what could have been a five star book to a 3.5 or 4 star book.