Bill Condon is one my absolute favourite writers and it's been a while since i read his work, so i was really looking forward to this one. i've been a bit dissappointed in his recent work, to be honest. this one too, also falls short of my favourite Condon books. on a scale from Daredevils and No Worries to Give Me Truth, it luckily falls further away from Give Me Truth, which for me was a terrible book. (so much that i can't remember what happened in it.) Maybe it's a little closer to Dogs and Confessions? either way, it's a fairly decent read, but not his best stuff.
things i liked:
Tiff. Bill Condon writing from a girl's POV. also, the fact that this was a likeable girl and a strong character. and what self-respecting reader could pass up that line: "If you can't get a boy, get a book, that's my motto."
the insanely aussie-ness of it all. it's just so beautifully Australian. slang and accents and everything. bloody love it.
the characters. there are so many lovely and interesting characters here. i think the picture of the small town of Gungee was done beautifully, from the descriptions of Tiff's neighbours to the Gunners, their local footy team which sucks. i especially loved Kayla, i found her really likeable, she was funny and real.
i also adored Bull and Reggie. especially Bull. i loved their slang, their care for Tiff and their gruff and true-blue aussie spirit.
things i didn't like:
...sigh. does every YA book have to make a stab at Twilight? we know it's crap already, we don't need to see it voiced in your book. i thought the same thing in John Green's The Fault in Our Stars and once again in this book- we don't need to know it. does it make your book any cooler- dissing another? no, it doesn't. it's not even funny.
the badly thrown in character of Davey. he was all right actually, awkward as hell, weirdest meeting with the main character as possible. character-wise, he's not half-bad. but he vanished in pretty much the whole middle of the book, and only appears in the very beginning and the very end. you almost forget who he is by then, which really doesn't work for the minimal romance side of this book.
also, there iis little to no development between him and Tiff, which doesn't make me care for him any more than i did before. the ending, which is technically strong and very cute, fails because it missed so much vital development between the two. when Tiff needs him there, i didn't understand why she was so upset without him, because THERE WAS NO DEVELOPMENT. bloody hell. for some reason, that really annoys me, i find the Davey/Tiff thing in this book to be one of its greatest failings. if Bill Condon devoted more pages and time to the two, we could wrap up this story well. it's the what-could-have-been that infuriates me so much.
besides, the romance aspect of this book isn't the strong point, because there is hardly any, despite the misleading cover. this book is essentially about family and friendship and a different kind of love. the focus is on Tiff's odd family unit and Kayla's struggling one. the strength is in this focus, why Condon needed to squeeze in the romance is really beyond me. as said before, it's really the weakest point in this book.
as i mentioned, the strength is in the characters. it's particularly at its best when it's focused on the different kinds of families in the book. Tiff's is especially strange, she doesn't live with anyone who's related to her, yet somehow they complete each other. we never know what happened to her dad, it's never even mentioned. kayla's family is brutal and real. it's beautiful, but painful to imagine, because it seems real and believable.
the whole newspaper thing was a bit dull. i didn't entirely understand it in terms of Tiff's character development. the Shark is there, kind of. it seems to miss where it could've made a bold statement about him, something that connects us as readers to him.
the thing with Joan and Dusty at the end seemed tacky. like the thing you see at the end of corny movies where side character gets with side character and we're supposed to be happy about it. truth is, i forgot who Dusty was. HE WAS THE POSTMAN! he was mentioned only once at the very beginning, and that is probably why it didn't work.
basically, i feel that this story, while it has such a great premise and characterization of these different families wastes such great potential and ultimately focuses on something else which leads to its downfall. i'm just upset that there was so much else that could've been done with it, but it wasn't. i rarely think this, but this is a book that could've benefitted with a couple more chapters, and more building up of the strengths of the book. it was almost there, but it didn't make me hurt along with Tiff the way I did with Jack in Daredevils.