Thoughts to come. Maybe 3,5 rounded down.
edit 11.11.2023
Right on time for Halloween AND the día de muertos did I open this bag of horror goodies! It turns out it's a mixed bag, it's how life sometimes goes - I was expecting something rather different, but sometimes it's a mixed bag you get.
It's not that I'm lazy as a reader or see myself above the task of letting my fantasy wander and complete the written story in front of me, but an open ending in horror stories is something that's effective when used sparsely and although I didn't count, I think every other story in The Secret Life of Insects had an open end, exhausting this narrative device for me. The introduction by Marianna Enriquez clarifies that Esquinca has a penchant for the genre true crime/detective, which would explain him wanting to give the reader an inquisitive role. Still, it was too much for me and honestly leaves the impression that the author can't write good endings. Which is, in fact, perfectly fine. For instance, I am fan of an author who has a collection of two Lovecraftian novellas, both of which are truly, amazingly written. You feel like the writing goes into your blood, they're so good, but both have endings that disappoint. There's no shame in it, but when in a collection of many more stories this happens repeatedly, it catches the attention.
Even though towards the end I found the themes repetitive and the characters a little non-distinct, like the narrator often being involved in an adventure either with his cousin/s or brother (I grew up with a ton of cousins and siblings too, so I can picture where that comes from), there were two stories I immensely enjoyed, here they are:
The Paradoxical Man in which a man having nightmares tries to get to the root of the issue and finds out an astonishing truth about himself. A very delightful, Lovecraftian piece of writing with one of the best (semi-open) endings I have come across. I love creativity like that!
Come to Me is my favorite in this collection - a "be careful what you wish for" kind of story, following a very likable main character who wanted nothing but eternal love, leading to a surprising outcome and a chuckle. I realize now while writing this that I prefer Esquinca's more humorous stories.
There's enough range for all kinds of readers, though, from the zombie epidemic to (my beloved) tentacles to a flabbergasting story about Senior Ligotti as a landlord harassing his tenants - I wonder how Thomas Ligotti reacted to that story!
Definitely worth a read, and, as I said, it's just that my personal expectations were different from this book, in that I was anticipating to be knocked off my socks and that didn't happen, but it was still a fun read.