Here’s the review I wrote in 2008, before I moved to Kauai.
Then I lived there for 8 years. This book (and it’s subsequent editions remained a useful but conflicted tool. I still found the author’s tone smug and dismissive of local concerns about safety. Many people die— actually DIE— at the places he recommends because he doesn’t give adequate warnings.)
So after using this book for years I still feel that it’s useful, but I should caution anyone using it to check conditions first and use common sense. I watched a woman’s body be retrieved after a fall off of the falls on Kuamoo road. The signs all say No Trespassing— but the guidebook says Go Right Ahead. That’s not okay. That was the most dramatic tourist safety fail I witnessed but the attitude of entitlement was unfailing. Grandma tourists slipping down rough trails without adequate water, children tourists walking out over thin crusts of lava around blowholes. Go ahead and use this book, just...please be smart. And show a little humility to the locals. Respect their No trespassing signs, and stay safe.
My old review:
Aaarghe, yes, this book is useful. Yes, it's easy to use, well written, informative and clear. The maps and illustrations, the sectioning, yes, yes, it's all great.
But the book's smugness with its insider status is endlessly annoying. And the attitude of priveledge and entitlement drives me nuts. I DESERVE to go tramping across "No Trespassing" signs! I'm a tourist! I've got more money than these ignorant locals. And besides, they're not taking advantage of all this great stuff! It should be mine. It IS mine! My own, my precious!
One bit summed it up for me: "I guess we're victims of our own success," the authors smirk. Nobody used to know about the unmarked treacherous path down to Queen's Bath. But now, thanks to us, there's a parkinglot and signs down the highway! And sure enough, the once-secret spot was thronged with tourists, appreciating it to death.
So yes, I'm glad that I too got to go see it in my short visit to the Garden Isle, and yes I know it's a double standard to wish that nobody else knew about it. BUT I believe in working for your Hawaii secrets a little bit. When I first moved to the Big Island, nobody would tell me anything about where they went to fish or swim or eat or hike. Only after 2 years here have I finally gained people's trust where they're willing to tell me about the unmarked unpaved roads that go to the best--and mostly empty-- beaches.
But I'm not telling!