I received a free copy of this book in return for an honest review.
Obviously, I loved it! I’d more accurately rate it at 4.5 stars, but I felt it deserved to be rounded up rather than down because the good attributes of this book far outweighed the “bad” ones.
The plot was pretty thought out and well executed. I found myself getting interested in the story from the start, though it took me a while to get into the book and get immersed in the world and the characters. For once, I was surprised by a twist in a book. Normally I can tell what’s coming by the not-as-subtle-as-it-should be foreshadowing done by quite a few authors, however, Frost got it right. After having learned of the secret, my mind backtracked to think of all the foreshadowing that supported this and suddenly incidents that hadn’t made complete sense to me before, did. It was refreshing not to spot all the major reveals right off the bat.
This being said, the downfall to the plot from my perspective was that it was slightly slow paced. Nothing big really happens until mid-book and even then the battles were a tad of a let down. They were well written, but I was missing a sense of tension in them. Probably because, while there were deaths on our heroes’ side, none of the main characters were ever really in danger of dying themselves. What I had thought would happen in the first battle actually happened in the second, but even then Akakiba and Yuki were never in life-threatening peril, which led me to not be hanging on the edge of my seat during the fights. However, this fact didn’t deter me from enjoying the overall story.
I can’t vouch for the historical accuracy of the setting because I’m certainly not an expert on Japanese history, though I didn’t see anything amiss based on my limited knowledge. In fact, sometimes this book vaguely reminded me of a history book. Probably because of several italicized Japanese words. It wasn’t necessarily a bad thing, but every time I saw one my mind was conditioned to look for a definition of the word at the end of the page or to look for a vocabulary list somewhere at the end of the chapter/in the back of the book. It’s just something textbooks did while I was growing up, so I put all the blame for this habit on them.
The characters are what really made this book for me though. I came to love Akakiba and Yuki and the subtlety of their relationship. Yes, it’s quite plain to others that the two have a rather intimate bond, but they never outright make proclamations of love to each other and their physical interaction is minimal. It’s evident they care quite a bit for one another, but it’s done in a lovely, toned down and more natural way, which I adored. I also came to like the secondary characters, even Jien, who at first inspired the will to kill in me because he was dreadfully annoying. I can’t say I developed a connection with the secondary characters to the point where I’d be upset if they died, but I still enjoyed their presence and thought they added a nice ambience to the story.
So in the end, I definitely loved this book and I will eagerly be waiting for the sequel.