This was a hilarious book. Not only does it ring true to life with siblings, the crafting and timing of the stories was superb! My response was similar to my friend Nicole - I would be reading in bed and start laughing out loud so much that I cried and was hitting the bed trying to breathe. My husband, who was still up and about, would look in to see what had got my funny bone, and I had to share. Other stories I did not love as much, like the one where Matthew was locked outside all day. I was going to name some of my favorite stories, but I started to list the whole book. Oh, okay, here are a few: the bedtime games (so close to home), "Pass it around, for heaven's sake!" on the road trip after Simon wouldn't count down on the 99 bottles of beer song, and of course, all about Farding. And although I wasn't laughing in the fight scene, I liked how the boys stood up for each other even though they wouldn't have chosen to start a fight on their own.
I also listened to most of the book on CD with my family. The stories were so funny, we ended up listening to practically the whole thing together on a road trip. The kids would beg to hear more and thought it was great since they knew I didn't want them to get any ideas--it was a good family experience. (Spoiler, although you can see it coming from near the beginning - my youngest was really sad when they killed the chickens near the end of the story.)
I rarely read AND listen to a book, so I found it interesting that a couple of things were different in the book than the CD. I liked both versions, so was glad I was able to experience both. If you're interested, page 91 is one of the first differences I noticed - in the book, Simon asks Matthew to hold up a sign (even though Matthew has already put up his own sign); but on the CD, Simon asks him to "moon" passers-by. Page 110 the last 2 paragraphs of the section in the book were not on the CD, and page 113 the discussion with Grandma was completely different than the one on the CD. I may have missed some other things because then I read some/listened to some sections depending on where we were on the road trip, but I always like to know about things like that! What a fun read.